For a long time there's been this idea of starting an anime board

~Bunbunmaru News~ > Letters to the Editor

<< < (2/7) > >>

Momiji:

--- Quote from: Shikieiki Matsyxanadu on October 02, 2010, 09:54:00 PM ---Of course, if you want it to be less-dead, there's also the possibility of making a general media subforum as well-- specifically for discussion of TV shows, books, music, and so on-- and really, it's more reasonable, too.
--- End quote ---
Maybe more like a subcategory of general media subforums, including Akyu's Arcade. All the anime/manga/gaming/media stuff that isn't Touhou. Either that, or just revamp Akyu's into a general gaming/manga/anime thread. That way you don't convolute the forum hierarchy.

Matsuri:
Mmm, I can't say I like that idea. AA gets plenty of activity as it is right now-- more than enough to justify its existence as its own category. I have a feeling the other media threads would get scattered around in there quickly if it were to be all merged together. It would be even less organized at that point. :/

HakureiSM:
Yeah, I think merging general media would create an entire different type of mess :s

edit: Suikama stop lurking and say something :<

Alfred F. Jones:

--- Quote from: HakureiSM on October 02, 2010, 09:56:31 PM ---As for the post ammount, many people noted in the past that the mere fact that there's just one megathread with no room for discussion supresses many posts and many potential discussions.
--- End quote ---
I can't really believe that, and for one reason only: Having come from the imageboard, where the post limit was 200 posts per thread and we still managed to get a lot of stuff talked about (along with plenty of hijacks), I think 1000 posts is more than enough to talk about anything-- hell, I think 500 is more than enough.

Still, doing a simple cost-benefit analysis, an amimu/mango/whateverthefuck board or subboard would be a fine idea. It's really no effort at all to create a new board (just a few clicks and whistles and you're done), and worst-case scenario is no one ever uses it, while the best-case scenario is the new board becomes a well-trafficked new portion of the site. I can't say I'd find such a board worth my time, per se, but if the userbase wants it enough, then... bread and circuses, eh?

HakureiSM:

--- Quote from: Aya Syameimaruro on October 02, 2010, 10:56:53 PM ---I can't really believe that, and for one reason only: Having come from the imageboard, where the post limit was 200 posts per thread and we still managed to get a lot of stuff talked about (along with plenty of hijacks), I think 1000 posts is more than enough to talk about anything-- hell, I think 500 is more than enough.

--- End quote ---
It gets crammed not due to the total post limit, but because of the linear nature of the forums. Like I said, one discussion overlaps the other and so forth. A lot more can be achieved in a bunch of threads on different subjects(in anime/manga, different series) with eh, 10,15 posts each, than in one 1000-limited gigathread for the entire area of discussion.

--- Quote from: Aya Syameimaruro on October 02, 2010, 10:56:53 PM ---Still, doing a simple cost-benefit analysis, an amimu/mango/whateverthefuck board or subboard would be a fine idea. It's really no effort at all to create a new board (just a few clicks and whistles and you're done), and worst-case scenario is no one ever uses it, while the best-case scenario is the new board becomes a well-trafficked new portion of the site. I can't say I'd find such a board worth my time, per se, but if the userbase wants it enough, then... bread and circuses, eh?

--- End quote ---
ilu anyway :3

dumb edit: if a new board/subboard is created, it'll need a name, right? I have to suggest something with Kaguya.
I mean, she's the NEET.

Navigation

 Message Index

Go to full version