Also don't like Zak for him being super sure NNR and Prims were town after a few short posts. Zak's criticism of Prims asking who Rai would shoot is also pretty shoddy, it feels like he's reacting as if Prims was telling him to shoot now, rather than just talk through his suspicions.
I tend to put a lot of stock into my day one reads. I'm just usually not as transparent about them as I was this game.
HW is still town. Even if he was scum, I can't see anybody including myself that could be his scum buddy, unless it was NNR somehow which I guess isn't out of the question?
plus HW does seem like he's trying to figure stuff out. I can see why he'd switch suspicions to Action Dan since it seems to in part be part of the results of getting too many towntells from Shadoweh.
I'm kind of starting to read Shadoweh as town too, because even if she's totally obvscumbuddies with CF7, it doesn't make sense to turn herself and CF7 into a double dichotomy against me and HW if they were both scum. If Shadoweh is scum, that would have to mean it's either NNR or or Action Dan (Or maybe me, since I've been quiet recently and she'd be counting on things having quieted down after Shadoweh -> HW -> CF7 chain, but yeah I don't know why I'm bringing this up).
and yes I'm attributing the double dichotomy to her since she was the last one to join it.
speaking of old games with polly in them i just remembered bard's vanilla mafia and now i'm paranoid about zak, Cool
if it makes you feel better, I'm also starting to abandon the double-dichotomy thing we started out with.
@Shadoweh: I was just making a post to make a post at the time. I did warn that I was too lazy to gather evidence.
As far as scum posts go it ranks pretty high, practically at the top of my scum BS list. It's a good excuse for a scum to lynch townie and then say, oh sorry, i thought he was scum, but, hey, gotta take risks or nobody gets the shit done.
The post you're responding to is probably one of the bests posts a person could make on MotK, regardless of if they are town or scum. My scum read on you is actually lessening because of this though - rather than being a scum-tactic for your own survival, it's starting to sound more like simple differences in playstyle.
also Dan is mafia, responses to me seemed more concerned about making me think he was town than that NNR was town and were kind of passive-aggressive[/quote[
Can you explain this more because from what I've read of Dan's responses to you this seems blatantly false. He was at the very least trying to get you to admit that NNR was town under certain circumstances using his Alignment, but I don't see him going "I'm town, trust me" in place of that.
hi nnr how are you today would you have anything to chip in maybe even about dan's clear on you at the very minimalest, i mean that would be pretty cool you know just saying is all thank you in advanced.
HW: Maybe. He never calls me scum and went from 'Shadoweh seems fine' to joining you in calling me scummy. I would love for him to tell me how my pristine obvtown suicidal self turned scum because I want to die.
Baaaaah.
uhh, I mean I'm sorry, I was just feeling lazy, I promise I won't forget to have dinner ready when you get home from work tomorrow.
CF7 still seems the most suspicious but now enough time has passed to start making me overthink things so uhh
Shadoweh, HW, and Dan are all speaking earnestly, and Shadoweh and HW both have a fair amount of stuff that only furthers town agenda to them. Which leaves NNR ripe for picking on since he seems to be avoiding commenting on anything.
In short, CF7 > NNR > AD > SHA = HW
