Of course anything can be a present but the question is will it fit the taste of the presentee?
There is nothing about "taste" in the rules of the game. As no descriptions of the items on hand are present, it's not possible to judge in any way the quality of the item.
On a slightly different point: the safest route through the game is also the most boring one. There should be no possible route that is boring.
Also, the very opening briefing of the game is misleading, as I had originally thought that the game would go on until each person was either dead or had left the party successfully
upon its conclusion. I.e. much, much later than 2000 hours.