Maidens of the Kaleidoscope

~Hakurei Shrine~ => Touhou Addict Recovery Center => Topic started by: Ghaleon on February 08, 2010, 10:54:17 AM

Title: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ghaleon on February 08, 2010, 10:54:17 AM
I'm curious what the general reaction would be if zun suddenly added men to Touhou. I don't mean the type that don't really affect much like rinnosuke. But playing major roles in the series, some bosses, maybe a final boss, maybe even a playable character.

As a touhou fan, I find it difficult to get friends to try and take the games seriously with it being female dominated. I know when I first heard that the game had nothing but girls and fairies I DID consider trying a different game instead. But I didn't, and now that I AM hooked on Touhou, I LIKE the estrogen overload.

I personally would be extremely dissapointed if zun started adding some men to the cast. But maybe it would turn out fine, I thought an all female cast was pretty dumb to begin with as well. Still though my reaction would definately be along the lines of "WTF!".
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Furienify on February 08, 2010, 10:58:04 AM
He'll be a gay man.

I know it.
And he better be hot.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ghaleon on February 08, 2010, 11:09:37 AM
Crap, I meant to mention that they wouldn't be traps... Gay non traps would be fine though...err I mean would be what I'm talking about.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Firestorm29 on February 08, 2010, 11:20:07 AM
I suppose for me, it really more depends on what kinds of a man is added in, or more like boy would be more appropriate. Much like how Touhou girls aren't like Bratz, I suspose I'd like to see something not like Rambo for a man or boy, depends on how he decides to draw it.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kinzo the Astro Curious on February 08, 2010, 11:36:17 AM
Maybe as a spin off with manly characters and manly danmaku.

Bring it on, Youki konpaku!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Solais on February 08, 2010, 12:41:42 PM
"Finally!"

He should add Buront.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Mounting Jaggis on February 08, 2010, 12:43:59 PM
In his UFO interview he originally planned Unzan to be a boss by himself
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Observer on February 08, 2010, 01:24:26 PM
Maybe as a spin off with manly characters and manly danmaku.

Bring it on, Youki konpaku!

THIS. This could work. Would be awesome to see Youki being kickass and firing danmaku+striking sword combos nonstop. As for other men, not so sure. Pretty much anything, including  Lovecraftian horrors, can be lolified so for every man you think, you can make a loli clone out of it. Or a trap. :V

Manly clouds, evil eyes, seals/shields with wings, crazy monks and those freaky things (scary bee-like youkai and others) are fine with me. Surreal mecha fishes are a plus.

But, for manly stuff, I would rather have Crimzon Clover with the "0% moe and 120% explosions" tagline instead.

*WARNING: Apocalyptic mode approaching fast!*

We have to consider that at this stage of the circumstances, any 'conflictive' male that is even attempted to approach any of these homicidal and psycho girls is going to cause an incredible rage (or worse) and sink down the entire doujin ship in the process. Because that way, *insert character* can't be your waifu, etc., etc.

THE END IS NIGH. IT'S WRITTEN IN THE HOLY SCRIPTURES! wwwwatatatatatatata!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Slaves on February 08, 2010, 02:25:28 PM
i wouldn't be able to draw them :(
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Mounting Jaggis on February 08, 2010, 02:38:21 PM
Don't worry Slaves, it's like drawing a loli except it's more masculine
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Sabino on February 08, 2010, 03:12:18 PM
Don't worry Slaves, it's like drawing a loli except it's more masculine
Ah, so the guy must be a Shota then!   ...I'm OK with that! lol

People who's genders weren't identified in the Kyusaku can comeback, like Shingyoku.
Since we are still uncertain about stuff like Sariel's gender.
(Although some people say that Angels can be both genders at once...)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dollywitch on February 08, 2010, 03:23:14 PM
A friend and mine are working on a game kind of like that, it's the opposite of Touhou, instead of being vertically scrolling and featuring cute girls, it's horizontally scrolling and features MANLY MEN.

http://img.youtube.com/vi/Lg5rxWhk_Ko/0.jpg (http://img.youtube.com/vi/Lg5rxWhk_Ko/0.jpg)

Not only is that image too wide, it's hotlinking as well. Don't do this. ~Matsuri
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Slaves on February 08, 2010, 03:25:08 PM
Don't worry Slaves, it's like drawing a loli except it's more masculine

oh, i see!

so, something like this?
(http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll115/fruitfat/sonano.png) (http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll115/fruitfat/sonano.png)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Mounting Jaggis on February 08, 2010, 03:27:28 PM
It's perfect
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on February 08, 2010, 04:14:23 PM
A friend and mine are working on a game kind of like that, it's the opposite of Touhou, instead of being vertically scrolling and featuring cute girls, it's horizontally scrolling and features MANLY MEN.
Cho Aniki?


...But seriously.  I think in the same UFO interview mentioned above ZUN mentioned, probably half-jokingly, that there was a male he wanted to use instead of Byakuren - but couldn't due to expectation and that it just wouldn't feel right.

...But with that said, I think it actually will occur at some point though, but it won't just be "Oh there's a male boss" - call me crazy, but I think that at some point the matter of men not being seen as combat-worthy will actually be a plot point in a future Touhou game; possibly in a sort of reverse-feminism thing where a small number of men in Gensokyo attempt to stand up for all men and prove themselves as equal to the women who're constantly screwing around with the world and/or being the heroines.  It may even be just one guy (and a subordinate) who decides he wants to cause a major incident just to prove that men can have just as much an impact on Gensokyo as women.

...But yeah.  Males (by themselves) in Touhou would be the kind of thing that I don't see ZUN doing without a plot-important reason reason; evidenced by the fact that he said he developped the hitbox Ichirin so there would be a female aspect to the Unzan fight, even if he wanted the focus to be on Unzan.

Also ZUN would draw shota, not manly men.

I'm totally okay with this.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 08, 2010, 04:43:24 PM
Call me stubborn or short sighted, but I really wouldn't like it multiple male characters would come rushing in. Rinnosuke is acceptable because he's a funny and charming character that doesn't mess around much with the actual plot. Being male also makes him unique. A male final boss however would seem extremely out of place. I once played a fangame of Touhou (flash game based on MoF and IN, you'll probably know it), and a male boss popped up as the third boss. An adolescent guy. It felt rather awkward and out of place. The main characters we're also males, but atleast they were cute monsters and furries, not giving the same impact, and females still accompanied them.

I would only accept a male boss if it were a monster or elderly man of some kind, like Unzan. Unzan is freaking awesome, because he's such an imposing figure, and mysteriously fitting among the characters. Youki also fits in the same way.

Conclusion: Touhou must consist mostly of young females, with male monsters and old farts thrown in at several times. I think it's most fitting. A bishonen or shotaro would just seem out of place. Atleast the old farts are badass, and there is a smaller chance they'll get paired up with the female cast (either through appearance and age difference or 'Hot Skitty on Wailord Action' syndrome). Bishonen and shotaro would just honk the spot light, and lure in the demonic scourge known as slash (yaoi) fangirls. *shiver*
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: KrackoCloud on February 08, 2010, 05:46:43 PM
One of these days, it would be cool to see a final boss that's a boy.

But besides that, I'm content with just Rinnosuke.
Unzan, to me, doesn't really count as much. He's awesome, but the fact that he's... Basically under Ichirin as a weapon or something makes him a lot different as a male character.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Toasty on February 08, 2010, 05:48:51 PM
A male or two wouldn't be too bad
even though ZUN would draw them as lolis in pants
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on February 08, 2010, 06:00:14 PM
If ZUN started adding more guys to touhou, VIVI, Pozeal, and I would flip
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: theshirn on February 08, 2010, 06:08:32 PM
I will eat ZUN's liver out of his still-warm body
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Slaves on February 08, 2010, 06:23:49 PM
adding males to Touhou seems like a good idea, but it would lose some of it's charm that way. just like if ZUN hired a professional artist to make all of his art.

and not like the fighting games, i mean like art you find in dating sims and stuff.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ♛ Apher-Forte on February 08, 2010, 06:49:38 PM
It would be nice if the men are these cute little shota traps that make Mode drool.

then I will play it.
Cute boys = traps = lots of fan art = even more publicity for Touhou = profit
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Alfred F. Jones on February 08, 2010, 07:00:39 PM
If it were in a new game, I would avoid it like the plague.

Alternately, I would play the game specifically so I could beat the shit out of him.

I'm a recovering androphobe okay :<
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: orinrin on February 08, 2010, 09:29:39 PM
Can ZUN even draw anything other than lolis?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on February 08, 2010, 09:31:24 PM
he can kinda draw turtles
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Matsuri on February 08, 2010, 09:32:37 PM
and giant cloud spirit men with fists
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Grand Octopus on February 08, 2010, 09:44:50 PM
Short answer: badly.

Long answer: very badly.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bananamatic on February 08, 2010, 10:15:46 PM
he can kinda draw turtles
i like turtles
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 08, 2010, 10:38:38 PM
my reaction: OH YEAHHHH! finally! (go to look the art of the new characters, add them to her collection of draws, begin to make pairings and all that)
at least, even if ZUN no has drawn males, he can create music for them (even if he says who is good in it...he composes the Erich song in Seihou, "Magical Girl's Crusade" who he says is awesome!)
I think who he would make another game, different of Touhou but incide the plot (something like the "other things who happen in Gensokyo"...or maybe in the past, before the Hakurei border, or 60 years before our Touhou) maybe in horizontal danmaku style but with the same spellcard system, but with only males...maybe this would explain why Rinnosuke is so misterious (he was like Marisa in the past! or was like Reimu! or...) why Youki is more powerful than Youmu, we can see how is Lord Tenma, why a judeo-cristhian creature like Sariel ends in Makai, the true form of Yuugen Magan, see if Sigma is a machine, an android or a cyborg of a certain lovecrafthian god, Unzan in free days, Namasu in a good day, the pimping father of Marisa (XD)...and new ones too. (ohh yes)
And probably in a year will see some fanarts, an even doujins with this adventures in manly ways, with lots of brofists, bromance...and yaoi doujins, because lately i see lot of good fanart of Rinnosuke made for people who can draw lot of Hetalia pairings...this smell like fujoshis who will discover soon the potencial of RinnosUKE. XD
meanwhile we can dream.
http://vivitheheiwa.deviantart.com/art/Touhou-XY-150706914


Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chaore on February 08, 2010, 11:04:35 PM
First off, I'd have to grudgingly admit defeat to one of my british friends.

'He'll have to' my ass... *Grumble Grumble*

Second off, I'd be somewhat intrigued. I mean, lets be honest. Who are the current men? Rinnosuke, Unzan, And Genji. All awesome in their own right.

He has hit 3/3 with guys so far, much better than his average with women. :V

It'd be a shocker, admittedly, but it could very easily turn out well.

This is coming from someone who thinks Rinnosuke has a tank, though, so.... :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Serela on February 08, 2010, 11:07:29 PM
In his UFO interview he originally planned Unzan to be a boss by himself
He also originally planned the final boss to be an old guy (Myouren). Now THAT would have really freaked some people out when the game was released :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: eclipse on February 08, 2010, 11:14:32 PM
NO.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kinzo the Astro Curious on February 08, 2010, 11:57:28 PM
It'd certainly mess with my Touhou rage.

AARRRRG DAMMIT YOU BIT- er, BASTARD!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Doomsday on February 09, 2010, 12:40:16 AM
I wouldn't mind if a male character were to appear in the games, So long as he fits in with the other characters, im all up for it
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: N-Forza on February 09, 2010, 01:19:36 AM
I think it would be kind of neat but it would only work if all of the bosses/mid-bosses in the game were male.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on February 09, 2010, 01:53:16 AM
He's got Unzan already. What more do you want!?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Patorikku on February 09, 2010, 02:06:45 AM
If there were males in Touhou? Well, for starters, they are forced to be shota, shonen at the oldest. They should fit in with the rest of the Touhou crowd, or at least be semi-noticable. In fact, if ZUN doesn't directly say it's a guy and they're in the trial of a new game, they should be capable of causing a "Wriggle Case". You know what I mean...

Overall, if Zun got a guy into Touhou, they'd be kinda similar to what's in my avatar, except quite differently detailed.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: beaver1231 on February 09, 2010, 02:46:29 AM
There would be two reactions to this, especially if he is a boss:

Lol Zun.

or

the word "TRAITOR" will flood the Touhou forums by the dozens and saying how Touhou is now ruined.

Also, http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/Wriggle_Nightbug (http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/Wriggle_Nightbug)

why hasn't this been mentioned yet?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on February 09, 2010, 02:52:13 AM
There is quite a bit of sexism towards males ITT which makes me very unhappy. >:(
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chaore on February 09, 2010, 02:55:38 AM
There is quite a bit of sexism towards males ITT which makes me very unhappy. >:(

This. I mean what the hell.

Genji has already starred in 4 different games. There has been a man in Gensokyo the entire time.

Respect the damn turtle. >: <
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on February 09, 2010, 02:59:02 AM
I wouldn't mind a male or two, but probably only in certain situations. Like a duo of male and female twins would be kinda cool. Or an ambiguous character like Wriggle that ZUN refuses to say whether it's male or female. :3


There is quite a bit of sexism towards males ITT which makes me very unhappy. >:(

... what do you mean by sexism? Or are you just throwing the term out because it sounds good? :P
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chaore on February 09, 2010, 03:01:27 AM
... what do you mean by sexism? Or are you just throwing the term out because it sounds good? :P

ITS AN UNFAIR STEREOTYPE A GUY HAS TO HAVE A GIRL FOR HIS HITBOX.

FIGHT THE POWER, MEN!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Patorikku on February 09, 2010, 03:04:19 AM
Also, http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/Wriggle_Nightbug (http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/Wriggle_Nightbug)

why hasn't this been mentioned yet?

Quote from: Patorikku
...they should be capable of causing a "Wriggle Case". You know what I mean...

Think about it...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on February 09, 2010, 03:15:13 AM
... what do you mean by sexism? Or are you just throwing the term out because it sounds good? :P

OkashiiNaito's post. Nuff said.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on February 09, 2010, 03:19:18 AM
Have you read OkashiiNaito's post? So many double standards it's not even funny.

*shrug* Still not seeing it. Preference for females over males != sexism. An almost completely female cast is part of Touhou's style, no one can deny that.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ebarrett on February 09, 2010, 03:27:27 AM
There aren't men in Touhou because men don't go WHOA BITCH CALM DOWN THERE OR I'LL FILL YOUR BONY ASS WITH DANMAKU WHO ARE YOU CALLING BONY ASS OLD HAG WHO ARE YOU CALLING OLD HAG BONY ASS at every opportunity even when there isn't a reason.

And OkashiiNaito's post, while certainly not sexist, does have double standards. A sort of pack mentality, I-am-the-alpha-male reflex reaction. (edit: scratch that, should've looked up what a "bishonen" is before writing)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on February 09, 2010, 03:28:10 AM
... Okay, now I'm confused. Is his post being sexist towards the women in the Touhou fanbase who are yaoi deprived? or men in general for only being accepting of 'manly' men...? :(
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Moerin on February 09, 2010, 03:29:55 AM
Also, http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/Wriggle_Nightbug (http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/Wriggle_Nightbug)

why hasn't this been mentioned yet?

I will murder you.  TO DEATH, if need be.

...Yes, I'm not exactly fond of that stupid meme that claims my favourite Touhou is the wrong gender.

Ahem.

But men in Gensokyo?  Depends... Are they hot~?  Really, I wouldn't mind at all... At least it'd be something new, right?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chaore on February 09, 2010, 03:33:49 AM
*shrug* Still not seeing it. Preference for females over males != sexism. An almost completely female cast is part of Touhou's style, no one can deny that.

Shingyoku. Genji.

-Unzan-.

It hasn't been exclusively 'female' from the very beginning. Just very much majority so.

After Genji retired was pretty much the first time it was all female. Asking for a guy is like asking for a bit of the olden days back. Though, we pretty much get a Genji in Unzan anyway.

This thread should rightly be 'How did you react when you saw Unzan'.

Fffs... Just because they're animals and abstract beings, doesn't mean they're not manly men.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 09, 2010, 03:49:24 AM
Why does this topic seem SO familiar...I mean, I remember this from somewhere only...worded differently.

I'd be all for men in Gensokyo, it's something new and it would be fairly interesting. Really though we have a few of them in Genskyo as it stands just none of them are mentioned on the gaming scene where most of the action is. Which is a shame being some of them seem interesting...like Lord Tenma, we hardly hear about him and he's the cheif of the Tengu, I think I can smell boss matieral, do you?

I think you do...

Fuck what the fandom thinks, Touhous going to grow stagnant if we keep doing the same thing, yeah it's doing good now, but we need a change at SOME point.


...Yes, I'm not exactly fond of that stupid meme that claims my favourite Touhou is the wrong gender.

You too huh?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on February 09, 2010, 03:50:59 AM
Now now oneechan.. is there a such thing as a 'wrong' gender? ;p
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on February 09, 2010, 03:54:39 AM
Men tend to get into fights more often, so That's less wrighting for ZUN
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chaore on February 09, 2010, 03:56:15 AM
Men tend to get into fights more often, so That's less wrighting for ZUN

'wait why the hell are we fighting'

'BECAUSE I AM A MAN! *punch*'
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Suikama on February 09, 2010, 03:56:41 AM
Didn't ZUN originally want Byakuren's brother to be the final boss of UFO, but changed it because he was a male? :V :V :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on February 09, 2010, 03:59:18 AM
'wait why the hell are we fighting'

'BECAUSE I AM A MAN! *punch*'

Pretty much
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ebarrett on February 09, 2010, 04:01:38 AM
Pretty much

And the fight ends on the spot because you knock out the other dude, or at least a couple of his teeth. Women on the other hand pretend they're hurting each other while making a spectacle of themselves while a crowd gathers. There, a much better starting point for the games!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 09, 2010, 04:02:07 AM
Men tend to get into fights more often, so That's less wrighting for ZUN
"What're you guys doing?"

"We're trying to see who's the more dominant male!" *Tosses absurdly heavy objects*

But I think this only applies to a few of them, as Rinnosuke shows us.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chaore on February 09, 2010, 04:02:42 AM
"What're you guys doing?"

"We're trying to see who's the more dominant male!" *Tosses absurdly heavy objects*

But I think this only applies to a few of them, as Rinnosuke shows us.

And then Rinnosuke fights Unzan for NO REASON.

and it was glorious.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 09, 2010, 04:05:07 AM
And then Rinnosuke fights Unzan for NO REASON.

and it was glorious.
Fuck Yeah
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Suikama on February 09, 2010, 04:07:59 AM
And then Rinnosuke fights Unzan for NO REASON.

and it was glorious.
Someone needs to draw this

now
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 09, 2010, 04:09:44 AM
i believed who originally the no male thing was for turn the story of Touhou more joyful and less dramatic, more comedic. For that i think in a parallel game when think about males in Touhou.
And, after all, the magic tradition in japan is more femenine, but no means who can be restricted to only girls...well,we know all that anime about magical girls, but magical boys or males are really rare.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 09, 2010, 04:12:58 AM
i believed who originally the no male thing was for turn the story of Touhou more joyful and less dramatic, more comedic. For that i think in a parallel game when think about males in Touhou.
And, after all, the magic tradition in japan is more femenine, but no means who can be restricted to only girls...well,we know all that anime about magical girls, but magical boys or males are really rare.
And then Rinnosuke fights Unzan for NO REASON.

and it was glorious.

that was so epic who i forget delete my anterior post and i can?t delete it now XD (but wait,Rinnosuke is pasifist...i believe XD)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 05:24:46 AM
I for one would welcome the addition of a male in a Touhou game that ISN'T a non-humanoid entity.

But yeah, if one were added, they would probably be shota or bishounen.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 09, 2010, 05:51:29 AM
I would welcome a male character, for a change at least. My ideal male character would be the older brother of another character in a new game for it would allow the other character to utter that oh so moe word "Oniichan".
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: JT on February 09, 2010, 05:56:33 AM
I would welcome a male character, for a change at least. My ideal male character would be the older brother of another character in a new game for it would allow the other character to utter that oh so moe word "Oniichan".

I like the cut of your jib, sir.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 05:57:16 AM
Yeeeeeeees~

Oniichan moe~

Also, it's worth noting that the first time I saw Shou, I though she was a boy.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: IcedFairy on February 09, 2010, 07:00:47 AM
Hm...  Depends on how well it was done of course, but I have to state that the very heavy lean towards a female cast (especially in positions of power) is one of the unique points about the series.  Even if it was a well done change I think touhou would lose something.  So there would have to be quite the gain in return to make up for it.

Also I expect the fanwork quality to take a sharp hit after such an introduction, but I can't blame ZUN for that.  I will still rage however.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 07:26:23 AM
Making one or two bosses male wouldn't exactly upset the positions of power in Gensokyo, especially if they were like, Stage 4 and below. And even more especially considering no one could hope to surpass, say, Yukari, Yuka, Yuyuko, Suika, Flandre, Remilia, etc.

And there are already three male characters that have been shown, either in-game or in print work, and a few others that have been mentioned. Adding a couple more wouldn't upset the heavy cast lean toward females - after all, what's a little over a half dozen male characters compared against the 90+ female cast?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: IcedFairy on February 09, 2010, 07:51:47 AM
I should perhaps clarify that I don't consider Unzan or Genji as really being "men."  Male, but not "men" which is a big difference.  (I don't even really consider Unzan a character, which may be unfair, but that's how I see it.)  I mean, if ZUN brought back the 5 magic stones or something similar and said it was Male I'd sort of shrug and move on.  But an actual man as a boss would feel off to me.

That leaves Rinnosuke, who's pure print works.

This is mostly an aesthetic sense on my part, so I can understand others not feeling the same.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DarkOverord on February 09, 2010, 08:06:38 AM
Didn't ZUN say the main reason why males don't do Danmaku fights is because their danmaku isn't beautiful enough or something on similar lines.

I wouldn't mind myself. So long as it still plays as Touhou and has awesome music, I'd have no problem.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 08:55:13 AM
Do not question Oniichan moe~
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on February 09, 2010, 08:59:13 AM
U Mad.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 09, 2010, 09:11:19 AM
You do not understand the ways of moe and in touhou the ways of moe are very strong.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on February 09, 2010, 02:05:23 PM
Moe is completely objective. The whole 'Oniichan' thing is definitely common.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 09, 2010, 03:19:26 PM
Didn't ZUN say the main reason why males don't do Danmaku fights is because their danmaku isn't beautiful enough or something on similar lines.
But can still perform Danmaku, am I right?

Going by that logic, we may see some soon enough, who's to say that there isn't be a male who has learned how to utilize the beauty of danmaku (hell that could probably even be his power; manipulation of beauty
lol Midboss
).
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 09, 2010, 04:03:24 PM
OkashiiNaito's post. Nuff said.

Have you read OkashiiNaito's post? So many double standards it's not even funny.
Quote from: ebarrett
And OkashiiNaito's post, while certainly not sexist, does have double standards. A sort of pack mentality, I-am-the-alpha-male reflex reaction. (edit: scratch that, should've looked up what a "bishonen" is before writing)

WHAT THE-?!

What did I do?! I tried my best to not come over as sexist or intolerant! I didn't even know what double-standard meant before all of this (and I'm still not to sure even after searching it up)! And I really can't see where the pack mentality and alpha-male notions can be picked up from my post, let alone what you mean by it.
I'm just saying that if bishonen, shonen or shotaro appear it might become prime bait for slash fangirls! Not explicitly yaoi (I put that in between caps after all), but straight slash. Why do I fear this oh so much? Two words:

Character Derailment.

I've seen it sooooo many times, it isn't funny any more! Fics and comics will appear matchin up these new male characters, boosting there powers and responsibilities to impossible proportions, dwarving the Gensokyo Top! Then these uber shonen's will be paired up with our favorite Touhous, and our beloved girls will be turned into helpless, weaker versions of themselves that need to cling onto their new boyfriends to get anything right, unable to take action themselves anymore in favor of their prince, with him appearing as the big damn hero. Every character will eventully be butchered into yamato nadeshiko's!
Sure. it'll first start with characters who slightly fit this role, like Alice, Parsee and Patchy. But soon it'll grow out of control. Marisa. Reimu. Remi. Mokou. YUUKA! All these strong independant characters will all fall victims to this, becoming mere shadows of their great, former selves, in favor of some overrated prissy boy!!!
This must never happen...

Never.Never.Never.Never.Never!
NEVEEEEEEEER!!!!!!!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 04:18:12 PM
._. I think you worry too much and have too little faith in the Touhou Fanbase. There may be a few who do that, but on the whole, I seriously doubt most Touhou fans are going to do any such thing.

Honestly, I'm more inclined to believe that most fanworks will probably depict any male character being made fun of by the majority of the female cast.

U Mad.

Lolno.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on February 09, 2010, 04:38:03 PM
Then these uber shonen's will be paired up with our favorite Touhous, and our beloved girls will be turned into helpless, weaker versions of themselves that need to cling onto their new boyfriends to get anything right, unable to take action themselves anymore in favor of their prince, with him appearing as the big damn hero. Every character will eventully be butchered into yamato nadeshiko's!
Sure. it'll first start with characters who slightly fit this role, like Alice, Parsee and Patchy. But soon it'll grow out of control. Marisa. Reimu. Remi. Mokou. YUUKA! All these strong independant characters will all fall victims to this, becoming mere shadows of their great, former selves, in favor of some overrated prissy boy!!!
This must never happen...
Well, I'm not into fanfics for several reasons, but from what I've seen there is already enough character derailment happening. You don't need a straight pairing to turn one (or both) of the respective characters into something awful. I mean, just look at Alice.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on February 09, 2010, 05:08:57 PM
Well, I'm not into fanfics for several reasons, but from what I've seen there is already enough character derailment happening. You don't need a straight pairing to turn one (or both) of the respective characters into something awful. I mean, just look at Alice.
This

Beside that, Rinnosuke.  There's already bait for those who object to the "Everyone's gay in Gensokyo" bit (With the exception of Rinnosuke/Youki something too horrifying to mention), so it's not like it would change too much.

And trust me there'd still be tonnes of lesbian fanarts.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 09, 2010, 05:16:42 PM
To  OkashiiNaito

That's the second reason for the big brother character. With my idea of the fanbase as is he would be safely paired off with his little sister character (who would be stronger than him, there is precedent for that) thus leaving the rest of the characters safe from him.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 09, 2010, 07:13:29 PM
This

Beside that, Rinnosuke.  There's already bait for those who object to the "Everyone's gay in Gensokyo" bit (With the exception of Rinnosuke/Youki something too horrifying to mention), so it's not like it would change too much.

And trust me there'd still be tonnes of lesbian fanarts.

don?t worry, in the doujin-games fandom exist really few yaoi fangirls. An example: In the Nazu Universe (Tsukihime,Fate Stay Night) can found a good group of males, who have all the needed for bait fans (oh, Archer...<3)...but no have lots of fanarts and doujins paired them. Same with Touhou: even after when the first draw of an handsome Youki appeared...i continue waiting for a doujin about it, even an insinuation (i only see joke ones with Bara,Yaranaika or the combination of this two XD) and i must conform with few draws and my own. An you need really a big imagination and be a bit eerie for found fujoshi baits in Touhou. (like me...don?t worry, im a fujoshi specie in danger XD)

if would exist more "normal" males in Gensokyo (no animals,creatures or floating names XD) probably the straight pairings will be more interesting (because the harem-harem can be bored) and the stories in the doujins maybe will turn more complex, for the masculine factor...and we can have more variety of situations, rivalities, facts of life, new comedy plots etc. suddenly i turn curious...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ghaleon on February 09, 2010, 07:32:41 PM
I find it funny how people think adding males would make things interesting because of the "pairing" potential. I mean Touhou is one of a kind, and we're all fans of this relatively niche phenominon. Why would changing it to become more like everything else make it MORE interesting. I just don't get it. But this is all a matter of taste. I just want to point out that the 3 males in Touhou do not qualify for my first post. 2 aren't humanoid for 1, those same two act like weapons/tools for their respective female, they never appear on their own, etc. Rinnosuke never even appears in a game.

Having a male added as a major character in an actual zun-made game would make a bigger male-oriented impact than those 3 combined I assure you. It would not be making the ratio 4:120ish from 3:120ish, it would be more like going from 0 to 1.

I expected some people would hate this change, some would tolerate it, and a few would like it, I totally didn't expect that so many want it, interesting.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 07:39:09 PM
I'm not saying I want it persay - like, oh, this MUST be in a future game. I'm just saying I would welcome it if it did happen. Because really, I can't imagine ZUN would add more than 2, at most, if any, so really, why would it be such a problem?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ghaleon on February 09, 2010, 07:49:34 PM
I'm not saying I want it persay - like, oh, this MUST be in a future game. I'm just saying I would welcome it if it did happen. Because really, I can't imagine ZUN would add more than 2, at most, if any, so really, why would it be such a problem?

Well the exact result of such a change can only be guessed. You figure that the ratio of male to female is so small they'd hardly be noticed. I on the other hand think that the guy has made nothing but females like 100 times in a row as major characters in his games, and apparently we love them. Why change what's not broken? It might not break it maybe not, but it has a greater chance of breaking it than adding more females at this point you know?

Where is the line that says you need this many males in Touhou so that it loses its dominating femininity. To me, that line is between 0 and 1. I understand people may think that line exists between two other numbers, so no point arguing about that. Of course, like I said, Zun already suprised me by making Touhou really cool as it is, perhaps he could suprise me again by adding a male that I enjoy and feel adds to the world of Gensokyo, who knows...I just would rather that chance not be taken if I had any say in it.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 09, 2010, 07:58:35 PM
Sounds like Naito's my reverse clone.

WHAT THE-?!

What did I do?! I tried my best to not come over as sexist or intolerant! I didn't even know what double-standard meant before all of this (and I'm still not to sure even after searching it up)! And I really can't see where the pack mentality and alpha-male notions can be picked up from my post, let alone what you mean by it.
I'm just saying that if bishonen, shonen or shotaro appear it might become prime bait for slash fangirls! Not explicitly yaoi (I put that in between caps after all), but straight slash. Why do I fear this oh so much? Two words:

Character Derailment.

I've seen it sooooo many times, it isn't funny any more! Fics and comics will appear matchin up these new male characters, boosting there powers and responsibilities to impossible proportions, dwarving the Gensokyo Top! Then these uber shonen's will be paired up with our favorite Touhous, and our beloved girls will be turned into helpless, weaker versions of themselves that need to cling onto their new boyfriends to get anything right, unable to take action themselves anymore in favor of their prince, with him appearing as the big damn hero. Every character will eventully be butchered into yamato nadeshiko's!
Sure. it'll first start with characters who slightly fit this role, like Alice, Parsee and Patchy. But soon it'll grow out of control. Marisa. Reimu. Remi. Mokou. YUUKA! All these strong independant characters will all fall victims to this, becoming mere shadows of their great, former selves, in favor of some overrated prissy boy!!!
This must never happen...

Never.Never.Never.Never.Never!
NEVEEEEEEEER!!!!!!!

1- Character Derailment is pretty much abundant in Touhou as it is, even without considering the yuri shit and whatnot (in fact most of the derailment COMES from the yuri).

2 -Alice to Marisa in fanworks. Words cannot describe how fucked up they made Alice once shit started going down between them. If anything Alice gets hit with Character derailment the most in this matter. How do you turn a normally cold-natured and aloof person into a lovesick, clingy pile of misplaced affection? Seriously. And don't even get me STARTED on other pairings that make little to no sense...

Even if we do have males in the series I'm going (hate having) to admit that the yuri fanart won't stop in the least. If anything folks will IGNORE the 1 or 2 males like they do the ones we have now and continue plugging shit into their fantasy. But really, I'm seeing that not everything revolves around the potential for pairings and what not, I want to visualize a Gensokyo where we have pretty much the same atmosphere now, only with a balance of both genders.

Me? I'd not only welcome it, I'd say I'd want to see it sometime soon, just to see how it would look like. Is part of this due to my vehement hatred for yuri in this series? Ehh, perhaps it is, but a majority of this is directed to me wanting to 'see something new' for a change rather than 'Oh look another loli with insane powers *yawn*'.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 09, 2010, 08:30:55 PM
._. I think you worry too much and have too little faith in the Touhou Fanbase. There may be a few who do that, but on the whole, I seriously doubt most Touhou fans are going to do any such thing.

Honestly, I'm more inclined to believe that most fanworks will probably depict any male character being made fun of by the majority of the female cast.
This

Beside that, Rinnosuke.  There's already bait for those who object to the "Everyone's gay in Gensokyo" bit (With the exception of Rinnosuke/Youki something too horrifying to mention), so it's not like it would change too much.

And trust me there'd still be tonnes of lesbian fanarts.
To  OkashiiNaito

That's the second reason for the big brother character. With my idea of the fanbase as is he would be safely paired off with his little sister character (who would be stronger than him, there is precedent for that) thus leaving the rest of the characters safe from him.

Perhaps, just perhaps your right. Alright, calm down Naito, blow off some steam. Repeat your mantra: Touhou isn't Naruto, Touhou isn't Bleach, Touhou isn't Death Note. It won't ever be ruined by something like this. It'll all end for the better...
It's just, while some of the current yuri pairings are absolute crack, in some way or another, you can almost always see it as funny or cute, because they're the Touhou Girls. I don't like yuri because of sexual excitement, but because the relationship between the characters can be become so adorable. That's why I usually don't want to see it beyond first base.
This cutesy theme just looks way harder to hold up if male characters pop up. If the males are relatively innocent and cute themselves maybe, just maybe, it'll be acceptable for me.
I just don't want to see respected Touhou characters degraded to nothingness because of male dominance. If I see something like that happen to the likes of the Old Maid Alliance I think I'd snap.

It'll be most fun if the comedy and cutesy basis was retained even if male characters entered the fray, like you said, Aeon. And I think that would be best retained with a big brother character, like shadow said. 'Cuz if Nanako and Sanji from Persona 4 are any indication, those relationships are just gosh darn adorable.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 09, 2010, 08:50:09 PM
Sounds like Naito's my reverse clone.

1- Character Derailment is pretty much abundant in Touhou as it is, even without considering the yuri shit and whatnot (in fact most of the derailment COMES from the yuri).

2 -Alice to Marisa in fanworks. Words cannot describe how fucked up they made Alice once shit started going down between them. If anything Alice gets hit with Character derailment the most in this matter. How do you turn a normally cold-natured and aloof person into a lovesick, clingy pile of misplaced affection? Seriously. And don't even get me STARTED on other pairings that make little to no sense...

Even if we do have males in the series I'm going (hate having) to admit that the yuri fanart won't stop in the least. If anything folks will IGNORE the 1 or 2 males like they do the ones we have now and continue plugging shit into their fantasy. But really, I'm seeing that not everything revolves around the potential for pairings and what not, I want to visualize a Gensokyo where we have pretty much the same atmosphere now, only with a balance of both genders.

Me? I'd not only welcome it, I'd say I'd want to see it sometime soon, just to see how it would look like. Is part of this due to my vehement hatred for yuri in this series? Ehh, perhaps it is, but a majority of this is directed to me wanting to 'see something new' for a change rather than 'Oh look another loli with insane powers *yawn*'.

This.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kanako Yasaka on February 09, 2010, 09:00:53 PM
I wouldn't care at all.
The characters just wouldn't be popular.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ramus on February 09, 2010, 10:02:03 PM
Funny thing, I've been having random ideas of a reverse Gensokyo set in the west with a bunch of males and a token female.  Still, while the sheer amount of females does keep that little "hidden away strange land" feeling, it's a bit over done.

Not to mention the tons of males off screen that we never see.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Xijiy on February 09, 2010, 10:04:26 PM
I would like to see males in touhou just because (as everyone else has said) it'd be nice to get a little variety into the games. Though I would hate to see what the fandom does to the poor male character that gets introduced. Something tells me they wouldn't paint him in a kind light.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Sen on February 10, 2010, 01:08:16 AM
Upon first seeing it, I'd probably go "oh, it's a guy, cool."

Halfway through the first spellcard I'd suddenly and be like "WHAT THE FUCK THAT'S A GUY" and then game over because I would be so stunned.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ~Yukari Yakumo~ on February 12, 2010, 03:21:09 AM
.....Men? In Touhou? Seriously? Besides Rinnosuke? They'd all gang up on me and the other Youkai! D=

It may be interesting to add like a few guys, but....eh. ._.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 12, 2010, 02:25:45 PM
I had a sudden realization. Touhou cosplaying for males is pretty hard thanks to the 99% female cast, with the only relatively possible cosplay for males being Rinnosuke, whose outfit is so complicated I get cross-eyed from merely looking at it. If more males appear in the series, they will be more cosplay possibilities for males without looking like cross-dressers!

GENIUS!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on February 12, 2010, 02:41:08 PM
1.
If you're a dude and want to do touhou cosplay without looking like a crosdresser, you can always try Mokou. Or Wriggle. Or Orange. Or Shou. Or Unzan.

2.
A huge part of the guys who cosplay male characters end up looking like crossdressers anywa- *shot*
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 12, 2010, 05:14:19 PM
Crossplay is wholly acceptable when dealing with Touhou. So adding males to the cast doesn't really help the relevance of Touhou cosplay for males.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kinzo the Astro Curious on February 12, 2010, 09:30:01 PM
To  OkashiiNaito

That's the second reason for the big brother character. With my idea of the fanbase as is he would be safely paired off with his little sister character (who would be stronger than him, there is precedent for that) thus leaving the rest of the characters safe from him.

Cirno's brother is not the strongest.  :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tonepoet on February 13, 2010, 02:07:02 AM
While a humanoid male character in Touhou would be an interesting for a change of pace, I'd have to seriously question the integrity of the series' setting after about a dozen games without ever really having one. If it wasn't executed perfectly, I'd probably default to disliking him just because the change would rip one of the more unique aspects away.

From the fandom in general, I imagine the utter disbelief in the community would be akin to that time in Azumanga Daioh where the class found out that Kimura had a wife. (A kind pretty one too at that.) It'd be total shell shock. Also, heaven forbid he be straight and fancy one of the already existent girls (including ones from the demo of his own game, if he's introduced in the later stages.) People would want him dead! XD
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 13, 2010, 02:08:53 AM
While a humanoid male character in Touhou would be an interesting for a change of pace, I'd have to seriously question the integrity of the series' setting after about a dozen games without ever really having one. If it wasn't executed perfectly, I'd probably default to disliking him just because the change would rip one of the more unique aspects away.

From the fandom in general, I imagine the utter disbelief in the community would be akin to that time in Azumanga Daioh where the class found out that Kimura had a wife. (A kind pretty one too at that.) It'd be total shell shock. Also, heaven forbid he be straight and fancy one of the already existent girls (including ones from the demo of his own game, if he's introduced in the later stages.) People would want him dead! XD

So basicaly he'd be Kaito? Poor sod suffers all the punishment of the Vocaloid fandom...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tonepoet on February 13, 2010, 03:10:37 AM
(Skims the wikipedia) You know, I was unaware that an in series character had a crush on Miku until now, since I'm not a Vocaloid fan per se but yeah, I'd presume it'd be more or less the same thing. The Touhou women do drive fans wild afterall. The Girl/Girl relationships work currently because they can either be perceived as unrealistically exaggerated, hot lesbian action or whatever other line of thought could be found fitting for the circumstance, dependent upon the individual fan's tastes. A guy however, would simply challenge whatever fantasies the fans have come up with, so a heterosexual male would simply spread Parsee's Syndrome amongst the fandom like it was the Bubonic Plague.

The only two ways I see a heterosexual male dodging the curtain-hatred is if he loved somebody the fans had absolutely no time to grow attached to or if he was simply a hound dog that never stood a chance to begin with, like Edgar of Final Fantasy VI or Brock from the Pokemon franchise. In the case of the latter option, the fans might actually even come to love him as a sympathetic character that they could live through vicariously: I kinda doubt it though.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 13, 2010, 03:30:03 AM
I'm almost afraid of the day ZUN brings forth a male character if only due to the way fandom will shit all over him once he debuts. I still don't understand why anyone is appealed by the way things are now (I've been trying to figure this out for a while now, but only found an answer in RAGE), but eh all I gotta say is; If I like it, fuck everyone else.

Still the idea of a male being Touhou's equivalent of Brock does sound like an amusing idea...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: dogseatfood on February 13, 2010, 03:41:36 AM
First reaction:  :barf:

Second reaction: :)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 13, 2010, 03:43:20 AM
I'm almost afraid of the day ZUN brings forth a male character if only due to the way fandom will shit all over him once he debuts. I still don't understand why anyone is appealed by the way things are now (I've been trying to figure this out for a while now, but only found an answer in RAGE), but eh all I gotta say is; If I like it, fuck everyone else.

Still the idea of a male being Touhou's equivalent of Brock does sound like an amusing idea...

'Touhou Brock' is indeed a hilarious notion. Might actually fit.

But Erebrus, let me show you why most people are appealed by the current status of Touhou:
- Most Touhou fans are lonely (most, not all).
- Most Touhou fans are male (I repeat most, not all).
- The Touhou girls appeal to them (and their fetishes).
Because of these three factors males in Touhou would be frowned upon, since they mostly aren't sought after by the fandom. It would slightly break the fantasy.
More points:
- One of the few game series with an all female cast, and that is special in and of itself. Adding males would remove some of Touhou's unique shine.
- There are more than enough all male cast series in existance. An all-female game series is a slight breather from the norm.
- It's been like this from the very beginning of the series. Changing it would cause confusion and rage.
- It's ZUN's series, he decides whatever the hell happens to it, and as far as I see he's going to keep it this way.

It amazes me you can cope with the series like this even though you don't like the current set up of the cast. Quite contradictive, no?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on February 13, 2010, 03:57:18 AM
- One of the few game series with an all female cast, and that is special in and of itself. Adding males would remove some of Touhou's unique shine.

No it isn't, and no it wouldn't. There are LOTS of all girl games in Japan. Probably created to offset the manliness of the Hokuto no Ken fighter.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: IcedFairy on February 13, 2010, 04:10:29 AM
- One of the few game series with an all female cast, and that is special in and of itself. Adding males would remove some of Touhou's unique shine.
Well, more correctly it's one of the few all girl games that doesn't fetishize the characters* in game.**  I think that's what I find interesting about it personally.

I wouldn't have a problem with seeing more male characters in print works.  In fact I was kind of surprised no male characters appeared in SSiB or any of the surrounding works.

* At least I don't think it does.  Maybe Zun art is throwing me off
**Fanworks on the other hand....
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 13, 2010, 04:13:14 AM
No it isn't, and no it wouldn't. There are LOTS of all girl games in Japan. Probably created to offset the manliness of the Hokuto no Ken fighter.

Fine then, but you have to admit they aren't as important and influential as Touhou. I still believe that adding to many males would destroy Touhous charm. And like IcedFairy stated, it hasn't a complete fetishised and over-sexualised basis and characters.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Coin Spire on February 13, 2010, 04:35:50 AM
Men would be nice in Touhou games.

EDIT: But...how would ZUN draw them?

But it would be fun if they all just go in a neutral stance, and no further. Let the fans do the pairings in their fanfics.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ghaleon on February 13, 2010, 04:36:57 AM
I'm almost afraid of the day ZUN brings forth a male character if only due to the way fandom will shit all over him once he debuts. I still don't understand why anyone is appealed by the way things are now (I've been trying to figure this out for a while now, but only found an answer in RAGE), but eh all I gotta say is; If I like it, fuck everyone else.

Still the idea of a male being Touhou's equivalent of Brock does sound like an amusing idea...

so basically, you think the current setup of touhou is dumb, and you want it to change so it fits your ideas of a better series? Don't you think the series should.. you know, cater to its fans than the people who dislike it? What the heck you a motk member for anyway if you don't know what is so great about Touhou? *boggle*
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: arcanesign on February 13, 2010, 04:56:05 AM
Since the thread is already four pages long I'm not sure if this has been said already, but...

Touhou Yaoi.

*cringe*

Although, like some other people mentioned, it's doable, like with Rinnosuke Morichika. Something with Youki Konpaku in it would be completely badass though.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 13, 2010, 05:03:26 AM
so basically, you think the current setup of touhou is dumb, and you want it to change so it fits your ideas of a better series? Don't you think the series should.. you know, cater to its fans than the people who dislike it? What the heck you a motk member for anyway if you don't know what is so great about Touhou? *boggle*
I didn't go and say that. Although change is good for something that's pretty much the same thing over and over, don't you think?

Maybe it's due to me losing touch with what's 'great' about Touhou, maybe it's because I'm a cholic bastard who doesn't know anything but RAGE BITCH KILL IT WITH FIRE, maybe I'm just bored, maybe it's all of the above?

However, I do know that it wasn't always like this and I used to be like 'everyone' else here, and loved Touhou to death. But, over time, I grew into the 'meh same ol' same ol' routine and kinda...fell out of it. When it comes to certain things, I don't like the same dish over and over again, it irritates and bores me and eventually leads to me leaving to go do something else.

If it's not gonna change and show me something interesting, then I'll find something else that will. Simple as that.

Also, there are folks here who don't mess around with Touhou, at least not as much as the average player does :V

Quote
It amazes me you can cope with the series like this even though you don't like the current set up of the cast. Quite contradictive, no?
It's fortunate that I'm a writer, otherwise I wouldn't have an outlet for the things that do please me in Touhou. Characters be damned, Gensokyo and the general mythos surrounding it interest me as a whole. I maybe displeased with whatever characters and blah blah blah, but I do want to see what else Gensokyo has to offer. What other regions are there to go to? Will we visit the undersea palace of Ryugu-jo anytime soon? Is there more beyond the Youkai Mountain? These questions are exactly why I 'cope' with what irks me about the series.

Sure the CAST isn't changing, but their world is...and with that I at least have something to look forward to when the next game arrives.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Slaves on February 13, 2010, 05:09:24 AM
Touhou Yaoi.

*cringe*

ever heard of brohou?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 13, 2010, 05:29:04 AM
Since the thread is already four pages long I'm not sure if this has been said already, but...

Touhou Yaoi.

*cringe*

Although, like some other people mentioned, it's doable, like with Rinnosuke Morichika. Something with Youki Konpaku in it would be completely badass though.

Ohh yes, Youki in a game.i want it so much...and he is a warrior, the danmaku play fits better in him than Rinnosuke, who is an intelectual and a kind of pacifist.(even if with training, have posibilities to be like Reimu (Abe no Seimei...Hanyou...))

And about the Touhou yaoi...nah, relax, because i think who will be very exclusive. I said this like fujoshi...the fangirl baits who i can found in Touhou are for a little group of fujoshis who likes "old time yaoi" or nanshoku, historical things, samurais,fundoshis and are more mature than the more young...and Touhou have a BIG male fandom, the girls are few and they are more normal or yuri-ish. Or angels, but in Japan, angels are seen more like girls than boys....(with exceptions...)
And personally, i don?t like how fangirls acts sometimes, like when hate female charas only because is loved for the guy who they likes pairing with other male chara...is silly XD

ever heard of brohou?

yes i wanted say that too XD (and Rinnosuko and Youkiko almost turn me les XD)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Coin Spire on February 13, 2010, 05:49:40 AM
Since the thread is already four pages long I'm not sure if this has been said already, but...

Touhou Yaoi.

*cringe*

It's best if it's taken only when it comes.

Although, like some other people mentioned, it's doable, like with Rinnosuke Morichika. Something with Youki Konpaku in it would be completely badass though.

And if it comes in a pair game like IN or SA, I'd love to see how the dialogue goes if Youki is paired with Yuyuko or Youmu.

Will he be a gung-ho master? A silent warrior? Or completely whack like Yukari?  :ohdear:
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on February 13, 2010, 06:15:55 AM
I wish ZUN would just throw in one more male so I can finally make a Touhou all-male foursome hentai doujin barbershop quartet. :(


Genji just ain't cutting it. >_>;

Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 13, 2010, 07:13:36 AM
I wish ZUN would just throw in one more male so I can finally make a Touhou all-male foursome hentai doujin barbershop quartet. :(


Genji just ain't cutting it. >_>;

hey, with imagination you can make a orgy choral group with ten charas (turning some ones in gijinkas) + ZUN. XD and even can turn Beer in a gijinka male and then we have a par number again n_n
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on February 13, 2010, 07:43:38 AM
and even can turn Beer in a gijinka male and then we have a par number again n_n

Hmmm~ That sounds like an idea~
Thank's for the inspiration, VIVI!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 13, 2010, 09:33:39 AM
How very immature that people are afraid of Touhou yaoi. =/ Not EVERYONE who likes yaoi is a "Rampant Yaoi Fangirl", as they have come to be known.

Besides, if ZUN adds one or two males, I ask again, HOW is there concern that it will really impact the series in any significant way?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ghaleon on February 13, 2010, 10:07:40 AM
How very immature that people are afraid of Touhou yaoi. =/ Not EVERYONE who likes yaoi is a "Rampant Yaoi Fangirl", as they have come to be known.

Besides, if ZUN adds one or two males, I ask again, HOW is there concern that it will really impact the series in any significant way?

How? Probably a large explosion followed by a mushroom cloud.

Seriously, nobody can tell you how. There are countless ways it could change the series significantly, just like it's possible it might not. The issue is that it creates lots of opportunities for bad changes to take place, and doesn't really offer anything good that an additional female character could probably give as well. I mean male characters in fictional stories and games are capable of contributing good things sure, but as I said before, it's a change, and most of us are perfectly happy with Touhou's current status.

To me, having nothing but females adds a certain goofy light-hearted charm to Touhou. I know men can be goofy, but the nature of Touhou's current goofiness isn't the same kind. I really can't explain it. It's possible Zun could create male characters that add to the goofy atmosphere in the same direction that it already goes, but I personally don't really see how it can be done. It's also possible that keeping it all-female keeps it from exiting niche status. I know that turns off alot of people form trying the game knowing that there are no males in the games. I doubt it, but maybe Zun likes keeping those people from trying it.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 13, 2010, 01:54:39 PM
How? Probably a large explosion followed by a mushroom cloud.

Seriously, nobody can tell you how. There are countless ways it could change the series significantly, just like it's possible it might not. The issue is that it creates lots of opportunities for bad changes to take place, and doesn't really offer anything good that an additional female character could probably give as well. I mean male characters in fictional stories and games are capable of contributing good things sure, but as I said before, it's a change, and most of us are perfectly happy with Touhou's current status.

To me, having nothing but females adds a certain goofy light-hearted charm to Touhou. I know men can be goofy, but the nature of Touhou's current goofiness isn't the same kind. I really can't explain it. It's possible Zun could create male characters that add to the goofy atmosphere in the same direction that it already goes, but I personally don't really see how it can be done. It's also possible that keeping it all-female keeps it from exiting niche status. I know that turns off alot of people form trying the game knowing that there are no males in the games. I doubt it, but maybe Zun likes keeping those people from trying it.

Well said, mate.

I don't think one extra male might cause a Touhou fandom implosion, but what I'm getting from many people on this thread is that they want to add a DOZEN new male characters at once.
THIS will cause a rage nuke.
THIS is what will upset the set up of the Touhou cast.
THIS is what I fear.
Just keep it at one new male, at most two. No more.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on February 13, 2010, 07:47:12 PM
I'd rather Rinnosuke or Youki show up, rather than some new guy. Alternately: Endboss Genji.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Jana on February 13, 2010, 07:54:13 PM
Following that line of thinking, some backstory on Unzan (in a written work) would be cool too. Since a nyuudou is supposed to be an enlightened spirit, maybe he'd share some backstory with Myouren..?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on February 13, 2010, 08:10:14 PM
Really, Genjii would be the best endboss. He could steal all of the green leafy vegetables, and then get in a crotchety old man lecture when you meet him and everything.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 14, 2010, 02:27:49 AM
=/ I haven;t gotten the vibe that people want several males at all.

Maybe it's just me, but I've just been assuming everyone here was talking about adding one or maybe two characters. I haven't seen a single, non-joking indication of adding an entire game-full of male characters.

And yeah, adding one new male character is not going to harm the fandom. Touhou can still remain a niche-status game with one more male character. If it can do that with Youki, Genji, Unzan, and Rinnosuke existing in the cast, then it can continue doing so with one new male.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Lloyd Dunamis on February 14, 2010, 03:21:04 AM
I'd rather Rinnosuke or Youki show up, rather than some new guy. Alternately: Endboss Genji.
^this. An echoing YES for Rinnosuke and/or Youki!

Case for new chara, as long as he's cute, I don't mind |3
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Sen on February 14, 2010, 04:16:53 AM
I haven't seen a single, non-joking indication of adding an entire game-full of male characters.

I would actually find it completely hilarious if Touhou 13 had an all-male cast.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on February 14, 2010, 04:55:15 AM
On the topic:
I wouldn't mind seeing one actually. He would have to be the endbosses butler character though. And his abilities have to be based on strategy alone. Those are my requirements.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 14, 2010, 04:57:31 AM
On the topic:
I wouldn't mind seeing one actually. He would have to be the endbosses butler character though. And his abilities have to be based on strategy alone. Those are my requirements.
why im thinking in Sebastian the Black Butler!!?? XD (I WANT)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on February 14, 2010, 08:07:48 AM
(http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/8175/kaimisc.png)

This will be the first humanoid male touhou boss. He will be a fifth boss.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on February 14, 2010, 05:10:34 PM
When I say "butler character" I don't mean butler. I mean a Youmu X Yuyuko type thing.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kilgamayan on February 15, 2010, 03:05:48 PM
What's all this then? We already have Wriggle, Mokou, Shou and Nue.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on February 15, 2010, 03:12:00 PM
They lack the mustache and manly brow that my example above provides. They, thus, do not count.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Patorikku on February 15, 2010, 05:26:45 PM
Wriggle is indeed questionable, Mokou has breasts, Shou has some bustiness and a dress of sorts, and Nue has a small dress with thigh highs and breasts. If anything, Murasa would be a better example than Shou and Nue, but overall, they don't count.

In the end, we need shotas. /thread
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on February 15, 2010, 05:57:53 PM
(http://img196.imageshack.us/img196/8175/kaimisc.png)

This will be the first humanoid male touhou boss. He will be a fifth boss.

We can only hope, Purvis.



And I'm still convinced that Shou is a male.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 20, 2010, 05:29:16 PM
Last night I came to a conclusion. Danmaku isn't really all that manly. When I thought of all the characters in Touhou that could be considered to be "badass" I realized that all or at least most of them fired something other than your standard shiny bullets be they a ton of knives, an anchor, fire, or a humungoid death laser.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on February 20, 2010, 07:18:28 PM
Last night I came to a conclusion. Danmaku isn't really all that manly. When I thought of all the characters in Touhou that could be considered to be "badass" I realized that all or at least most of them fired something other than your standard shiny bullets be they a ton of knives, an anchor, fire, or a humungoid death laser.

Soooo.....you still think they're badass? You're not making any sense here.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Mounting Jaggis on February 20, 2010, 07:21:27 PM
I think he said that Touhous that can be considered badass shoot things other than the standard bullet. Like Sakuya, Murasa, Unzan, Utsuho, etc.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 20, 2010, 07:46:32 PM
I think he said that Touhous that can be considered badass shoot things other than the standard bullet. Like Sakuya, Murasa, Unzan, Utsuho, etc.
bingo.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 20, 2010, 08:12:31 PM
=/ I haven;t gotten the vibe that people want several males at all.

Maybe it's just me, but I've just been assuming everyone here was talking about adding one or maybe two characters. I haven't seen a single, non-joking indication of adding an entire game-full of male characters.


Take another good look. I spotted at least three people on this thread explicitly saying that they want a game with an entire boss cast of males. That's automatically SEVEN males, maybe eight if the game has an phantasm stage. That's a whole lot more than just one or two!

VIVI, N-Forza and SenSageUn all want an all-male cast for an upcoming game! I'm getting even slight vibes of this from Erebrus and Ramus!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hieda no Aya on February 20, 2010, 08:58:30 PM
Re: danmaku not being manly, come to think of it, Perfect Memento did say that the main reason Spell Card duels tend to use danmaku is that it appeals to women and youkai. Maybe we just never see guys because they don't care for bullet hell, eh?

I'd take issue with treating "manly" as interchangable with "badass", though. ;)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 20, 2010, 09:03:37 PM
Take another good look. I spotted at least three people on this thread explicitly saying that they want a game with an entire boss cast of males. That's automatically SEVEN males, maybe eight if the game has an phantasm stage. That's a whole lot more than just one or two!

VIVI, N-Forza and SenSageUn all want an all-male cast for an upcoming game! I'm getting even slight vibes of this from Erebrus and Ramus!

I honestly could care less on how many males show up; just as long as I have at least one that'll show up to give me a decent surprise for once. Although, I lean more into wanting one playable than having it as a boss, but I'm sure the fanbase would be all "Fuck that."

...It'sreally quite frustrating when you have such varying opinions and tastes compared to everyone else >_>
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 20, 2010, 09:23:04 PM
Perhaps it might not be such a big deal if this new male character explicitly had the power to change gender at will. But then we wouldn't be sure if his/her original form is male or female.

And it might provide some new fandom jokes and doujin ideas.

Oh, wait, we already have Shingyoko.... An expy of him/her/it might still be possible though (atleast if you believe Byakuren, Remilia, Meiling and Kaguya are expies of respectively Shinki, Mai, Orange and Kotohime).
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ebarrett on February 20, 2010, 09:42:29 PM
Here's hoping ZUN trolls his "fanbase" and puts a few male characters in the next games. With luck that'll alienate a good bunch of the creepier "fans". Even if it might bring some new, different weirdos.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 20, 2010, 09:52:02 PM
Here's hoping ZUN trolls his "fanbase" and puts a few male characters in the next games. With luck that'll alienate a good bunch of the creepier "fans". Even if it might bring some new, different weirdos.

I really don't see what's so creepy about the fanbase's liking to the current state of affairs.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Toasty on February 20, 2010, 09:54:30 PM
I really don't see what's so creepy about the fanbase's liking to the current state of affairs.

Last I checked, the creepy ones were a minority, and on 2ch, so yeah :|

Also, full support for toubrohou 13.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Moerin on February 20, 2010, 09:58:41 PM
Even if it might bring some new, different weirdos.

Nope, we're already here~

I for one would love to see a full male cast in Touhou 13, even if I know it's not going to happen.  Especially if they're all traps~ Ahem.  But it'd be refreshing to have something different for once.  Or hell, even just one or two males would be nice to see... I was actually a bit disappointed when I found out the the final boss of UFO was originally supposed to be Myouren.  It was like ZUN was too scared of doing something different this time around... But I digress~
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Esifex on February 21, 2010, 01:50:58 AM
lol first page quote shows how far I got

...call me crazy, but I think that at some point the matter of men not being seen as combat-worthy will actually be a plot point in a future Touhou game...

I'm banking on that fact for my story - that men are just terrible at using danmaku. It'd kind of make sense, too, since the ones saving the world Gensokyo most of the time are a couple of teenage (if even that) girls.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 21, 2010, 02:30:10 AM
lol first page quote shows how far I got

I'm banking on that fact for my story - that men are just terrible at using danmaku. It'd kind of make sense, too, since the ones saving the world Gensokyo most of the time are a couple of teenage (if even that) girls.

Or maybe the males are having their own battles and adventures while the girls are busy. Perhaps while Reimu and friends were busy making sure the moon festival went as planned, a wizard from the Magic Forest was duking it out with Remilia's daddy. While Reimu faced Kanako and Suwako a warrior was wrestling with Zeus and Thor. While Marisa was in a Beam-O-War with Utsuho a ninja was taking down a steampunk mech. I could go on with this for quite some time.

This gives me another theory, one with a comparison that'll probably make several of the MotK thirst for my blood.
*equips armor blessed by every pantheon and Shinki, hides in a bunker and makes sure no one knows his whereabouts*
In the My Little Pony cartoons (Or So I Heard. I've never watched it myself and I know jack shit about it besides this, which I read in an article) the male ponies travel the world, while the females keep living in their cutesy land of fluff and magic. The males haven't been there for eons, and people have been theorising the ponies just survive by parthenogenesis until the males get back.

What if a same situation is going on in Gensokyo? But replace 'parthenogenesis' with 'having impossibly long life spans'. Male youkai and Gods are fighting or traveling outside of Gensokyo, relying on their own abilities to survive in this magic-less world. They probably have ulterior motives for this, like getting rid of the thing that is causing the decline of magic (Ancient Evil? Power hungry sorcerer organization? The Hebrew God?). Only every few hundred years do they get back home to rest, get some family time and perhaps give some lovin', ensuring a new generation of youkai. After that they set out on their quest again.
Hmmm... now I'm wondering if various Touhous are already married...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Esifex on February 21, 2010, 03:45:05 AM
Well, apparently Suwako is the first confirmed non-virgin in the game, whatwith Sanae being her granddaughter.

Although, being a Goddess, that all sort of loses its definition in the laws of physics and becomes incredibly vague and grainy around the edges.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Lloyd Dunamis on February 21, 2010, 04:04:50 AM
I'm banking on that fact for my story - that men are just terrible at using danmaku. It'd kind of make sense, too, since the ones saving the world Gensokyo most of the time are a couple of teenage (if even that) girls.
One probable reason is because men would have themselves as their hitbox, heheh xD *thought*

Also, a male navi or navi-like (referring to SA) could be nice, methinks :3
... oh wait, Ace Combat has them, also Touhou Soccer.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: IcedFairy on February 21, 2010, 04:14:26 AM
now I'm wondering if various Touhous are already married...
The Watatsuki sisters are married to relatives of Eirin.  One of the two reasons I'm somewhat surprised that no males appeared in SSiB.  Though I imagine those are arranged marriages.

As for the rest of Gensoukyo?  I imagine some species of youkai have very different views on how romantic relationships work then humans.  Gods might have odd views as well.

My theory as to the gender imbalance is that it's just natural for youkai.  A lot of the humanoid youkai types are female in the old stories.  Especially ghosts and trickster spirits.  When the non humanoid types started assuming humanoid forms they gravitated towards female ones as well.  Toss in a lunar war causing a lot of casualties and the ratio of male to female youkai is probably pretty skewed outside of the Tengu Oni and Kappa populations. 

Youkai don't work off of biology, they work off of belief.  And if the populace believes women are more likely to be witches and ghosts, and that demons are more likely to assume female form you're going to end up with some odd demographical quirks.

Of course this is vastly overthinking it.  I'm not drunk enough to know the truth as ZUN sees it.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on February 21, 2010, 05:44:39 AM
The Watatsuki sisters are married to relatives of Eirin.  One of the two reasons I'm somewhat surprised that no males appeared in SSiB.  Though I imagine those are arranged marriages.
Yeah, I had a theory that marriages on the Moon are political/arranged/"for procreation," and that the children are mostly raised by "the system" until they reach the age at which Lunarians stop aging (which I've also theorized is "the point when the brain stops developing" at around 23). I just got the impression that familial bonds aren't particularly strong. But I digress ...

And I stand by my previous "What, Unzan doesn't count?"
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 21, 2010, 06:18:14 AM

VIVI, N-Forza and SenSageUn all want an all-male cast for an upcoming game! I'm getting even slight vibes of this from Erebrus and Ramus!

exactly i said who want a parallel game, no exactly a Touhou 13 but related to the Touhou universe...
im very curious to know how is the life to the Gensokian males, the "normal" ones i said (no the excentric ones like Kourin, he is special XD)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on February 21, 2010, 11:49:20 AM
=/ Even still, with those opinions brought to my attention, I still feel that the nay-sayers are overreacting. Statements like "It'll ruin the series" are not what I'd call even hypothetically accurate.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 21, 2010, 11:59:13 AM
Actually one thing to remember is that Youkai don't reproduce like humans do. For example animal Youkai like Mystia or Tewi probably had parents that were non-sentient animals. Tsukumogami like Kogasa or medicine don't even need parents, they were originally objects.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on February 21, 2010, 02:55:41 PM
im very curious to know how is the life to the Gensokian males, the "normal" ones i said (no the excentric ones like Kourin, he is special XD)
This. This would be very interesting to see.

Yeah we ALL know what the females do, but what about the males?

Yes I know, Naito said something about them running around the world with their own adventures, but that honestly rubs me the wrong way for some reason
...probably because it's a My Little Pony reference
. I honestly think that there are males are in Gensokyo, albeit overlooked due to "lol we want more lolis".
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 21, 2010, 02:58:23 PM
This. This would be very interesting to see.

Yeah we ALL know what the females do, but what about the males?

Yes I know, Naito said something about them running around the world with their own adventures, but that honestly rubs me the wrong way for some reason
...probably because it's a My Little Pony reference
. I honestly think that there are males are in Gensokyo, albeit overlooked due to "lol we want more lolis".

I repeat, the youkai and Gods travel the world, not the normal humans and lesser spirits/youkai. They just hang out in Gensokyo, doing normal jobs and following ordinary lives.
And I never watched that show myself...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on February 21, 2010, 10:20:22 PM
...probably because it's a My Little Pony reference
.
uh, i know another (in reverse) example XD.
The Smurfs... one Smurfette and a loli ginger for all 99 (or 100) male smurfs XD
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on February 22, 2010, 07:41:01 PM
lol first page quote shows how far I got

I'm banking on that fact for my story - that men are just terrible at using danmaku. It'd kind of make sense, too, since the ones saving the world Gensokyo most of the time are a couple of teenage (if even that) girls.
If the men of Gensokyo use a different combat method that would explain Meiling a bit better. She would have to deter intruders of both sexes and thus would have to be capable in both forms of combat and thus not that specialized in Danmaku.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on February 22, 2010, 10:03:23 PM
Women use danmaku. Men use kung-fu!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Moerin on February 22, 2010, 10:06:08 PM
So hermaphrodites use danmakufu~?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on February 22, 2010, 10:12:48 PM
(http://i174.photobucket.com/albums/w88/KimikoMuffin/muffinhoratio1.jpg)
Women use danmaku.

(http://i174.photobucket.com/albums/w88/KimikoMuffin/muffinhoratio2.jpg)
Men use kung-fu!

(http://i174.photobucket.com/albums/w88/KimikoMuffin/muffinhoratio3.jpg)
So hermaphrodites use danmakufu~?

(http://i174.photobucket.com/albums/w88/KimikoMuffin/miami-yeah.jpg) (http://www.epiconeliner.com)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on February 22, 2010, 10:46:55 PM
If the men of Gensokyo use a different combat method that would explain Meiling a bit better. She would have to deter intruders of both sexes and thus would have to be capable in both forms of combat and thus not that specialized in Danmaku.

That can't be right. Reimu created the spellcard system explicitly to give everyone an equal fighting chance and to make sure some idiotic youkai doesn't kill her off, causing the destruction of the Hakurei Border. Spellcard battles are performed via danmaku, so males have to do danmaku too, or else they'd break the battle rules of Gensokyo. And men can't avoid fighting Reimu forever.

Oh, wait, the fighter games also have the spellcard system and that one does involve physical combat. Males could use a different form of dueling after all, prefering physical combat over danmaku patterns.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hieda no Aya on February 23, 2010, 12:51:07 AM
Like I said on the last page. Akyuu pretty much said that Spell Card battles tend to use danmaku because women (and youkai) like danmaku, which is why other forms of fighting don't catch on as well.

Of course, come to think of it, that's sort of the same reasoning from the other direction; it starts from the position that the tastes of women (and youkai) are the ones that matter, which could point to the expectation that women are the ones who do the fighting. But, then, I guess the Spell Card system and the current module of incident resolution were created by women and youkai, so they get to pick the rules. Heh heh, maybe the real reason we don't see Gensokyo's dudes is cause they'd just rather stay out of it altogether.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Mr_Bob on February 23, 2010, 11:11:43 AM
It is also interesting to consider what manipulations/occupations male characters would take up.
An engineer who fights in a spaceship would be a throwback to Evil Eye Sigma, and would be another shocker to have mechs fightin' lolis in Touhou.
Carpenters would be an intersting way to explore ideas for Wood Sign spell cards, jewelcutters could have some down right beautiful Earth Sign cards, and
architects could have a lot of Kogome, Kogome reminiscent variations.
Male or female doesn't matter gameplay-wise, the patterns are what haunt you, not the characters.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Solais on February 23, 2010, 11:25:50 AM
Gensokyo's men are always in the local knife thrower drinking beer and ranting 'bout how their wives doesn't want to have sex at nights because they've got headaches from the incident solving and youkai exterminating.

Touhou 13 will be about a Manimist Movement, the Last Boss will be Al Bundy.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on March 02, 2010, 04:22:16 AM
Sudden idea: Ryoshima Taro who apears as an adorable shota when you fight him, but in the ending he is a MANLY OLD MAN because the magic keeping him young wore off and Japan is sniggering at us behind our backs because we didn't see the ending and still draw him as a shota
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tempest on March 03, 2010, 02:35:41 PM
As long there is no character that makes me think of Raiden, ok. And as long they're as rare as they are now.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: fatfree on March 03, 2010, 03:34:48 PM
Kratos would make a nice add to the residents of Gensokyo.
I can see it now. Having killed off the gods of Olympus, reality warps around him and he finds himself in Gensokyo.



 :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 03, 2010, 03:51:47 PM
Kratos would make a nice add to the residents of Gensokyo.
I can see it now. Having killed off the gods of Olympus, reality warps around him and he finds himself in Gensokyo.



 :V

All divine beings in Gensokyo should hide far, far away in that case....
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tempest on March 03, 2010, 05:07:36 PM
All divine beings in Gensokyo should hide far, far away in that case....
Oh God Kratos.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 03, 2010, 06:52:14 PM
You know how there's only one dragon? That one dragon should be a shota.

Totally.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Moerin on March 03, 2010, 06:56:22 PM
Whenever I see the name Kratos, I always think of ToP rather than GoW.  And to be honest, I'd prefer to see that one, ufufu~

You know how there's only one dragon? That one dragon should be a shota.

Totally.

I like the way you think.  Especially if he's a shota trap~<3  Um... Ahem.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 03, 2010, 09:42:42 PM
You know how there's only one dragon? That one dragon should be a shota.

Totally.
We already have someone who's totally a dragon, sorry.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 03, 2010, 09:43:39 PM
We already have someone who's totally a dragon, sorry.

What? Who?

I must have severe memory loss.....
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 03, 2010, 09:51:36 PM
HONG!
MEI!
LING!!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 03, 2010, 09:56:58 PM
I support Shota Dragon.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 03, 2010, 10:03:12 PM
HONG!
MEI!
LING!!


IS NOT!!!!
A DRAGON!!!!!


Hong is awesome. But she isn't a one of a kind cataclysmic ultra being. I've heard this discussion a shitload, but Hong is

NOT

A

DRAGON!

I like the way you think.  Especially if he's a shota trap~<3  Um... Ahem.

Ehhhhh........Only a very minor trap. Very subtle.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Alice Fact on March 03, 2010, 10:09:42 PM
if it was done right it'd actually be alright but everyone would fucking hate just the idea, period

REIMU'S GOD IS A FUCKING THUNDER DRAGON

NAMED MIYAMOTO

MAYBE.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 03, 2010, 10:11:24 PM
if it was done right it'd actually be alright but everyone would fucking hate just the idea, period

REIMU'S GOD IS A FUCKING THUNDER DRAGON

NAMED MIYAMOTO

MAYBE.


What. If it was a thunder dragon, I'd be out of business!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 03, 2010, 10:16:10 PM
if it was done right it'd actually be alright but everyone would fucking hate just the idea, period

REIMU'S GOD IS A FUCKING THUNDER DRAGON

NAMED MIYAMOTO

MAYBE.


Can this Thunder Dragon summon a super powered Italian plumber, a courgeous elf hero, a great ape and a squadron of furry space fighters?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 04, 2010, 04:07:11 PM
Kratos in Gensokyo should be funded. That's all I'm going to say.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 04, 2010, 08:01:49 PM
IS NOT!!!!
A DRAGON!!!!!


Hong is awesome. But she isn't a one of a kind cataclysmic ultra being. I've heard this discussion a shitload, but Hong is

NOT

A

DRAGON!

Ehhhhh........Only a very minor trap. Very subtle.

Hmmmm.... she may not be the/a real dragon... but there might be a possibility she's a weaker subspecies. A Wyvernn or Wyrm perhaps?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on March 04, 2010, 09:19:15 PM
No, she isn't. At all. She's just a youkai with Street Fighter moves. That's all. :|
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 04, 2010, 10:02:55 PM
I thought ZUN said something about her being a Dragon a while back?

Or was he just fucking with us
like always.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 04, 2010, 10:14:11 PM
I thought ZUN said something about her being a Dragon a while back?

Post this, Muffin, and I will take back everything I ever said and will eat my own heart.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 04, 2010, 11:26:58 PM
I honestly don't see Meiling as a dragon (her kung-foolery be damned). Saying that she's a dragon...just seems rather stupid in my opinion.

You mean to tell me that something like this (http://www.majhost.com/gallery/OwlBear1337/Comix/07ef9c41758753e96c1d80be07561f89.png) has been under our nose the entire time? I mean...I don't see it making any sense, especially considering that Dragons are pretty high up in ranking amoung youkai and suddenly saying Meiling is THAT powerful just blows everything out of whack. Hell, if Meiling were THAT powerful, why the fuck would she need to be gaurding a crapshack like the Scarlet Devil Mansion AND take shit from Sakuya no less? If anything she could have her own fine ass mansion in the mountains somewhere, plus legions of youkai followers as well.

I dunno, that's just me.

Anyway, my obvious distaste of this aside, I do remember hearing somewhere that ZUN confirmed her as being a Dragon or something...I need a valid source on this though, so...anyone got a verdict on this?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Byakuren Hijiri on March 04, 2010, 11:48:44 PM
''Her race remains unconfirmed, but she's commonly associated with dragons due to her many shared motifs with them, such as her use of rainbows, hat, and name, and possible inspiration by the Chinese Hong. This is most prevalent during depictions of her theoretical EX mode in which she often adopts dragon characteristics. '' Touhou Wikia
Does not HAVE to be true.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 05, 2010, 12:57:05 AM
So she draws power from dragons. Simple answer.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Chainsaw Guitar on March 05, 2010, 04:52:24 AM
Hell, if Meiling were THAT powerful, why the fuck would she need to be gaurding a crapshack like the Scarlet Devil Mansion AND take shit from Sakuya no less? If anything she could have her own fine ass mansion in the mountains somewhere, plus legions of youkai followers as well.

Taking what shit from Sakuya now? wait, don't tell me you think that shitty fanon joke is canon... :/
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on March 05, 2010, 10:12:29 AM
The only thing to support Sakuya abusing Meiling is the respective win quotes against each other in the fighters, and even those don't have to be interpreted that way.

On the other hand, the only thing supporting Meiling being a dragon is the "long" star on her cap, which stands against a high number of reasons for us to believe that Meiling is not a dragon, including there being no implication anywhere whatsoever that she is actually a being of cataclysmic power and Akyu stating explicitly that there were no dragons seen in Gensokyo since the creation of the Hakurei border, yet having a regular article on Meiling. And, really, if Meiling was a dragon, either Yukari, Suika or Iku would remark something that points in that direction. At least one of them would definitely notice, but they don't.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 05, 2010, 03:37:08 PM
Maybe ZUN meant with that 'confirmation' that Meiling that Meiling is indeed a dragon, but perhaps she doesn't know HERSELF that she is one. She may have been sealed in this form with severely weakened powers for a very long time, with her memories removed too.

Or maybe she's just a simple avatar for the Dragon God who was too lazy to keep up a Shrine and just went with a simpler job....
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 05, 2010, 06:42:13 PM
Maybe ZUN meant with that 'confirmation' that Meiling that Meiling is indeed a dragon, but perhaps she doesn't know HERSELF that she is one. She may have been sealed in this form with severely weakened powers for a very long time, with her memories removed too.

Or maybe she's just a simple avatar for the Dragon God who was too lazy to keep up a Shrine and just went with a simpler job....

So now 3 characters from EoSD have a chance of minor amnesia?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Shizzo on March 06, 2010, 08:13:26 PM
So now 3 characters from EoSD have a chance of minor amnesia?

"Wait, I have a library?!"

"I didn't remember my house beeing teleportated.."

"Why am I here in the basement, again?"

Yay, now they are 6! :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Sen on March 07, 2010, 06:09:49 AM
Well getting back on topic, only a week left until the game's release!

EDIT: Shit, wrong thread, how did I confuse this with the TH13 thread.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on March 07, 2010, 09:18:15 AM
Since youkai can control how they look, maybe Male touhous wouldn't be so cute?
Danmaku is all about being pretty so maybe since guys don't play danmaku that often Male youkai don't have to worry about being cute, so they look more like monsters.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 07, 2010, 12:41:30 PM
Since youkai can control how they look, maybe Male touhous wouldn't be so cute?
Danmaku is all about being pretty so maybe since guys don't play danmaku that often Male youkai don't have to worry about being cute, so they look more like monsters.

Alternatively:
All the males turned into females with their appearance control to be beautiful/cute enough to effectively use danmaku.

Wriggle may very well actually be a guy, only shapeshifted. Female fireflies can't fly afterall, while Wriggle, a supposedly female firefly, clearly can :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 07, 2010, 12:51:09 PM
Since youkai can control how they look, maybe Male touhous wouldn't be so cute?
Danmaku is all about being pretty so maybe since guys don't play danmaku that often Male youkai don't have to worry about being cute, so they look more like monsters.
That's what I'd think. Most of the more monstrous of gensokyo are the male variants who don't wish to take on the form of the others in order to use danmaku. If this were the case, I'd see them as relying on crazy youkai strength (exaggeration) instead of the danmaku way of fighting. Come to think of it; it's actually rather hard to picture a male youkai using danmaku in all honesty...unless you count mouth lasers or kamahamahadou's as danmaku.

Them being incapable of danmaku can be another route, but the latter seems to fit a bit better for some reason.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Moerin on March 07, 2010, 01:47:58 PM
Wriggle may very well actually be a guy, only shapeshifted.
(http://i45.tinypic.com/rjqm9d.jpg)

Ahem... And of course everyone who took part in the events of EoSD has amnesia~  It explains why none of them remember her...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 07, 2010, 02:08:07 PM
(http://i45.tinypic.com/rjqm9d.jpg)

Oh come on Moerin, no need to kill someone just because they claim your romantic interest isn't your sexual preference.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Moerin on March 07, 2010, 02:12:12 PM
Quote
Moerin
Quote
sexual preference.

...Huh?

Really, I just find the "LOL WRIGGLE IS A GUY!" jokes rather grating.  And I kinda have a thing for tomboys, so... Yeah~
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 07, 2010, 02:21:20 PM
Leave it to people to totally fuck up an androgynous character. That single joke alone is why I can't stand Wriggle as a character anymore.

I don't think Naoto ever got it this bad, did she?

Then again, she had her gender stated out right as it is, so I suppose that nulls the chance of it reaching the same level as 'Wriggle is a guy lol' bullshitery.

*I say Naoto because she's the only other androgynous character I've experienced in my gaming experiences.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 07, 2010, 04:00:35 PM
...Huh?

Really, I just find the "LOL WRIGGLE IS A GUY!" jokes rather grating.  And I kinda have a thing for tomboys, so... Yeah~
Leave it to people to totally fuck up an androgynous character. That single joke alone is why I can't stand Wriggle as a character anymore.

I don't think Naoto ever got it this bad, did she?

Then again, she had her gender stated out right as it is, so I suppose that nulls the chance of it reaching the same level as 'Wriggle is a guy lol' bullshitery.

*I say Naoto because she's the only other androgynous character I've experienced in my gaming experiences.

Geeze, settle down, a joke is a joke. Fine I'll take back what I said. But you have to admit,: the fact that Wriggle sports a wing-like cape and can fly is a curious fact. Like I said, female fireflies don't have wings and can't fly. They remain in a form that ressembles their larval state. Actually, I found a Wriggle song that actually discussed this point. In the song Wriggle wished she was more girlish and couldn't fly, like normal female fireflies. She sung the song in a high, pretty voice, until the end, where Wriggle failed to reach a high note and then started coughing with a far more boyish voice, indicating she was forcefully changing her voice.
I prefer Wriggle as 100% girl too, but come on, there's no fun in anything if you can't joke about it.

There are lots of game characters who suffer the same point, like Birdo and Vivian. They are now commonly accepted as female, yet jokes still fly about. Everyone knows these characters are female by now, and nobody truly believes they're male, but gags about it will keep coming none the less. You can't really stop it, so there's no point in arguing over it. Bridget from Guilty Gear has the same problem, only with the opposite gender...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Sen on March 07, 2010, 04:08:51 PM
ZUN admitted to being drunk during part of IN's development, I don't think he really paid too much attention to the fact that female fireflies can't fly :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on March 07, 2010, 05:38:14 PM
ZUN admitted to being drunk during part of IN's development, I don't think he really paid too much attention to the fact that female fireflies can't fly :V

but Wriggle is a youkai female firefly...and youkai have strong powers...and can fly XD

That's what I'd think. Most of the more monstrous of gensokyo are the male variants who don't wish to take on the form of the others in order to use danmaku. If this were the case, I'd see them as relying on crazy youkai strength (exaggeration) instead of the danmaku way of fighting. Come to think of it; it's actually rather hard to picture a male youkai using danmaku in all honesty...unless you count mouth lasers or kamahamahadou's as danmaku.

Them being incapable of danmaku can be another route, but the latter seems to fit a bit better for some reason.

that is the thing who i imagined when draw them. How youkai have shapeshift powers, they have "combat danmaku mode" (monster like, for scary and power) and a normal mode (like demons,animals,spirits,etc) who can be a real contrast to their combat form (more terrorific monster mode,then very handsome normal humanized mode) more powerful, more beautiful. And i talk about of a strange beauty, no human like. This can fear too. (probably this is the cause because Kourin no lives with humans: he fears them because he lives for a long time without get old, and look eerie,always young and bishie...)
But probably males no are interested in danmaku (remember Rinnosuke, for example) because they are more warriors than magicians (well, all have a little part of youkai blood) and their magical strength are used for defend the territory, meanwhile girls do the same but in the spiritual side.This no means who they can?t do danmaku, only who no want. XD (maybe male childs do, only for fun)

that is a least the thing who i imagined XD

about Meiling...i read a legend about who all chinese people are descendants of a dragon god, that is why she have dragon related powers, is her heritage.

Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on March 07, 2010, 05:39:26 PM
Leave it to people to totally fuck up an androgynous character. That single joke alone is why I can't stand Wriggle as a character anymore.

I don't think Naoto ever got it this bad, did she?

Then again, she had her gender stated out right as it is, so I suppose that nulls the chance of it reaching the same level as 'Wriggle is a guy lol' bullshitery.

*I say Naoto because she's the only other androgynous character I've experienced in my gaming experiences.

some fireflies, in their mating moment, come in great numbers and confuse males with females, for their smell. or something like that.

Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 07, 2010, 07:07:39 PM
Yeah. Female fireflies can't fly, but neither can cats or wolves or rabbits or, frankly, humans. Using "this Touhou character can fly" as evidence for anything is like using "this Touhou character can shoot danmaku" or "this Touhou character can breathe."
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Solais on March 07, 2010, 08:54:36 PM
I dunno about wolves or rabbits, but humans can fly with airplanes, and there are some winged cats in Ukraine, so yeah.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 07, 2010, 10:21:49 PM
Wolpertingers have wings, but they're a mythological creature and not really noted to utilize flight that often (if at all).

And since when were there flying cats?

Link/pic or I call bullshit.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Recon 5 on March 07, 2010, 10:29:33 PM
Personally, I would fully accept any male characters that ZUN himself introduces simply because I trust him to be drunk enough to make them fit. Ascended OCs are a BIG NO and I wouldn't even accept them in a position similar to Meimu/Ex-Rumia/ etc., much less in an official game.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 07, 2010, 10:36:14 PM
Ascended OCs
I'm afraid I don't understand what you're talking about...

You mean, like Buront or other characters?

*Using him as an example.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Recon 5 on March 07, 2010, 10:54:07 PM
I meant OCs that have become a major fixture of fanon. Buront isn't popular enough yet as far as I can see.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 08, 2010, 02:57:30 AM
Have any OCs become a "major fixture of fanon"?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Paul Debrion on March 08, 2010, 06:04:25 AM
I suppose men in Touhou would be ok. I think the problem would be trying to introduce them well without making them seem too much out of place.

On the other hand, maybe it would be better if they did seem strange and out of place. I have to admit that I've thought would be interesting if Zun were to suddenly introduce a male boss and use a lot of crazy gimmicks in his attacks to make fighting him seem different from the girls.

Like I said, female fireflies don't have wings and can't fly. They remain in a form that ressembles their larval state.

This is true for some fireflies, but it doesn't apply to all species. In some species the adult females are more like the adult males and don't stay in a larva-like form.
As to which species do and do not, I'm not sure. That kind of information is a bit too obscure to be Google friendly.

I recall reading somewhere that with Japanese fireflies ("hotaru" or whatever they call them) the females have wings.
Of course, that comes from that mass of information in my head collected over time through curiosity and boredom that isn't exactly reliable.  :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 08, 2010, 10:32:05 AM
The best way ZUN could introduce a male character is if that male just showed up. and that's it.

No gimmicks, no remarkable noteworthiness, no feeling or seeming out of place, and the girls don't make any apparent notice of his status as a male whatsoever.

Basically, play his appearance just like ZUN would any female character. Calling unique attention to the fact that "OMG IT'S A BOY" will just cause the fans to freak out even more than they will from seeing a boy at all.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Alice Fact on March 08, 2010, 11:49:09 AM
Can this Thunder Dragon summon a super powered Italian plumber, a courgeous elf hero, a great ape and a squadron of furry space fighters?
more like shinkuu giri from hell (http://www.world-of-arcades.net/R8zing/Dimahoo/Myamoto.gif)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 08, 2010, 11:55:43 AM
The best way ZUN could introduce a male character is if that male just showed up. and that's it.

No gimmicks, no remarkable noteworthiness, no feeling or seeming out of place, and the girls don't make any apparent notice of his status as a male whatsoever.

Basically, play his appearance just like ZUN would any female character. Calling unique attention to the fact that "OMG IT'S A BOY" will just cause the fans to freak out even more than they will from seeing a boy at all.
I think I get where you're coming from. So, by your logic, the girls would just treat the new guy like they would anyone else?

I'm not sure if that would actually help in toning down the fanon freak out, though. After all fans can still see that it's a male regardless of the Touhou's reaction(s) to him.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 08, 2010, 05:57:09 PM
Alright, alright, I was wrong on the gender and firefly thing.

Have any OCs become a "major fixture of fanon"?

Yeah, as far as I know Touhou OC's aren't given that much attention. Ex-Rumia and Ex-Meiling are the only real ascended ones, and Buront is still way more popular than the likes of Meimu and Mitori. Meimu, Mitori and all those other fan characters who pose as extra/phantasm bosses hardly get any an art. Danbooru has almost nothing of those girls. They only have about a dozen fanarts, while even the most underrated Windows character has atleast a thousand. Buront has over 200, far more impressive than any other OC I've seen. Maybe it's because he isn't so overpowered like all the others, and just a nice guy that get's along well with the Gensokyo girls in a friendly manner. Apparently he doesn't mind to be joked about either.

Buront is a pretty good example on how a male Touhou chjaracter should be shown. Not overpowered, not a spotlight hogger and just an overal ordinary but nice guy, who is about on par with most 1-3 stage bosses, maybe 4. And like the previous posts said, his gender shouldn't be blown out of proportion by the main characters. He may become pretty likable this way.

I suppose men in Touhou would be ok. I think the problem would be trying to introduce them well without making them seem too much out of place.

On the other hand, maybe it would be better if they did seem strange and out of place. I have to admit that I've thought would be interesting if Zun were to suddenly introduce a male boss and use a lot of crazy gimmicks in his attacks to make fighting him seem different from the girls.


This would be quite interesting actually. It would support the whole 'males don't do danmaku'. The boss would use physical attacks or somethig similiar, like kicking across the screens, leaving flames behind, or spinning and bouncing around the screen like a top and shooting energy slashes around. A few large sword slashes wouldn't hurt either.
Alternatively, this boss would act more like more classic arcade SHMUP boss, with lesser but more random shots, lacking any patterns. Facing this boss will make you rely more on reflexes than strategy. Sure, there will be less bullets in his attacks, but they approach you FAST, and the pattern is completely random, so you can't hide in a safe zone. A tricky opponent indeed. This would show the males' more brutal and wild way of fighting, sacrificing beauty and finesse for strength and speed.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hieda no Aya on March 08, 2010, 06:25:11 PM
It depends what you count as an OC to some degree. Shanghai and/or Hourai? Lily Black? From a certain line of thinking you could kind of apply it to Daiyousei and Koakuma, really. (I don't, but I do have a friend who refuses to acknowledge those two as characters, hey.)

Pure OCs invented wholesale, though... nah, there must be a cutoff in terms of canon basis. Even Buront wasn't a Touhou OC to begin with, he's from FF11. ZUN's work still means something, apparently!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 08, 2010, 06:38:09 PM
Yeah, as far as I know Touhou OC's aren't given that much attention. Ex-Rumia and Ex-Meiling are the only real ascended ones, and Buront is still way more popular than the likes of Meimu and Mitori. Meimu, Mitori and all those other fan characters who pose as extra/phantasm bosses hardly get any an art. Danbooru has almost nothing of those girls. They only have about a dozen fanarts, while even the most underrated Windows character has atleast a thousand. Buront has over 200, far more impressive than any other OC I've seen. Maybe it's because he isn't so overpowered like all the others, and just a nice guy that get's along well with the Gensokyo girls in a friendly manner. Apparently he doesn't mind to be joked about either.

Buront is a pretty good example on how a male Touhou chjaracter should be shown. Not overpowered, not a spotlight hogger and just an overal ordinary but nice guy, who is about on par with most 1-3 stage bosses, maybe 4. And like the previous posts said, his gender shouldn't be blown out of proportion by the main characters. He may become pretty likable this way.
This is part of the reason why I like the 'Buront' comics and Touhou Iron Yin and Yang as a whole. Because it's the 'adding males to Touhou' trope (sorry lack of a better word) done right. It goes over surprisingly well, given how so few people will like a change in ANY of their Touhou (at least on Danbooru). Having an overpowered male can definately cause some fan backlash so I can probably say that him being about of above average strength rather than hax goes into his favor a bit (much to how you already explained).

Hopefully, ZUN follows this aspect when he actually does plan to make a male character appear. After fans get used to the idea of males in Gensokyo then we can probably take things up a notch and add more powerful characters and the like. But this is just me talking here...

Also there are other Touhou OCs out there. Adding "touhou" and "original" in Danbooru can give you a look at 2 even lesser known OCs "Maybell" and "Karen Yatawa".
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Menreiki on March 08, 2010, 06:52:54 PM
Seeing a male as a real antagonist (trying to actually destroy or take over Gensokyo) would be really interesting. It seems Touhou is actually really close to get a male character since ZUN was about to add one in UFO as a final boss. Let's just wait.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 08, 2010, 07:11:57 PM
The best way ZUN could introduce a male character is if that male just showed up. and that's it.

No gimmicks, no remarkable noteworthiness, no feeling or seeming out of place, and the girls don't make any apparent notice of his status as a male whatsoever.

Basically, play his appearance just like ZUN would any female character. Calling unique attention to the fact that "OMG IT'S A BOY" will just cause the fans to freak out even more than they will from seeing a boy at all.
Isn't this pretty much exactly how Unzan was introduced? Except that he is the gimmick, of course. And there's still a girl involved.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 09, 2010, 06:52:52 AM
I still support Shota Dragon.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Spidere on March 09, 2010, 01:43:10 PM
I still support Shota Dragon.

I'm praying!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 09, 2010, 03:39:48 PM
I still support Shota Dragon.
Fuck, I can actually get behind this.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 09, 2010, 05:28:15 PM
Fuck, I can actually get behind this iykwim
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 09, 2010, 06:34:38 PM
(http://www.majhost.com/gallery/OwlBear1337/Screens/erebus_face.png)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 09, 2010, 10:39:21 PM
Shota Dragon: I am duh dwagon king! Feah my powah!

Yukari: *Giggles* Yes, and you are a truly might king.

SD: And don't you fowget it!

Sanae: Saaaaa, kawaii desu ne~

SD: >_< *assumes horrifyingly frightening dragon form and lays waste to all of Gensokyo in a fit of wrath*

Bad End
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 09, 2010, 10:42:56 PM
For some reason I'd imagne the Shota Dragon to be something of a Laharl...

Well, not sure if that'd be well recieved amongst fans being he'd be an enormous egoist >_>
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 09, 2010, 10:53:37 PM
For some reason I'd imagne the Shota Dragon to be something of a Laharl...

Well, not sure if that'd be well recieved amongst fans being he'd be an enormous egoist >_>

If he REALLY was a Laharl, he would be a lovable enormous egoist.

Shota Dragon: Now your name will be Mid-Boss!
Yukari: W-WHAT?!
And then Yukari was a Mid-Boss.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 09, 2010, 11:29:44 PM
If he REALLY was a Laharl, he would be lovable enormous egoist.

Shota Dragon: Now your name will be Mid-Boss!
Yukari: W-WHAT?!
And then Yukari was a Mid-Boss.
It's funny, that in Disgaea the name it self never really worked with that style of gameplay. In Touhou, however, that name actually seems to work, which makes it all the more amusing.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: arcanesign on March 20, 2010, 04:06:22 AM
I was just watching a ZUN interview, he actually touches on males in Touhou in the second half:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SK3k-J-mpuU&NR=1#t=8m5s
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on March 21, 2010, 06:25:22 AM
I still support Shota Dragon.
I support this way more than I should admit
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 21, 2010, 07:27:52 AM
There is no shame in Shota Dragon.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 21, 2010, 05:22:55 PM
I'd support shota dragon iykwim if it's a trap.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 21, 2010, 08:47:39 PM
Pffffft. Screw Traps.

...

Wait...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: MaronaPossessed on March 22, 2010, 12:15:46 AM
Speaking of OC's

Here and start making fun of him (http://dmf.shrinemaiden.org/wiki/index.php?title=Hakushi_Mahou)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on March 22, 2010, 03:34:14 AM
I'd support shota dragon iykwim if it's a trap.
Actually I'm more like this.  But a trap is fine too.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 22, 2010, 04:54:33 AM
But a shota trap is less cute.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 22, 2010, 05:12:45 PM
Wait...so a Shota Trap is a boy dressed as a girl right?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 22, 2010, 06:00:00 PM
Yes.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on March 22, 2010, 06:03:05 PM
Oh dear Shinki, imagine all the horrid puns that would spawn if it really was a shota trap...

Trap Dragon: "I'll show you my Great Dragon!"

THAT WAS PHYSICALLY PAINFUL TO WRITE!!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on March 22, 2010, 06:04:42 PM
Trap Dragon: "I'll show you my Great Dragon!"
(http://i174.photobucket.com/albums/w88/KimikoMuffin/miami-yeah.jpg) (http://www.epiconeliner.com/)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 22, 2010, 06:13:48 PM
Dx I just want an adorable little boy. Maybe with some scruffy, spiky hair.

Traps frighten me. Both varieties.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 22, 2010, 06:41:07 PM
I'd rather it be that as well.

But knowing Touhou in general we still might get some form of gender issue with him, provided ZUN gives us a Shota Dragon. If we do manage to get your average Shota (pluse Dragon) then he will be my new favorite character (not going higher than Shinki, but still ranked high).
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Ragnarok on March 22, 2010, 07:17:17 PM
it's like destroying everything touhou is made of, that would be like male amazons, totally missplaced :P

well but honestly i guess it wouldn't make much difference since there are already many tomboys
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on March 22, 2010, 08:04:44 PM
Dx I just want an adorable little boy. Maybe with some scruffy, spiky hair.
Fffft.  You're going to make me draw this if this keeps up...  And I'm a __terrible__ artist.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: MaronaPossessed on March 22, 2010, 10:01:24 PM
Fffft.  You're going to make me draw this if this keeps up...  And I'm a __terrible__ artist.
So am i. Hey, draw mine if you like. At least you draw better than me(obviously)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on March 23, 2010, 01:44:46 PM
I would take up on this, since I don't think I've ever drawn Shota type characters before.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Rikter on March 23, 2010, 02:12:22 PM
I wouldn't care personally. It's just a male character nothing really different.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on March 24, 2010, 06:39:16 AM
Maybe I should draw him. x3
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on March 24, 2010, 03:18:35 PM
Somebody better.  (As in to say, "Somebody had better do this")
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: game2011 on April 04, 2010, 02:07:39 PM
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't Shingyoku's (the first boss of the original Touhou) third form a man?  At least the clothing resembles men's clothing to me...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tengukami on April 04, 2010, 02:54:27 PM
Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't Shingyoku's (the first boss of the original Touhou) third form a man?  At least the clothing resembles men's clothing to me...

Looks male to me. (http://touhou.wikia.com/wiki/File:Th01singyoku03.png)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Patorikku on April 04, 2010, 04:33:24 PM
Is this the shota dragon youkai with relatively scruffy, spikey hair, Laharl-ish attitude, and overall shota-ness you were looking for?

(http://img121.imageshack.us/img121/84/shotadragon.th.png) (http://img121.imageshack.us/i/shotadragon.png/)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on April 05, 2010, 07:42:05 AM
It's not quite how I imagined it... but it works 8D

EDIT: Wait, he needs a hat or other accessory.  Hm.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on April 05, 2010, 03:45:53 PM
A pretty pink ribbon. Like an oversized version of Shanghai's. :3
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Garlyle on April 05, 2010, 07:19:05 PM
A pretty pink ribbon. Like an oversized version of Shanghai's. :3
We think alike 8D

Though, it wouldn't quite match him.  For some reason I was thinking of having just a little tiny baby dragon curled up on his head or something, asleep, as a hat  XD
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 05, 2010, 07:37:00 PM
I actually imagined him more with some cool short robe with shorts and gloves, shoulder length, fuzzy, red hair, a serious look on his face, horns and a long dragon tail. A lot more calm looking than mischievous.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on April 05, 2010, 08:33:23 PM
I actually imagined him more with some cool short robe with shorts and gloves, shoulder length, fuzzy, red hair, a serious look on his face, horns and a long dragon tail. A lot more calm looking than mischievous.
This.

But hey, we got our shota dragon so it's all good in da hood.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Augen on April 11, 2010, 04:19:12 AM
A full-blown blatant male character... I wouldn't like it. Just wouldn't feel touhou to me anymore.

However, I love characters like Unzan and Genji, due to the fact that they manage to be male without breaking the streak of Touhou's estrogen tradition. However, I'd be fine with a trap... In fact, I'd love to see Zun put in a trap that isn't Wriggle. If we live to see an androgynous Touhou character say "Hey, who are you calling a girl!" Then I can finally die happy.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: game2011 on April 11, 2010, 08:16:41 AM
People really do forget about Shingyoku's male form, right?  But then, his/her/its original gender isn't exactly known...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 11, 2010, 10:36:59 AM
A full-blown blatant male character... I wouldn't like it. Just wouldn't feel touhou to me anymore.

However, I love characters like Unzan and Genji, due to the fact that they manage to be male without breaking the streak of Touhou's estrogen tradition. However, I'd be fine with a trap... In fact, I'd love to see Zun put in a trap that isn't Wriggle. If we live to see an androgynous Touhou character say "Hey, who are you calling a girl!" Then I can finally die happy.


 Flea for Touhou 13? (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwskOkyFY_E)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Augen on April 11, 2010, 02:54:45 PM

 Flea for Touhou 13? (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JwskOkyFY_E)
Only if the other stage bosses (Ozzie, Slash, Magus, Lavos) are all turned into prepubescent girls.

... Bloody hell, I just gave myself a horrid visual.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on April 11, 2010, 03:20:21 PM
...Lavos loli?
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Augen on April 11, 2010, 04:11:00 PM
...Lavos loli?
There's a picture of her on Danbooru.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 11, 2010, 04:16:09 PM
There's a picture of her on Danbooru.

I've seen that one. Lavos's maw is on a....questionable place on her body.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Augen on April 11, 2010, 05:09:48 PM
I've seen that one. Lavos's maw is on a....questionable place on her body.
... I don't think I can ever think of that sound (http://content.ytmnd.com/content/e/f/8/ef83c8ee1300e4b140ec1c2eb1cf9df1.wav) the same way again.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on April 14, 2010, 04:27:42 AM
Actually, I know for sure my first reaction to men in Touhou.

"Oh god, here come the memes.  ::) "
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Mounting Jaggis on April 14, 2010, 06:04:47 AM
I think it would be more like

"Oh god, here come the fics."
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: orinrin on April 14, 2010, 06:11:21 AM
I think it would be more like

"Oh god, here come the fics."
Yaoi AND yuri.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 14, 2010, 09:33:03 AM
I bet images of gender-bent versions of the male characters would appear in a few hours after the male's reveal.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on April 14, 2010, 12:46:11 PM
Yaoi AND yuri.
After seeing (and getting shit tired of) the latter, I can actually deal with the Yaoi. Hell, I can actually see myself liking it being any positive view I have on yuri is all but destroyed now.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on April 14, 2010, 02:12:40 PM
I bet images of gender-bent versions of the male characters would appear in a few hours after the male's reveal.

And I would enjoy it sooo much.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 14, 2010, 02:22:31 PM
And I would enjoy it sooo much.

Me too~ <3
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on April 14, 2010, 02:35:22 PM
Now that's just defeating the purpose :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on April 14, 2010, 08:02:59 PM
And I would enjoy it sooo much.
Ditto~
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Pai! on April 14, 2010, 11:16:22 PM
And I would enjoy it sooo much.

Agreeeee. They're so funnnn~
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Patorikku on April 15, 2010, 12:23:50 AM
I'm curious, what other ideas do you people have for male Touhous, or Brohous, as I shall call them hereafter? I got bored, and drawing Brohous is a fun thing to do every once in a while. =3

Also, if Mr. Shota Dragon were to have a hat or extra head appendage, it'd be dragon horns, like on Charizard.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 15, 2010, 09:22:38 AM
I'm curious, what other ideas do you people have for male Touhous, or Brohous, as I shall call them hereafter? I got bored, and drawing Brohous is a fun thing to do every once in a while. =3

Also, if Mr. Shota Dragon were to have a hat or extra head appendage, it'd be dragon horns, like on Charizard.

I'd think he'd rather have Shenron horns, really...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on April 15, 2010, 12:19:15 PM
I'd think he'd rather have Shenron horns, really...
inb4TouhouDBZ :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on April 15, 2010, 07:47:19 PM
Chen Long.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on April 15, 2010, 07:49:21 PM
Chen Long.

Long Meiling.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ravaens on April 27, 2010, 02:49:50 PM
ZUN drawsintroduces a new male cast for Touhou 13:
(http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/7133/malet.png)

(runs away)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: necorelli on May 02, 2010, 02:49:29 AM
ZUN drawsintroduces a new male cast for Touhou 13:
(http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/7133/malet.png)

(runs away)

I wouldn't be surpised
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on May 27, 2010, 10:59:47 PM
Genderbent Touhous? Yaoi brouhous?


... I'm on board.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: TheMasterSpark on May 30, 2010, 09:28:23 PM
Quote from: DarkOverord
Didn't ZUN say the main reason why males don't do Danmaku fights is because their danmaku isn't beautiful enough or something on similar lines.

I think it's safe to say that one Mr. Tenji would like to object to that statement.  ;)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kayden on May 30, 2010, 11:13:48 PM
Yaoi..in touhou ~drools~
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: BobTheWaitress on May 30, 2010, 11:52:53 PM
I suppose I don't really like the thought of males in Touhou, to me part of it's charm was that it was always an all female cast.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: NEET on May 31, 2010, 04:12:13 AM
I think if there was like one guy that fit into the story would be interesting. Like How ZUN was gonna put Myouren. I would have actually wanted to see that. It would be pretty refreshing. Maybe ZUN wouldn`t draw an old man, but I`m picturing a young teenager or boy, with weird clothes of course XD it could totally work.

It`s not like it`s gonna be some plain-clothes normal human man in Gensokyo. Gensokyo is an enigmatic place. Of course the boys in Gensokyo will be the same. Rinnosuke is charming, and so are all the other males. They`re all unique like all the girls.

To me, Touhou isn`t good or charming because in-game everyone is female. To me it`s unique and charming because the characters are so outlandish, different, and they`re all oddly overpowered (in a fun way). I don`t get why some of you are freaking out.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Montblanc on May 31, 2010, 09:47:41 AM
I think if there was like one guy that fit into the story would be interesting. Like How ZUN was gonna put Myouren. I would have actually wanted to see that. It would be pretty refreshing. Maybe ZUN wouldn`t draw an old man, but I`m picturing a young teenager or boy, with weird clothes of course XD it could totally work.

It`s not like it`s gonna be some plain-clothes normal human man in Gensokyo. Gensokyo is an enigmatic place. Of course the boys in Gensokyo will be the same. Rinnosuke is charming, and so are all the other males. They`re all unique like all the girls.

To me, Touhou isn`t good or charming because in-game everyone is female. To me it`s unique and charming because the characters are so outlandish, different, and they`re all oddly overpowered (in a fun way). I don`t get why some of you are freaking out.

The truth.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on May 31, 2010, 01:09:18 PM
If handled properly I see no problem with a male. However, the idea of a shota dragon god strikes me as bad. Having a setting where 99% of the relevant characters are female, some with mind-bendingly overpowered abilities, and then making the by far most powerful known being in the setting a male... I don't know about you, but I get a bad feeling from that.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Zannlovecraft on May 31, 2010, 02:18:21 PM
if there where more guys there would be yaoi...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Anon on May 31, 2010, 05:05:59 PM
If handled properly I see no problem with a male. However, the idea of a shota dragon god strikes me as bad. Having a setting where 99% of the relevant characters are female, some with mind-bendingly overpowered abilities, and then making the by far most powerful known being in the setting a male... I don't know about you, but I get a bad feeling from that.
Then the translators have to change something, because the dragon god of Gensokyo has always been refered to as "he" over here.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on May 31, 2010, 05:10:57 PM
Then the translators have to change something, because the dragon god of Gensokyo has always been refered to as "he" over here.

The dragon god probably was never strictly declared as male or female, which is easier to get away with in Japanese as opposed to English. But the dragon god is a dragon and not a loli/shota humanoid, thus its gender is kind of a moot point.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Anon on May 31, 2010, 05:11:46 PM
The dragon god probably was never strictly declared as male or female, which is easier to get away with in Japanese as opposed to English. But the dragon god is a dragon and not a loli/shota humanoid, thus its gender is kind of a moot point.
That's my point. Why not go with "it"?

Edit: On second thought, it's not a big thing anyway. Carry on.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Blackraptor on June 04, 2010, 10:10:54 AM
No...

Wait...

Okay!

Mima comes back...AS A MAN!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DgBarca on June 04, 2010, 10:34:32 AM
No...

Wait...

Okay!

Mima comes back...AS A MAN!
Ho...Miman ? Please...my mind...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on June 05, 2010, 03:14:48 AM
if there where more guys there would be yaoi...
yes oh yes please. with one, only one male (shota or bishonen, or even a biseinen (Youki is fan-drawed sometimes like one)...and all the RinnoSUKE potencial finally will can bloom. XD

Miman

for some reason, when i read Miman the song of He-man and the Masters of the Universe resounds in my head XDXDXD
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on June 05, 2010, 03:28:31 AM
I think if there was like one guy that fit into the story would be interesting. Like How ZUN was gonna put Myouren. I would have actually wanted to see that. It would be pretty refreshing. Maybe ZUN wouldn`t draw an old man, but I`m picturing a young teenager or boy, with weird clothes of course XD it could totally work.

It`s not like it`s gonna be some plain-clothes normal human man in Gensokyo. Gensokyo is an enigmatic place. Of course the boys in Gensokyo will be the same. Rinnosuke is charming, and so are all the other males. They`re all unique like all the girls.

To me, Touhou isn`t good or charming because in-game everyone is female. To me it`s unique and charming because the characters are so outlandish, different, and they`re all oddly overpowered (in a fun way). I don`t get why some of you are freaking out.
You're probably the only one who sees Touhou in this light. For that, I compliment you.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on June 05, 2010, 03:39:29 AM
You're probably the only one who sees Touhou in this light. For that, I compliment you.

ne, you have the word. How Gensokyo is a wonder place with very misterious people, all charas have that strange air...and the males must be the same.Then, if some males appear in the games, we will know more about that world ...how they fight, in first place, if they are interested in magic or not, etc. (and very interesting BL stories too, with magic, samurais, shinto priests, male shapeshipters and hanyos with shops ...)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Patorikku on June 05, 2010, 03:42:07 AM
This new talk has inspired me to further my creation of the shota dragon. To work with me!

Also, please don't assume the shota dragon is the dragon god, because I wouldn't make a shota a god. Then we'd have raining pancakes every day, and he'd probably get the followers of his to run around naked every morning. I mean, I wouldn't complain if Nue or Mokou was one of his followers, but...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on June 05, 2010, 03:49:40 AM
This new talk has inspired me to further my creation of the shota dragon. To work with me!

Also, please don't assume the shota dragon is the dragon god, because I wouldn't make a shota a god. Then we'd have raining pancakes every day, and he'd probably get the followers of his to run around naked every morning. I mean, I wouldn't complain if Nue or Mokou was one of his followers, but...

don?t worry about that, in some cultures gods are seen like childs...specially the iluminated ones.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Blackraptor on June 05, 2010, 04:15:31 AM
In the practical sense, we need a guy to at least impregnate Reimu otherwise the Hakurei clan will be extinct...which I guess would be bad for the border or at least the residents of Gensokyo.


Unless of course ZUN makes her immortal for some strange reason...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: atoms2ashes on June 05, 2010, 04:24:53 AM
With more men (or boys), it would mean, as said, more yaoi.

More yaoi means more fangirls.

One day, the fangirls will overpower the fanboys.

Touhou would be ruined, and ZUN would be sent homeless.

So for now, let us settle for futaWriggle and Rinnosuke porn.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on June 05, 2010, 05:33:11 AM
With more men (or boys), it would mean, as said, more yaoi.

More yaoi means more fangirls.

One day, the fangirls will overpower the fanboys.

Touhou would be ruined, and ZUN would be sent homeless.

So for now, let us settle for futaWriggle and Rinnosuke porn.

wow.i never see that kind of stuff (futaWriggle and Kourin porn...) i want.
don?t worry, because if that happens (males in Touhou games) only the girls who knows things about Touhou, videogames, anime or manga MAYBE can turn fans of them. and a little group, maybe,only maybe would be yaoi fans with artistic things and draw a doujin or two...and...

(http://i46.tinypic.com/wjyvbm.jpg)

from the last Touhou poll.we are really few actually,and a male in a game no will be "a revolution" for turn backwards this numbers XDXD
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Shizzo on June 05, 2010, 06:33:15 AM
Boys in touhou would be pretty~


I wonder if a guy's danmaku would differ from girl's...

Well, whoever man becomes a touhou, I can imagine him as a bit, um, either REALLY manly or really "affected", let's say..

I mean... I'm a girl, but if I would look with a guy's point of view; living in a place where there are cute and beaitiful girls/women literally flying on your face, those personalities are what comes in mind to me.

Buut, as a girl I am, so a fangirl am I~ ♪  So I'd love to have in Gensokyo a flamboyant dude shooting lazers and stuff! <3

(I kindda had a dream about a new touhou game, where the phantasm boss was a boy , but it is a bit blurred in my mind, plus, it's not thaaat worth telling~)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Blackraptor on June 05, 2010, 06:40:11 AM
I wonder if a guy's danmaku would differ from girl's...

A guy's danmaku would be based from horizontal shooters like Gradius. Vic Viper-grade projectiles...LIKE A MAN!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on June 05, 2010, 11:36:48 AM
futaWriggle
(http://www.majhost.com/gallery/OwlBear1337/Screens/excalibur_face_of_disgust.png)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: atoms2ashes on June 05, 2010, 12:16:55 PM
Wriggle has no boobs or curves in the first place, so futaWriggle would just be Wriggle's shota genderbend...plus some muscles here and there.

Besides, I never saw Wriggle as a girl anyway. I tried, but it was just impossible for me to digest.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 05, 2010, 12:23:39 PM
In the practical sense, we need a guy to at least impregnate Reimu otherwise the Hakurei clan will be extinct...which I guess would be bad for the border or at least the residents of Gensokyo.


Unless of course ZUN makes her immortal for some strange reason...

Note that it's highly possible for Reimu to end up a youkai or a deity, depending on what happens.

Wriggle has no boobs or curves in the first place, so futaWriggle would just be Wriggle's shota genderbend...plus some muscles here and there.

Besides, I never saw Wriggle as a girl anyway. I tried, but it was just impossible for me to digest.

Exhibit A (NSWF warning, due to them danboorus) (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/389459/absurdres-alice_margatroid-bad_id-chen-cirno-every)

Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on June 05, 2010, 12:39:50 PM
Exhibit A (NSWF warning, due to them danboorus) (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/389459/absurdres-alice_margatroid-bad_id-chen-cirno-every)
You know, when drawn correctly (i.e. not overly bishonen), brohous can be pretty cool. I especially like that Yuyuko.

Also: Dat evil spirit.   :]
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 05, 2010, 12:56:44 PM
Those are the best brohous, for reals. I hope that guy gets to the UFO cast soon.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: atoms2ashes on June 05, 2010, 02:32:49 PM
Why so manly, mikos? O___O

It's surprising that Reimu was manlier than Marisa O___O
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Shizzo on June 05, 2010, 03:16:35 PM
Oh yea, a thing I'd like to add

There ARE men in Gensokyo, they just don't danmaku


Reimu could be pregnant, she could start a relationship anytime with any of the guys in Gensokyo, and it is highly possible she has..

I mean, you can even say that Rinnosuke's a half-youkai, but there's that human village drawing from PMiSS, for example; it clearly shows men talking
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 05, 2010, 03:23:10 PM
Also Lord Temna.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on June 05, 2010, 03:25:46 PM
And Marisa's dad.


You know, I think this topic is going in circles, and not for the first time. The content of almost every post is the content of another a few pages back...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 05, 2010, 03:40:16 PM
Pretty much.

But people need to remember the only known black man in Gensokyo. =[
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on June 05, 2010, 04:04:49 PM
Wriggle has no boobs or curves in the first place, so futaWriggle would just be Wriggle's shota genderbend...plus some muscles here and there.
Neither do the other touhous in official art :V

Seriously...you're not looking hard enough. (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/561322/adult-antennae-bent_over-breasts-cape-cleavage-gre)

I'll never understand why (or how) a simple pair of pants can fuck up a character so much. I like girls in pants, lets me get a load of DAT ASS, but god dammit shit yo...

Besides, I never saw Wriggle as a girl anyway. I tried, but it was just impossible for me to digest.
That's not healthy bro. You should see your gastroenterologist about that sorta thing.

Quote
But people need to remember the only known black man in Gensokyo. =[
That they do. If I can remember'em so can everybody else, god mutha fucking dammit.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on June 05, 2010, 08:06:24 PM
Wriggle has no boobs or curves in the first place, so futaWriggle would just be Wriggle's shota genderbend...plus some muscles here and there.
Not necessarily. She could have both sets of genitals.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 06, 2010, 03:39:01 AM
I find it strange and rather cool that some of the ideas for this thread about the men in genso--they don't so Danmaku; instead they use physical attacks--was also what I came up with for my OC's; Almost none of them use Danmaku, preferring to beat on enemies with their fists/slash them to pieces with a Big Fucking Sword/ Tear them to pieces with a chainsaw/Bash their heads into a bloody pulp/Stab them to death with a Rapier/Shoot the hell out of them with an Einsteinien Relativistic Cannon capable of obliterating entire galaxies in one shot.....

 Rather interesting coincidence.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: atoms2ashes on June 06, 2010, 04:26:20 AM
Not necessarily. She could have both sets of genitals.

Why did I NOT think of that O___O

I'll never understand why (or how) a simple pair of pants can fuck up a character so much. I like girls in pants, lets me get a load of DAT ASS, but god dammit shit yo...

Mokou has pants, but she has long hair and ribbons. Wriggle has pants, but Wriggle has short hair and no girly accessories. So...

I find it strange and rather cool that some of the ideas for this thread about the men in genso--they don't so Danmaku; instead they use physical attacks--was also what I came up with for my OC's; Almost none of them use Danmaku, preferring to beat on enemies with their fists/slash them to pieces with a Big Fucking Sword/ Tear them to pieces with a chainsaw/Bash their heads into a bloody pulp/Stab them to death with a Rapier/Shoot the hell out of them with an Einsteinien Relativistic Cannon capable of obliterating entire galaxies in one shot.....

 Rather interesting coincidence.

Meiling is an expert in some sort of martial art...then why does she have spellcards? Why not just beat up the Miko? She doesn't need to necessarily kill her.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 06, 2010, 04:30:24 AM
Meiling is an expert in some sort of martial art...then why does she have spellcards? Why not just beat up the Miko? She doesn't need to necessarily kill her.

Reimu is still a normal human. A punch from someone as strong as Meiling would probably cause her entire body to explode.

And Meiling probably has spellcards to let her perform extremely poweful and advanced Martial Arts.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: KrackoCloud on June 06, 2010, 04:35:55 AM
Meiling is an expert in some sort of martial art...then why does she have spellcards? Why not just beat up the Miko? She doesn't need to necessarily kill her.
Wasn't the danmaku system created in Gensokyo to avert fighting?
So even if we did have physically strong male characters or something, they'd be forced to play along.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on June 06, 2010, 04:41:02 AM
Wriggle has pants, but Wriggle has short hair and no girly accessories. So...
People must not know what most Tomboys look like then...seriously.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 06, 2010, 04:50:52 AM
Wasn't the danmaku system created in Gensokyo to avert fighting?
So even if we did have physically strong male characters or something, they'd be forced to play along.

They could just beat their opponent up before they could set up a danmaku fight.

This happens a lot my fanfic; In one notable moment, Reisen challenged an OC, Jack, to a danmaku fight.

Jack responded by running up to her and ripping her heart out of her body with his bare hands, MadWorld Style (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sk8zqgj2sw0#t=0m38s).  (NSFW)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Dizzy H. "Muffin" Muffin on June 06, 2010, 08:09:51 AM
People must not know what most Tomboys look like then...seriously.
Well, most of the rest of the cast has "girly" turned up to eleven ...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on June 06, 2010, 12:32:01 PM
They could just beat their opponent up before they could set up a danmaku fight.

This happens a lot my fanfic; In one notable moment, Reisen challenged an OC, Jack, to a danmaku fight.

Jack responded by running up to her and ripping her heart out of her body with his bare hands, MadWorld Style (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sk8zqgj2sw0#t=0m38s).  (NSFW)

But that would break the danmaku rules, resulting in the entirety of Gensokyo ganging up on the fool who broke the rules and kickling the shit out of him with their REAL powers instead of danmaku. It is a VERY stupid thing to break the spellcard rules and/or to kill someone in Gensokyo. You might be strong enough to tear hearts out of people's chest, but that doesn't save you when Yukari makes your head explode as punishment.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 06, 2010, 12:56:23 PM
You might be strong enough to tear hearts out of people's chest, but that doesn't save you when Yukari makes your head explode as punishment.

Related image. (http://img256.imageshack.us/img256/506/heartday.png)

But yeah, if nothing else, it'd get Reimu on your ass. And she was kicking around deities and shit before spellcards. Not to mention it's pretty canonical that most of the big ballers also like spellcards, so they'd want to help.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: game2011 on June 06, 2010, 02:21:02 PM
Meiling is an expert in some sort of martial art...then why does she have spellcards? Why not just beat up the Miko? She doesn't need to necessarily kill her.
Because we're going to end up with something like this:
http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/541556 (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/541556)
Obvious NSFW warning due to the ads of Danbooru, and the picture itself is also very violent and bloody.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on June 06, 2010, 02:28:07 PM
Well, most of the rest of the cast has "girly" turned up to eleven ...
Again.
People must not know what most Tomboys look like.

Also

Quote
Spellcard bullshit
I'll have to agree with everyone else on this one. If you want to fight you have to play by the rules, bro. If that means going by spellcard rules, then you gotta do as the romans do. Speaking as a rather rebellious individual myself, I'd have to say this is one of those cases where going against the majority ISN'T the most genius move you can make, especially since most of the Touhous know how to pull some OHKO asshaterry out the wazoo when they aren't nerfed with SC rules.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 06, 2010, 02:45:09 PM
Especially since spellcards are actually designed to give you a chance. Which is why Cirno and Mystia were able to lay the smack down on Shikieiki.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Nobu on June 06, 2010, 03:33:59 PM
My theory is that ZUN has no idea how to make someone 'girly' while wearing pants at the same time. If it wasn't obvious by their clothes/hair, everyone'd probably look gender ambiguous. Fucking Shou. :v

Also Mima is Satan.
Title: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tengukami on June 06, 2010, 03:49:12 PM
My theory is people see pants and/or short hair on a female Gensokyan and fall into the played-out trap talk as if on Pavlovian cue.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 06, 2010, 04:52:25 PM
But that would break the danmaku rules, resulting in the entirety of Gensokyo ganging up on the fool who broke the rules and kickling the shit out of him with their REAL powers instead of danmaku. It is a VERY stupid thing to break the spellcard rules and/or to kill someone in Gensokyo. You might be strong enough to tear hearts out of people's chest, but that doesn't save you when Yukari makes your head explode as punishment.

Well, my fic is mainly comedy, so nobobdy really did anything, espicailly I take the "Youkai never die" thing Up To Eleven (They literally re-form in seconds), so Reisen just got up and blasted the shit out of him with Danmaku.

And why the hell would the other residents care about some random psychopathic Moon Rabbit breaking the SC rules? I don't think it was ever said that breaking them resulted in everyone hating you.

And Jack would've just sliced Yukari's head off too :V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on June 06, 2010, 05:39:16 PM
Well, my fic is mainly comedy, so nobobdy really did anything, espicailly I take the "Youkai never die" thing Up To Eleven (They literally re-form in seconds), so Reisen just got up and blasted the shit out of him with Danmaku.

And why the hell would the other residents care about some random psychopathic Moon Rabbit breaking the SC rules? I don't think it was ever said that breaking them resulted in everyone hating you.

And Jack would've just sliced Yukari's head off too :V

Everyone hates you if you kill someone or break the law in real life too, so do you really think it is any different in Gensokyo, even if everyone is way more durable? If you break the law you get punished, and in a magical worlds punishments will be very, very horrific.

And Yukari can make your head explode or worse from the other side of Gensokyo. The moment you crush Reisen's heart BOOM goes your head. You wouldn't even notice you're dead. And even if she was in front of you she would erase your sword from existence and THEN make your head explode.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 06, 2010, 05:59:32 PM
Well, my fic is mainly comedy, so nobobdy really did anything,
And Jack would've just sliced Yukari's head off too :V

Sorta like how My Immortal or whatever's popular these days is a comedy?

Okashii exaggerates a bit, insomuch as retribution wouldn't be instantaneous. But it'd happen. And you'd have to write Yukari being uncharacteristically retarded to have her get beheaded.

Also, Youkai die. It's the faeries that are reborn.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on June 06, 2010, 06:23:32 PM
Sorta like how My Immortal or whatever's popular these days is a comedy?

Okashii exaggerates a bit, insomuch as retribution wouldn't be instantaneous. But it'd happen. And you'd have to write Yukari being uncharacteristically retarded to have her get beheaded.

Also, Youkai die. It's the faeries that are reborn.

Youkai do have some degree of super regeneration. They can survive and heal from being cut in five pieces according to Japanese mythology. They're made of tough stuff, but take down the head and it's game over for youkai. Fairies, celestials and immortals can't be killed in any way. Gods and vampires are borderline cases. Gods can only die when their faith runs out, and Flandre claims that she tried to kill herself in various ways without any success, so vampires might be nigh immortal too.

I guess to perma-kill vampires you need to kill them like the very first vampires (when they were actually badass and hard-to-kill as opposed to modern vampires), which involved having to stake them in the heart, cut of their head, put garlic in their mouth, cut their body to pieces, burn the body and head to ashes and then throw the ashes over holy grounds BEFORE the full moon shines on the ashes. Only THEN will they permanently die. And yes, the full moon will cause the vampire to completely revive without a scratch on him/her/it even if he/she/it is utterly obliterated. The ashes NEED to be thrown on holy grounds like a church to stop the regeneration.

And according Remilia's profile she is capable of splitting up in swarm of countless bats. No matter how many of those bats you kill, as long as there remains ONE bat Remilia can revive. I wouldn't be surprised when it is revealed Remilia has hundreds of those bats hidden in safe places across Gensokyo or even the world to ensure that she doesn't die.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 06, 2010, 06:57:24 PM
Everyone hates you if you kill someone or break the law in real life too, so do you really think it is any different in Gensokyo, even if everyone is way more durable? If you break the law you get punished, and in a magical worlds punishments will be very, very horrific.

And Yukari can make your head explode or worse from the other side of Gensokyo. The moment you crush Reisen's heart BOOM goes your head. You wouldn't even notice you're dead. And even if she was in front of you she would erase your sword from existence and THEN make your head explode.

DANMAKU IS SERIOUS BUISNESS

Okay, with that idiocy out of the way, I never really took Gensokyo that seriously. Touhou is great in that it's about the only series where you can say "Fuck canon!" and no one will care.

And Jack uses a chainsaw attached to his right arm.

Sorta like how My Immortal or whatever's popular these days is a comedy?

...Why did you just compare my fic to My Immortal
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Iryan on June 06, 2010, 07:11:19 PM
Catharsis...

Without trying to sound offensive, I think Purvis' (Diamond's) comment was based on how the few revelations you have made about your fic in this thread thus far were that you introduce OC(s) who defeat canon characters in ways that seem both out of place in the setting and disgraceful to the canon character in question. Regarding fan fiction, in a case of doubt it is reasonable to assume that a work is bad unless proven otherwise, and these points you brought up are all stuff you would fin on a checklist for how to make bad fanfiction. The comment that your OC would simply decapitate Yukari is pretty much the icing on the cake here, even if it was meant to be a joke.

I have no idea whether or not you handled this stuff in your fic in a way that makes it actually enjoyable to read, but I don't read ff anyways, so I don't really care.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 06, 2010, 07:22:19 PM
Catharsis...

Without trying to sound offensive, I think Purvis' (Diamond's) comment was based on how the few revelations you have made about your fic in this thread thus far were that you introduce OC(s) who defeat canon characters in ways that seem both out of place in the setting and disgraceful to the canon character in question. Regarding fan fiction, in a case of doubt it is reasonable to assume that a work is bad unless proven otherwise, and these points you brought up are all stuff you would fin on a checklist for how to make bad fanfiction. The comment that your OC would simply decapitate Yukari is pretty much the icing on the cake here, even if it was meant to be a joke.

I have no idea whether or not you handled this stuff in your fic in a way that makes it actually enjoyable to read, but I don't read ff anyways, so I don't really care.

Most of the stuff in my fic is a big joke anyway. And trust me, the Touhou girls could easily kick my OC's asses, since they have the advantage of Danmaku and actual brains when fighting. I actually parody this, with my OC's constantly having the belief that they are some kind of Knight's in Shining Armor to the girls, and therefore stupidly valiantly ride into battle.....and get obliterated because they need the girls to provide cover fire so they can go up and start beating on enemies without getting swarmed.

Trust me, I know how to write.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 06, 2010, 07:23:28 PM
Youkai do have some degree of super regeneration. They can survive and heal from being cut in five pieces according to Japanese mythology. They're made of tough stuff, but take down the head and it's game over for youkai. Fairies, celestials and immortals can't be killed in any way. Gods and vampires are borderline cases. Gods can only die when their faith runs out, and Flandre claims that she tried to kill herself in various ways without any success, so vampires might be nigh immortal too.

I guess to perma-kill vampires you need to kill them like the very first vampires (when they were actually badass and hard-to-kill as opposed to modern vampires), which involved having to stake them in the heart, cut of their head, put garlic in their mouth, cut their body to pieces, burn the body and head to ashes and then throw the ashes over holy grounds BEFORE the full moon shines on the ashes. Only THEN will they permanently die. And yes, the full moon will cause the vampire to completely revive without a scratch on him/her/it even if he/she/it is utterly obliterated. The ashes NEED to be thrown on holy grounds like a church to stop the regeneration.

And according Remilia's profile she is capable of splitting up in swarm of countless bats. No matter how many of those bats you kill, as long as there remains ONE bat Remilia can revive. I wouldn't be surprised when it is revealed Remilia has hundreds of those bats hidden in safe places across Gensokyo or even the world to ensure that she doesn't die.

Let's see some sources on the vampire thing. That looks like you just mishmashed several separate vampire traditions together and claim they have to all be done at once.

Faeries can die; look at Cirno, she's separated herself from nature.  Immortals, I could think of ways to do it, but they are beyond the scope of Touhou. Gods may be able to die; one of the major themes of Shinto tales is that anything can lose their state of purity and fall down the ladder of being. A disgraced god (such as Susano-O often was) is vulnerable. Whether this applies to Touhou is debatable. Celestials can die; Komachi's path in SWR establishes that.

As for Remilia splitting herself up, I'd argue that's rather like popping out an organ and hiding it. All those bats are her, and she'd need all of them to reform herself correctly. I'd argue destroying even one would mess her up at least a little bit, especially if she doesn't have the capacity to restore them.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Bias Bus on June 06, 2010, 07:34:36 PM
iirc, Gods will "die" if they lose enough Faith, being they sorta disappear or something. Such is the factor that motivates Kanako in alot of things that involve gaining faith...or at least why she's so determined to get alot of it.

Also Mima is Satan.
*cough* what's that? I can't seem to hear you over how wrong you are. You might wanna speak up in a tone that's a bit more correct, so I can hear what you have to say, buddy boy!
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Hello Purvis on June 06, 2010, 07:40:02 PM
Indeed. If anyone is Satan, it's Tenshi.

I mean, favored child of heaven, fall from grace, not actually all that bright...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: OkashiiKisei on June 06, 2010, 08:04:06 PM
Let's see some sources on the vampire thing. That looks like you just mishmashed several separate vampire traditions together and claim they have to all be done at once.

Faeries can die; look at Cirno, she's separated herself from nature.  Immortals, I could think of ways to do it, but they are beyond the scope of Touhou. Gods may be able to die; one of the major themes of Shinto tales is that anything can lose their state of purity and fall down the ladder of being. A disgraced god (such as Susano-O often was) is vulnerable. Whether this applies to Touhou is debatable. Celestials can die; Komachi's path in SWR establishes that.

As for Remilia splitting herself up, I'd argue that's rather like popping out an organ and hiding it. All those bats are her, and she'd need all of them to reform herself correctly. I'd argue destroying even one would mess her up at least a little bit, especially if she doesn't have the capacity to restore them.

I read several sources that the original way of killing vampires was doing all that in that EXACT order without blundering. They got pussied up along the way in fiction so people wouldn't be too afraid at night.

The Celestials immortality stems from the fact that they are already dead basically. According to Touhou Wiki the shinigami are in fact trying to get them day-in day-out as if they were normal souls, but Celestials are so ungodly powerful that they can actually kick the shit out of the shinigami and chase them away. Since the shinigami can't get them, they can't die. It is an odd form of immortality, but still immortality.

I thought so too at first, but according to her profile Remilia can regenerate completely fully fine and dandy with all her power intact in mere seconds from only ONE bat, even if you just killed five billion of the things. It even states she can turn into INFINITE bats. So yeah, just check up on the profiles again.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tengukami on June 06, 2010, 09:25:29 PM
Vampire traditions notoriously contradict each other, even when separate tales are contemporary. Granted, there are contradictions that happen with time, but you'll also find contradictions from the same age. For the sake of clarity, we cannot speculate on Remilia's strengths and weaknesses; we have just canon material to go by.

Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Helepolis on June 06, 2010, 10:09:54 PM
(http://th216.photobucket.com/albums/cc75/jasonmuzie/th_Spiderman04-1.jpg)

My possiblepowerleveldiscussion senses are tingling.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Teewee on June 12, 2010, 10:00:13 PM
Indeed. If anyone is Satan, it's Tenshi.

I mean, favored child of heaven, fall from grace, not actually all that bright...
Wait, since when did she actually fall from grace? the wiki says she is in heaven, so she must have been let off the hook for threatening to destroy gensokyo's land. The latter is perhaps true, though :V
As for the topic, I would be likely  slightly surprised by a man appearing in a future game, but not so much other material. Marisa could be revealed to have a brother in future fiction, but i wouldn't be  surprised by that. A more powerful brother though, and that would make me go lolwut :o
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Kuma on June 12, 2010, 11:18:21 PM
Tenshi just went to fuck with the Mortals because heaven was boring, she wasn't actualy kicked out, she left on her own.

While Shinki can be seen as the "God" of a hell-like dimension, there is no real Saten/Lucifer-like touhou


Hatate is tottaly Samiel though 8V
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Blackraptor on June 12, 2010, 11:38:33 PM
So about discussing about having men in Touhou and the possible ramifications of such...
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: VIVItheFujoshi on June 12, 2010, 11:47:57 PM
wow...that means who Sariel was in "home" all this time? then, Gensokyo is the Pandemonium? (where all the fallen angels-demons legions live)
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Shanghai Alice on June 13, 2010, 03:48:26 AM
Bastard... ruining my loli paradise....

I'd kill 'em.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: warpshadow on June 13, 2010, 05:58:58 AM
(http://th216.photobucket.com/albums/cc75/jasonmuzie/th_Spiderman04-1.jpg)

My possiblepowerleveldiscussion senses are tingling.
You guys need to make the power level thing explicit in the forum rules if the topic is so bad.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Sen on June 13, 2010, 06:34:49 AM
Most of the stuff in my fic is a big joke anyway.

A bad joke is still bad.


In any case, I will drop in and say that touhou+genderswap is my favorite tag combination in Danbooru (warnings ahoy!). Seriously some of that (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/587838/) stuff (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/643354/) is (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/433254/) delicious (http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/574350/) (DAT MURASA <3).
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Tengukami on June 13, 2010, 03:56:15 PM
You guys need to make the power level thing explicit in the forum rules if the topic is so bad.

Honestly? It doesn't come up that often. Most of the user base here realizes by now that power level discussions are utterly pointless and lead only to e-peen my-god-can-beat-up-your-god bickering. It happens so seldomly that normally someone will just step in to say "hey, chill on the power levels" and that's that.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: DeathShot Catharsis on June 13, 2010, 04:46:03 PM
A bad joke is still bad.

Is trolling me the only enjoyment you get out of your pathetic life? It must be, because you just wont shut the fuck up.

This is getting fucking annoying.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: Matsuri on June 13, 2010, 06:34:49 PM
Knock if off, guys. SenSageUn, it's one thing to criticize, but doing so simply to antagonize is pretty low. Chagen, please control your temper. Annoying as it may be, there's no reason to not be civil about it.

Regardless, if you both wish to carry on, take it to PMs, since it doesn't belong here.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: ♛ Apher-Forte on June 18, 2010, 06:31:54 AM
only if said men had a white belt which can shoot seven color rainbows and jump 50 feet high screaming their attack moves.
Title: Re: How would you react to men in Touhou
Post by: MysTeariousYukari on June 18, 2010, 07:06:22 AM
only if said men had a white belt which can shoot seven color rainbows and jump 50 feet high screaming their attack moves.

^ This.

For the topic, I'm not sure how I'd react to men in Touhou. Some of my fan-fics involve a guy(usually a friend, with me being a girl) in Gensokyo, being saved by one of the girls, living with her and such.