Capt.h here is your spotlight!
Firstly, I've just re-read everything in this game. But in the end, in addition to what I've said already, I only wish to talk about new and original opinions on Capt. h, Schezo, and Zak.
I might as well do it in that order.
So to start off:
I had a lot of trouble following Dan's case on Shadoweh, which kept me from commenting on it. I think it's based on Shadoweh claiming that each lynch gives scum a night kill after Omba suggested it, which I don't find scummy on its own, nor do I find it scummy that an early D1 vote not be well backed. I think Dan also went after Shadoweh for trying to keep Dormio from being lynched for stepping in LLD's traps while Shadoweh hinted at but didn't mention any of the other reasons Dormio was scummy. It's a thought-out case, but I didn't think it was a great case.
Actually, Dan, could you clarify your case on Shaodweh?
My case on Shadoweh is not hard to follow. It involves a disconnect in thought processes between her initial vote post and her later posts claiming different reasons for why she voted me earlier. This kind of thinking I don't find to be town-motivated. Shadoweh not taking ideas from Omba 10 min after Omba posted is inconsequential to the fact that she didn't mention that "each lynch gives scum a night kill" was one of the reasons she voted for me until significantly later.
Now, capt. h, you say that you don't find it scummy if "an early D1 vote not be well backed". That's fair as long as the reason behind the vote was a good one (or at least one that carried town intent). Shadoweh's reason in her vote post was that I didn't attach a vote to my attack on K4U. Later, after I have pointed out why I did not attach a vote (because I wanted town to speculate with me and reach an agreement on how we implement lynches), she then proclaims that my speculation itself was scummy and that that was the reason she voted me in the first place. I have said that I see little to no evidence of this. Hence the thought disconnect. Hence my Case. As for Dormio x Shadoweh: Yes, I commented on it because I thought it strange and unusual, and scummy. Since then Shadoweh has said she is watching Dormio.
The first part is a misrep, the second is IIoA. Hope this clarifies things for now. Considering you thought me scum for the ED1 argument between me and K4U, you haven't asked for "clarification" between the much more significant battle between me and Shadoweh, even when you didn't understand it. That shouldn't keep any townie from asking questions about one of their potential "scumspects".
Meanwhile, for posterity, What are your current scumspects and why? All I am certain of is that you think Shadoweh "is playing a very town game".
SCHEZO, I have been watching you! I looked at you strangely ever since your capt. h vote post, not because of voting capt. h, but because you had no clear opinions on whether which one of LLD/Dormio was scum, only that one of them was in fact scum. I cannot tell whether you are scum trying to shoot fish in the barrel, or whether you are town tripping up over that fight from your stances on this fight alone. I lean the latter because I think your original Omba vote touched on something that I myself was irate about, namely, it was frustrating that when I wanted town to discuss our options, I was condemned for it since I didn't originally place a vote down, meanwhile everybody did exactly what I wished for i.e. speculation while reaching a conclusion. The only other person to say that was Affinity (although he was only unhappy with PX and Zak and skipped Shadoweh).
Now for Zak. You know when you first voted me, I said "Wat" to myself, because your argument sounded copied from Shadoweh's ... and it turns out it was. But now I realize, reading back, If you were just voting whoever Shadoweh voted, for whatever reason, one would think that you weren't actually serious. But I think you were! So I want to know directly from you, did you seriously consider me the scummiest at the time or were your posts an act? Because, you know, if you weren't serious, your posts are Deliberately Misrepping me (or at least trying to). And it's bad enough this town can't read correctly (seriously people, take an eye test and buy some glasses).
As for the Capt. h. Claim. I don't think it serves any town purpose, like, Capt. h might as well have been a regular townie if town aligned. And while as the cutting K4U said, it would be a powerful scum tool in LyLo, Perhaps it was never meant to get that far. Of course this is all speculation and we should focus on who is Scum :V
In anycase we shouldn't vote him I think... but there is no way I am treating him as confirmed town.
