Going right down the list.
Farina is extremely active D1, posting many good posts and both clear scumhunting and prodding. Of particular interest is
this which contains an echo of my thoughts on the D1 Eclair wagon and some nice Meiya prods, and
this which is an acceptable explanation of her switch off Eclair. D2 starts out well with
soundly explained suspicion of Tenshi's ED2 actions, though the RP gets a bit thick.
This is noteworthy as it's a strong stance on BlackRose; it also shows she clearly favors that lurker lynch over Kaori's. Overall I think she's obvtown. The only real weirdness I see from her is the distrust of Eclair but I guess that's mostly because I disagree with it.
Meiya's been a huge question mark for me all game, and her low-content posts today haven't helped matters much. Her
original vote on Eclair felt too opportunistic to be legitimate, and she follows it up with what is explained as a "mistaken" vote on Tenshi before
apologizing and moving to Eclair. Rereading this stuff doesn't give me the same "townie slapfight" feeling I had yesterday, but I did think she was acting townie at the time, probably because buried in her pile of :words: she's at least putting effort into her cases and reads. D2 content she starts to get markedly worse. Basically nothing but a
couple prods until today, when she moved her votepark off Eclair (the vote for which I'm still not clear on) to BlackRose. I dislike the timing of the vote but at least she's consistent, as one of the prods was towards BlackRose anyway. The rest of the day she's been mostly minimum-content so I have a slightly worse read of her today than I did yesterday.
Yuno is the townest player in the game. I don't think this requires much elaboration, but she posts
good cases,
good analysis, and knows what she wants and tries to get it. All of these things are good strong town reads. To respond to a query she raises
here, I was not satisfied with Sayaka's quick switch to another case as soon as she got called out for the no-explanation Meiya vote. Yuno was pretty quiet for some of today but she's made up for it, so no problems here.
Still not sure about Irene. An extremely heavy weight hangs over her head from D1's no-content lurkfest, but Irene 2.0 is proving that at least she's not continuing the lurk strategy. High level of detailed analysis in
her reads, and they
continue all day. Unfortunately, I still keep coming back to Old Irene's
supreme weirdness claim - I know Irene 2.0 said she had no idea what was going on, but I still feel like she's hiding something, because there's no way a townie makes that claim outside of a jester role or a crazy gambit, and Old Irene never followed up on the gambit if it was one. She might be third party, but otherwise I'm just not seeing her as scum.
BlackRose was my preferred lynch
yesterday behind Sayaka. This one's not hard. Lurks all through D1 and D2, posts
awful things when she's not lurking.
Given that she hasn't showed up yet I suspect she's given up. Correction, as she showed up. Thoughts on her claim (and Kaori's) in a bit.
PART TWO FEAT: ECLAIR TENSHI MYSELF MAKA ESUNA KAORI to come after this commercial break! (aka - I'm getting some food and getting this out there before writing the rest, writing long analysis posts makes my head hurt)