UK's latest reasoning is bullshit. It implies that if she's scum she'd be telling the TRUTH about whatever info she got. So yeah, I'd still rather we lynched her ASAP, but no-one listens to me. T_T
That actually doesn't matter.
Because if I do get an alignment, if I say someone is scum who isn't, well, you lose a townie and get a scum in exchange. That's a fair trade. If I say someone is town who isn't, well, you get less information, of course, but you can to a degree use my connections to decide if I'm more likely lying or not.
It's less benefit to leave me alive as scum than as town, yes, I agree.
But I argue there is still benefit regardless of my alignment. I also know that I'm town and will give you a true result. I also plan to be killed after I use it. Unless you all find reason to spare me.