It's been a long day for me, so bear with me if this post is a bit disjointed.
First, an update on my previous opinions.
Dormio: At least now he has a firm stance and a vote down somewhere, although I almost completely disagree with his rationale for voting Pesco in post #103. But he seems to be trying a bit harder now, so I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, at least for now.
##Unvote:DormioDolls: Dolls isn't looking much better, what with his only addition being the infamous post #138 and a pretty weak vote on Shadoweh, which he keeps even after Shadoweh directly addresses the issue he brought up. At this point it feels like he won't or can't form an opinion out of this headache of a game (an understandable feeling), but that's no excuse for the almost complete lack of content. I would be happy with a Dolls lynch at this point.
Pesco: Pesco looks a lot better in retrospect after I realized what he was actually talking about in his first few posts, derp derp :V. For those people still harping on about the "lolwut" posts, try reading Shadoweh's first posts again. Mind, I still don't I think Pesco's accusations against Edible made much sense, but Pesco was like that last game too.
Whatever, he's stepped up his game since that exchange. I'll look at him again later if people really see a case on him, but I don't think his actions so far have been particularly scummy, just more than a little paranoid.
A response to Kitten Re: My first post. I will admit it was pretty bad, but at that point the game was only just getting out of RVS with the Shadoweh vs everybody else banter. I would have waited a little while longer to gather my thoughts and make a more substantial post, but I wanted to answer Shadoweh's question first. In any case, a lot of stuff happened after that, so material wasn't lacking afterwards.
Now that that's out of the way...
Oh boy, PX and Hourai. I believe Kitten already said most of what can be said on the matter. I tried rereading both of them.
Hourai: I originally thought his post #152 looked really bad, but now that I actually look at it, it's not
that bad. Granted, it's a pretty blatant OMGUS, but his reason for thinking PX looks scummy is pretty much the same as mine, and in any case PX's previous posts haven't been too impressive. Hourai's post #90 is unimpressive upon first glance, second glance, third glance, etc. but I find that he has very clear cut opinions to go with his votes, even if I completely disagree with his case on Shadoweh.
PX: But compare that to PX. Vote on Hourai in #150 came out of almost nowhere, as he never deems to explain why he thinks Hourai deserves the vote more than Pesco. Mind, I think the points on Pesco don't really hold, but still, he seems to believe them. His initial vote on Pesco was similarily weak - the rationale for voting only came afterwards, which leads me to think he voted first and thought afterwards. His meatiest post "recaps things," much like what he accuses Hourai of doing.
##Vote:PXPosting this to get it out of the way; I'm too tired to format properly. I have class in 3 hours I hate you all.
