I'm just missing the Spy and Engie masks, and I have 2 extra Soldier masks.
I think I'll use the Haunted Metal for the axe. But I'll craft some off the Polycount hats first, unless Valve decides to take away the metal after Halloween.
I also saw a guy who traded his Heavy Mullet for a fish and milk, and another fish dropped for him when he traded. I wish I could trade with people like him.
EDIT: Why did Valve change the Tosslecap's paint scheme? Now I hate it again, unless I get black paint.