I still don't see Tenshi's distinction between the two lurkers. Both lurkers have posted enough that there is content to their name that they can be judged beyond how much effort they're putting into playing. I imagine town would want to look into them enough to decide which has outright scummier behavior instead of just treating them like a coinflip.
You say this like effort and scummy behavior are independent concepts, which I disagree with pretty heartily. I suppose if this is the stance you hold on the concept of effort, though, then I can at least try to verbally transform Kanzaki's lack of effort into something you'd more easily consume as scummy behavior.
WARNING: PBPA-ISH STUFF BELOW (but at least there's assessments/explanations to go along with it)
#67: Waffle on Gasai, waffle (complete with "it's too early to judge" buzzwords) on Irene, obvious and largely irrelevant comment directed toward Mitsurugi. Empty, empty, empty. No effort here.
#103: Question/accusation of Martinozzi that was easily seen to be garbage just from looking at Martinozzi's case. Demonstrates no effort in reading her own case target. The Gasai and Irene one-liners aren't noteworthy considering they completely lack explanation. Demonstrates no effort in commenting on things that aren't her case.
#185: Asks me a question with an (I think) obvious answer. Empty. Asks Yuno questions with obvious answers. Empty. Total lack of actual opinions. Empty. No effort here.
#213: A lackluster case that I've already addressed, but I will admit it's more effort than anything else she's done, even if I'm not fully confident she was paying it full attention while writing it. Then asks Esuna a question with an obvious answer. Empty.
#266: Busy "covered" this in #295 with as much coverage as it warranted. Not quite
pure empty, but damn close, and what little is there is laughable.
Look at that collective post-to-content ratio and marvel at how bad even given how little she's posted. There's practically nothing there, and the one notable thing across an entire two days is a very lackluster Busy case. Does this better explain my issue with "no effort"? It translates directly into contentless filler.
As for BlackRose, #101 actually looks like it has actually semblances of thought behind it, actually provides explanations, and actually provides a few suspicions even if they were directed at people that found her suspicious, for all that Gasai's #102 is the proper response to it and it still stopped thirty posts short of where it should have. The #201 case on me is nothing at all special, but I don't think I was a particularly obvious vote target at the time. The act of trying to justify a vote for me at that time is, by itself, more effort than basically everything Kanzaki's put together across the entire game. It's still content. Crappy content, but content nonetheless.
Gotta go. Sorry if the latter half of the post looks kinda rushed, because it is. Will be back in a little over two hours, assuming hammer hasn't fallen by then.
##Vote: Kaori KanzakiKANZAKI IS AT L-1 AGAIN PLEASE DO NOT SURPRISE HAMMER
