| ~Beyond the Border~ > Mystia's Stored Games |
| Defend the Maiden - Assassin |
| << < (5/21) > >> |
| UncertainJakutten:
EBWOP: *that way as |
| Kiro:
Zakeri: Does this game play out that even if the Assassin is lynched, he is given the opportunity to fire his shot after his death? Naturally, Yes. The Assassin if lynched will be given a period of time where they can still use their kill command. I apologize for not making this clear in the rules. huh what: If the above is true, then it's not really a matter of us finding the Assassin before the VIP is lynched or shot; ultimately, it's that the VIP's identity must have as few leads as possible. Not answering questions is kind of a no-no in Mafia so I'm just adopting that kind of a stance. It's probably because conversely, the Assassin is going to try to fit in, pretending he knows just like everyone else and try to be lynched as late as possible. UK: You're worried that after my question to you, I may say something to draw the VIP out? Heck, anything could lead the Assassin to the VIP, maybe even something the VIP himself says. And it can't be fully controlled due to the burden of information almost the entire game is dealing with. I expect to see a better reason as to why I should be lynched than that since you haven't even mentioned the likelihood that I'm actually the Assassin. Let's see where this train of thought goes with everyone else. |
| Affinity:
Ah, how nostalgic. And it's nice to have my name in the title even! Again thanks a lot for holding this game.., though I think there's a little meta-game element here. Outwifoming the mod isn't a very nice practice though. Kiro's post seems more like a simple opinion on UK's post rather than anything serious, I don't think we have any Mafia game where the Mafia tries to fish on day one, though we certainly have people voting others in suspicion of that, and this case is no different. However, the above post seems to point towards a defensive overreaction over something that isn't very substantial (e.g early game votes against someone don't point towards that someone being lynched immediately), without a vote. My gut sense tingles. ##Vote: Kiro |
| Kitten4u:
Alrighty, so I had never played this variation before, so I decided to look up a little info about it so I knew what to look for. Anyway found the MS Wiki article on it. Is that strategy at the bottom still viable or is that just the MS Wiki being itself (IE, old and outdated)? That strategy at the bottom is why rule 3b was put into place. It's also a potential violation of rule 2 and 11 --- Quote from: Pesco on April 08, 2010, 07:17:41 PM ---##Vote K4U *nag nag* --- End quote --- :< Don't have much to add beyond that at this point, but since Kiro's the center of discussion I'll throw in my two cents. His second post looks more like responding to UK than fishing. His third post looks more like him being himself. So, I find both posts totally null. Also, I agree that outguessing the mod is silly. ##Vote huh what because his name lacks capital letters and I'm not feeling witty with my random votes today. |
| Pesco:
--- Quote from: Kitten4u on April 09, 2010, 05:11:28 AM ---##Vote huh what because his name lacks capital letters and I'm not feeling witty with my random votes today. --- End quote --- Are you aiming for speedlynches or still randomvoting? Either way, I'm not feeling scumKiro. The lack of a path made of names is the best guard against giving away the King in my experience of the game. ##Unvote ##Vote Rou Stop screwing around |
| Navigation |
| Message Index |
| Next page |
| Previous page |