I have a few suspicions about the setup, but I don't know if it's worth putting everyone's information into the open for. My point was that I had no idea how much health UK had. Heck, I still don't - we have to trust her when she says she has 6 health, don't we?
As for scum, I had a couple of theories.
- Scum get a NK after X days.
- Each scum gets their own attack, which effectively charges for every day they don't use it. So activate it on D4, it hits for 4-damage. Then it resets to 0. Obviously, it's secret.
Honestly, though, I don't know for sure. The people who'd suffer the most from this plan are the ones with low HP, so it might be a good idea to keep it in the dark until someone gets dangerously low. Maybe not even then if there's a good reason.
That's almost as bad. Instead of presenting convincing arguments to support her death, you were just encouraging dissenters to act and negate both sides' efforts.
D1. What more could I really have said against her at the time?
As I said, I agree that your reason for suspicion was somewhat decent. The problem is that you did exactly what you said you didn't want to do one post (and less than half an hour) earlier.
I didn't want to, but I had to because no-one else was. If I left it to deadline there was the risk of everyone sending in a tackle at once and utter chaos.