There were hordes of attitude/etiquette issues. I'll probably go into further detail when I get home, though it depends on what else gets posted here in the meantime.
Guilty as charged.
In any case!
IHNNSolid play, despite what some might say. A Cop's interest is in neither getting lynched nor getting killed at night, and he's dodged the bullet right well he has. In the end he won the game for Town, but that is more due to the role rather than the player. Playerwise I think IHNN could benefit from more clarity and involvement. I didn't actually notice his play much this game, and I'm not sure if that's due to trying to pull off a right proper Coplurk or just being generally forgettable. The latter isn't exactly good if you're scumhunting.
ShadowehPlayed like an absolute turd this game. Participation is way below acceptable and scumhunting is non-existant for nearly all, if not all of the game. Some points awarded for actually snagging Scum with her rolepower, but this has nothing to do with good play. I'd be curious to know why Shadoweh thought not playing the game from the start would be acceptable: Nothing about her role struck me as necessitating a lack of participation. Next game, I'd advise participating. Rather than call people Town, explain why they are Town.
RaikariaOnly got caught by Cop. Solid play. Some stuff here and there, but ultimately you only got lynched because Cop got lucky. Not too bad for a relative newbie. I can't counsel on Scum gameplay because that's a completely different bag of chips. Abstaining from the night kill to fool Hero was cunning, it's a shame that didn't work out. Try to get an alibi for when you get spotted at night performing an action you haven't claimed when you should've!
Hero999Picked up massively in the last few stages of the game. Before that, didn't exist, didn't really participate. If you don't have a lot of time to participate, try to keep a QuickTopic or a notepad handy where you jot down notes and compensate your low availability with sage posts.
SerelaNo matter how convinced you are someone's Scum, it's useless voting them if you cannot convince others of it. Try to distribute your time between people you think are Scum and people you can actually point to as being Scum. Also, seriously try less to give answers for others: I get that you're trying to be helpful, but in Mafia you should only ever speak for yourself and leave others to fend for themselves. There's a small justification if you think the attacker is actually Scum, but then it's more pertinent to show the rest why Scum would make that case, instead of just yelling at them.
SirChaotickSpent most of his time worrying how others will view him. It's all right to do that, just don't talk about how it's leading your actions. Act in the best interest of Town, not in the interest of keeping up appearances. Appearances are important in Ponyville, Mafia cares only about acting in the interest of your team. Your game was all right in the first stages, but the last stages had too little activity. Even if role madness is swirling around, do try to attempt to scumhunt. Read the game again and see what the Scum did this game, you can try to look for those kind of behaviourisms in future games. You didn't do terrible.
Dormio시작이 반이다.
ActionDanKilling yourself is the worst idea ever. Don't play to Scum's win condition. If you didn't want to play, just don't sign up.
RaitakiMastered the ability of brown-nosing. Staved off a lynch long enough to be effective, so no complaints from my side. Under the circumstances you did well. Try to have an original opinion, though, to avoid this in the future.
ConquerorOnly player who kept a straight face and played till the end. His end. Logic reigned supreme, reasonability seeped into every post. Keep playing as you are.
DrRawrIf people think you're being rude, threatening to get worse isn't the way forward. Not in Mafia, not in social interactions with people. Don't sign up to games if you intend to treat other players like crap.
ZakeriStopped playing after D2. Was okay-ish on Day 1. Not a lot to say about you. I guess it was fine.
BardicheJust stop playing forever you piece of shit.
PX##Vote: PX
