@Nav: Actually, that's the part of the One case I find to be the most agreeable. It really becomes a toss up over which position you think newbscum would be more likely to make. I believe Depore looks scummier because she seemed to go for the early point on the wagon where she would have a larger chance of blending in, which makes sense as something that would be combined with her opportunism. As for One, I don't think this is One's first game, but even if it is, I think that the contents of the RVS would be enough for him to realize that late votes on wagons look rather iffy. Scum!One would be drawing unnecessary attention to himself by placing Xix at so many votes, and I think he would have actually gone for Moonin instead, seeing as he was clearly in the place where he could do so. The awkward prioritization looks like a derp mistake to me.
Additionally, One's case on Xix seems like he was looking for scum intent to me, even though the case itself made no sense. Depore doesn't have this luxury. I realize this is just an interpretation argument, but I hope you can at least understand my side better from what I'm explaining.
@Just: I expect to be lambasted for this, but I believe that completely neutrality tends to a null tell when seen in weaker players. I've seen enough newbtowns who actually have inward struggles trying to figure out who they think is scum that I find it difficult to think otherwise. I think aggressive attempts to start wagons like what Depore tried are a lot more indicative of newbscum status than not being able to form opinions.
The hypocrisy doesn't really bug me because I don't see how it's scummy hypocrisy. I know you seem to believe he's scum by his own logic, but if you read into One's post and suspicions then it starts to seem a little like he's focusing more on lurking than actual neutrality, only failing to properly explain himself.
The One case as a whole feels rather mechanical to me. It's like people are automatically jumping him for what they know to be bad play, without actually thinking about whether or not newbscum would want to make these bad plays here and why they would actually do so. This is a very good way to get bad townies lynched for being bad at the game. The only point about One which I feel holds any water is the way he jumped on Xix, and even then, I feel Depore's jump on Xix is a lot more worthy of scrutiny.