Can't complain too much at SB's case given I was legitimately pretty terrible d2, but there's definitely -some- parts I can refute.
His later vote switch to Sky basically seems to be reporting what he did, then saying that he hadn't really done anything noteworthy.
Um, yes, voting people who are doing basically nothing worth anything at all, is a completely legit course of action.
I also find it weird how he gives CF7 a newbie pass but not SkyPaladin?
What? Are you being serious here? I can't even understand how you can -seriously- come to this conclusion. I'm not entirely sure how to respond to this though, because it's fairly meta I guess? But I think this is a ridiculous accusation.
also find his random voteblocking of BT weird since there was no reason for someone to doubt the Ascetic claim and nobody even suspected BT iirc?
This is also ridiculous. I have a day power I'm literally
probably not even going to use otherwise, I see no reason not to test BT's claim with it just in case. Yeah, I highly doubted he was lying, and even if he was scum he was probably a scum ascetic. But if I'm
not even going to use it otherwise, why in the world is it bad for me to test the claim?
He also says "man someone on the CF7 wagon is probably scum" but then doesn't actually do anything about looking into the votes ------------ His change of opinions on CF7 just seems like he's accepted that he's going to be lynched.
I read over everyone and said in probably the same sentence that I can't tell who it'd be. CF7 actually flipped scum though so. Anyway, if you look back at D1, there's a part where CF7 comes back and he's just like "well I could vote X, Y, or Z I guess I'll vote Z lol bye" and I immediately went "uh, okay cf7 you're making it really hard for me to argue you're null anymore >_>;" which is supposed to explicitly imply "god that post was scummy" and in my later posts I explicitly say that, especially once he never came back and said anything else. I didn't just accept his lynch, CF7 make a post that was actually scummy as hell levels of lazy and he never came back, so he actually became really bad. At the end of the day I had forgotten it for a minute so I was searching for a different wagon but then I realized that wouldn't work, and only afterwords remembered cf7 probably needed lynching after all :V
The next read he actually posts is basically him waffling on O4rfish saying that it could be town!O4rfish but it was also really scummy which is pretty much a terrible read to give out.
This is a big misrep of how I handled o4rfish; I was saying "Well, he's new, but... well actually these posts are pretty scummy." Then I complained about the bickering over Kingault's presence and said that part was null but, that, again, o4rfish's actions were actually fairly scummy. After awhile I remembered BT had given reasons for the slot to be town, and upon that I immediately started going against the o4rfish lynch. BT never restated those reasons though like I asked (He said -himself- he was going to do it before I even asked, so I figured that was fine, the second time I didn't have any time to do it myself) so bah.
...but yeah all the parts where I didn't really scumhunt d2 are totes legit `-` But, uh, half of your case misrepresents me and the rest I feel are completely unwarranted pokes. Still want you lynched even if I never actually made a case on why *coughcough* but I'd probably not feel bad about OMGUS'ing you for this case if it wasn't that it's Kingmaker today.
