2 cents++
Imo, last thing we want is subjectively and heavy opinion based script reporting and hunting. As far as I know the Japanese upload place for scripts and such isn't moderated either and people just seem to do fine there. At least, that is the general impression(?).
Somehow I keep getting the feeling that the mind set and behaviour of our western fanbase is often the problem. Perhaps not entirely justified for me to express this feeling but left and right noting the posting behaviour of people plus various locations on the net somehow makes me iffy about it all. It is something that Eastern fanbase succeeds in doing better (i.e: Doujin works and guidelines)
There is a reason RikaNitori is a no-drama zone and for some reason this has been generally well maintained. Few little incidents here and there but nothing dramatic. This isn't because of any iron ruling or heavy moderation. But more like creating a clear statement and laying down the rules of the game. From there on it is community driven. Members pass down indirectly the "behaviour rules" to each other and keep each other close.
Plagiarism is not nice and frowned upon, but to start a form of battue is in my eyes poisonous behaviour. If the person is a roaming member of MotK, then perhaps we can engage dialogue to ask reasoning. If the person is not a member of MotK then there is not much we can do. You could e-mail the author yourself and ask kindly to stop the plagiarism but that too shouldn't become a battue. I know how easy it is to conduct to mass-cyber bullying/hunting. The report button as Blargel had pointed out should be used to report bad things such as: Piracy, porn, disgusting stuff, non-danmakufu etc. So it doesn't becomes a dumping site. And that would require some admin-based moderation, but nothing really else than that I would say.
Last thing I prefer to see is Bulletforge drama spilling to our forums or other way around. I am glad the win/fail voting disappeared, a good step towards a neutral non-biased dnh hosting site.
Curious what others think of it.