Zak, if you think Huh What is a more likely scum, then we can lynch him instead. Heck, I just want to get killed without losing the game for town.
Unfortunately, there is no way that both Huh What and myself are scum. Either Edible's test registered false, Neo is scum, or Edible is lying.
If we're talking about probabilities though, I'll build an Edible case for you. Edible (Pesco. Whatever.) selected four talkive, knowledgable players to test and Schezo. He wanted Schezo dead for certain. I think we all agreed on that. But I think Schezo was always just bait. He was the schmuck (sorry Schezo) among 4 players I would consider very valuable for their intelligence and the logic they apply to mafia. And his five players were strange picks as well; once again, I mentioned that there were a lot of less inherently valuable players he could have tested, who sorting through would not have caused nearly as much damage to town. Players who would probably be offended if I mentioned them by name. And he claimed a one day cop check. Even at the time, this power was considered, well, overpowered. And it had just enough slots in it that if every player were lynched, town would lose even with the assumption of two zombies.
Today, he tests 5 fairly suspicious looking players, and gets a negative. Bard confirmed that he would probably have set off the test if there was another zombie. Now, I'm going to kill myself off and flip town, and the remaing people not on Edible's list, Neo and Huh What, are not both zombies, as they plan to prove with their night actions.
Either there is another zombie blocking power in the game and only one of Neo or Huh What are zombies, or both Neo and Huh What are zombies, or Edible is lying. There is the chance that Bard is lying and there are only two very powerful zombies including him, but I don't see it. You don't have to believe me at all because I'm probably going to end up lynched anyway, and you can make the decision for yourself then. But at the end of the day, there is no way two of Edible's three are zombies without a Huh What/Neo scum team, and they are already coordinating their actions so that a night kill tonight immediately confirms them as town.
If we are talking about probabilities, what do you figure the probability that both me and Edible are town is? And if I flip town, what are the odds that Edible will be as well? And the reverse, if Edible flips town what are the odds that I will?
I think Edible is a zombie because I'm town. You think he's town because you think Huh What and I are a zombie team. If I were on Huh What's scum team, I would not have spent today trying to make sure he got lynched before you kill me, nor would I advocate a plan that would immediately implicate Huh What when I die. Nor would I have spent most the day barrelling through with plan after plan that would explicitly prove the impossibility of me and Huh What being a scum team together. Basically, everything I've suggested today in regards to Huh What only makes sense if I am in no way on a scum team with him, including this, since if we were both scum, my actions would implicate him and his flips would implicate me. If me and Huh What are not on a scum team, who do you think the most likely scum is?