~Beyond the Border~ > Mystia's Stored Games
Gensokyo Worker's Facepalm Mafia - Topic 2, Game Over, Man, Game Over
FinnKaenbyou:
Well, the moral of this story is that sometimes the cop is wrong.
Hopefully Alice would've been a little more obvious if it were pointed out that Pesco was a reverse framer/lawyer, but yeah. :/
I should really have got around to tracking Alice sooner. I spent the whole game thinking 'How can he possibly balance a game with two docs, a cop and a tracker/watcher combo?' and couldn't think of anything, but obviously it didn't seem that outrageous to everyone else since I didn't claim...and even when my role came out, Alice managed to convince people otherwise.
Still, congrats for pulling it off. I'll make a mental note to cut the crap and just lynch you D1 next time for my own good.
WHMZakeri:
--- Quote ---And Zakeri's a serious trooper for taking a beating as donut and then offering to take another beating as UK.
--- End quote ---
--- Quote ---D5 I can't comment on much due to the modkill cutting the day short. I'm not sure what to make of the modkill, but if Kilga had simply let the day go on I think I likely would have been screwed, so it would either have highly benefited Town or highly benefited Scum, with no middle ground.
--- End quote ---
I really wanted to replace badly, but I knew it would make people uneasy if I had jumped right in the same game, so I asked Kilgamayan and he asked everyone else. I was really dissapointed - especially since Edible was making a lot of sense to me that day even with the innocent result on Alice. I really wanted the chance to go after her, especially since I only lost that chance because of the duty I had to the town to get a lynch in.
Plus, I don't think I would have asked if I believed UK was actually the final scum - but either way I still would have tried to lynch Alice.
Affinity:
I personally think that out of anyone in the game except for wrathie, I made the most mistakes in terms of voting, as seen from my L-1 votes and my pitiful attempt to switch to wrathie. I think the day phases could have lasted much longer if I didn't vote to L-1.
In any case, Alice played very very well as scum; he produced solid content all around (other than D1) that was plausible and generally looked really really town. You're right in saying that had you not have claimed doctor, you would have been pegged as obvtown through the entire game.
As for wrathie, I feel sorry for you since I think you tried very very hard to play the game as town. However, you definitely have to brush up on both your language and your Mafia basics in order for me or anyone else to take you seriously in future games. I suggest you play with your friends or something in your native lanaguage and try and improve from there, since I don't think you really understand us fully either.
Roukanken basically kept everyone on their toes with his very good questioning skills and I think that is applaudable. I think I have to refine my definitions about what is 'playing the setup' and what is not after this game, but yes, Town MVP for this game.
Not much else to say about everyone else. Town generally played quite well outside of wrathie, S.P, Kanako, and me (to some extent). I think pesco and Nietz could have played much better for the first two days, though.
?lice Bl?ckb?rn:
--- Quote from: FallenAngelV on May 11, 2009, 06:34:50 AM ---First time logging in for a week or so (exams etc), but I just want to say, that was bleedin' beautiful Alice. Never have I wanted scum to win so badly before. You're right, I'm proud of you.
--- End quote ---
Thanks <3
And good luck with exams!
--- Quote from: Roukanken ---I'll make a mental note to cut the crap and just lynch you D1 next time for my own good.
--- End quote ---
Thanks :V
You do qualify as Town MVP in my eyes, especially for being unconvinced about my roleclaim and pegging Nietz immediately after being the third person to vote pesco on D2. Good job.
For that matter, half of Town played pretty well, and half of it played pretty terribly. donut, don't /in if you're not going to play the game. Also, you didn't get NK'd, you got deadline lynched D4.
I really must commend Zakeri for almost managing to save himself when playing as Zaknut on D4. That was done really well, if only it was done sooner and not hours before deadline. I think this shows why waiting until the last minute to form all of your cases and place all of your votes is quite honestly a terrible idea.
@Affinity: quite literally, that mistake of bringing Nietz up to L-1 was fatal and really should not have happened. On the other hand, you did play very well in LYLO in the end so I don't think you should place yourself next to people like wrathie, Sodium Bicarbonate and donut in terms of how well you played in this game.
WRATHIE_Beatrice:
--- Quote from: Edible on May 11, 2009, 06:16:57 AM ---That's reasonable enough, I suppose.
I hereby declare wrathie permanent honorary scum. This probably doesn't need to be said.
--- End quote ---
I know, I'm sticking to it.
I dunno about playing mafia, my call on Day 5 was to get lynched period, No matter what the cost is... even if it is going against what Town will do.
I know i will be absolutely worthless in LYLO and I was right.
I wanted an Alice lynch at the start but when i got into the analysis it ended up that Alice's protect made more sense and etc etc etc... so yea, Alice leaving me till the end was the right call.
Me wailing on Day 5 and Day 6 was both to lynch myself and to gauge response on who would want me dead, that didn't work out to well so meh.
Anyways, on to the next game, but I doubt i'll be playing unless some1 give me a reason to,
besides being scum >3