~Beyond the Border~ > Mystia's Stored Games
Himelander Mafia Thread (Over! Scum Win!)
Kilgamayan:
--- Quote from: Roukanken on February 26, 2010, 07:01:26 PM ---I don't understand why people are arguing over MVP. Remember, in the end Mafia is a team game - one good Townie does not a good Town make.
--- End quote ---
In this case I was arguing it because I wanted to make sure I pointed out good play in a game that provided some pretty good examples of bad play. Read the first bullet point here again. I don't want to ostracize, I want to fix. (This can be considered a response to Pesco addressing me as well.) I want to make this site's version of this game better on the whole. In retrospect, what I should have done in the first place was ask Chaore who he thought deserved it over Alex, because that would have given me something more to work with to better people's gameplay (unless his choice was/is Kefit, who I think did fine as well).
UncertainJakutten:
Kefit didn't do as much. That's the only reason I don't suggest him over Alex. Honestly, I don't think anyone (town) played particularly WELL, I just think some players sucked LESS. But, that's just my take.
Kilgamayan:
Again, it's an environmental thing. No one in this game is Superman, we're all bounded by what's going on around us. Kefit may have been wrong a lot as an individual, but I think he did fairly well as a team player. Posts founded in logic, not contributing to chaff, didn't give very many people reason to suspect him (I think you were the only one that had him on a scum list).
Pesco:
I had Kefit in my death list.
UncertainJakutten:
--- Quote from: Kilgamayan on February 26, 2010, 07:40:56 PM ---Again, it's an environmental thing. No one in this game is Superman, we're all bounded by what's going on around us. Kefit may have been wrong a lot as an individual, but I think he did fairly well as a team player. Posts founded in logic, not contributing to chaff, didn't give very many people reason to suspect him (I think you were the only one that had him on a scum list).
--- End quote ---
And even that was circumstantial and he was my least certain pick. Nah, mainly I just think he didn't contribute a lot. What he did contribute was decent, though I still think his Serp case was dubious.