Maidens of the Kaleidoscope

~Bunbunmaru News~ => Front Page Headlines => Topic started by: Drake on June 11, 2013, 12:57:33 AM

Title: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Drake on June 11, 2013, 12:57:33 AM
5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
(http://i.imgur.com/TOWj3BB.png) (http://vote.nicodosai.com/)
http://vote.nicodosai.com/

Voting has ended. Results are linked below.



It's time for another Touhou Popularity Contest! Usually, the Annual Touhou Popularity Contest is a yearly event held by the Japanese Touhou wiki (http://thwiki.info/), where fans from across the globe vote in polls to make it clear who the most beloved (or at least the most currently-popular) characters are in the series. The folks at thwiki decided not to put on the contest this year at the usual time due to a lack of new characters, so people putting up the Touhou Nico Dousai (http://nicodosai.com/) this year have decided to run their own contest!

While this contest is in the exact same format as the contests held by thwiki, this is not a replacement for the thwiki's 10th popularity contest. Since the participating voters might be a different sample than usual, note that the results aren't necessarily going to reflect the results for the usual contest, although you can expect they will follow similar patterns.

Feel free to fill this thread with your votes, your reasoning and any thoughts you have on the contest. If you're lucky, someone from Japan will take one of your horrible comments and stick it in a results video. It's happened before.



Results

http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Touhou_Nico_Dousai_Popularity_Contest

Questionnaire



Voting
Voting has ended and results have been announced.

http://vote.nicodosai.com/users/new (http://vote.nicodosai.com/users/new)
Enter email address here to receive a voting key. (It might take several minutes for you to receive an email.) Enter this key when voting in each category, in the bottom box.

Please refer to this site (http://wwp.greenwichmeantime.com/time-zone/asia/japan/time/) to check JST time if you can't perform timezone arithmetic

There are now four available polls for fans to vote in (and they're in this order on the site):

Character Poll (http://vote.nicodosai.com/character_votes/new) - Vote for your (maximum of) 5 favourite characters. 3 points for the "first", 2 points for the next two, and 1 point for the last two.
Music Poll (http://vote.nicodosai.com/music_votes/new) -  Vote for your (maximum of) 7 favourite songs. 3 points for the first, 2 points for the next two, and 1 point for the last four.
Best Partner Poll (http://vote.nicodosai.com/best_partner_votes/new) - Vote for your favorite character combination. There is no point distribution, just the one vote.
Voter Questionnaire (http://vote.nicodosai.com/questions/new) - Miscellaneous questions about the games, e.g. which ones have you played, when did you get into Touhou, etc. (limited in comparison to thwiki polls)

Here (http://nicodosai.com/vote/list) is a list of the characters and songs that you can vote for. Anything marked ▼ are choices that are not available for Best Partner.
Here (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,14938.msg984880.html#msg984880) is list of translated character names, in the order they appear to select.
Here (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,14938.msg985286.html#msg985286) is a list of translated music titles, in the order they appear to select. Thanks to Luin for preparing it!



Previous Threads

9th ATPC - Voting & Results (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,12072.0.html)
8th ATPC - Voting & Results (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,8445.0.html)
7th ATPC - Results (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,5052.0.html)
7th ATPC - Voting (includes voting guide) (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,4966.0.html)



Post will be updated.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Drake on June 11, 2013, 12:58:01 AM
RESULTS

Available here:
http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Touhou_Nico_Dousai_Popularity_Contest
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Starxsword on June 11, 2013, 05:25:35 AM
Okay, I definitely do not know enough Japanese to find Darkening Dusk.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Helepolis on June 11, 2013, 05:38:17 AM
Huh, I thought the popularity contest was delayed for this year due to no new games being released or something? Remember talking about it on #shrinemaiden.

Edit: Also lol at Reimu's amulet. Hokuto much.

Edit2:
Quote
the folks at thwiki were not able to put on the contest this year, so for the Touhou Nico Dousai, we have some new hosting!
I assume it has to do with this?
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Drake on June 11, 2013, 06:04:39 AM
Yeah, these aren't the usual thwiki folk hosting the contest. The top part of the website is even a parody of the HM prologue replacing the scenario with the popularity poll's postponement.

I'm working on the character name translations, in the order they appear on the selector, for the people who somehow don't recognize their favorite Touhou's name. If somebody could help doing the same with the Music titles or the questionnaire it would be appreciated.



List of Characters
(In the order they appear to select)

博麗 霊夢 - Reimu Hakurei
霧雨 魔理沙 - Marisa Kirisame
秦 こころ - Hata no Kokoro
幽谷 響子 - Kyouko Kasodani
宮古 芳香 - Yoshika Miyako
霍 青娥 - Seiga Kaku
蘇我 屠自古 - Soga no Tojiko
物部 布都 - Mononobe no Futo
豊聡耳 神子 - Toyosatomimi no Miko
二ッ岩 マミゾウ - Mamizou Futatsuiwa
姫海棠 はたて - Hatate Himekaidou
ナズーリン - Nazrin
多々良 小傘 - Kogasa Tatara
雲居 一輪 - Ichirin Kumoi
雲山 - Unzan
村紗 水蜜 - Murasa Minamitsu
寅丸 星 - Shou Toramaru
聖 白蓮 - Byakuren Hijiri
封獣 ぬえ - Nue Houjuu
キスメ - Kisume
黒谷 ヤマメ - Yamame Kurodani
水橋 パルスィ - Parsee Mizuhashi
星熊 勇儀 - Yuugi Hoshiguma
古明地 さとり - Satori Komeiji
火焔猫 燐 - Rin Kaenbyou
霊烏路 空 - Utsuho Reiuji
古明地 こいし - Koishi Komeiji
永江 衣玖 - Iku Nagae
比那名居 天子 - Tenshi Hinanawi
秋 静葉 - Shizuha Aki
秋 穣子 - Minoriko Aki
鍵山 雛 - Hina Kagiyama
河城 にとり - Nitori Kawashiro
犬走 椛 - Momiji Inubashiri
東風谷 早苗 - Sanae Kochiya
八坂 神奈子 - Kanako Yasaka
洩矢 諏訪子 - Suwako Moriya
射命丸 文 - Aya Shameimaru
メディスン・メランコリー - Medicine Melancholy
風見 幽香 - Yuuka Kazami
小野塚 小町 - Komachi Onozuka
四季映姫・ヤマザナドゥ - Shikieiki Yamaxanadu
伊吹 萃香 - Suika Ibuki
リグル・ナイトバグ - Wriggle Nightbug
ミスティア・ローレライ - Mystia Lorelei
上白沢 慧音 - Keine Kamishirasawa
因幡 てゐ - Tewi Inaba
鈴仙・優曇華院・イナバ - Reisen Udongein Inaba
八意 永琳 - Eirin Yagokoro
蓬莱山 輝夜 - Kaguya Houraisan
藤原 妹紅 - Fujiwara no Mokou
レティ・ホワイトロック - Letty Whiterock
橙 - Chen
アリス・マーガトロイド - Alice Margatroid
リリーホワイト - Lily White
ルナサ・プリズムリバー - Lunasa Prismriver
メルラン・プリズムリバー - Merlin Prismriver
リリカ・プリズムリバー - Lyrica Prismriver
魂魄 妖夢 - Youmu Konpaku
西行寺 幽々子 - Yuyuko Saigyouji
八雲 藍 - Ran Yakumo
八雲 紫 - Yukari Yakumo
ルーミア - Rumia
大妖精 - Daiyousei
チルノ - Cirno
紅 美鈴 - Hong Meiling
小悪魔 - Koakuma
パチュリー・ノーレッジ - Patchouli Knowledge
十六夜 咲夜 - Sakuya Izayoi
レミリア・スカーレット - Remilia Scarlet
フランドール・スカーレット - Flandre Scarlet
サラ - Sara
ルイズ - Luize
ユキ - Yuki
マイ - Mai
夢子 - Yumeko
神綺 - Shinki
オレンジ - Orange
くるみ - Kurumi
エリー - Elly
夢月 - Mugetsu
幻月 - Gengetsu
エレン - Ellen
小兎姫 - Kotohime
カナ・アナベラル - Kana Anaberal
朝倉 理香子 - Rikako Asakura
北白河 ちゆり - Chiyuri Kitashirakawa
岡崎 夢美 - Yumemi Okazaki
玄爺 - Genji
里香 - Rika
明羅 - Meira
魅魔 - Mima
シンギョク - Shingyoku
ユウゲンマガン - YuugenMagan
エリス - Elis
サリエル - Sariel
キクリ - Kikuri
コンガラ - Konngara
宇佐見 蓮子 - Renko Usami
マエリベリー・ハーン - Maribel Hearn
稗田 阿求 - Hieda no Akyuu
マーフィーの妖怪 - Murphy's youkai
森近 霖之助 - Rinnosuke Morichika
名無しの本読み妖怪 - Unnamed Book-Reading Youkai
サニーミルク - Sunny Milk
ルナチャイルド - Lunar Child
スターサファイア - Star Sapphire
綿月 豊姫 - Watatsuki no Toyohime
綿月 依姫 - Watatsuki no Yorihime
レイセン - Reisen
茨木 華扇 - Kasen Ibaraki
本居 小鈴 - Kosuzu Motoori
核熱造神ヒソウテンソク - Thermonuclear Titan Hisoutensoku
大ナマズ - Unnamed Giant Catfish
命蓮 - Myouren Hijiri
毘沙門天 - Bishamonten
UFO(赤・青・緑、その他) - UFO (all colors)
妖精(メイド妖精・ひまわり妖精他) - Fairies (Maid, Sunflower, etc)
カラス(地獄鴉、紫・文の使い魔他) - Crows (Hell crows, Yukari's/Aya's familiars, etc)
アリスの人形(上海、蓬莱、大江戸他) - Alice's dolls (Shanghai, hourai, etc)
毛玉 - Kedama
幽霊(怨霊、化け化け含む) - Phantoms (Vengeful spirits, Bakebake)
魂魄 妖忌 - Youki Konpaku
レイラ・プリズムリバー - Layla Prismriver
るーこと - Ruukoto
ミミちゃん - Mimi-chan
大ガマ - Giant Toad
ツチノコ - Tsuchinoko
永遠亭の妖怪兎 - Eientei Rabbits
月の兎(玉兎) - Moon rabbits
月の都の門番 - Lunar capital gatekeepers
水江浦島子 - Mizue no Uranoshimako
岩笠 - Iwakasa
木花咲耶姫 - Konohana-Sakuyahime
酒虫 - Sake worm
天狗(大天狗他) - Tengu (incl. Daitengu)
河童 - Kappa
化け狸 - Bake-danuki
子龍 - Dragon child
大鷲(久米、竿打) - Unnamed Dapeng (Sea eagle)
雷獣 - Raijuu
妖怪狐 - Youkai fox
神降ろしの神霊(天照、伊豆能売他) - Summoned Gods (Amaterasu, Izunome, etc)
福の神(茨歌仙) - Fortune gods
ホブゴブリン - Hobgoblin
字食い虫 - Word-eating bug
人里の人間(運松翁、筍取り、花屋の娘、小鈴のおじいちゃん等) - Human villagers
煙々羅 - Enenra
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: ToyoRai on June 11, 2013, 06:39:22 AM
Quick tip to those who want to vote now: Go to Touhou wiki and search up your favourite characters. Their profiles should have their names in kanjis. Copy them and paste on the right box if I understand the progress right.If not, then you can still insert them there to compare the names on the list to find the right one.

Also, music list also can have same song multiple times if they have appeared in multiple games. So if you like one version of particular song, keep that in mind.The songs are paired together by games so that can help find the right version.

Character:
1. Momiji Inubashiri
2. Reisen Udongein Inaba
3. Toyosatomimi no Miko
4. Hong Meiling
Ichirin Kumoi

Music:
1. Shoutoku Legend ~ True Administrator (Hopeless Masquerade)
2. Cute Devil ~ Innocense
3. Fall of Fall ~ Autumnal Fall
4. Bhavaagra As Seen Through a Child's Mind
5. Our Hisoutensoku
6. Heian Alien
7. Swordsman of a Distant Star

Pairing:
Yoshika Miyako x Seiga Kaku
Reason: Closest canon pairing lol
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Clarste on June 11, 2013, 07:11:40 AM
Quick tip to those who want to vote now: Go to Touhou wiki and search up your favourite characters. Their profiles should have their names in kanjis. Copy them and paste on the right box if I understand the progress right.If not,t en you can still insert them there to compare the names on the list.

Also, music list also can have same song if they have appeared in multiple games. So if you like one version of particular song, keep that in mind.
The right box is for comments. If you only put things there I don't think it'll do anything. You have to use the menu on the left.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: ToyoRai on June 11, 2013, 07:14:04 AM
The right box is for comments. If you only put things there I don't think it'll do anything. You have to use the menu on the left.
I did say that if not, then just put it there so that you can compare the names on the list to find the right name.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Forte Blackadder on June 11, 2013, 07:15:21 AM
I wonder if Reimu and Marisa would ever out of top 10
Can Kokoro take the throne in such a short time? :3

Also, I'm quite fine with the characters, but the music vote killed me twice. Where the hell is my beloved 砕月 D:
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Clarste on June 11, 2013, 07:36:48 AM
Here are my votes, along with the reasons I put in the comments. Looking at it now, I think I might be either be trying to skew the results away from the earlier games, or I just kind of forgot about them.

Character:
1. Seiga Kaku (Evil Seiga is best Seiga)
2. Mamizou Futatsuiwa (Tanuki Pride)
3. Kasen Ibaraki
4. Toyosatomimi no Miko (Almighty Taoist Ruler of the Universe)
5. Hieda no Akyuu

Music:
1. Solar Sect of Mystic Wisdom ~ Nuclear Fusion
2. Fires of Hokkai
3. Futatsuiwa From Sado (Ten Desires version)
4. Lullaby of Deserted Hell
5. Satori Maiden ~ 3rd Eye
6. The Mystery in Your Town
7. ...I can't remember what I put

Pairing:
Mamizou Futatsuiwa and Kosuzu Motoori
Reason: So Cool.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Helepolis on June 11, 2013, 07:38:59 AM
I wonder if Reimu and Marisa would ever out of top 10
Can Kokoro take the throne in such a short time? :3
Byakuren managed to do it with her BGM to take a top 3, though based on characters themselves, that is always a huge guess. And taking Reimu's throne? That requires guts!

I might have a slight feeling Septette will be perhaps kicked from #1 this time and then people will cry in joy and pelvic thrust until the morning dawn.

Heh.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Cadmas on June 11, 2013, 07:49:46 AM
Reimu wins every year.

Welp. Vote anyways.

1.Shikieiki 2.Hina  3. Minoriko 4. Tewi 5. Futo


Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Zil on June 11, 2013, 07:55:38 AM
I'll post my votes I guess.

1. Chiyuri
2. Yumemi
3. Reimu
4. Rika
5. Eiki

1. Higan Retour ~ Riverside View
2. the Last Judgement
3. Now, Until the Moment You Die
4. Septette for the Dead Princess
5. Satori Maiden ~ 3rd Eye
6. Plastic Mind
7. Faith is for the Transient People

Pairing: Chiyuri and Yumemi
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: cuc on June 11, 2013, 08:33:05 AM
Problem is, this is not the 10th Popularity Contest at all. It is simply Touhou Popularity Contest, hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai, no relation to the THWiki one.

If you call this "the 10th", what do you call THWiki's 10th proper contest?
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Helepolis on June 11, 2013, 09:34:22 AM
Problem is, this is not the 10th Popularity Contest at all. It is simply Touhou Popularity Contest, hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai, no relation to the THWiki one.

If you call this "the 10th", what do you call THWiki's 10th proper contest?
Oh? Needs clarification on this. Is there a THwiki 10th contest?  Because now we are hearing different things.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: cuc on June 11, 2013, 10:17:00 AM
From their site (http://nicodosai.com/vote/what):
Quote
"Touhou Popularity Contest" is an entirely separate and different project from THWiki's delayed "The 10th Touhou Series Popularity Contest", and is not its replacement event.
Emphasis theirs.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Tengukami on June 11, 2013, 10:32:08 AM
This contest is rigged; the humans always win. How long are they gonna keep the youkai down? What is it going to take? I say to you today, my friends, that in spite of the difficulties and frustrations of the moment, I still have a dream. It is a dream deeply rooted in the Gensokyan dream. I have a dream that one day this country will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: "We hold these truths to be self-evident: that humans and youkai are created equal." I have a dream that-

Alright. Voting.

Thanks, Drake!
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Helepolis on June 11, 2013, 10:55:28 AM
Cuc,  crystal clear explanation. So I assume thwiki is going to hold their voting sometime in the future?

I assume that we cannot consider this voting contest official then and cannot be compared with previous results? I am doubting the situation now. Or am I over-thinking too much?
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Quwanti on June 11, 2013, 11:59:34 AM
It was not hard to choose.
Characters:
3pt. Hina Kagiyama
2pt. Tenshi Hinanawi
2pt. Ichirin Kumoi
1pt. Kogasa Tatara
1pt. Mononobe no Futo

Music:
3pt. Magus Night
2pt. Unknown X ~ Unfound Adventure
2pt. Wind of Agartha
1pt. Sky Ruin
1pt. Voyage 1969
1pt. Spring Lane ~ Colorful Path
1pt. The Traditional Old Man and the Stylish Girl  (Shinkirou)
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Limian on June 11, 2013, 12:52:12 PM
1. Mai
2. Mokou
3. Koishi
4. Youmu
5. Ellen

I actually like Mokou and Koishi more than Mai, but I didn't want to pick one over the other, so I just decided to give Mai a little boost.

1. Satori Maiden ~ 3rd Eye
2. Necrofantasia
3. Onigashima in the Fairyland ~ Missing Power
4. Flight of the Bamboo Cutter ~ Lunatic Princess
5. Strange Bird of the Moon, Illusion of Mysterious Cat
6. the Last Judgement
7. Greenwich in the Sky

...and this one was more "pick random songs I like" than "decide which songs are my favourites".

Pairing:
Ellen and Kana
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Arcorann on June 11, 2013, 01:00:42 PM
Cuc,  crystal clear explanation. So I assume thwiki is going to hold their voting sometime in the future?

I assume that we cannot consider this voting contest official then and cannot be compared with previous results? I am doubting the situation now. Or am I over-thinking too much?

The voting contest will be attracting a slightly different pool of voters due to different methods of publicity, in general creating a skew towards the Nico community. Having said that, I wouldn't discount this poll's results entirely. It should be interesting to see what the differences are like.

Anyway, can someone edit the OP to clarify that this is not the THWiki 10th popularity contest but instead the Touhou Nico Dousai popularity contest?
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Ciel on June 11, 2013, 01:35:32 PM
Voter's questionaire (http://vote.nicodosai.com/questions/new)
1) Please tell us your age.

2) Please tell us the state you live in.

3) Which of the following original works do you own?

4) What do you like about Touhou? (Multiple answers allowed)

5) When did you know about Touhou?

6) Do you use Nico Nico Douga? If so, when did you start watching it?

7) Have you seen any of it's published works on the internet? If so, where do you see them announced?

8) Have you ever participated in a Doujin circle?

9) Out of the following, which of these doujin festivals have you joined?

10) In the past year, aside from Touhou-only doujin festivals, how many did you participate in?

11) Have you ever participated in a doujinshi party other than a sale? (Game tournaments, Live concerts, Reading clubs, Meetings)

12) How much money did you spend on doujins in the last year? (Excluding original work)

13) Out of these, which of the following websited do you use? (Multiple answers allowed)

14) Have you ever voted for the Touhou Popularity Poll?

15) Have you ever traveled to the Suwa Grand Shrine on a 'pilgrimage', aware that Touhou's material is based on it?
~*~
Most likely wrong. 8D; Feel free to correct me for those who do know.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Forte Blackadder on June 11, 2013, 01:43:36 PM
I think it's due to the number of voters in this contest compared to the "proper one"
Since they're all surveys, voting contest so if both have similar quantity then it's ok. There will be differences of course, since they may or may not attract different range of people. Let's see what the result will be. If Hakurei Reimu is not in top 3 then I'll celebrate.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Kingault on June 11, 2013, 02:19:56 PM
Characters:
Yukari(For the hell of it)
Ran
Hong Meiling
Koakuma
And then I picked the first choice to make it 5
Should've gone with Patchy instead of Koakuma and maybe Mamizou for #5 but I was too lazy to go through the list)

Songs:
Kid's Festival Innocent Treasures
Extend Ash Hourai Victim
Faint Dream Inanimate Dream
Ghostly Eyes(from one of the CDs I think?)
Reincarnation
Demystify Feast
Romantic Children

Would've been Eternal Shrine Maiden instead of Feast but I couldn't find it.

OH WELL.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Helepolis on June 11, 2013, 03:00:55 PM
The voting contest will be attracting a slightly different pool of voters due to different methods of publicity, in general creating a skew towards the Nico community. Having said that, I wouldn't discount this poll's results entirely. It should be interesting to see what the differences are like.

Anyway, can someone edit the OP to clarify that this is not the THWiki 10th popularity contest but instead the Touhou Nico Dousai popularity contest?
That is exactly my worries and more like speculative outcome. It cannot be compared with previous voting contests since it is not the same. Also kind of weird why Nico Dousai would start such a voting contest with the exact same method as Thwiki has been doing. Has there been any official communication or announcements made between the two?

All we know now by Cuc is that NicoDousai firmly confirms that it is not a replacement.

I think it's due to the number of voters in this contest compared to the "proper one"
Since they're all surveys, voting contest so if both have similar quantity then it's ok. There will be differences of course, since they may or may not attract different range of people. Let's see what the result will be. If Hakurei Reimu is not in top 3 then I'll celebrate.
That is highly doubtable. I wouldn't consider this a 10th voting contest. We need to imo clear this in the opening.

I'll wait Drake's action first, don't want to go ahead and change things without proper communication.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Zengar Zombolt on June 11, 2013, 03:44:16 PM
We could call this the 9.5th popularity contest. Just sayin'.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: chum on June 11, 2013, 04:02:55 PM
My votes were:
Kogasa
Satori
Yumemi
Nazrin
Byakuren

Cosmic Mind
Ultimate Truth
Retrospective Kyoto
UFO Romance in the Night Sky
Capital City of Flowers in the Sky
Fairy Wars
Hellfire Mantle
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: highzealot on June 11, 2013, 04:27:31 PM
My character votes were:

1. Marisa
2. Momiji
2. Mystia
3. Lily White
3. Mima
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: tohosubs on June 11, 2013, 06:09:40 PM
That is exactly my worries and more like speculative outcome. It cannot be compared with previous voting contests since it is not the same.
Based on views and comments on Nico (Nicopedia article, video announcing the poll), there still seem to be many people who don't know that this is being held. There's a push (though not led by any group in particular) to promote the poll on Twitter; I've been seeing tweets and RTs from popular video creators that they voted. There were comments dated 6/10 that they found out about the poll on Twitter, so hopefully the word is getting out.

Some relevant links for those of you who can read Japanese: poll announcement (http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm20981003), comments on Nicopedia articles on Touhou Wiki poll (http://dic.nicovideo.jp/a/%E6%9D%B1%E6%96%B9%E3%82%B7%E3%83%AA%E3%83%BC%E3%82%BA%E4%BA%BA%E6%B0%97%E6%8A%95%E7%A5%A8), Touhou Nico Dosai poll (http://dic.nicovideo.jp/a/%E6%9D%B1%E6%96%B9%E3%83%8B%E3%82%B3%E7%AB%A5%E7%A5%AD%E6%9D%B1%E6%96%B9%E4%BA%BA%E6%B0%97%E6%8A%95%E7%A5%A8)

The response to the new poll, among those who do know about it, seems to be positive overall. There's a minority that don't like the coupling category. Some seemed worried that the event would blow up, with negative comments being posted on result announcement video etc. Related: "Coupling" was changed after the initial announcement to "Best partners."

Also kind of weird why Nico Dousai would start such a voting contest with the exact same method as Thwiki has been doing. Has there been any official communication or announcements made between the two?
No. The Nico Dousai organisers seem to be doing it because hey, why not? and the usual organisers at Thwiki haven't said anything. (The last announcement is from December saying no poll this year.) It makes sense to me for Nico Dousai to use the same method (it'd be interesting to see how say increasing the number of characters you can vote for would affect the result, but you wouldn't be able to assess that effect well anyway since the sample will be different). The partner category is their way of trying something new.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Clarste on June 11, 2013, 06:13:00 PM
The response to the new poll, among those who do know about it, seems to be positive overall (though there's a minority that don't like the partner category).
What's wrong with the Partner category? I like the fact that it's so vague. You could think of in terms of shipping, shot types, how well they get along in canon, how well they work in Manzai comedy, whatever. Two characters you like seeing together for whatever reason.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: tohosubs on June 11, 2013, 06:24:50 PM
What's wrong with the Partner category? I like the fact that it's so vague. You could think of in terms of shipping, shot types, how well they get along in canon, how well they work in Manzai comedy, whatever. Two characters you like seeing together for whatever reason.
Sorry, I edited the post above. People didn't like the "Coupling" category (there were apparently some inflammatory comments, though I haven't looked hard enough to find them), so it was changed to the more neutral "Best partners."
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Clarste on June 11, 2013, 06:29:34 PM
Sorry, I edited the post above. People didn't like the "Coupling" category (there were apparently some inflammatory comments, though I haven't looked hard enough to find them), so it was changed to the more neutral "Best partners."
Oh, I see. I think I would have been one of the people complaining then. ;)
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Helepolis on June 11, 2013, 07:21:24 PM
Coupling probably leans more towards a love-love impression and partner is more neutral? Well, I guess it depends on how each individual grasps the words.

I have to be honest about the fact that I have never voted for the previous, nor will for the future. I prefer more like to compare votes/polls for myself and figure out some numbers. Since subjective remains subjective, there will be logically no explanation nor anything. It just fuels my curiosity in general.

Which is why I am kind of pressing the subject on the differences. I don't intend to boycott it or anything. Lets get that straight, just to provide proper information to prevent "misleading"/confusing information.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Shikieiki on June 11, 2013, 08:08:35 PM
Thanks for the reminder! I went with:

1. Shikieiki
2. Kanako
3. Shou
4. Yumemi
5. Seiga

1. Missing Power
2. Greenwich in the Sky
3. Mysterious Mountain
4. The Tiger-Patterned Vaisravana
5. Suwa Foughten Field
6. Himorogi, Burn in Violet
7. Till When?
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Kilgamayan on June 11, 2013, 08:52:43 PM
The best 2hu pairing is Shoutoku-taishi x Tojiko no Iratsume. Trufax.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Sage Ω (Ultima) on June 11, 2013, 09:12:15 PM
1:Reisen Undongein Inaba
2:Eirin
3:Miko
4:Youmu
5:Sanae Kochiya


1:Desire Drive
2:Dimension Reverie (from Mystic Square)
3:Futasuiwa from Sado
4:Tiger Patterned Bishamonten
5:Reach for the Moon ~ Immortal Smoke
6:Loose Rain
7:Staking your life on a prank (it should've been "stalking")

鈴仙・優曇華院・イナバ - Reisen Udongein Inaba
レイセン - Reisen

There are two Reisens?
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Darkness1 on June 11, 2013, 09:18:17 PM
My pick:
Character votes:
3. Yuuka Kazami.
2. Gengetsu.
2. Suika Ibuki.
1. Fujiwara no Mokou.
1. Reimu Hakurei.

Music votes:
3. Faint Dream ~ Inanimate Dream.
2. Septette for the dead princess (EoSD).
2. Dichromatic Lotus Butterfly ~ Ancients (SG).
1. Plastic Mind (MS).
1. Cosmic Mind (UFO).
1. Hartmann's Youkai Girl (SA).
1. The Youkai Mountain ~ Mysterious Mountain (MoF).

Partner:
1. Marisa and Mima :V

Hope I just took the right choices in the menu, as it was a bit difficult to get the right names together.

There are two Reisens?
Yes, the one called Reisen, or Reisen II, first appears in Silent Sinner in Blue. Apparently she is another lunar rabbit soldier from the moon, but with no specific powers(?).
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Drake on June 11, 2013, 10:54:33 PM
I was aware of all the things mentioned, and pretty much took care to point out that this isn't the same poll, but I'll reword the OP again and TITLE CHANGE
EDIT: DONE
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Kingault on June 12, 2013, 12:13:17 AM
Hm, I could use my two other e-mails to get the characters/songs I couldn't fit in...
That would be cheating, though.
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: commandercool on June 12, 2013, 12:23:28 AM
Characters:
1: Keine
2: Mokou
3: Youmu
4: Reimu
5: Patchouli

Music:
1: Solar Sect Of Mystic Wisdom~Nuclear Fusion
2: Fires Of Hokkai
3: Lullaby Of Forgotten Hell
4: Futatsuiwa From Sado (Ten Desires)
5: Let's Live In A Lovely Cemetery
6: Heartfelt Fancy
7: Border Of Life
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Kosachi on June 12, 2013, 12:34:41 AM
Characters:
-Tenshi Hinanai (3 Points)
-Kogasa Tatara (2 Points)
-Remilia Scarlet (2 Points)
-Toyosatomimi no Miko (1 Point)
-Koishi Komeiji (1 Point)

BGMs
-Flawless Clothing of the Celestial (3 Points)
-Catastrophe in Bhava-Agra (2 Points)
-Shoutoku Legend~True Administrator (2 Points)
-Faith is for the Transient People (1 Points)
-Satori Komeiji's 3rd Eye (1 Point)
-Lost Emotion (1 Point)
-Septette for the Dead Princess (1 Point)
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: Clarste on June 12, 2013, 12:40:56 AM
Yes, the one called Reisen, or Reisen II, first appears in Silent Sinner in Blue. Apparently she is another lunar rabbit soldier from the moon, but with no specific powers(?).
For the record, since her name is spelled differently in Japanese (in katakana, like a foreign name), I've always been in favor of calling her Raysen instead of Reisen II, but it's way too late to get that to stick.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 12, 2013, 01:03:21 AM
List of Music titles
(In the order they appear to select)
Thanks to Luin for preparing this!

春色小径 ~ Colorful Path(東方心綺楼) - Spring Lane ~ Colorful Path (HM)
メイガスナイト(心綺楼) - Magus Night (HM)
時代親父とハイカラ少女(東方心綺楼) - The Traditional Old Man and the Stylish Girl (HM)
感情の摩天楼 ~ Cosmic Mind(東方心綺楼) - Emotional Skyscraper ~ Cosmic Mind (HM)
大神神話伝(心綺楼) - Legend of the Great Gods (HM)
聖徳伝説 ~ True Administrator(東方心綺楼) - Shoutoku Legend ~ True Administrator (HM)
芥川龍之介の河童 ~ Candid Friend(東方心綺楼) - Akutagawa Ryuunosuke's "Kappa" ~ Candid Friend (HM)
ハルトマンの妖怪少女(東方心綺楼) - Hartmann's Youkai Girl (HM)
佐渡の二ッ岩(東方心綺楼) - Futatsuiwa from Sado (HM)
幻想郷の二ッ岩 - Futatsuiwa from Gensokyo (HM)
亡失のエモーション - The Lost Emotion
塵界不変のペシミズム - This Dull World's Unchanging Pessimism
心綺楼囃子 - Shinkirou Orchestra
人気のある場所 - A Popular Location
人気のない場所 - An Unpopular Location
丑三つ時の里 - The Village in the Dead of Night
本日の一面記事 - Today's Front-Page Headline
暁雲 - Morning Clouds
官板黄昏新聞 - Officially-Sanctioned Tasogare Newspaper

緑のサナトリウム - Green Sanatorium
牛に引かれて善光寺参り - Led On by a Cow to Visit Zenkou Temple
ハートフェルトファンシー(伊弉諾物質) - Heartfelt Fancy (NToJ)
六十年目の東方裁判 ~ Fate of Sixty Years(伊弉諾物質) - Eastern Judgement in the Sixtieth Year ~ Fate of Sixty Years (NToJ)
アガルタの風 - Wind of Agartha
イザナギオブジェクト - Izanagi Object
妖怪裏参道(伊弉諾物質) - Youkai Back Shrine Road (NToJ)
アンノウンX ~ Unfound Adventure(伊弉諾物質) - Unknown X ~ Unfound Adventure (NToJ)
日本中の不思議を集めて - Gathering the Mysterious from All Around Japan
素敵な墓場で暮しましょ(伊弉諾物質) - Let's Live in a Lovely Cemetery (NToJ)

衛星トリフネ - Satellite TORIFUNE
トロヤ群の密林 - Trojan Asteroid Jungle
デザイアドライブ(鳥船遺跡) - Desire Drive (TGA)
フェアリー冒険譚(鳥船遺跡) - The Fairies' Adventurous Tale (TGA)
天鳥船神社 - Ame-no-torifune Shrine
夜空のユーフォーロマンス(鳥船遺跡) - UFO Romance in the Night Sky (TGA)
ハルトマンの妖怪少女(鳥船遺跡) - Hartmann's Youkai Girl (TGA)
天鳥船神社の結界 - The Barrier of Ame-no-torifune Shrine
感情の摩天楼 ~ Cosmic Mind(鳥船遺跡) - Emotional Skyscraper ~ Cosmic Mind (TGA)
宇宙に浮かぶ幻想郷 - The Gensokyo That Floats in Outer Space

欲深き霊魂 - Spirit of Avarice
死霊の夜桜 - Night Sakura of Dead Spirits
ゴーストリード - Ghost Lead
妖怪寺へようこそ - Welcome to Youkai Temple
門前の妖怪小娘 - Youkai Girl at the Gate
素敵な墓場で暮しましょ(東方神霊廟) - Let?s Live in a Lovely Cemetery (TD)
リジッドパラダイス - Rigid Paradise (TD)
デザイアドライブ(東方神霊廟) - Desire Drive (TD)
古きユアンシェン - Old Yuanxian
夢殿大祀廟 - The Hall of Dreams' Great Mausoleum
大神神話伝(東方神霊廟) - Legend of the Great Gods (TD)
小さな欲望の星空 - Starry Sky of Small Desires
聖徳伝説 ~ True Administrator(東方神霊廟) - Shoutoku Legend ~ True Administrator (TD)
妖怪裏参道(東方神霊廟) - Youkai Back Shrine Road (TD)
佐渡の二ッ岩(東方神霊廟) - Futatsuiwa from Sado (TD)
神社の新しい風 - A New Wind at the Shrine
デザイアドリーム - Desire Dream
プレイヤーズスコア(東方神霊廟) - Player's Score (TD)

春の氷精 - An Ice Fairy in Spring
可愛い大戦争のリフレーン(妖精大戦争) - The Refrain of the Lovely Great War (GFW)
いたずらに命をかけて - Staking Your Life on a Prank
年中夢中の好奇心 - Year-Round Absorbed Curiosity
真夜中のフェアリーダンス - A Midnight Fairy Dance
妖精大戦争 ~ Fairy Wars - Great Fairy Wars ~ Fairy Wars
ルーズレイン - Loose Rain
メイガスナイト(妖精大戦争) - Magus Night (GFW)
春の氷精 - 静 -  -  An Ice Fairy in Spring - still -
プレイヤーズスコア(妖精大戦争) - Player's Score (GFW)

ニュースハウンド - Newshound
あなたの町の怪事件 - The Mystery in Your Town
妖怪モダンコロニー(ダブルスポイラー) - Youkai Modern Colony (DS)
ネメシスの要塞 - Nemesis' Stronghold
無間の鐘 ~ Infinite Nightmare(ダブルスポイラー) - Bell of Avici ~ Infinite Nightmare (DS)
妖怪の山 ~ Mysterious Mountain(ダブルスポイラー) - The Youkai Mountain ~ Mysterious Mountain (DS)

君はあの影を見たか - Did You See that Shadow?
萃夢想(東方非想天則) - Memory of Forgathering Dream (Soku)
伝説の巨神 - The Legendary Titan
ぼくらの非想天則 - Our Hisoutensoku
人形のある風景 - The Scenery of Living Dolls
悠久の蒸気機関 - The Eternal Steam Engine
信仰は儚き人間の為に(東方非想天則) - Faith Is for the Transient People (Soku)
おてんば恋娘(東方非想天則) - Tomboyish Girl in Love (Soku)
上海紅茶館 ~ Chinese Tea(東方非想天則) - Shanghai Teahouse ~ Chinese Tea (Soku)
霊知の太陽信仰 ~ Nuclear Fusion(東方非想天則) - Solar Sect of Mystic Wisdom ~ Nuclear Fusion (Soku)
明日ハレの日、ケの昨日(東方非想天則)  - Tomorrow Will Be Special, Yesterday Was Not (Soku)
二色蓮花蝶 ~ Ancients(東方非想天則) - Dichromatic Lotus Butterfly ~ Ancients (Soku)
恋色マジック(東方非想天則) - Love-Colored Magic (Soku)
the Grimoire of Alice(東方非想天則) - the Grimoire of Alice  (Soku)
ヴワル魔法図書館(東方非想天則) - Voile, the Magic Library  (Soku)
東方妖恋談(東方非想天則) - Eastern Mystical Love Consultation (Century's End Version) (Soku)
アンノウンX ~ Unfound Adventure(東方非想天則) - Unknown X ~ Unfound Adventure (Soku)
空に浮かぶ物体X - X, the Floating Object in the Sky
巨大な影と小さな結末 - A Huge Shadow and a Tiny Conclusion

青空の影 - A Shadow in the Blue Sky
春の湊に - At the End of Spring
小さな小さな賢将 - A Tiny, Tiny, Clever Commander
閉ざせし雲の通い路 - The Sealed Cloud Route
万年置き傘にご注意を - Beware the Umbrella Left There Forever
スカイルーイン - Sky Ruin
時代親父とハイカラ少女(東方星蓮船) -The Traditional Old Man and the Stylish Girl (UFO)
幽霊客船の時空を越えた旅 - Interdimensional Voyage of a Ghostly Passenger Ship
キャプテン・ムラサ - Captain Murasa
魔界地方都市エソテリア - Rural Makai City Esoteria
虎柄の毘沙門天 - The Tiger-Patterned Bishamonten
法界の火 - Fires of Hokkai
感情の摩天楼 ~ Cosmic Mind(東方星蓮船) - Emotional Skyscraper ~ Cosmic Mind (UFO)
夜空のユーフォーロマンス(東方星蓮船) - UFO Romance in the Night Sky (UFO)
平安のエイリアン - Heian Alien
妖怪寺 - Youkai Temple
空の帰り道 ~ Sky Dream - Returning Home From the Sky ~ Sky Dream
プレイヤーズスコア(東方星蓮船) - Player's Score (UFO)
 
地霊達の起床 - Awakening of the Earth Spirits
暗闇の風穴 - The Dark Blowhole
封じられた妖怪 ~ Lost Place - The Sealed-Away Youkai ~ Lost Place
渡る者の途絶えた橋 - The Bridge People No Longer Cross
緑眼のジェラシー - Green-Eyed Jealousy
旧地獄街道を行く - Walking the Streets of a Former Hell
華のさかづき大江山 - A Flower-Studded Sake Dish on Mt. Ooe
ハートフェルトファンシー(東方地霊殿) - Heartfelt Fancy (SA)
少女さとり ~ 3rd eye - Satori Maiden ~ 3rd eye
廃獄ララバイ - Lullaby of Deserted Hell
死体旅行 ~ Be of good cheer! - Corpse Voyage ~ Be of good cheer!
業火マントル - Hellfire Mantle
霊知の太陽信仰 ~ Nuclear Fusion(東方地霊殿) - Solar Sect of Mystic Wisdom ~ Nuclear Fusion (SA)
ラストリモート - Last Remote
ハルトマンの妖怪少女(東方地霊殿) - Hartmann's Youkai Girl (SA)
地霊達の帰宅 - The Earth Spirits' Homecoming
エネルギー黎明 ~ Future Dream... - Energy Daybreak ~ Future Dream...
プレイヤーズスコア(東方地霊殿) - Player's Score (SA)

緋想天 - Sky of Scarlet Perception
日常坐臥 - Usual Days
地の色は黄色 - The Ground's Color is Yellow
甲論乙駁 - Argue for and Against
風光明媚 - Beautiful Nature Sight
香る樹葉花 - Fragrant Plants
踊る水飛沫 - Dancing Water Spray
以魚駆蠅 - Swing a Fish to Drive Away Flies
放縦不羈 - Drunk as I Like
嘲りの遊戯 - Ridiculous Game
冷吟閑酔 - Free and Easy
雲外蒼天 - Skies Beyond the Clouds
黒い海に紅く ~ Legendary Fish - Crimson in the Black Sea ~ Legendary Fish
天衣無縫 - Flawless Clothing of the Celestials
有頂天変 ~ Wonderful Heaven - Catastrophe in Bhavaagra ~ Wonderful Heaven
幼心地の有頂天 - Bhavaagra As Seen Through a Child's Mind
暮色蒼然 - Darkening Dusk
東方緋想天 - Eastern Sky of Scarlet Perception
東方妖恋談(東方緋想天) - Eastern Mystical Love Consultation (SWR)
星の器 ~ Casket of Star(東方緋想天) - Vessel of Stars ~ Casket of Star (SWR)
フラワリングナイト(東方緋想天) - Flowering Night (SWR)
ブクレシュティの人形師(東方緋想天) - The Doll Maker of Bucuresti (SWR)
広有射怪鳥事 ~ Till When~(東方緋想天) - Hiroari Shoots a Strange Bird ~ Till When? (SWR)
ラクトガール ~ 少女密室(東方緋想天) - Locked Girl ~ The Girl's Secret Room (SWR)
幽雅に咲かせ、墨染の桜 ~ Border of Life(東方緋想天) - Bloom Nobly, Ink-Black Cherry Blossom ~ Border of Life (SWR)
亡き王女の為のセプテット(東方緋想天) - Septette for a Dead Princess (SWR)
夜が降りてくる - Night Falls
砕月(東方緋想天) - Broken Moon (SWR)
狂気の瞳 ~ Invisible Full Moon(東方緋想天) - Lunatic Eyes ~ Invisible Full Moon (SWR)
風神少女(東方緋想天) - Wind God Girl (SWR)
彼岸帰航 ~ Riverside View(東方緋想天) - Higan Retour ~ Riverside View (SWR)

封印されし神々 - Sealed Gods
人恋し神様 ~ Romantic Fall - A God That Misses People ~ Romantic Fall
稲田姫様に叱られるから - Because Princess Inada Is Scolding Me
厄神様の通り道 ~ Dark Road - The Road of the Misfortune God ~ Dark Road
運命のダークサイド - Dark Side of Fate
神々が恋した幻想郷 - The Gensokyo the Gods Loved
芥川龍之介の河童 ~ Candid Friend(東方風神録) - Akutagawa Ryuunosuke's "Kappa" ~ Candid Friend (MoF)
フォールオブフォール ~ 秋めく滝 - Fall of Fall ~ Autumnal Waterfall
妖怪の山 ~ Mysterious Mountain(東方風神録) - The Youkai Mountain ~ Mysterious Mountain (MoF)
少女が見た日本の原風景 - The Primal Scene of Japan the Girl Saw
信仰は儚き人間の為に(東方風神録) - Faith Is for the Transient People (MoF)
御柱の墓場 ~ Grave of Being - Cemetery of Onbashira ~ Grave of Being
神さびた古戦場 ~ Suwa Foughten Field - The Venerable Ancient Battlefield ~ Suwa Foughten Field
明日ハレの日、ケの昨日(東方風神録) - Tomorrow Will Be Special, Yesterday Was Not (MoF)
ネイティブフェイス - Native Faith
麓の神社 - Shrine at the Foot of the Mountain
神は恵みの雨を降らす ~ Sylphid Dream - The Gods Give Us Blessed Rain ~ Sylphid Dream
プレイヤーズスコア(東方風神録) - Player's Score (MoF)

天狗の手帖 ~ Mysterious Note - Tengu's Notebook ~ Mysterious Note
風の循環 ~ Wind Tour - Wind Circulation ~ Wind Tour
天狗が見ている ~ Black Eyes - Tengu is Watching ~ Black Eyes
東の国の眠らない夜(東方文花帖) - Sleepless Night of the Eastern Country (StB)
レトロスペクティブ京都(東方文花帖) - Retrospective Kyoto (StB)
風神少女(東方文花帖) - Wind God Girl (StB)

花映塚 ~ Higan Retour - Flower Viewing Mound ~ Higan Retour
春色小径 ~ Colorful Path(東方花映塚) - Spring Lane ~ Colorful Path (PoFV)
オリエンタルダークフライト - Oriental Dark Flight
フラワリングナイト(東方花映塚) - Flowering Night (PoFV)
東方妖々夢 ~ Ancient Temple(東方花映塚) - Eastern Mystical Dream ~ Ancient Temple (PoFV)
狂気の瞳 ~ Invisible Full Moon(東方花映塚) - Lunatic Eyes ~ Invisible Full Moon (PoFV)
おてんば恋娘の冒険(東方花映塚) - Adventure of the Lovestruck Tomboy (PoFV)
幽霊楽団 ~ Phantom Ensemble(東方花映塚) - Ghostly Band ~ Phantom Ensemble (PoFV)
もう歌しか聞こえない ~ Flower Mix - Deaf to All but the Song ~ Flower Mix
お宇佐さまの素い幡(東方花映塚) - White Flag of Usa Shrine
風神少女  (Short Version) - Wind God Girl (Short Version)
ポイズンボディ ~ Forsaken Doll - Poison Body ~ Forsaken Doll
今昔幻想郷 ~ Flower Land - Gensokyo, Past and Present ~ Flower Land
彼岸帰航 ~ Riverside View(東方花映塚) - Higan Retour ~ Riverside View (PoFV)
六十年目の東方裁判 ~ Fate of Sixty Years(東方花映塚) - Eastern Judgement in the Sixtieth Year ~ Fate of Sixty Years (PoFV)
花の映る塚 - The Mound where the Flowers Reflect
此岸の塚 - Mound of Life
花は幻想のままに - The Flower Like the Fantasy
魂の花 ~ Another Dream... - Flower of Soul ~ Another Dream...

萃夢想(東方萃夢想) - Memory of Forgathering Dream (IaMP)
東方妖恋談(東方萃夢想) - Eastern Mystical Love Consultation (IaMP)
少女綺想曲 ~ Capriccio(東方萃夢想) - Maiden's Capriccio (IaMP)
恋色マジック(東方萃夢想) - Love-Coloured Magic (IaMP)
魔女達の舞踏会 - The Witches' Ball
メイドと血の懐中時計(東方萃夢想) - The Maid and the Pocket Watch of Blood (IaMP)
月時計 ~ ルナ・ダイアル(東方萃夢想) - Lunar Clock ~ Lunar Dial (IaMP)
ブクレシュティの人形師(東方萃夢想) - The Doll Maker of Bucuresti (IaMP)
人形裁判 - Doll Judgment
ラクトガール ~ 少女密室(東方萃夢想) - Locked Girl ~ Girl's Secret Room (IaMP)
ヴワル魔法図書館(東方萃夢想) - Voile, the Magic Library (IaMP)
広有射怪鳥事 ~ Till When~(東方萃夢想) - Hiroari Shoots a Strange Bird ~ Till When? (IaMP)
東方妖々夢 ~ Ancient Temple(東方萃夢想) - Eastern Mystical Dream ~ Ancient Temple (IaMP)
亡き王女の為のセプテット(東方萃夢想) - Septette for a Dead Princess (IaMP)
幽雅に咲かせ、墨染の桜 ~ Border of Life(東方萃夢想) - Bloom Nobly, Ink-Black Cherry Blossom ~ Border of Life (IaMP)
Demystify Feast(東方萃夢想) - Demystify Feast (IaMP)
夜が降りてくる ~ Evening Star(東方萃夢想) - Night Falls ~ Evening Star (IaMP)
御伽の国の鬼が島 ~ Missing Power - Oni's Island in the Fairyland ~ Missing Power (IaMP)
夏明き - End of Summer
東方萃夢想 - Eastern Memory of Forgathering Dream
魔所 - Demonic Place
月輪 - The Moon
遍参 - Wanderings
裏心 - Inner Heart
Intermezzo - Intermezzo
あゆのかぜ - Eastern Wind
森閑 - Silence
仰空 - Skygazer
幽境 - Solitary Place
珍客 - Unexpected Visitor
紅夜 - Scarlet Night
戦迅 - Swift Battle
禍機 - Bad Omen
砕月(東方萃夢想) - Broken Moon (IaMP)

永夜抄 ~ Eastern Night. - Eternal Night Vignette ~ Eastern Night
幻視の夜 ~ Ghostly Eyes(東方永夜抄) - Illusionary Night ~ Ghostly Eyes (IN)
蠢々秋月 ~ Mooned Insect - Stirring an Autumn Moon ~ Mooned Insect
夜雀の歌声 ~ Night Bird - Song of the Night Sparrow ~ Night Bird
もう歌しか聞こえない - Deaf to All but the Song
懐かしき東方の血 ~ Old World - Nostalgic Blood of the East ~ Old World
プレインエイジア - Plain Asia
永夜の報い ~ Imperishable Night. - Retribution for the Eternal Night ~ Imperishable Night
少女綺想曲 ~ Dream Battle - Maiden's Capriccio ~ Dream Battle
恋色マスタースパーク - Love-Colored Master Spark
シンデレラケージ ~ Kagome-Kagome - Cinderella Cage ~ Kagome-Kagome
狂気の瞳 ~ Invisible Full Moon(東方永夜抄) - Lunatic Eyes ~ Invisible Full Moon (IN)
ヴォヤージュ1969(東方永夜抄) - Voyage 1969 (IN)
千年幻想郷 ~ History of the Moon(東方永夜抄) - Gensokyo Millennium ~ History of the Moon (IN)
竹取飛翔 ~ Lunatic Princess(東方永夜抄) - Flight in the Bamboo Cutter ~ Lunatic Princess (IN)
ヴォヤージュ1970 - Voyage 1970
エクステンドアッシュ ~ 蓬莱人 - Extend Ash ~ Person of Hourai
月まで届け、不死の煙 - Reach for the Moon, Immortal Smoke
月見草 - Evening Primrose
Eternal Dream ~ 幽玄の槭樹 - Eternal Dream ~ Mystical Maple
東方妖怪小町 - Eastern Youkai Beauty

妖々夢 ~ Snow or Cherry Petal - Mystical Dream ~ Snow or Cherry Petal
無何有の郷 ~ Deep Mountain - Paradise ~ Deep Mountain
クリスタライズシルバー - Crystallized Silver
遠野幻想物語 - The Fantastic Tales from Tono
ティアオイエツォン(withered leaf) - Diao Ye Zong (withered leaf)
ブクレシュティの人形師(東方妖々夢) - The Doll Maker of Bucuresti (PCB)
人形裁判 ~ 人の形弄びし少女(東方妖々夢) - Doll Judgment ~ The Girl who Played with People's Shapes (PCB)
天空の花の都 - The Capital City of Flowers in the Sky
幽霊楽団 ~ Phantom Ensemble(東方妖々夢) - Ghostly Band ~ Phantom Ensemble (PCB)
東方妖々夢 ~ Ancient Temple(東方妖々夢) - Eastern Mystical Dream ~ Ancient Temple (PCB)
広有射怪鳥事 ~ Till When~(東方妖々夢) - Hiroari Shoots a Strange Bird ~ Till When? (PCB)
アルティメットトゥルース - Ultimate Truth
幽雅に咲かせ、墨染の桜 ~ Border of Life(東方妖々夢) - Bloom Nobly, Ink-Black Cherry Blossom ~ Border of Life (PCB)
ボーダーオブライフ - Border of Life
妖々跋扈 - Youkai Domination
少女幻葬 ~ Necro-Fantasy(東方妖々夢) - A Maiden's Illusionary Funeral ~ Necro-Fantasy (PCB)
妖々跋扈 ~ Who done it! - Youkai Domination ~ Who done it!
ネクロファンタジア(東方妖々夢) - Necrofantasia (PCB)
春風の夢 - Dream of a Spring Breeze
さくらさくら ~ Japanize Dream... - Sakura, Sakura ~ Japanize Dream...

赤より紅い夢  -  A Dream that is more Scarlet than Red
ほおずきみたいに紅い魂 - A Soul as Red as a Ground Cherry
妖魔夜行 - Apparitions Stalk the Night
ルーネイトエルフ - Lunate Elf
おてんば恋娘(東方紅魔郷) - Tomboyish Girl in Love (EoSD)
上海紅茶館 ~ Chinese Tea(東方紅魔郷) - Shanghai Teahouse ~ Chinese Tea (EoSD)
明治十七年の上海アリス(東方紅魔郷) - Shanghai Alice of Meiji 17 (EoSD)
ヴワル魔法図書館(東方紅魔郷) - Voile, the Magic Library (EoSD)
ラクトガール ~ 少女密室(東方紅魔郷) - Locked Girl ~ The Girl's Secret Room (EoSD)
メイドと血の懐中時計(東方紅魔郷) - The Maid and the Pocket Watch of Blood (EoSD)
月時計 ~ ルナ・ダイアル(東方紅魔郷)  - Lunar Clock ~ Luna Dial (EoSD)
ツェペシュの幼き末裔 - The Young Descendant of Tepes
亡き王女の為のセプテット(東方紅魔郷) - Septette for a Dead Princess (EoSD)
魔法少女達の百年祭 -The Centennial Festival for Magical Girls
U.N.オーエンは彼女なのか?(東方紅魔郷) - U.N. Owen was Her? (EoSD)
紅より儚い永遠 - An Eternity that is More Transient than Scarlet
紅楼 ~ Eastern Dream... - Crimson Tower ~ Eastern Dream...

怪綺談 ~ Mystic Square
Dream Express
魔法陣 ~ Magic Square
夢想時空
霊天 ~ Spiritual Heaven
Romantic Children
プラスチックマインド
メイプルワイズ
禁断の魔法 ~ Forbidden Magic
真紅の少女 ~ Crimson Dead!!
裏切りの少女 ~ Judas Kiss
the Last Judgement
悲しき人形 ~ Doll of Misery
世界の果て ~ World's End
神話幻想 ~ Infinite Being
不思議の国のアリス
the Grimoire of Alice(東方怪綺談)
神社
Endless
久遠の楽園
Mystic Dream
Peaceful Romancer
魂の休らむ所
幻想郷 ~ Lotus Land Story
Witching Dream
Selene's light
装飾戦 ~ Decoration Battle
Break the Sabbath
紅響曲 ~ Scarlet Phoneme
Bad Apple!!
霊戦 ~ Perdition crisis
アリスマエステラ
少女綺想曲 ~ Capriccio(東方幻想郷)
星の器 ~ Casket of Star(東方幻想郷)
Lotus Love
眠れる恐怖 ~ Sleeping Terror
Dream Land
幽夢 ~ Inanimate Dream
禁じざるをえない遊戯
メイド幻想 ~ Icemilk Magic
かわいい悪魔 ~ Innocence
Days
Peaceful
Arcadian Dream
幻想の住人
Lotus Road
Dreamy pilot
Incomplete Plot
Border Land
Magic Shop of Raspberry
Crescent Dream
夢は時空を越えて
Selection
東方妖恋談(東方夢時空)
Reincarnation
Dim. Dream
Tabula rasa ~ 空白少女
Maniacal Princess
夢消失 ~ Lost Dream
夢幻遊戯 ~ Dream War
魔法決戦! ~ Fight it out!
Sailor of Time
Strawberry Crisis!!
非統一魔法世界論
魔法鐘愛
久遠の夢
東方の青い空
永遠の満月
Maple Dream...
霊人の休日
勝利デモ
ゲームオーバー
時の風
スターボウドリーム
Phantasmagoria
東方封魔録 ~ 浄土曼荼羅
博麗 ~ Eastern Wind
She's in a temper!!
End of Daylight
やみのちから
幻夢界
死を賭して
ひもろぎ、むらさきにもえ
恋色マジック(東方封魔録)
東方封魔録 ~ 幽幻乱舞
Complete Darkness
エキストララブ
戦車むすめのみるゆめ
遠野の森
昔話わんだーらんど
博麗神社境内
陽落ちて
封魔終演
A Sacred Lot
永遠の巫女(東方靈異伝)
The Positive and Negative
Highly Responsive to Prayers
東方怪奇談(東方靈異伝)
天使伝説
Oriental Magician
破邪の小太刀
魔鏡
the Legend of KAGE
いざ、倒れ逝くその時まで
Civilization of Magic
星幽天使
アイリス
風の神社
秋霜玉 ~ Clockworks
フォルスストロベリー
プリムローズシヴァ
幻想帝都
ディザストラスジェミニ
華の幻想 紅夢の宙
天空アーミー
スプートニク幻夜(秋霜玉)
機械サーカス ~ Reverie
カナベラルの夢幻少女
魔法少女十字軍(秋霜玉)
アンティークテラー
夢機械 ~ Innocent Power
幻想科学 ~ Doll's Phantom
少女神性 ~ Pandora's Box
シルクロードアリス
魔女達の舞踏会 ~ Magus
二色蓮花蝶 ~ Ancients(秋霜玉)
ハーセルヴズ
タイトルドメイド
稀翁玉 ~ Fairy Dance
天鵞絨少女戦 ~ Velvet Battle
Castle Explorer -in the Sky-
オルフェの詩 ~ Pseudoclassic
新幻想 ~ New Fantasy
オルレアンの聖騎士
My Maid, Sweet Maid
桜花之恋塚 ~ Flower of Japan
乙女戦士 ~ Heart of Valkyrie
エニグマティクドール ~ God Knows
蓬莱伝説
二色蓮花蝶 ~ Red and White
桜花之恋塚 ~ Japanese Flower
明治十七年の上海アリス(蓬莱人形)
東方怪奇談(蓬莱人形)
エニグマティクドール
サーカスレヴァリエ
人形の森
Witch of Love Potion(蓬莱人形)
リーインカーネイション
U.N.オーエンは彼女なのか?(蓬莱人形)
永遠の巫女(蓬莱人形)
空飛ぶ巫女の不思議な毎日
夜のデンデラ野を逝く
少女秘封倶楽部
東方妖々夢 ~ Ancient Temple(蓮台野夜行)
古の冥界寺
幻視の夜 ~ Ghostly Eyes(蓮台野夜行)
魔術師メリー
月の妖鳥、化猫の幻
過去の花 ~ Fairy of Flower
魔法少女十字軍(蓮台野夜行)
少女幻葬 ~ Necro-Fantasy(蓮台野夜行)
幻想の永遠祭
童祭 ~ Innocent Treasures
華胥の夢
上海紅茶館 ~ Chinese Tea(夢違科学世紀)
ヴォヤージュ1969(夢違科学世紀)
科学世紀の少年少女
永夜の報い ~ Imperishable Night
夜が降りてくる ~ Evening Star(夢違科学世紀)
人形裁判 ~ 人の形弄びし少女(夢違科学世紀)
夢と現の境界
幻想機械 ~ Phantom Factory
幽玄の槭樹 ~ Eternal Dream
ヒロシゲ36号 ~ Neo Super-Express
53ミニッツの青い海
竹取飛翔 ~ Lunatic Princess(卯酉東海道)
彼岸帰航 ~ Riverside View(卯酉東海道)
青木ヶ原の伝説
お宇佐さまの素い幡(卯酉東海道)
月まで届け不死の煙
レトロスペクティブ京都(卯酉東海道)
ラクトガール ~ 少女密室(卯酉東海道)
千年幻想郷 ~ History of the Moon(卯酉東海道)
最も澄みわたる空と海
月面ツアーへようこそ
天空のグリニッジ
東の国の眠らない夜(大空魔術)
車椅子の未来宇宙
Demystify Feast(大空魔術)
衛星カフェテラス
G Free
大空魔術 ~ Magical Astronomy
ネクロファンタジア(大空魔術)
向こう側の月
未知の花 魅知の旅 New
無間の鐘 ~ Infinite Nightmare(未知の花 魅知の旅)
明日ハレの日、ケの昨日(未知の花 魅知の旅)
風神少女(東方文花帖(書籍))
おてんば恋娘の冒険(東方文花帖(書籍))
花映塚 ~ after Higan Retour
ジャパニーズサーガ
阿礼の子供
夜の鳩山を飛ぶ‐Power Mix
サニールチルフレクション
夜だから眠れない
妖精燦々として
サニーミルクの紅霧異変
雪月桜花の国
スターヴォヤージュ2008
可愛い大戦争のリフレーン(東方三月精)
フェアリー冒険譚(東方三月精)
二つの世界
神域のかくれんぼ暮らし
妖怪モダンコロニー(東方三月精)
妖怪宇宙旅行
綿月のスペルカード ~ Lunatic Blue
呑んべぇのレムリア (Retro Ver)
魔法使いの憂鬱
スプートニク幻夜(TheGrimoireofMarisa)
テーマ・オブ・イースタンストーリー
呑んべぇのレムリア
AN ORDEAL FROM GOD
キュアリアス上海古牌
神魔討綺伝 AN ORDEAL FROM GOD
Witch of Love Potion(トルテルマジック)
Magical and Hopeless
Sacred Battle
宵闇の魔術師
Magic of Life
Plastic Space
Frontal Attack
Inventive City
夢幻回廊
蓬莱幻想 ~ far East
夜の鳩山を飛ぶ
妖々跋扈 ~ Speed Fox!



Obviously not all the tracks are done, but large portion of them are. If anyone wants to pick up the rest that would be fantastic.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Suikama on June 12, 2013, 02:00:32 AM
man zun is a beast
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Starxsword on June 12, 2013, 04:44:32 AM
Yeah, I should mention my vote:

Character:
1. Youmu Konpaku
2. Remilia Scarlet
2. Tenshi Hinanai
3. Hata no Kokoro
3. Yuyuko Saigyouji

Music:
1. Septette for the Dead Princess
2. As Seen Through a Child's Mind
2. Lost Emotion
x. Phantom Ensemble
x. Nuclear Fusion
x. Missing Power
x. Wonderful Heaven

Partner:
1. Yuyuko and Yukari.

Quote
暮色蒼然 - Darkening Dusk

Heh, I already voted, but now that I know what Darkening Dusk looks like, I'll vote for that next time.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: warpshadow on June 12, 2013, 07:37:55 AM
My votes
3. Nitori
2. Meiling
2. Shou
1. Sakuya
1. Aya

I will vote for music later

Partner Meiling and Sakuya.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: PhantomSong on June 12, 2013, 08:08:52 AM
Characters:
3.Yuyuko
2.Youmu
2.Hata no Kokoro
1.Lyrica
1. Parsee
1. Koishi

Songs:
3.Phantom Ensemble
2. Bloom Nobly Cherry Blossoms of Sumizome ~ Border of Life
2. Greenwich in the Sky
1. Green Eyed Jealousy
1. Ultimate Truth
1. Love Coloured Master Spark
1. Necrofantasia

Partner: Yuyuko and Youmu
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: iK on June 12, 2013, 03:04:20 PM
Done

Characters

3pt: Medicine Melancholy
2pt: Toyosatomimi no Miko
2pt: Mononobe no Futo
1pt: Elly
1pt: Ellen


Character Pairing

Medicine Melancholy and Alice Margatroid


Music

3pt: Green-Eyed Jealousy
2pt: Lullaby for a Deserted Hell
2pt: Tabula Rasa ~ The Empty Girl
1pt: A Rural Makai City Esoterica
1pt: A Small Desire's Starry Sky
1pt: Fires of Hokkai
1pt: The Fantastic Tale of Touno

With a special mention to: Lovely Mound of Chery Blossoms ~ Flower of Japan
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: MewMewHeart on June 12, 2013, 08:39:29 PM
This is my first time participating in a Touhou popularity poll contest, so I hope I'm doing this right.  :ohdear:

Characters:
3 points: Reisen Udongein Inaba
2 Point:  Kaguya Houraisan
2 Point:  Toyosatomimi no Miko
1 Point:  Tewi Inaba (*facepalm* Now how did I let Miko get the second 2 point spot.)
1 Point:  Reimu Hakurei

Songs:
3 Point:   Cinderella Cage ~ Kagome-Kagome
2 Point:   Flight in the Bamboo Cutter ~ Lunatic Princess
2 Point:   Maiden's Capriccio ~ Dream Battle
1 Point:   Love-Colored Master Spark
1 Point:   Emotional Skyscraper ~ Cosmic Mind
1 Point:   Shotoku Legend ~ True Administer
1 Point:   Septette for a Dead Princess

Partner Choice:  Toyosatomimi no Miko and Mononobe no Futo  (I was gonna put something crazy, but then I realized I would probably get canned for it.  :derp: )
Title: Re: 10th Annual Touhou Popularity Contest (Hosted by Touhou Nico Dousai)
Post by: cuc on June 13, 2013, 01:13:30 AM
For the record, since her name is spelled differently in Japanese (in katakana, like a foreign name), I've always been in favor of calling her Raysen instead of Reisen II, but it's way too late to get that to stick.
Judging from things like SWR's patch history file, the method favored by ZUN and company seems to be using "Udonge" for Reisen U. I., and leave "Reisen" exclusively to the second Reisen.

I'm trying to stick to "Udonge" for her, but also constantly failing to do so.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: tohosubs on June 14, 2013, 01:07:47 AM
The official hashtag is #thnc_vote: https://twitter.com/search?q=%23thnc_vote
Results so far based on tweets with this hashtag (sample size 1687): http://pic.twitter.com/v2IgxL0EiS
I can't find the official source.

Number of votes as of the 11th, from the official nicodosai Twitter account:
Characters: ~12200, Music ~9400, Best partners: ~9700, Questionnaire: ~5000
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Blue on June 14, 2013, 02:12:07 AM
Characters:
3 points: Fujiwara no Mokou
2 points:  Lyrica Prismriver
2 points:  Minamitsu Murasa
1 point:  Patchouli Knowledge
1 point:  Nitori Kawashiro

The other Prismrivers would be here, but they weren't because diversity.

Songs:
3 points:   Magus Night
2 points:   Reach for the Moon ~ Immortal Smoke
2 points:   Ghostly Band ~ Phantom Ensemble
1 point:   Faith is for the Transient People (Soku ver.)
1 point:   Unknown X ~ Unfound Adventure
1 point:   Captain Murasa
1 point:   Satori Maiden ~ 3rd Eye

The 1 point choices were basically whatever good pieces I could think of off the top of my head.

No partner choice because I haven't given any thought at all to that. Maybe later.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Aqua Soo on June 14, 2013, 09:39:56 AM
Participated, even though I like too many characters/music and cannot choose "favorites." Just ordered most things on whim. Tried to lean toward underrated (relatively) songs to raise awareness (?) for them.

Characters:
[3] Ibuki Suika
[2] Shiki Eiki Yamaxanadu
[2] Yakumo Yukari
[1] Medicine Melancholy
[1] Ibaraki Kasen

Music:
[3] Onigashima in the Fairyland ~ Missing Power
[2] Eternal Shrine Maiden (Dolls in Pseudo Paradise)
[2] Sixtieth Year' Eastern Judgement ~ Fate of Sixty Years
[1] Night Falls ~ Evening Star
[1] Blue Sea of 53 Minutes
[1] Magician Mary
[1] Heartfelt Fancy

I am kinda curious why Nico Dousai decided to separate a lot of similar pieces that simply have different renditions (sometimes with very slight differences). It will probably split the votes for that music and end up "hurting" its rank. In that situation, I ended up just picking the original rendition in hopes that most will vote for that, except Eternal Shrine Maiden because of sheer difference in sound quality lol.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: monhan on June 15, 2013, 03:03:11 AM
I'm borrowing your format, aquamarin. Here's mine:

Characters:
[3] Yakumo Yukari
[2] Hijiri Byakuren
[2] Reiuji Utsuho
[1] Shiki Eiki Yamaxanadu
[1] Hinanai Tenshi

Music:
[3] Emotional Skyscraper ~ Cosmic Mind(TGA) , any version really but I had to pick
[2] Night Falls ~ Evening Star
[2] The Venerable Ancient Battlefield ~ Suwa Foughten Field
[1] Sixtieth Year' Eastern Judgement ~ Fate of Sixty Years
[1] Solar Sect of Mystic Wisdom ~ Nuclear Fusion (SA)
[1] The Gensokyo the Gods Loved
[1] Eastern Sky of Scarlet Perception

Kinda worried that they separate the music in different games, Cosmic Mind have 3 for example. I wonder if  they'll combine the votes for them...

Best Partner : Yakumo Yukari and Hijiri Byakuren
An odd one, I know. Well, it's because of a certain doujin...
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Grand Octopus on June 15, 2013, 01:51:39 PM
I was disappointed when the thwiki poll didn't go ahead, so I'm glad for this alternative. Anyway:

Characters
1. Kanako Yasaka
2. Satori Komeiji
3. Nue Houjuu
4. Alice Margatroid
5. Hata no Kokoro

Music
1. Satori Maiden ~ 3rd eye
2. Illusionary Night ~ Ghostly Eyes
3. Fall of Fall ~ Autumnal Waterfall
4. Septette for a Dead Princess
5. The Venerable Ancient Battlefield ~ Suwa Foughten Field
6. Lullaby of Deserted Hell
7. Broken Moon (SWR)

No real changes from last year other than Kokoro squeezing into my top 5 characters. I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt on a few points for the time being.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: iK on June 15, 2013, 03:12:25 PM
Kinda worried that they separate the music in different games, Cosmic Mind have 3 for example. I wonder if  they'll combine the votes for them...


Don't worry about it, Septette will win like always making the whole thing irrelevant.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: monhan on June 16, 2013, 01:22:34 AM
Dunno about that though, this isn't the one from THwiki. For example, the recent result showed that Alice is on top, followed by Koishi and Remilia. Who knows how it'll end.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kingault on June 16, 2013, 03:15:25 AM
In retrospect, I should have put Mokou as #1, but of course I decided to mess around.
Meh, whatever.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: MewMewHeart on June 16, 2013, 03:20:16 AM
Now, I'm curious to see what's the results for this poll so far.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kingault on June 16, 2013, 03:32:57 AM
Now, I'm curious to see what's the results for this poll so far.

Unnamed TD Stage 1 midboss #1!
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: AnonymousPondScum on June 16, 2013, 03:35:08 AM
THERE IS NO GOD BUT CATFISH.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kilgamayan on June 16, 2013, 03:44:31 AM
Characters:
[3] Aya Shameimaru
[2] Reisen Udongein Inaba
[2] Eiki Shiki, Yamaxanadu at Law
[1] Toyosatomimi no Miko
[1] Komachi Onozuka

Music:
[3] Wind God Girl (StB ver because I was too lazy to hunt down the BAiJR ver)
[2] Doll Judgment (PCB ver)
[2] Invisible Full Moon (IN ver)
[1] Fires of Hokkai
[1] Nuclear Fusion (SA ver)
[1] True Administrator (XD ver)
[1] Autumnal Waterfall

Best Partner: Toyosatomimi no Miko and Soga no Tojiko
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Aya Reiko on June 16, 2013, 04:33:03 AM
Charas

1. Alice
2's. Cirno & Meiling
3's. Reisen & Yukari

Music.
I forget

Pair
Yukari & Yuyuko

Survey
Said I was from Hokkaido but otherwise told the truth.

...in hindsight, I wish I picked Momiji & Kagerou
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Clarste on June 16, 2013, 05:11:30 AM
...in hindsight, I wish I picked Momiji & Kagerou
The poll doesn't have Kagerou anyway, since it doesn't include DDC characters. It does have Kokoro though.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Captain Vulcan on June 16, 2013, 07:28:52 PM
Hmm. Here are my votes:

Characters:

1. Aya Shameimaru
2. Byakuren Hijiri
3. Seiga Kaku
4. Kasen Ibaraki
5. Eirin Yagokoro
6. Satori Komeiji

Music:

1. The Gensokyou That the Gods Loved
2. UFO Romance In the Night Sky
3. Alice In Wonderland & Old Yuanxian
4. Last Remote
5. Maiden's Cappricio

Partners or whatnot:

Kasen & Seiga. C'mon, when the jasen gave Kasen her a business card I thought it was beyond hilarious.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Forte Blackadder on June 18, 2013, 05:10:19 PM
Has it already ended or what ?

(http://img843.imageshack.us/img843/5940/bz2k.jpg)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Clarste on June 18, 2013, 05:31:38 PM
Has it already ended or what ?

(http://img843.imageshack.us/img843/5940/bz2k.jpg)
Voting ended on the 16th, but I thought it was supposed to be announced on the 30th. Since it's being tallied by computer though, it shouldn't really take any time to count so I wouldn't be surprised if the results were leaked.

Looks like Kokoro wormed her way up to #20.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kaze_Senshi on June 18, 2013, 07:00:57 PM
Koishi is pretty popular this year  :o anyway Youmu is between the top10 so it is OK :)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 18, 2013, 07:09:12 PM
While these numbers may be good, I'm still obviously not going to count this as an official result.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Sage Ω (Ultima) on June 18, 2013, 07:27:08 PM
Yeah so can anyone tell me who's in the top 10 or 20?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 18, 2013, 07:35:51 PM
remilia alice koishi reimu marisa aya flandre sakuya youmu satori tenshi sanae mokou yuuka momiji nitori yuyuko yukari patchouli kokoro
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Sage Ω (Ultima) on June 18, 2013, 07:39:36 PM
Didn't expect Remilia to win.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Suikama on June 18, 2013, 07:49:37 PM
remilia alice koishi reimu marisa aya flandre sakuya youmu satori tenshi sanae mokou yuuka momiji nitori yuyuko yukari patchouli kokoro meiling
fixed

just out of top 20 ;_;
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 18, 2013, 07:50:21 PM
Didn't expect Remilia to win.
it




was




luck
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Aya Reiko on June 18, 2013, 08:42:33 PM
it




was




fate

Fixed that for ya.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: tohosubs on June 18, 2013, 09:42:05 PM
This is a more recent version of what I posted earlier. It's an "exit poll" based on tweets that have the official hashtag and are in a certain format. Given the point differences at the top, definitely not final.

They're making the results announcement video, to be posted on the 30th.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 18, 2013, 11:22:07 PM
Fixed that for ya.
(http://i.imgur.com/QoZPfI7.png)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Gpop on June 18, 2013, 11:48:08 PM
remilia alice koishi reimu marisa aya flandre sakuya youmu satori tenshi sanae mokou yuuka momiji nitori yuyuko yukari patchouli kokoro
If this is true holy fuck Koishi your popularity really did increase.

...pun probably intended :V
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Suikama on June 18, 2013, 11:49:35 PM
If this is true holy fuck Koishi your popularity really did increase.

...pun probably intended :V
now shes confirmed op :V
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Star King on June 19, 2013, 01:40:44 AM
Never posted my list:

1. Byakuren Hijiri
2. Yukari Yakumo
2. Komachi Onozuka
3. Shou Toramaru
3. Remilia Scarlet

Pretty bad about picking favorites though. A lot of others had the potential to make it. The only two that clearly feel the best of the best are Byakuren and Yukari.

Speaking of which...

Best Partner : Yakumo Yukari and Hijiri Byakuren
An odd one, I know. Well, it's because of a certain doujin...

OK, normally I wouldn't care but seeing as who it is, I have to ask.

-------

Music:
1. Emotional Skyscraper ~ Cosmic Mind
2. Septette for the Dead Princess
2. Night Sakura of Dead Spirits
3. The Tiger-Patterned Bishamonten
3. Native Faith
3. Desire Drive
3. The Ground's Color is Yellow

Also bad at picking favorites here. Except Byakuren's theme. BEST.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: iK on June 19, 2013, 07:15:27 PM
I find it a bit funny that even with a substantially smaller voter base, it seems Medicine still ends up at exactly 65th place.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: MewMewHeart on June 21, 2013, 01:06:42 AM
I guess Remilia just *shades* manipulated her fate, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YMPAH67f4o (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6YMPAH67f4o)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kingault on June 21, 2013, 02:17:50 AM
OK, normally I wouldn't care but seeing as who it is, I have to ask.

I have a guess, but I'd rather be sure...
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: PhantomSong on June 21, 2013, 07:13:16 AM
remilia alice koishi reimu marisa aya flandre sakuya youmu satori tenshi sanae mokou yuuka momiji nitori yuyuko yukari patchouli kokoro
Didn't expect Satori to be so high up :o
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Arcorann on June 21, 2013, 11:07:40 AM
Didn't expect Satori to be so high up :o
Satori was already 10th in the 2012 THWiki popularity poll. By my analysis she could be anywhere between 7th to 16th in this one.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: tohosubs on June 29, 2013, 01:45:14 AM
Come watch the results announcement video released live with other Touhou fans!
http://nazr.in/5nh
11am eastern, 8am pacific

I'm also compiling videos from the Nico Dousai at http://nazr.in/5ng

[edit] Sorry, am not pm.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Arcorann on June 29, 2013, 11:07:46 AM
Well, I've come up with some projected score and rank ranges. The score range is intended to be an approximation of a 95% confidence interval (hence the large width). The rank ranges are narrower than the score ranges due to the way I generated them (keeping the scores for all other characters constant and taking the extreme values of the score). The analysis methodology is available on request.

If anyone knows how to make the table fancier, please share.

EDIT: Rearranged in order of estimated rank. Changes: (Alice, Koishi) (2, 3)-->(3, 2), (Mokou, Yuuka) (13, 14) --> (14, 13), (Yuyuko, Yukari) (17, 18) --> (18, 17), (Cirno, Byakuren) (23, 24) --> (24, 23),  (Parsee, Utsuho) (25, 27) --> (27, 25), (Ran, Nue) (30, 31) --> (31, 30), (Iku, Miko) (37, 38) --> (38, 37), (Eiki, Rin, Hatate) (39, 40, 41) --> (40, 41, 39), (Kaguya, Seiga) (45, 46) --> (46, 45), (Keine, Maribel) (49, 50) --> (50, 49), (Koakuma, Yuugi, Kyouko) (57, 58, 59) --> (58, 59, 57), (Medicine, Tojiko) (65, 67) --> (67, 65), (Yoshika, Tewi) (71, 72) --> (72, 71), (Alice's dolls, Rinnosuke) (76, 77) --> (77, 76), (Yumeko, Reisen II, Mai) (89. 90, 91) --> (91. 89, 90)
Also fixed a couple of typos.

EDIT2: One last fix (for entries near the bottom). And yes, I know the results are already out.

NameLow pointsHigh pointsLow rankHigh rank
Remilia4775597951
Koishi4769593951
Alice4711590461
Reimu4404556671
Marisa4354549471
Aya4231539281
Flandre39065007104
Sakuya37874886116
Youmu34894582147
Satori34994541147
Tenshi33924400158
Sanae31304166159
Yuuka30664060179
Mokou30384055179
Momiji299639831811
Nitori263935932013
Yukari266435891913
Yuyuko259835502013
Patchouli240433182216
Kokoro228931162616
Meiling214130072919
Kogasa209829462919
Byakuren201428183220
Cirno195328143320
Utsuho195527563320
Renko194727563320
Parsee190827293420
Rumia180226233521
Hina179726153521
Nue175224943622
Ran170725013822
Futo172024673823
Suwako162723874123
Reisen158923354225
Mystia152322734328
Nazrin147421854428
Miko142421234730
Iku141221324730
Hatate139320604833
Eiki133620535033
Rin133020265033
Daiyousei131619995033
Suika123919195135
Mamizou121618555136
Shou115818125136
Seiga115317845237
Kaguya114017945237
Kasen113517665337
Maribel110417215339
Keine107817235539
Minamitsu100116055943
Shizuha89515006345
Akyuu87714826345
Kanako84314486346
Wriggle83114406446
Ichirin81013816549
Kyouko81813506551
Koakuma78413456751
Yuugi78013356751
Minoriko74012906851
Lunasa71812636852
Komachi71412536852
Chen71212226952
Yamame63211327254
Tojiko63511007255
Kosuzu60310857256
Medicine58310907356
Eirin55310437358
Lyrica5159987360
Letty5069777361
Tewi4869167364
Yoshika4749197364
Yumemi4178567764
Yorihime3197018171
Lunasa3176908171
Rinnosuke3026848271
Alice's dolls2886788571
Shinki2756338673
Star2576168773
Merlin2405998773
Kisume2005428874
Lily1805138874
Gengetsu1775018974
Sunny1744898974
Toyohime1744898974
Mugetsu1724779074
Mima1544609276
Unnamed book-reading youkai1194149779
Reisen II933459981
Mai943319981
Yumeko7934210381
Kana7632910382
Kotohime6732610382
Fairy6231210482
Leila5829910484
Elly5726910487
Chiyuri5726910487
Unzan4126810987
Ellen3925310988
YuugenMagan2623710988
Kurumi2222211889
Yuki2222211889
Tsuchinoko2222211889
Hobgoblin1320611889
Genjii719011889
Rikako719011889
Youki719011889
Kappa517411890
Sake bug517411890
UFO214114895
Crow/raven214114895
Konngara214114895
Sara214114895
Eientei youkai rabbits214114895
Meira214114895
Kedama214114895
Sariel214114895
Moon rabbit214114895
etc.010614899
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: tohosubs on June 29, 2013, 12:17:40 PM
Nice. Do cool kids like you live in Japan?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Imosa on June 29, 2013, 01:03:35 PM
The analysis methodology is available on request.
Yeah, I'd like to hear it. The numbers are pointless without knowing how you got them.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Arcorann on June 29, 2013, 01:28:57 PM
Well, there were a few steps involved:

* Finding confidence intervals for the proportion of 3-point and 2-point votes. This was the easiest, simply construct confidence intervals (I used the Wilson score interval (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binomial_proportion_confidence_interval#Wilson_score_interval) due to the probabilities being small).
* Estimating the number of 1-point votes and finding a confidence interval. For this step I used a weighted average of (no. of 2-point votes) and 2*(no. of 3-point votes), with somewhat arbitrarily chosen weights of 3/4 and 1/4 respectively. (I considered using a regression based on THWiki's polls, then remembered that they don't post the number of 2-point votes.)
* Combining the estimates to create a final confidence interval. This was the least rigorous part; the method I used consisted of adding the confidence intervals together, then adjusting the centre and width of the interval based on the ratios of the true standard deviation to the sum of (half) the widths.

The spreadsheet I used is here. (https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/67879549/nicodousai_surveyanalysis.ods)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Ciel on June 29, 2013, 02:38:52 PM
First Place: Remilia

FIRST PLACE: REMILIA

I KNOW THIS ISN'T THE OFFICIAL RESULTS BUT

IS REIMU FINALLY BEATEN!?!?!?

TY ARCO~
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: tohosubs on June 29, 2013, 03:15:36 PM
Results announcement now postponed to 18:00.
http://nicodosai.com/event/live_list/each/22

source: https://twitter.com/nicodosai
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: MewMewHeart on June 29, 2013, 09:05:36 PM
Remilia Scarlet got charisma! <3
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Arcorann on June 30, 2013, 03:06:47 AM
First Place: Remilia

FIRST PLACE: REMILIA

I KNOW THIS ISN'T THE OFFICIAL RESULTS BUT

IS REIMU FINALLY BEATEN!?!?!?

TY ARCO~

You're behind the times. These are based on the exit poll conducted last week. Anyway, Reimu still has a chance, just not a high one since she needs to beat Remilia, Koishi and Alice who are basically neck and neck.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 30, 2013, 09:08:22 AM
LIVE RESULTS

70 Hieda no Akyuu
69 Yumemi Okazaki
68 Medicine Melancholy
67 Lunasa Prismriver
66 Maribel Hearn
65 Soga no Tojiko
64 Yoshika Miyako
63 Tewi Inaba
62 Rinnosuke Morichika
61 Minoriko Aki
60 Yamame Kurodani
59 Koakuma
58 Eirin Yagokoro
57 Shizuha Aki
56 Kyouko Kasodani
55 Minamitsu Murasa
54 Chen
53 Hatate Himekaidou
52 Yuugi Hoshiguma
51 Ichirin Kumoi
50 Kanako Yasaka
49 Komachi Onozuka
48 Daiyousei
47 Shou Toramaru
46 Mystia Lorelei
45 Seiga Kaku
44 Suika Ibuki
43 Rin Kaenbyou
42 Renko Usami
41 Mamizou Futatsuiwa
40 Kasen Ibaraki
39 Nazrin
38 Keine Kamishirasawa
37 Hina Kagiyama
36 Kaguya Houraisan
35 Nue Houjuu
34 Iku Nagae
33 Cirno
32 Suwako Moriya
31 Parsee Mizuhashi
30 Rumia
29 Reisen Udongein Inaba
28 Shikieiki Yamaxanadu
27 Toyosatomimi no Miko
26 Mononobe no Futo
25 Kogasa Tatara
24 Ran Yakumo
23 Utsuho Reiuji
22 Nitori Kawashiro
21 Byakuren Hijiri
20 Momiji Inubashiri
19 Hong Meiling
18 Patchouli Knowledge
17 Tenshi Hinanawi
16 Yuyuko Saigyouji
15 Fujiwara no Mokou
14 Hata no Kokoro
13 Yukari Yakumo
12 Yuuka Kazami
11 Youmu Konpaku
10 Sanae Kochiya
9 Satori Komeiji
8 Aya Shameimaru
7 Remilia Scarlet
6 Sakuya Izayoi
5 Alice Margatroid
4 Flandre Scarlet
3 Marisa Kirisame
2 Koishi Komeiji
1 Reimu Hakurei
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 30, 2013, 09:23:51 AM
Remilia must have cheated to get so high in the prelim count.

REIMU STILL REIGNS SUPREME
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Arcorann on June 30, 2013, 09:31:04 AM
LIVE RESULTS

70 45-63 Hieda no Akyuu
69 64-77 Yumemi Okazaki
68 56-73 Medicine Melancholy
67 52-68 Lunasa Prismriver
66 39-53 Maribel Hearn
65 55-72 Soga no Tojiko
64 64-73 Yoshika Miyako
63 64-73 Inaba Tewi
62 71-82 Rinnosuke Morichika
61 51-68 Minoriko Aki
60 54-72 Yamame Kurodani
59 51-67 Koakuma
58 58-73 Eirin Yagokoro
57 45-63 Shizuha Aki
56 51-65 Kyouko Kasodani
55 43-59 Minamitsu Murasa
54 52-69 Chen
53 33-48 Hatate Himekaidou
52 51-67 Yuugi Hoshiguma
51 49-65 Ichirin Kumoi
50 46-63 Kanako Yasaka
Four misses so far out of 21. I was wondering what kind of accuracy I would get.

@Drake: Isn't it more like Reimu getting abnormally low in the exit poll? After all, Remilia, Koishi and Alice all beat her.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 30, 2013, 09:32:41 AM
Yeah basically.

Anyways they're doing the pairings now but I keep getting kicked out of the room.
31 is Alice + Patchouli at least
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kilgamayan on June 30, 2013, 11:20:55 AM
Haha Remilia, 1st place in the exit polls and she can't even beat her own servant.

Koishi at #2 is legit shocking.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Ciel on June 30, 2013, 11:55:09 AM
You're behind the times. These are based on the exit poll conducted last week.
... *brb crying*;;

and she just dropped far DDD:

Here's hoping Koishi beats Reimu or something. D: ... She gets 1st place for who knows how long already.

Edit: Nevermind, I keep forgetting that voting has already ended. *sits quietly*
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: monhan on June 30, 2013, 12:01:26 PM
Any results for the musics?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Ciel on June 30, 2013, 12:52:00 PM
Any results for the musics?
http://nicodosai.com/vote/result/music

1) Septette for the dead princess
2) UN Owen was it Her
3) Emotional Skyscrapper ~ Cosmic Mind
4) Hartmann's Youkai Girl
5) Border of Life
6) The Gensokyo the Gods loved
7) Desire Drive
8) Necrofantasia
9) Satori Maiden ~ 3rd Eye
10) Last Remote

View the rest here! http://nicodosai.com/vote/result
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Quwanti on June 30, 2013, 01:11:38 PM
I've created a wiki article (http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Touhou_Nico_Dousai_Popularity_Contest), which may give the music list a better overview. It's a start.

And what, Hina on 37? (and under the character I really dislike) Blasphemy!
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kosachi on June 30, 2013, 01:27:22 PM
Septette and U.N Owen first and second again... not surprised why?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: monhan on June 30, 2013, 01:41:20 PM
The top 3 for the musics is the usual(yay, Cosmic Mind! Seems like they summed all the version).
The best paring is also the usual most popular ones, ReiMari on top. I'm the only one who vote for Yukari and Byakuren, they seriously need to read this http://www.mediafire.com/?zsgad4v73cqsxvg (I'll be working on it soon)
Aside from the obvious Reimu, the nice surprise is Koishi at 2nd, her theme is also at 4th. She's getting really popular lately.
Fun things to note from the questionnaire, though it mostly consists of people around the age of 20, there's still more than 800 people over the age of 30.
 
I expected a different result from the usual, but I guess I'm fine with this.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Limian on June 30, 2013, 02:45:52 PM
Quote
58 Eirin Yagokoro
50 Kanako Yasaka
49 Komachi Onozuka
45 Seiga Kaku
44 Suika Ibuki
43 Rin Kaenbyou
41 Mamizou Futatsuiwa
36 Kaguya Houraisan
-
48 Daiyousei
37 Hina Kagiyama
30 Rumia
25 Kogasa Tatara
20 Momiji Inubashiri
keep it up, fandom

Pleasantly surprised to see Eiki and Miko in the top 30, though (even if they're still beaten by Momiji), and Koishi at 2nd is nice as well.
Not sure why Flanbutt is beating Remilia and Sakuya, though.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: c l e a r on June 30, 2013, 03:29:44 PM
(waiting for g pop to come squeeing in)
any minute now...

In any case, I love how Koishi is doing so well.  Has Sanae been doing this bad since last year?  She should be way lower than 10.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Gpop on June 30, 2013, 04:37:40 PM
LIVE RESULTS
...
3 Marisa Kirisame
2 Koishi Komeiji
1 Reimu Hakurei

...

...WAT

WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT


This was REAL?

This is real right guys?

Not a joke or fake count?

Seriously guys why is Koishi becoming mainstream now guys this is too good why didn't she beat Reimu oh god Koishi you're getting noticed now asdkjlsdc- *shot*

...

...okay seriously though, this was a huge shocker for me. Like, I always felt like Koishi was always as popular as say...Nue. But I'd never think that Koishi's popularity would just THIS HIGH, even after the release of Hopeless Masquerade.

I guess this is probably because "she's is the girliest girl in touhou now." (quote from someone I forgot who)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Darkness1 on June 30, 2013, 05:17:18 PM
Attack of the flanfans.

Yuuka holds a steady place, so I'm pleased. I wouldn't disagree about the music votes either.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: AnonymousPondScum on June 30, 2013, 07:50:05 PM
HIJIRI TOP 25 YEAH.

I'm surprised Toyo no Miko is still relatively low on the totem pole after HM, on that note.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Starxsword on June 30, 2013, 08:15:38 PM
Hopeless Masquerade must have skyrocketed Koishi's popularity. I didn't think she was that popular.

Kokoro's 14th.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Algo on June 30, 2013, 08:33:03 PM
My beloved Suika still hold 30-40 places T_T nobody loves drunk loli with DFC. Koishi popularity be so good with hopeless masquerade and Kokoro in 20 top girls too. I wonder how new character reached that high rank popularity.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on June 30, 2013, 10:15:26 PM
I've created a wiki article (http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Touhou_Nico_Dousai_Popularity_Contest), which may give the music list a better overview. It's a start.
You need a medal.


Questionnaire: "What are your favorite parts about Touhou?" Despite multiple votes, "the gameplay" and "the story" are two of the least liked.
very disappoint
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: commandercool on July 01, 2013, 01:36:19 AM
Hmm. Keine in 38th place. Guess I can live with that. Almost in the top half. Next year can we make this a stupid hat contest instead of a popularity contest? Then victory is assured!

Questionnaire: "What are your favorite parts about Touhou?" Despite multiple votes, "the gameplay" and "the story" are two of the least liked.
very disappoint

I... see? :wat:

Edit: I wonder what facilitated Renko massively outranking Maribel. Can't imagine how that happened.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 01, 2013, 01:53:38 AM
I wonder what are the ranks for the partner section?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on July 01, 2013, 02:22:29 AM
If you went to the link Quwanti posted or the link that I posted in the OP under "Results" or the link I put in the post right after the OP meant for the results you would find it.

:derp:
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Kilgamayan on July 01, 2013, 02:40:59 AM
Holy shit, ReMari took third place in the partners poll? Beautiful.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: commandercool on July 01, 2013, 03:07:17 AM
Many of the partners pairings with only one vote are great. Nazrin and Yuugi? Sure, why not?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 01, 2013, 03:09:25 AM
Thanks Drake, I seriously should start looking more.

@Commandercool: *spittake* Nazrin and Yuugi?! What the hell were they smoking when they tried that pair???
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: AnonymousPondScum on July 01, 2013, 03:14:42 AM
I'm surprised Toyo no Miko is still semi-low on the totem pole after Hopeless Masquerade.

Questionnaire: "What are your favorite parts about Touhou?" Despite multiple votes, "the gameplay" and "the story" are two of the least liked.
very disappoint

Tragically I think you overestimate the priorities of a swath of the fanbase.

I feel your pain, bro. :(
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Drake on July 01, 2013, 03:44:53 AM
I knew that's how it would pan out; that's how it always does. I'm still disappointed lol.

oops new page
RESULTS: http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Touhou_Nico_Dousai_Popularity_Contest
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: tohosubs on July 01, 2013, 03:50:12 AM
Something to keep in mind when interpreting the results: Since this poll was organized by Nico Dosai, a bigger percentage of the voters were frequent Nico users. That means they were more likely to have been influenced by the latest handwritten/MMD fanworks popular on Nico, as well as old-time favorites on Nico.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest
Post by: Zil on July 01, 2013, 04:07:37 AM
Looks like my vote actually made a difference. Just enough to push Yumemi to 69th place. I call that a success.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: AnonymousPondScum on July 01, 2013, 04:09:34 AM
AaaaaaaAAAAAAAAAAAND Reimu takes 1st place again.

...

Well that was disappointing. I hate status quo. It's so predictable. :V
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Star King on July 01, 2013, 05:04:22 AM
^Don't we all.

Edit: I wonder what facilitated Renko massively outranking Maribel. Can't imagine how that happened.

Renko's outfit is far more stylish, duh.

OK, not meaning to attack people or anything, but seriously can someone explain to me why Momiji is so popular. I barely even know anything about her, considering she's a dialogue-less midboss. I'm definitely not mad about her keeping Byakuren out of the top 20 or anything >:(
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Shin Rokuren on July 01, 2013, 05:06:32 AM
Keine at 38.... At least Aya's top 10. But hmm, Kasen at 40th and 45th.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: AnonymousPondScum on July 01, 2013, 05:07:49 AM
^Don't we all.

OK, not meaning to attack people or anything, but seriously can someone explain to me why Momiji is so popular. I barely even know anything about her, considering she's a dialogue-less midboss. I'm definitely not mad about her keeping Byakuren out of the top 20 or anything >:(

She has a surprising amount of fanart that makes her look a lot more badass while still very pretty. I guess.

That much said...Yes. Why do the UFO and TD crew have such a hard time of it?

Even after HM Hijiri's still in the low top 25 and ToyoMiko's barely below that. Futo's the only lucky one. ;_;
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Gpop on July 01, 2013, 05:58:49 AM
Meanwhile, KoKoishi is top 10 in pairings. I like that. My new favourite pairing that outranks FlanKoi
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Algo on July 01, 2013, 06:16:28 AM
Embodiment of Scarlet Devil summary:
3 characters in top 10 ( 4 - Flandre, 6 - Sakuya, 7 - Remilia)
2 music in top 10 (first and second places)
2 partners in top 10 (5 - SakuyaxRemilia, 6 - SakuyaxChina)

EoSD so popular. Why we don't have touhou games contest :D
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: monhan on July 01, 2013, 02:10:28 PM
^Don't we all.

Renko's outfit is far more stylish, duh.

OK, not meaning to attack people or anything, but seriously can someone explain to me why Momiji is so popular. I barely even know anything about her, considering she's a dialogue-less midboss. I'm definitely not mad about her keeping Byakuren out of the top 20 or anything >:(
One of the reasons I can think of is she's the first inumimi character to show up before Inu-Sakuya came in. Not to mention that she's often paired with the popular Aya, that should raise her popularity. This also applies to the cast of EoSD.
Fans often find her cute and even after SoPM showed that she doesn't really have animal ears, fans just don't care. And with Kagerou now, don't expect her to go down anytime soon.

I'm fine with Byakuren being in top 25(along my top 3) she's 21 among over 150 characters and she's the most popular character from UFO, that's already good enough. And I'm quite satisfied that aside from Yukari and Yuyuko, she's one of most popular that's not just about being adorable or crazy, from the fandom perspective. Me like mature women, you see.
What I find funny though is that the highest partner for both Byakuren and Miko is actually HijiMiko. So much for the pairing from their respective games...
Isn't it sad, Tojiko?

For the music, I just think of Septette and UN'Owen as just the fans bias for the nostalgia much like Reimu for the most popular character, but hey, both of them are pretty good so I don't mind. Besides, Cosmic Mind at third place, again! That certainly pleases me! The rest are pretty nice too.
However, I wonder why is Evening Star so low? It's not that I don't like Necrofantasia but it sounds way too similar to Necro-Fantasy(I know it's based on it) and if I consider it as Yukari's theme then Ran won't have a unique one. Evening Star is way more unique and suits Yukari better than Necrofantasia, at least for me. Also, the fact that the mash-up of IaMP and SWR perfectly synched is bloody awesome. Give it a listen http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tTr80r7k0e0
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Kilgamayan on July 01, 2013, 10:39:29 PM
Isn't it sad, Tojiko?

That was my vote. ;_;
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: monhan on July 02, 2013, 04:25:24 AM
That was my vote. ;_;
Too bad, Kilga. I know that feel. Mine didn't fare any better, only 1 vote, by me....(┛?__?)┛彡┻━┻
Well, it was an unusual choice. If there's another one I like then it's TenKuu Combi, too bad it didn't score so good.

I liked both of them too so I'm quite shocked to see it scored that low. Though I wonder how can it even lose to MikoFuto...those guys really need to delve deeper into the story...
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 02, 2013, 04:30:37 AM
Too bad, Kilga. I know that feel. Mine didn't fare any better, only 1 vote, by me....(┛?__?)┛彡┻━┻

Though I wonder how can it even lose to MikoFuto...those guys really need to delve deeper into the story...
I was one of those people who voted for it. :V
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: FinnKaenbyou on July 02, 2013, 02:35:36 PM
Koishi taking second place? THAT I didn't see coming.

Similarly Kokoro making 14th even though she's been around for a month is pretty ridiculous.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Aqua Soo on July 02, 2013, 10:38:28 PM
Welp, only Yukari and Eiki-sama in top 30 among those I voted for.

For partner, I actually voted SuiKasen. I want to go hug that ONE other guy who also put that down. We are probably just way ahead of our time. Warmly waiting for more Wild and Horned Hermit. :V

The only definite conclusion I can draw: I am a weird guy apparently.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sagus on July 03, 2013, 02:02:03 AM
For partner, I actually voted SuiKasen. I want to go hug that ONE other guy who also put that down. We are probably just way ahead of our time. Warmly waiting for more Wild and Horned Hermit. :V
i'm the one that voted that

fools don't know about the theory that the oni they're based on (Ibaraki-doji [Kasen] and Shuten-doji [Suika]) were lovers :V

Koishi taking second place? THAT I didn't see coming.

Similarly Kokoro making 14th even though she's been around for a month is pretty ridiculous.
Japan's obsessed with emotionless girls, it seems =P (well, Kokoro isn't emotionless, but she looks so)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: SatorKoi57 on July 06, 2013, 12:13:45 PM
My thoughts on the results:
1   Reimu Hakurei   6430   23.5%   3.95%   827 Expected, but I kinda find her overrated.
2   Koishi Komeiji   5992   20.56%   3.68%   801 I like her, but THIS high, wow!
3   Marisa Kirisame   5895   23.33%   3.62%   778 Like her more than Reimu but still kinda overrated.
4   Flandre Scarlet   5311   23.57%   3.26%   705 PRIME EXAMPLE OF OVERRATED CHARACTER HERE!
5   Alice Margatroid   5271   28.45%   3.24%   613 She's a interesting character, but not my favorite.
6   Sakuya Izayoi   5171   26.37%   3.18%   657 Finally, someone I actually like!
7   Remilia Scarlet   4854   23.21%   2.98%   615 Overrated, not much more to be said.
8   Aya Shameimaru   4630   26.64%   2.84%   632 SHAMEIMARU!
9   Satori Komeiji   4270   19.04%   2.62%   476 I like the SA characters more, but Satori's cool.
10   Sanae Kochiya   3960   27.12%   2.43%   457 Just this......: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFEkBu9RDgA
11   Youmu Konpaku   3854   29.49%   2.37%   474 I character I love, alot.
12   Yuuka Kazami   3782   24.15%   2.32%   435 I keep getting reminded of her creepy antics in fandom, *gets chills*.
13   Yukari Yakumo   3670   23.98%   2.25%   441 :3
14   Hata no Kokoro   3550   9.23%   2.18%   580 More creepy than cute (Especially with those masks), and bland. NOT A GOOD CHARACTER TO ME.
15   Fujiwara no Mokou   3463   25.26%   2.13%   409 BURN BABY BURN!
16   Yuyuko Saigyouji   3322   27.37%   2.04%   388 The lovable and motherly fatass.
17   Tenshi Hinanawi   3245   19.35%   1.99%   429 :3
18   Patchouli Knowledge   2843   21.54%   1.75%   341 I like Koa more.
19   Hong Meiling   2764   28.81%   1.7%   338 Interesting character to say the least.
20   Momiji Inubashiri   2612   21.56%   1.6%   367 I think Kagerou did the wolf youkai idea better, sorry.
21   Byakuren Hijiri   2556   16.51%   1.57%   315 The Arceus of Touhou, really.
22   Nitori Kawashiro   2524   21.74%   1.55%   362 I like Hina more, and that FUCKING Funi video about her V-V.
23   Utsuho Reiuji   2492   18.04%   1.53%   318 :3, needs to be higher though.
24   Ran Yakumo   2324   27.03%   1.43%   304 Yukari's Shikigami. Loyal guard and obessor of Chen.
25   Kogasa Tatara   2313   14.96%   1.42%   322 I don't care for her, AT ALL.
26   Mononobe no Futo   2301   11.82%   1.41%   341 See Utsuho
27   Toyosatomimi no Miko   2183   14.69%   1.34%   299 See Kogasa
28   Eiki Shiki, Yamaxanadu   2159   25.89%   1.33%   273 MY FAVORITE CHARACTER FROM MY FAVORITE TOUHOU GAME!
29   Reisen Udongein Inaba   2094   19.17%   1.29%   252 See Futo
30   Rumia   2000   26.45%   1.23%   268 Cute, but creepy. Funny, but somewhat horrifying.
31   Parsee Mizuhashi   1969   21.33%   1.21%   255 She's boring boring very very boring........
32   Suwako Moriya   1950   19.71%   1.2%   243 Cute as hell, curious and quirky.
33   Cirno   1895   28.32%   1.16%   293 The du.......I mean strongest!
34   Iku Nagae   1850   16.51%   1.14%   279 FEVER!
35   Nue Houjuu   1848   10.62%   1.14%   251 See Parsee
36   Kaguya Houraisan   1775   24.76%   1.09%   228 NEET X15!
37   Hina Kagiyama   1621   23.52%   1%   170 SPIN SPIN SPIN! Needs to be higher.
38   Keine Kamishirasawa   1567   19.44%   0.96%   185 The were history eraser!
39   Nazrin   1501   14.5%   0.92%   186 Hey, Rat, can't you be more interesting to me. And if you can't tell, UFO is my least favorite Windows game.
40   Kasen Ibaraki   1450   12.37%   0.89%   188 I haven't read the manga, so don't know
41   Mamizou Futatsuiwa   1434   7.78%   0.88%   222 :3
42   Renko Usami   1414   17.3%   0.87%   181 She only appeared on a freakin' CD! What's so interesting about her?
43   Rin Kaenbyou   1375   15.63%   0.84%   211 Hell kitty! I love her.
44   Suika Ibuki   1369   17.65%   0.84%   176 I like her, druken oni.
45   Seiga Kaku   1335   11.81%   0.82%   181 I like the other TD characters more, but Seiga is cool.
46   Mystia Lorelei   1299   19.48%   0.8%   209 Yuyuko's bait. Song bird!
47   Shou Toramaru   1294   21.26%   0.79%   169 Sadly my favorite UFO character. A wild cat youkai is a nice idead TBH.
48   Daiyousei   1289   18.73%   0.79%   180 Cool fairy.
49   Komachi Onozuka   1209   14.98%   0.74%   152 I prefer her boss, but I still like Komachi.
50   Kanako Yasaka   1133   19.94%   0.7%   144 A nice idea, but a weird execution.
51   Ichirin Kumoi   1075   19.51%   0.66%   152 See Sanae.
52   Yuugi Hoshiguma   1067   14.98%   0.66%   159 See Suika.
53   Hatate Himekaidou   969   8.7%   0.6%   158 I prefer Aya more. All I need to say.
54   Chen   934   18.51%   0.57%   140 CHEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNN!
55   Minamitsu Murasa   901   15.46%   0.55%   117 Captain, can't you be as good as you are in the Littleshrimp comics?
56   Kyouko Kasodani   897   8.17%   0.55%   146 I like her, cute as fuck.
57   Shizuha Aki   855   12.31%   0.53%   128 I'm surprised, really.
58   Eirin Yagokoro   845   16.33%   0.52%   101 She's a cool nurse, really.
59   Koakuma   837   15.49%   0.51%   120 Koa being this low is a travesty.
60   Yamame Kurodani   814   16.42%   0.5%   113 Needs to be higher, one of my most underrated Touhous to me.
61   Minoriko Aki   800   10.75%   0.49%   123 See Shizuha
62   Rinnosuke Morichika   795   35.25%   0.49%   119 See Ichirin.
63   Tewi Inaba   776   14.47%   0.48%   117 The lowest IN character. Surprising.
64   Yoshika Miyako   718   8.57%   0.44%   87 Being her master, nice Zombie character.
65   Soga no Tojiko   704   7.13%   0.43%   91 She's no Mima, but it is a interesting character anyways.
66   Maribel Hearn   701   7.66%   0.43%   103 See Renko
67   Lunasa Prismriver   677   18.9%   0.42%   87 Needs to be higher.
68   Medicine Melancholy   628   21.59%   0.39%   94 I don't care for this one all that much.
69   Yumemi Okazaki   615   13.72%   0.38%   104 Badass redhead.
70   Hieda no Akyuu   614   20.86%   0.38%   83 See Nue.
71   Wriggle Nightbug   562   36.73%   0.35%   74 I understand, but I like her...............
72   Letty Whiterock   549   25.5%   0.34%   86 *Insert fat joke here*
73   Kosuzu Motoori   448   5.16%   0.28%   92 The retro Komachi!
74   Shinki   444   8.74%   0.27%   73 YEAH! Needs to be higher.
75   Mima   433   13.58%   0.27%   83 See Shinki. I have a soft spot for this forgotten character too.
76   Luna Child   364   7.17%   0.22%   56 See Wriggle
77   Watatsuki no Yorihime   346   10.8%   0.21%   60 Badass swordsman. Needs to be higher.
78   Star Sapphire   339   14.22%   0.21%   64 See Luna Child
79   Lily White   322   22.53%   0.2%   45 IT'S SPRING. NOT NOW.
80   Lyrica Prismriver   301   23.46%   0.18%   45 See Star Sapphire
81   Sunny Milk   285   16.18%   0.18%   50 So fuckin' adorable :3.
82   Alice's dolls (Shanghai, Hourai, Ooedo etc.)   260   11.04%   0.16%   45 I love these little buggers.
83   Unnamed book-reading youkai (Tokiko)   259   12.74%   0.16%   38 See Yaname.
84   Gengetsu   252   22.7%   0.15%   45 God Fairy, YEAH!
85   Merlin Prismriver   246   11.03%   0.15%   44 My least favorite of the Music trio.
86   Kisume   234   19.85%   0.14%   34 Bucket loli.
87   Watatsuki no Toyohime   176   13.51%   0.11%   31 Needs to be higher.
88   Unzan   168   7.5%   0.1%   44 BRO FIST!
89   Yumeko   117   10.67%   0.07%   8  Red dress maid. Cool.
90   Mugetsu   114   11.94%   0.07%   20 Okay to me.
90   Kana Anaberal   114   16.18%   0.07%   18 See above.
92   Mai   101   9.38%   0.06%   16 Fuckin' cool.
93   Reisen   94   17.31%   0.06%   20 See Kasen.
94   Chiyuri Kitashirakawa   85   5.08%   0.05%   12 The cousin of Murasa and Nitori. Not much more.
95   Kurumi   79   3.57%   0.05%   11 Needs to be higher.
96   Elly   77   10.64%   0.05%   15 Needs to be way higher.
97   Fairies (fairy maids, sunflower fairies etc.)   73   23.91%   0.04%   27 See the dolls.
98   Kedama   67   6.38%   0.04%   11 FOE!
99   Youki Konpaku   64   9.76%   0.04%   16 Don't care.
100   Layla Prismriver She didn't even appear in an official Touhou media!

My thoughts on the Top 100. May be biased, but whatever.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Starxsword on July 06, 2013, 10:26:47 PM
Its an opinion, of course its going to be biased. No need to worry about that.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 06, 2013, 10:41:41 PM
My thoughts on the results:
1   Reimu Hakurei   6430   23.5%   3.95%   827 Expected, but I kinda find her overrated.
She's at hax-level, has lots and lots of themes and is totally calm about everything (well, mostly). What's not to love?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Drake on July 06, 2013, 10:43:21 PM
I DISAGREE WITH SATORKOI57'S OPINIONS AND COMMENTS ON THE CHARACTERS AND THEIR RANKINGS
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Suikama on July 06, 2013, 10:52:31 PM
I DISAGREE WITH SATORKOI57'S OPINIONS AND COMMENTS ON THE CHARACTERS AND THEIR RANKINGS
hey man, just because he has a different opinion than you doesn't mea
Quote
39   Nazrin   1501   14.5%   0.92%   186 Hey, Rat, can't you be more interesting to me. And if you can't tell, UFO is my least favorite Windows game.
oh

nvm
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 06, 2013, 11:01:27 PM
I have a hard time with the word overrated, but well, opinions are opinions.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Drake on July 06, 2013, 11:26:23 PM
"Popular when I'm not fond of it" = Overrated
"I don't like it because it's popular" = Overrated
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Lavalake on July 06, 2013, 11:27:20 PM
I like how when some characters are so supposedly underrated, that they get overrated.
Rumia is 30th place?
And Diao Ye Zong is in 133th place? HOW DARE YOU PEOPLE!
Quote
30   Rumia   2000   26.45%   1.23%   268 Cute, but creepy. Funny, but somewhat horrifying.
She is not one bit creepy, she just wants a hug...
And only roams at night...
And has red evil eyes...
And sometimes an evil grin...
THAT'S NOT SCARY ONE BIT.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: SatorKoi57 on July 06, 2013, 11:29:25 PM
If you want to why I dislike UFO so much, it's because the roster of new gals is the worst in the series for me, only about 3 characters that I can like for 1 reason or another.  (Byakuren,Shou and Nazrin).  Plus it introduced slut  (Sanae) as a playable character. I dissed Nazrin because she's a youkai based on a type of species I freakin' despise (Rodent, I only like Mice, Guinea Pigs, Chinchillas and Hamsters), plus NIGHTMARES ABOUT THAT FUCKIN' FUNI VIDEO ABOUT HAMTARO NAZRIN THAT RUINED MY CHILDHOOD!

Edit: The only chars I called underrated were Yaname and Tokiko. And I only called Reimu, Marisa and the scarlet sisters overrated. Unless, people (talking to you Drake), that by my description on my thoughts I was calling your fave overrated without saying the word.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Tiamat on July 07, 2013, 12:24:35 AM
"She only appeared on a freakin' CD! What's so interesting about her?"

Multiple CDs, actually. The sum of those CDs' plots means she's technically had more write-time than half the Touhou cast. Which... fittingly is around where she ended up ranking.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sagus on July 07, 2013, 05:55:36 AM
Plus it introduced slut  (Sanae) as a playable character
I know OPINIONS and all that but

I will never understand that shit right there
Calling Sanae a slut
I mean, why? Just what the hell does that has to do with anything? She's not a sexually charged character. She's a nice girl that greatly enjoys what basically amounts to glorified dodgeball. She began as a very devoted, serious person (10), was somewhat overwhelmed by all the crazy zaniness of her new home (11, 12), and then calmed considerably to what's pretty much the normal levels of sociopathy shown by Gensokyians (13). And even then, she's certainly not as assholish as Reimu or Marisa. I mean, she even calls her own gods on their secretive bullshit (12.3) and tries to perk Mamizou up after she defeats her ffs
One could say she's one of the very few characters that has any sort of "character evolution" at all in the whole series

I just don't get the hate, man
I mean sure
you don't have to like her
but come on.
slut? really? really?
that's low, crass, and really fucking nonsensical.
and just plain stupid.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Tiamat on July 07, 2013, 02:15:10 PM
"Sanae is a slut" is one of the stupider memes to arise, and it comes from people using it as a derogatory term due to how ZUN seems enamoured with her enough to include her in a ton of games despite being new.  Personally, I find the usage of calling a female character a slut just because you don't like the attention she's getting from the creator to be rather immature.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Gpop on July 07, 2013, 05:23:59 PM
Also it was all the Sakuya fanboy hate. :V

I remember when it was Aya back then as well, appearing in almost every game from PoFV onwards (up to SA at least, then again in DS).
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 07, 2013, 09:15:04 PM
I agree with SatoriKoi about Reisen Udongein Inaba needing be higher although Tewi Inaba needs love two I love the rabbits and Eientei crew.

*sees Sanae comment* DON'T DISS SANAE, she's a good girl m'kay.  :V
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: AnonymousPondScum on July 07, 2013, 11:14:13 PM
Any sexual promiscuity on Sanae's part is purely far-fetched fan conjecture that basically went human girl on the outside = schoolgirl = OBVIOUSLY HOT BECAUSE WE'RE HORNY OTAKU = SLUT. It's a dumb meme and seeing it used in some fanart celebrating Sakuya's return...Rubbed me the wrong way.

I like Sakuya *and* Sanae, for the record, though I admittedly don't mind Sanae taking a break from the playable roster. I just wish it hadn't been so sudden.

Let us be more dignified than name calling. I've talked people out of bringing up some fairly incendiary topics/comparisons in Touhou discussions elsewhere and I think it was for the best for all parties involved.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: tohosubs on July 08, 2013, 11:19:31 AM
By the way, the Japanese Touhou community on G+ is organizing its first (probably very small-scale) popularity poll: http://nazr.in/5D5
7/7-7/21. Result to be announced 8/4.

In case the organizer hasn't fixed them, the last four questions are supposed to mean the following:
"What is your favorite storyline in Touhou, among official works? e.g. Imperishable Night, Silent Sinner in Blue."
"What is your favorite storyline in Touhou, among fanworks?"
"How did you find out about Touhou Project?"
"If you have any last comments about this poll, please enter them here."
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Aqua Soo on July 08, 2013, 04:40:27 PM
tbh, I like every character. I just prefer some a bit more than others. :3 I understand some people have dislikes and stronger preferences, but there's no need to argue.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Tiamat on July 08, 2013, 05:37:41 PM
I think the only Touhou character that's canonically displayed any confirmable signs of a sex drive "on-screen" is Reimu, hilariously enough (when she commented in SSiB that she was interested in summoning a god because he was said to be quite handsome). Anything else that could remotely have anything confirmable to do with love (such as characters who had spouses and children) all happened off screen.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 08, 2013, 08:32:44 PM
tbh, I like every character. I just prefer some a bit more than others. :3 I understand some people have dislikes and stronger preferences, but there's no need to argue.
Pretty much the same for me. If there is something I hate, it is some of the characters from the "popular" fanon view. I were close to hating characters like yuuka/flandre/kaguya just because of their dumbed down fanon versions.

For the other discussion; embers of love anyone? :V
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Critz on July 08, 2013, 10:39:23 PM
Sanae being higher than the last (official) Popularity Poll, if only a place higher is rather comforting. She's still well-liked despite her disapperance  :3. I miss her #2 days though.

Too bad Alice isn't #2 anymore either, but I guess it's Koishi's time to shine - she's actually pretty interesting now, being crucial to HM and all. I'm more than satisfied with Youmu, Udonge and Kogasa too (sucker for moe).
Scarlets' place was obvious considering their doujin backing. Now, if someone could only explain what is it with Wriggle being so low? She's full forty places below Rumia despite being IMO far more memorable and actually pretty nice and hardworking (the bug service campaign)  :derp:. Yuuka staying so high despite her repulsive personality kind of puzzles me too.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 08, 2013, 11:28:13 PM
Yuuka staying so high despite her repulsive personality kind of puzzles me too.
Because she's Youkai moe~

Seriously though, the personality part is subjective. Most people may see Yuuka as a brutal sadistic monster, but I would rather see her as a peaceful flower lady, being one with nature but with her ancient and powerful youkai side hidden inside. Just being powerful may be a reason for some to like her, after all. (She also seems to enjoy annoying others or being creepy, but that's another story.)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: commandercool on July 09, 2013, 03:33:37 AM
Yuuka staying so high despite her repulsive personality kind of puzzles me too.

She's arguably the closest thing we have to a villain. Some people like villains. I do. Hell, I wish she was more evil and around more often. Then she'd be higher on my list.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Starxsword on July 09, 2013, 05:28:12 AM
Quote
Scarlets' place was obvious considering their doujin backing. Now, if someone could only explain what is it with Wriggle being so low? She's full forty places below Rumia despite being IMO far more memorable and actually pretty nice and hardworking (the bug service campaign)  :derp:.

Rumia's the first boss in the Windows series. That should score some points.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Desu_Cake on July 09, 2013, 10:53:52 PM
Why has this thread become "Why is this character so popular despite the fact that I don't completely love them therefore they are disgusting and overrated Ugh" so much?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Drake on July 09, 2013, 11:32:18 PM
Why has this thread become "Why is this character so popular despite the fact that I don't completely love them therefore they are disgusting and overrated Ugh" so much?
does this really require an answer
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Gpop on July 10, 2013, 12:14:25 AM
Y'all know Koishi should've been #1 fuk dat slut Raymoo
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sage Ω (Ultima) on July 10, 2013, 01:40:32 AM
Y'all know Koishi should've been #1

Wrong.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 10, 2013, 01:59:59 AM
Everybody knows that Reimu is #1 due to she's the main character!  :trollface:

Nope, Reisen for the win!
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sage Ω (Ultima) on July 10, 2013, 02:06:13 AM
Nope, Reisen for the win!

This woman knows what she's talking about.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 10, 2013, 02:07:28 AM
This man knows what he's talking about.
I'm a girl.  :derp:
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sage Ω (Ultima) on July 10, 2013, 02:09:26 AM
Let me just edit my post then, sorry. The typical internet rule is that if you don't know the gender assume it's male.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Zil on July 10, 2013, 02:12:05 AM
fuk dat slut Raymoo
Gladly
Let me just edit my post then, sorry. The typical internet rule is that if you don't know the gender assume it's male.
Or check the profile.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Gpop on July 10, 2013, 02:17:26 AM
Right. Even better then Reisen.
ftfy

BV
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Firestorm29 on July 10, 2013, 03:18:12 AM
Never really understood why people see Kokoro as creepy...

There's worse out there. (http://reboot.wikia.com/wiki/Hexadecimal)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: MewMewHeart on July 10, 2013, 03:22:24 AM
Kokoro in my opinion is cute due to the fact she uses masks to express her feelings which makes her more interesting.

@Firestorm29: Damn you nostalgia!
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 10, 2013, 05:28:31 AM
Everybody knows that Reimu is #1 due to she's the main character!  :trollface:
Never heard of a better reason. :V

Additionally, my special Yuuka ideas in the comment section: www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4gaWY5THh4&lc=oRmGROe9JPUML2fy_1PmP7wC_tnW5qiDRKiURUnz9cc (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C4gaWY5THh4&lc=oRmGROe9JPUML2fy_1PmP7wC_tnW5qiDRKiURUnz9cc)
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: SatorKoi57 on July 13, 2013, 01:28:03 AM
I'm sorry to bring this up again, but it just made me made when I heard it.

Sanae replaced Mokou, Kaguya, Nitori and Wriggle (All of which were scrapped) in Hisoutenko and was made weak because "weak characters are funny".

Spoiler alert:

THEY'RE FUCKING NOT

Merely just one of the reasons I call Sanae a "slut". Plus it killed my love for Cirno for good. She is pretty much barely makes it off my Top 30 Touhou characters (She's number 30 now).
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sagus on July 13, 2013, 03:44:22 AM
Source? Like, a good source. An interview transcript. A blog post. Not "I heard it from somewhere".

Also? Replacing characters you wanted to be in a game does not makes her a "slut".
So it's still an unbelievable immature, nonsensical, and just plain stupid thing to call her.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Drake on July 13, 2013, 06:10:05 AM
Sanae replaced Mokou, Kaguya, Nitori and Wriggle (All of which were scrapped) in Hisoutenko and was made weak because "weak characters are funny".

Merely just one of the reasons I call Sanae a "slut". Plus it killed my love for Cirno for good. She is pretty much barely makes it off my Top 30 Touhou characters (She's number 30 now).
I can guarantee that you are making things up and/or received this blatantly absurd information from people who were making things up.
Even if you weren't, it's totally nonsensical reasoning. Like wow.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 13, 2013, 08:07:58 AM
Sanae replaced Mokou, Kaguya, Nitori and Wriggle (All of which were scrapped) in Hisoutenko and was made weak because "weak characters are funny".

Merely just one of the reasons I call Sanae a "slut". Plus it killed my love for Cirno for good. She is pretty much barely makes it off my Top 30 Touhou characters (She's number 30 now).
1. I have heard that rumor, but I don't think it was that Sanae "replaced" them. I can't really see Sanae as not being in unl, as she played quite a large role in it.
2. I haven't looked into the unl balancing, but was Sanae really that weak?
3. I don't really understand the last part. Why would Sanae stop you from liking Cirno?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Critz on July 13, 2013, 09:21:37 AM
Ugh... I usually don't respond to this kind of idiocy to avoid feeding the trolls and fanning the flames, but what the hell are you talking about?

Sanae is not a weak character in any way in canon - as of 12.3 she's one of the girls to have possibly defeated Byakuren. She *is* low tier in Soku (http://hisouten.koumakan.jp/wiki/Diagram), but that's the problem of Tasofro balancing and she's still very much viable (if one of the harder girls to master).

As for these characters not being in 12.3, I quote the wiki:
Quote
ZUN said in a radio interview that Wriggle Nightbug and Nitori Kawashiro were originally slated to appear in the game, but were scrapped due to time restraints. Kaguya Houraisan and Fujiwara no Mokou were also considered, but it was decided that they were too strong. [1] Instead, Twilight Frontier decided to put in mostly weak characters, as they would humorously face off against the very powerful characters featured in Immaterial and Missing Power (most every mainstream character was featured there). Sanae Kochiya was added instead of these possibilities, and perhaps made as weak as she is on purpose.
They didn't get scrapped because of Sanae, but because of "time restraints" and "being too strong". These are idiotic reasons, true. The "weak characters" they meant are Cirno and China, as Suwako and Okuu are even higher on the list than Sanae, so as far as I'm concerned, that was just an excuse for Tasofro's lazyness. :wat:  So please, stop attacking Sanae for every character that could have appeared instead of her, because that's how ZUN planned it and because it's idiotic. Hell, Sanae herself did not appear in HM despite it being the one game where she should be a heroine.

I also don't get why would you hate Cirno because of Sanae. These two have exactly one interaction, the outcome of which depends on who are you playing as. Please elaborate.
And the top 30 is still pretty high, considering the number of characters at the moment is well above a hundred. Her being named a slut is a result of massive trolling and fanon idiocy, because she was conveniently an easy scapegoat by the time UFO got announced. I don't know if you want to be associated with the worst of 4chan shitposters, but real fans don't  take kindly to this kind of stuff.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Fonzi on July 13, 2013, 09:36:35 AM
Well, of course Reimu would win time and time again. It's a popularity poll. If someone asks who's the iconic character of the series, it can only be the main one (or two). Apparently, people grew to like the new HM characters really quickly. IMO, the people who organized the poll should have at least waited for the full release of DDC. I wonder if the new characters in the later stages would score some of the higher ranks. I personally don't feel too inclined to declare my love for new characters too quickly. It's just like a fad that comes and goes as soon as the fans calm down from thier euphoria of being introduced to a new character. I assume Kokoro or Koishi won't score so high next year.
Seeing Satorkoi's opinions made me chuckle, as it was more like a meme spam. And seriously, guys, what's with the "weaker character in Soku" crap? A character is only as good/as weak as the player controling her. If you suck, it's not Sanae's fault. Really.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: SatorKoi57 on July 13, 2013, 11:39:22 AM
I think Cirno was put in just BECAUSE she is considered to be a weak youkai. And that's bullshit, though on the plus side, we did get pretty nice Cirno artwork and spritework from Tasofore.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Sagus on July 13, 2013, 12:20:24 PM
Wasn't the "too strong" justification for Kaguya and Mokou's thing related to balancing issues instead of lore? As in, they run out of time to properly balance a moveset for them?

Granted, the game isn't that well-balanced anyway.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: SatorKoi57 on July 13, 2013, 12:39:22 PM
The "weak characters" they meant are Cirno and China

But China was in IAMP as well, and the wiki stated they wanted weak characters to face the "stronger" ones. Couldn't they just bring Meiling back and put a weaker character from the same game (EOSD)?

I did get the Sanae "replaced" Wriggle,Nitori,Mokou and Kaguya info from Touhou wiki (Touhou.wikia.com to be exact).

If someone can tell me how "put in instead" is different from "replaced", I will give you a internet, cookie or whatever.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Fonzi on July 13, 2013, 12:54:56 PM
"replaced" would indicate that a character has substituted another that was already placed in the game or its previous installment or unpatched version or whatever.

"put in instead" means that the creators decided use one character rather than another one.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Gpop on July 13, 2013, 01:00:00 PM
I think you're just butthurt and need a time out to calm down.

No seriously.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: SatorKoi57 on July 13, 2013, 01:01:42 PM
"replaced" would indicate that a character has substituted another that was already placed in the game or its previous installment or unpatched version or whatever.

"put in instead" means that the creators decided use one character rather than another one.

So replaced would be stuff like Mewtwo in Melee getting replaced by Lucario in Brawl, right?

And another thing:
Is "Slutnae" a forced meme or something? From the ways you are responding to my Sanae posts, I would think yes.

And if I was butthurt I would be spamming stuff like "SHUT UP!" or "LEAVE ME ALONE!!@SDHSDOIDSA!!".

Something like this:
"That's it!!

I will not use SMvC Template!

But, I WILL USE CvS SPARKS AND I'LL LOCK THIS!!

GOOD-BYE, GENIUESES!"
or
"God, I hate it when those stupid users ruining my creations!"
both provided by this goofball:
http://mugenguild.com/forum/profile/area.summary;u=66781

We don't know this "Goofball" and practically your post has nothing to do with the topic. Mind stopping the nonsense please?  -Hele
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Fonzi on July 13, 2013, 01:16:27 PM
I'm not sure if this is the best place to discuss memes. The fact remains that Sanae made it to top 10. And I doubt she has slept with the judges of the poll to get there.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Gpop on July 13, 2013, 04:06:20 PM
I'm not sure if this is the best place to discuss memes. The fact remains that Sanae made it to top 10. And I doubt she has slept with the judges of the poll to get there.
Nah she slept with all those guys that voted for her. Brilliant, I say.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Tiamat on July 13, 2013, 05:39:37 PM
Yea, I hope this isn't starting a power discussion (I'm going to be listing specifics), but it's kinda hard to imagine Kaguya and Mokou being disregarded due to lore strength when you consider the other characters in the game...
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Critz on July 13, 2013, 07:04:27 PM
 NeptuniAmra nailed it pretty well when I once had the same doubts: (http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,13556.msg910726.html#msg910726)
Quote from: me
Aren't spell card battles specifically designed  to be non-lethal in canon anyway? If they wanted to, they could have implemented something like a spell card that regains some of the HP upon knockout for that last chance to win (something Kaguya already does in IN).
Quote
Resurrection is relevant because it's intrinsic to the characters at hand, as much as fantasy seal or master spark or gap manipulation is to their respective characters. Their moveset needs to feel like Mokou and Kaguya, and be a full mechanic much like Sanae's wind or Suwako's weird movement; we can't just put it in as a spellcard because Soku's mechanics mean that it's possible for them to not have it, and it just feels sloppy when compared to characters that have a full-representation, not just a token spellcard. Not to mention that such an easy 'I don't lose yet' button would be in stark contrast to all the other 'healing' options in Soku which have ridiculous recoveries, and if we're to give their resurrection cards such recovery then the whole point is moot; just punish again into a full-damage combo. It's needless extending of a round, not to mention a waste of meter. They could've given them much higher HP, but since they decided that everyone needs the same HP total then that options out.

Drake explains why I can't think of any way to implement Kisume or Parsee. Some characters are just too simplistic, some characters' powers don't translate well into a fighting game, etc. Which is why putting a character into a fighting game isn't as easy as it seems unless the characters were created with fighting games already in mind, which Touhou wasn't, and from a developer standpoint it's far simpler to just put in characters that don't require so much headache; ie recent characters and or well established ones with powers and or abilities that are simple to translate into fighting game mechanics. I don't think Mokou would be too simplistic though, as I can very easily see her moveset. It's just the whole 'hey I'm immortal' thing is a mind boggler. Give her a much lower health bar but multiple lives? And whenever she loses a life bar she disintegrates and reappears where she wishes? Who knows. It even applies to other games like DotS; Trance would agree with me that Kaguya and Mokou's state of balance have been dramatic, to say the least.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Starxsword on July 13, 2013, 08:30:04 PM
Quote
Is "Slutnae" a forced meme or something? From the ways you are responding to my Sanae posts, I would think yes.

I would assume this is a meme, since people go with this. Do note, that like Sakuya wears pads, Meiling being a Dragon, etc., nothing in canon supports this.

Quote
And seriously, guys, what's with the "weaker character in Soku" crap? A character is only as good/as weak as the player controling her. If you suck, it's not Sanae's fault. Really.

This is mentioned in the interview. They were talking about wanting to add weaker characters to the fighting game cast. Presumably, that would be Cirno, Meiling, Sanae, Wriggle, and Nitori.

Here is the link (http://en.touhouwiki.net/wiki/Interview_on_Nae_Radio_(September_2009)). Here is what was said:
Hisoutensoku at the beginning 
Z>Wriggle and Nitori and ~ Kaguya and Mokou?let's stick to stage 1 and 2s, so they got scrapped

Z>Sanae was decided [to be added in] later
Z>Anyhow, let's make it into a separate game (form SWR)
Z>And have weaker characters comes out, that'd be great
(Having weak characters go against strong ones in IaMP on even grounds gave it rounding approvals)



Quote
But China was in IAMP as well, and the wiki stated they wanted weak characters to face the "stronger" ones. Couldn't they just bring Meiling back and put a weaker character from the same game (EOSD)?

Meiling was never in story mode, not in Immaterial and Missing Power, not in Scarlet Weather Rhapsody. They might be talking about story mode.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Fonzi on July 13, 2013, 08:37:54 PM
Immortality does not make one immune to pain or to being knocked out for a while. For that matter, as far as Touhou lore is concerned, every single fairy in Touhou is in essence immortal, so the same excuse could apply to Cirno, but she's there, unlike our two Hourai Elixir drinkers.

Like Tiamat said; the reason why Kaguya and Mokou were left out of the game was much more likely due to balancing issues and lack of time to fix them, rather than the canonical "superiority" of the two girls to everyone else present in the cast. Why are we even talking about fighting games anyway, when this thread is focused on a popularity poll?
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Darkness1 on July 13, 2013, 10:02:21 PM
Why are we even talking about fighting games anyway, when this thread is focused on a popularity poll?
Because the words slut and Sanae were used in the same sentence.
It should be obvious that the problem was balance issues for Kaguya and Mokou, since the spellcard rules makes noone too superior compared to the other characters.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Helepolis on July 14, 2013, 02:28:44 AM
I think we've had enough insulting of the Touhou cast. Memes or not, keep it civil and tidy. No need to repeat the same words over and over, they don't become any funnier or obvious that way.

Mind you all, this is also an unofficial popularity contest held by a different bunch of people. Treat the results as you please, but behave yourself regarding them and to each other.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Firestorm29 on July 14, 2013, 01:31:26 PM
To be personally honest, in regards to the immortality thing, the only game I've seen do something like that was Metal Bokuchin. His immortality worked that he had 8 revives, each KO would have the fighter fly back like he was KO'd and restore restore 1/8 less health than the last, then get up again. Every match against him turned into a very lengthy affair, and a bit momentum killing since he would drift off mid-combo and air recover.

Kinda annoying, though that's kinda drowned out by his annoying "NAMAMETA!" everytime he did something. Either way, it seems like that resurection thing would make a match very not fun to deal with.
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Tiamat on July 14, 2013, 02:07:58 PM
I dunno, none of Mokou's spell cards in Imperishable Night had anything to directly do with ressurection, did they? Closest one were the phoenix ones, and that was more symbollic than anything else. Although I guess there was that whole "Mokou dies and revives after each spell card" thing, but that was kinda in the "Blink and you'll miss it" category.

Although there already was Okuu for a fire themed character in Hisoutensoku, anyways...
Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Kirin no Sora on July 15, 2013, 09:37:14 PM
Actually, I think that Okuu counts more as a "sun themed" character than a "fire themed" one. As for Mokou, you could simply have her burst into flames and stuff, and even give her a trick that lets her explode and then reform almost immediately. That could work, maybe?

Title: Re: 5th Touhou Nico Dousai - Touhou Popularity Contest - Results are in!
Post by: Branneg Xy on August 16, 2013, 08:50:18 PM
Old topic,although I believe it is ok to post in it as long as it is still open and without warnings.
Actually, I think that Okuu counts more as a "sun themed" character than a "fire themed" one. As for Mokou, you could simply have her burst into flames and stuff, and even give her a trick that lets her explode and then reform almost immediately. That could work, maybe?

A little correction:Okuu is conceived by Zun more as a recipient for the "Ultimate Energy" aka  an advanced form of nuclear fusion,so it is regarded more as a dual "nuclear and radiations-sun themed" character than as a pure "sun and sunlight themed" like  Amaterasu is.
As for Mokou,it might work out as a basis.
However,thinking deeply about this one, there are sprites and animations which would overlap with Mokou's eventual  fire and reforming moves;on top of my head I recall Remilia's and a bit of Marisa's during all fighters and Utsuho in HTS ,especially Story mode for  Remi and Okuu, but there might be more in HM .
An additional loss of value  would be the absence of Mokou -Kaguya 'cause the latter "Manipulation of Eternity" requires too much work to be both balanced and enjoyable and so another character pulls ahead replacing her,which might be for the better as they both need comprehension and polishing to not come out half-baked.
Brainstorming aside,  http://youtu.be/WWaLxFIVX1s  is my reaction  to missing out on voting on a new and unexpected Touhou Poll.Nice addition on the partner thing!
Well,it really shows the hype for HM boosted quite a lot of faces in the Single Character popularity poll*looks at Koishi*! In spite of that,the Music and Partner polls are minimally affected and IMHO less hype-influenced.