BT, what's wrong with just posting what you have instead of posting a huge wall that no one will read fully because it'll take several seconds to scroll down?
lol you asked for it
~~~~~~
Shadoweh's clear on Dan sucks - scum Dan with an announcer action could have done the exact same stuff. "Yeah this is what Town!Dan does with a shitty role" is easy to say if you're not really trying to find out Dan's alignment. The Polly stance is the same with "this role fits" followed by "I'm willing to assume he's town" for no given reason. Her point of showing off people's bad voting history is really dandy when you could do that for every other player in the game. If she as town thought BBM's D1 was obvscum she could've analyzed it in front on everyone's faces instead of getting mad about people criticizing it. It's the kind of response that comes from scum trying to :effort: it up and failing - town can just continue strengthening their arguments instead.
Btw, it probably would have been easier talking about your Serela stance now if you were clear about it, which you usually are. I got the feeling your D1 post was giving Serela a townlean but then you kind of regressed into null-ing him again without any thought process or anything. As for your "slip" I thought saying "X Y Z should have died" implies you at the very least leaned town of them. I guess you're right about the ensuing paranoia but now I'm wondering what happened to your paranoia
before D3, since that makes no sense all the same. It stays that the comment on Rou not dying probably wouldn't have been there if your read was real.
RE stuff about the D2 switch to Polly and self-depreciation, the Rai wagon wasn't likely to happen and it felt like the game was going slow because of lurkers which kind of demotivated me in general. (notice my effort into pushing a lynch on an active slot that stood no chance against lurker lynch a , lurker lynch b or even lurker lynch c) It also kind of lingered into D3 but it should be fine now. I did actually try making a ~*~big reread~*~ entering D3 but lost motivation to do so immediately after the thought, so there ended up being no "hint" of it (that sentence on SB/Prims/BBM in my last post was admittedly pathetic). From what I DID end up reading I thought Shadoweh was scum and the Rai/Serela kills don't change much on that front when you think about it - except maybe force people to look at the townier people, which actually fits nicely considering Shadoweh was lurking it up. In response to Conq, the rest of the Shadoweh case wasn't fluff? The bits about Serela and Rou were there because I thought they were two inconsistencies and were actually a big factor in the placement of my vote. And on Polly, when I think about a role like the one he claimed I think about a game based around duplicates of roles, and the advent of "different" roles like announcer and vengeful spirit went against that idea completely. The recent claims only strengthen this. His claim wouldn't be there to check the existence of actions, it'd be there to quantify them. It's a "really good" fakeclaim because it's easy to fake results and it sounds original, so it doesn't surprise me that they wouldn't think it through. Btw Conq if you mean "looking for townreads" in the extreme sense like what I did last game, well, that was extreme. Not every game goes like that.
I want to continue thinking down this line of "scum wanted to shake things up with the NKs because ____" but besides Polly/Shadoweh's situation it doesn't really point to a "last scum". SB would have been an early busser who didn't expect everyone to immediately jump on Shadoweh today? The way Shadoweh pushes the BBM counterwagon without differentiating between her suspects before voting and without expanding on "BBM should be speedlynched", something that isn't obvious in the least, it could actually be a bus, especially since BBM's recent defenses of "why THIS and not THAT" don't sit well with me, but oh boy I'm assuming too many things again, plus the vig claim makes a lot of sense in the current game balance so bleh. The simple answer would be to look at the origin of the BBM wagon and it's Dan doing PoE after ignoring Shadoweh and Polly, so it'd probably be him. I think.
So let's actually look at those other dudes without connections shall we. <_<
~~~~~~
I'm Kozue Kaoru, VT.
It's hilarious I wanted to say how I'm tempted to read BBM town over the "what if SB/Prims tipped Dan off" thing among others but, uh, double hated.
