UsuallyDead: (7): UncertainKitten, Edible, Carthrat, Arashi Kurobara, Nietz, Chaore, Kanako
Using the
Octotab Nonatab Method of Analysis through Find Next! I call Nietz to the stand!
This post is the vote of UD and...to be fair I don't have much issue with it. It's slightly questionable that too scummy to be scum is implied for my tactics but overall the post seems solid. I wish there had been more solid pokes on Cha but keeping him in mind is decent as well.
I guess I don't see Alice's argument that Nietz is reporter style here...I guess at best I'd say that he could explain why certain things are scummy...
This post, however, is significantly more worrysome. I still argue even the most obvious unopposed wagon isn't liable to end well. But that's not the main point. The main point is he's dropping his main case and doesn't appear to be willing to find a substitute (which is the key difference between he and I). I...hope to see more from him though, since if he does reread he might come up with something.
Overall, Nietz is questionable. Not sure if he's more questionable than Arashi or not though...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Using the
Octotab Nonatab Method of Analysis through Find Next! I call Chaore to the stand!
Ok, let me preface this by saying this will probably be the most annoyingly long one since CHA HAS ACTUALLY POSTED MORE THAN TWICE!
Ok,
This is the first post of his that bothers me. Was it a Just as Planned or wasn't it? Why didn't you pursue it, if it was supposedly so important as to make a post about it?
This rather sarcastic post when under VERY mild pressure also makes me feel a bit iffy about him. It feels like he's getting hemmed in and trying to joke about how he feels (if that makes sense)
This post involves a strange dodginess trying to be played off as a joke...which doesn't help my opinion of him much.
surprised I didn't call
this out when I saw it. You give opinions on two players completely unrelated to their alignment. Really?
I was kind when I read
this at first. The wiggle room he left is beginning to look a lot more scummy, and his vote on UD is the least justified as of yet...there's not even a case on UD in this post. You could actually have voted KANAKO for what you said on him more than what you said on UD. This does not bode well.
Oh god, how did I miss
this gem. I guess I was so ecstatic to see a list from you that committed you to a stance that I skimmed over the content and future mentionings of it. Seriously, if you were just summarizing, that doesn't help. You should probably provide REASONS for voting someone.
I will admit, Cha's case on UD seems decent, and more so once post numbers are browbeat out of him...but I think Alice was being a little unfair.
I guess what I want from him is opinions on other players besides UD and Zak. Not a summary. Not some random list that says nothing. Actual opinions and reasoning on why some other players are town or scum. Preferably the latter.
Cha is the most questionable wagoner so far, IMO.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Using the
Octotab Nonatab Method of Analysis through Find Next! I call Kanako to the stand!
This post is lulzworthy. I mean, I know I pretty well attacked it back then, but jeez. I think Alice covers it best. Why is not stopping the argument when I "should have" scummy, especially for me? You also seem to think UD is something other than town since you don't buy it's a newbie mistake. That was really meh. Also, the number of bases covered was ridiculous. you basically accused four of the people in your list through votes, FoS', and supposed vote changes given obnoxiousness. I can safely say this post contained nothing of value.
The I'm trying to get my vote out thing kinda makes things worse.
This post...suddenly, a switch! Out of nowhere! With no real explanation. WHAT did you reread in his posts, Kanako? Or was it just "yay, bandwagon, since I got called out on my OTHER terrible vote?"
I'm not impressed. Not at all.
I'm not impressed to the point of
##Vote KanakoI'd also probably be convinced of a Cha lynch. Both of you need to post opinions of other players. Well reasoned ones.
Court Adjourned
NINJARS:
I think Chaore is experiencing what happened to Sol in ⑨ Squad. He's digging himself into a hole with every single post he makes, and then being persecuted for bad play. I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt for now. I say that he's trying too hard.
Jam: I believe the general consensus is that Zakeri is insisting that UD is town, so that when/if he gets lynched, Zakeri will get townie points. This makes him look REALLY scummy, since his insisting that UD is town came from nowhere and his reasoning is even worse.
...oh fuck I have to get a haircut now. What a great time to cut off a post.
Better. I'll keep my vote on you until you produce more of this. I'd also like a fuller case on Zak. This seems to be a fair start though.
Pesco is correct Chaore. At this point you're going to have to speak in order to try to defend yourself as you still have the most votes and will thus be lynched at the end of the day unless this changes.
Kanako: Yeah I get that. I'm unsure as to whether that makes Zakeri clearly scum or not as it seems a very transparent move and thus he could still be town but just not thinking it out to well. Either way, he's one I'll keep my eyes on.
Oh shit Jam's playing! Umu...what were her stances for the time being again?
