~Beyond the Border~ > Mystia's Stored Games
Touhou Remix: Game Over Man, Game Over!
Nachtwanderlied:
EDIT FOR ROU: Why did you create a role with so many powers unknown to the role-bearer?
i love you rou
UncertainJakutten:
--- Quote from: Carthrat on August 21, 2009, 02:08:50 AM ---Swinginess makes the game unbalanced by definition. It's like a seesaw where one side has a huge rock, and the other side has many little rocks, and for each lynch, you remove a rock. >_>
I'm not sure what to think about the sudden death haiku doublekill...
--- End quote ---
I wasn't entirely happy with it myself but I think it actually gave town a slight edge.
But, Pesco told me to, Edible told me to, a few others told me to...it seemed just as sound as any other solution.
--- Quote ---Yes, the game could have swung any way, but I still consider it unbalanced because the probability of it swinging against Town was a lot higher. Granted, Town didn't play any good, but Scum didn't have to play well either to secure the victory.
--- End quote ---
I disagree. Scum needed to be on it's toes to avoid a vig, a JoaT, and an SK depending on the mood.
--- Quote ---I'm not particularly annoyed though, since I was expecting some sort of crazy setup anyway.
Flavor was great too, I was just disappointed by how the Haiku Duel turned out (I mean, geez, even the bystanders were all better than the contestants.)
--- End quote ---
Yeah...anyone here that has watched Soul Eater should know I got that one face you make when you meet Excalibur.
--- Quote ---@UK: Ahh, I understand what you mean now. And no, the whole Jan-san != Sodium thing was entirely my fault, and I'm basically kicking myself now because I had no reason not to kill Serp, which would have instead lead to a 3:2 game which was still much more salvageable than the 2:2:1 could be.
--- End quote ---
Yep, a serp kill basically would have guaranteed a town win. Kiro, you, and Alice were practically confirmed.
See? Swingy ^-^.
--- Quote ---Speaking of which, I'm gonna grab myself a SOFT drink
--- End quote ---
And even this is superior to those haiku :P.
--- Quote from: William Wordslayer, Champion of Khorne on August 21, 2009, 02:13:10 AM ---What was the reason behind having a huge number of power power Townie power power role.
--- End quote ---
Role madness. I tend to do set ups like that. This one though is probably the worst/most swingy I've done.
I'll have to play with SK theory a little more.
Jana:
--- Quote from: Zakeri on August 21, 2009, 01:54:42 AM ---Cut by Jan-san: wait a minute... GOD DAMN IT. I just now realized that my reason for not targeting Serp was invalid. It was because I had confused Jan-san for Xan and thought Sodium had replace Jan-san instead of Xan. which means the whole time I thought it was Jan-san's role that flipped scum during the Haiku-off. fuck me with a spork, I had been trying to reason all day 4 why SerpScum would target JanScum for the time he did. I really hate inactives now.
--- End quote ---
Yeah, that inactivity was pretty bad, but it cost town the game?
BRB Seppuku. Like I said, I'll stay away from Mafia for a good long time.
Kiro:
--- Quote from: Nietz-R-PHD-1 on August 21, 2009, 02:09:34 AM ---(*ﾟ▽ﾟ)つ凵 Cheers!
--- End quote ---
You rock! I'm feeling better already!
One more thing about the Cop role. Action wise, I played it the worst way possible, not being able to confirm anything until Day 3. That's pretty dastardly in a game like this where we might be in LYLO by then. You should have made it so you can Drink and Investigate at the same time like I had asked in my PM during Night 1.
Zakeri: Ah, I didn't realize you had that kind of a confusion with Jan-san != Sodium. *shrug* Sub optimal performance by both of us in Day 4.
UncertainJakutten:
--- Quote from: Kiro on August 21, 2009, 02:19:53 AM ---
--- Quote from: Nietz-R-PHD-1 on August 21, 2009, 02:09:34 AM ---(*ﾟ▽ﾟ)つ凵 Cheers!
--- End quote ---
You rock! I'm feeling better already!
One more thing about the Cop role. Action wise, I played it the worst way possible, not being able to confirm anything until Day 3. That's pretty dastardly in a game like this where we might be in LYLO by then. You should have made it so you can Drink and Investigate at the same time like I had asked in my PM during Night 1.
Zakeri: Ah, I didn't realize you had that kind of a confusion with Jan-san != Sodium. *shrug* Sub optimal performance by both of us in Day 4.
--- End quote ---
If I did that, all players would do that. Using more than one action is always optimal. Therefore, it would have been a sane cop. I see sane cops as broken. So, no go. Now, what I should have done is made it more explicit that your buzz from drinking wears off after one night phase. That would probably have made the proper actions obvious.