Revolutionary Girl Utena Mafia - Night 3 (Student Council Thread)

[Polaris]

I'm not really sure how voting bofh is that scummy anyway? I mean really it was my hour-after-the-day-started vote-to-pressure-bofh-to-see-what-he-comes-up-with and I was kinda expecting him to post since then but I can't take it away because my objective hasn't been fulfilled yet, so...?? I guess it kinda looks bad because I left it there for 24+ hours but it's really bofh's fault for not being here for 24+ hours >_>

[Serela]

Yeah it's a little awkward because bofh hasn't actually done anything I suppose

But I mean IT'S NOT LIKE THAT DOESN'T MEAN YOU CAN'T SCUMHUNT ON ANYONE ELSE

Bofh not showing up doesn't mean you cannot move on with your scumhunting life while you wait

[Serela]

I do apologize for at least half of my desire to vote you being the girl you replaced in for, but you haven't done anything that would make me want to not vote the slot either, so.

[Serela]

im sorry nnr i meant to write

idk something else

:C

[Polaris]

ah yes, and serela of course is the leading expert on scumhunting on other people, which is why his d2 play is absolutely spectacular with posts such as

Half of the playerlist still has a depressingly low amount of content (even -with- considering it was a 48 hour d1), is it okay if I postpone having serious opinions until I get back from work tomorrow so they'll hopefully have posted?

[Polaris]

on a completely unrelated note, I didn't want to let Serela's hilarious malapropisms go unnoticed.

nothing to be gleamed,

with the potential to 160 his slot status

afterwords

[Serela]

oh wait it's 360 isn't it

or is 180 better ;_;

[BigBangMeteor]

sigh

##Unvote

I don't really like Serela's explanation for the difference between NNR and Bofh (no, 1 post is not okay for even a 48 hour day phase, and you were arguing in favour of the NNR lynch even after he said he was busy), but his thought process is so open and he just readily admits to faults in his play so easily that I feel like he's not scum.

##Vote: Polaris

I don't like his way of speaking about some people. His posts are just :words: about them without actually giving a real opinion. Like despite all his posts about Serela, I don't know whether he thinks Serela is suspicious or not and after his paranoia about the PX wagon I don't know what his opinion there is either. When will the PX wagon analysis become necessary? I believe he's leading votes atm. Or if you mean after his lynch, I don't see how just pointing out that everyone is suspicious of him is laying any foundation. Polly's townreads are just based on activity in the thread and his Bofh vote is totally a park. Even if Bofh's not here to respond to your vote, you could still be looking at other people's posts, even if you want to keep the Bofh vote until he responds. All his posts after he's voted Bofh seem to consist mainly of defence.

[ActionDan]

meanwhile Bofh's existence is questionable.

Though today is definitely going in the right direction.

I think.

[Serela]

Yeah in the end I'm not sure how to properly explain how I feel about the bofh thing. I attempted to do so and just went with it but it felt kind of bad and not right.

[ActionDan]

I wonder if this game will need a hitler rant 2.0 just for bofh

[ActionDan]

and on that note I am going to play FFXIV and not care about other people or their cases.

[Polaris]

If I thought Serela was suspicious I would have said so. I already said that I didn't like PX, but there's nothing more to say because he isn't posting either.

The very act of pointing it out is laying down a foundation. It's a point that'll become relevant if PX get's lynched, so I don't see a problem with pointing it out ahead of time. I'm not telling anyone "THIS IS IMPORTANT WE MUST DISCUSS THIS IMMEDIATELY", I'm saying "hmm this could be important later on". BBM your case on me looks pretty uninspired. I dunno if that's because you're scum or if it's because this game is kind of stagnant in general

[Polaris]

Actually I feel like all the cases here are just uninspired. I think this is why we usually have winter mafia breaks during this time. :V

[Serela]

I'm not sure, but I think it's actually a combination of 48 hour day1 and the current playerbase, because the previous game felt kinda like this too to me, apart from like... the ACTUAL SCUM making big case things.

but his thought process is so open and he just readily admits to faults in his play so easily that I feel like he's not scum.

My playstyle makes me obvtown whenever I'm not immediately lynched first (or if I'm scum and end up being pretty clearly not-town-serela as usual, with some RARE BUT AWESOME EXCEPTIONS) it's just, so fabulous :D

[Polaris]

bofh (2): Polaris, ActionDan
Raikaria (2): BT, PX
PX (3): Raikaria, Roukan, Shadoweh
Polaris (3): huh what, Serela, BigBangMeteor
Roukan (1): SB

Not Voting: Alice bofhatroid

7 to lynch.

aw yeah I'm a leading wagon B) now everyone who hasn't already done so is obligated to comment on me whether you like it or not.

[Serela]

Polly reminded me SB actually -did- post today! I forgot.

I don't like Serela's "least helpful in RVS" vote on PX, it just seems fabricated because nobody really did townie stuff in RVS, although PX's slot's been weak on the whole and I don't really have a lot to say on him that hasn't been already. I would lynch him I guess?

the game was still barely out of RVS and I was voting him because, when slightly more serious discussion was starting, he just came in for "lol you're idiots" and left, so I voted him for most useless 'contribution'

If you want a better explanation, Zakeri had questioned me about this in ED1 and I gave him a more comprehensive answer! It's probably on page 3 or 4 or something. If you care I could grab it, but I'm not sure anything from that early in the game (aka my PX vote in barely-not-rvs) could really matter -that- much anyway.

[Kilgamayan]

Wearing A Cowbell And Turning Into a Cow Like A Boss Vote Count

BigBangMeteor (0): Roukan
bofh (2): Polaris, ActionDan
Raikaria (2): BT, PX
Serela (0): BigBangMeteor
PX (3): Raikaria, Roukan, Shadoweh
Polaris (3): Prims, Serela, BigBangMeteor
Roukan (1): Serious Bananas

Not voting (1): bofh

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. You have 44.5 hours remaining.

bofh has been prodded for inactivity. Where have I heard this before?

[GMOFucker: Makin' GMOs To Fuck 'Em]

Polly if you're town you should be posting something of actual significance and not meta-thoughts.

[Polaris]

If I had something of actual significance to post then I would.

[Polaris]

I mean, you can always prompt me to talk about something and I will.

[GMOFucker: Makin' GMOs To Fuck 'Em]

You could start by addressing BBM's accusations against you instead of dismissing them as "uninspired".

[Polaris]

I have every right to be dismissive of cases on me since I know that they're wrong anyway but ok

The first half of BBM's "case" is just him saying that he doesn't understand my posts, which is really more his fault and doesn't really make me scummy. The only relevant point is "voteparking on bofh" and "should scumhunt on other people" but laffo. Have you looked at the votecount? I've already said Raikaria and Roukan are my townreads. I've already said my part on PX. I'm already voting bofh, and I very well can't discuss myself as a vote option. ?_? What do you want me to do, force myself to vote someone that I don't care about and that nobody else cares about?

[Polaris]

In other words, I said BBM's case was uninspired because he's padding it with things that don't even matter, like "what is my opinion on serela" and "what is he talking about with the px thing" (also I addressed both of those earlier).

for the record I don't really care about BBM. Besides, Serela is worse in the "voting me with an uninspired case" department. I don't care about him either.

[Polaris]

Well I'm going to log off now. Good night!

[FinnKaenbyou]

OK so Polaris' general attitude is one thing, but there's another point that really got me a bit anxious about him. I realised this pretty much right after I turned the computer off and went to bed:

I feel like almost the entire game has implied that they don't mind lynching PX at this point and I feel just a little bit uneasy about it. Like, even I think PX is kinda scummy, but if everyone's in agreement then scum are undoubtedly taking part in this PX lynch mob which is where my paranoia kicks in.

Now my question here is this: why PX in particular? The game is just as eager to come together and lynch bofh, from what I'm aware. Why are you anxious about one wagon but not the other?

His holier-than-thou attitude has really not been of much help either. In his exchange with Serela there's a lot of ad-hominem flying about and not much in the way of actual content. That combined with the former owner of the slot being NNR means I can definitely get behind a case on him today if necessary. Still I really don't want PX and bofh flying under the radar -_-;

[Raikaria]

Honestly I'm pretty neutral on Polly. I generally have a null read on him.

Man this day is slow. You know it's a slow day when the only thing I've really changed my opinion on is Shadoweh.

[Kilgamayan]

PX has been prodded for inactivity.

[Serela]

PX has been prodded for inactivity.

/wrist

[Raikaria]

Are you guys waiting for me to make some crackpot ~*Raikaria Theory*~ out of my rear like I used to or is this just national lurker day?