Okay, so I admit to having had suspicion of Affinity in that his play was weaker on Day 1 than I am used of him, but I don't think he's the scum we're looking for. Chiefly because I do not think Scum!Affinity would consign himself to death by actually pushing for herdcrabs over PX the way he did, and secondarily because GUT.
When I initially vote her for jokevoting Schezo, her response is
that she didn't jokevote, and a defence of why PX is a Town read for her. Note who she finds a Town read, and how she attacks that point rather than explain why Schezo is scum to us. When I voted her for jokevote and what BT calls contrived reasons,
Shadoweh defends me, and further clears Schezo of any scum-accusations... except she never levelled any. It seems Shadoweh's more interested in clearing people as Town than pointing at them as Scum from the onset of the game.
And for someone who warns not to talk about true claims early in the game,
she is adamant about clearing PX based on her own true claim. You understand, with PX's flip, this is getting messier and messier. Proposing to
lynch Hero is nice, but it comes after 24 hours into the game. We all know how active lurking is scummy, and it's ironic how Shadoweh mentions scum may be lying low. Turns out PX and Rawr were doing that at least.
Again,
Shadoweh defends PX, this time suggesting not to vig him. Reasons still unexplained, and
this continues. It's actually distressing Shadoweh never makes much of a case on Hero:
the best she gets is that "look at a previous game, draw your conclusions". Then comes the
false claim that she has explained why people are Town. I still hold that she does not explain why people are Town, only that she "has more reasons to see people as Town than Scum" and doesn't actually, you know, provide strong reasons for why they're Town.
I recall she called Dormio Town for saying No to mass-claims. That's still a bit shakey for me.
Also she clears me as Town as well. So far: Shadoweh thinks Hero is Scum. Dormio, PX, Serela, Bardiche and Schezo are Town. Oh,
but Serela (despite telling herdcrabs not to vig him) isn't that Townie, but Townie enough. BT fills this category as well and huh what becomes Town as well. Only Affinity and Hero are mentioned as even a little scummy. Further D1 content isn't interesting: it's helpful, but Scum can be helpful. As I noted, Scum!Shadoweh plays for Town.
D2, though, we have Shadoweh
talking about PX again, revealing his true claim and talking about her true claim power... again, despite early in D1 saying that
we shouldn't talk about true claims. Also, she claimed pretending to be someone else. Scum Imps pretend to be someone else. Shadoweh claiming Scum? :derp:
Distressingly, it takes Shadoweh
a while again to consolidate a case, which ultimately... what was it someone accused me of? Oh right. An empty case that could change if the votee made one post explaining the question. So at this point it's a prod.
More Town clears, and
inexplicably asking a vig on me despite saying I was Town before, and ten minutes later,
it's Rawr. Without any explanation of why Rawr over Bard. More linking to PX
later on, which looks like Shadoweh is really insistent on tying her to PX more solidly than Serela is to uselessness.
Again, Shadoweh proposes
shooting me, but never really says WHY I am Scummy. This is consistent with her suggestion of Affinity, as she does not say why Affinity is scummy either. (She doesn't say people are scummy a lot.)
She defends PX again here, and unvotes emptily. Understandable, but we never get why Affinity was Scum in the first place much, and she doesn't exactly devote a lot of time to her case either.
Shadoweh continues to invite
role speculation by talking about her role, even though no one's inclined to ask about her role. Claiming herself Town for being active after claiming Scum'd lurk out the confusion early D1 is also another point I hold against her and would lynch her for.
Her reads are all over the place as she went from the above Serela + Bard aren't scummy to
Serela and Bard are very scummy, she misrepresents my actions and case and still refuses to vote.
All of this is a lot of noise where Shadoweh portrays how she has no reads. Ultimately she
does vote me, but without a case other than undefined "worst logic" and playing to Town's paranoia, except there was no confused Town with paranoia. The further accusation that
I am scum for defending PX contrasts with her own defence of PX. When the boat looks about to sink,
Shadoweh does a 180, suddenly declaring both Scum as, well, Scum and her top targets for lynch, dropping Affinity, Serela and me for reasons unexplained.
Her reason for lynching Rawr, again, was to
get info on Affinity, maintaining that one of two was Scum... but I already pointed out why lynching Rawr said nothing about Affinity's alignment. Also more
Shadoweh X PX OTP, totes jealous but more LINKING.
So yeah. Shadoweh is scum.
Any questions?
##VOTE: Shadoweh
