PX, I'm going to be honest with you.
I'm certain you're town now because there is no way your scum buddy would not have corrected you or held you back a bit, but your logical methods are flawed.
I assume the radio I received was just a standardized PM given out with any radio. You would have gotten the same message about it using up your night action, in spite of you being vanilla. Each person gets one action per night, and passing the radio was confirmed as a night action. Furthermore, this partially had to do with the fact that radios can be spoken through at night without using up an action, so a player can use his radio and pass it in the same night.
Bard - The primary suspects today are me and Huh What. I'm assuming that won't change. The fact that I'm suggesting the tactics that I am with roles means that I'm certain I can prove one if not both of us town.
And by the by, you just proved exactly what I said before - no matter what we do in our scum hunts, we should lynch you today. That will give Edible another chance with his test, and let us do some role confirmation. I'm not sure why you are suggesting that we would lose if we lynched you, unless there is another part of your role you want to reveal.
From an information perspective, lynching you is the best option. As you confirmed, if we don't, we will not get a go at an Edible scum pair. We should still scum hunt naturally, I'm merely suggesting the best course of action for the night while we do it. Strategy is our friend, and the lack of it here is annoying. Since we lose if town is wrong, and town still gets both scum with my method if town is right, the fact that I'm suggesting what seems like the best course of action and being labeledscum for it is annoying.
There is no reason why I should have been the one to suggest you were the safest lynch for tonight, and that a miss-lynch would lose us the game. That should have been accepted. If we are going to lose from a bad lynch, we might as well take the only certain good lynch and use the extra time to find scum. (Furthermore, we need two scum to utilize Edible's ability.)
The most immediately scummy looking player from my perspective is Dormio, because she not only was opposed to my tactics while offering none of her own, but she was actively opposing the concept of tactics altogether. Once again PX gets points for trying to keep up with tactics and form them himself, even if I find them flawed and his enthusiasm to immediately vote a liability. The real problem is that I'm not sure what to think of anyone.
Bard - when I said you looked scummy, I made a list of things you did that hinted that you were scum. I'm a bit suspicious, so I tend to look at both sides of every coin. In your case, everything you said you did works out if you were scum except for the Affinity kill.
I'm sorry, but I find it hard to believe any mod would wrangle their game so that town can win the game by sheer virtue of its roles rather than its efforts to scumhunt, and that you would suggest this is the case and that town should take full fledged advantage of it seems downright silly to me.
The mod said the roles are experimental. I figure there's probably imbalances to be found.
Capt H, again, why are you suggesting town not scum hunt nor lynch scum on LYLO, in favour of eliminating a third party and playing a role game?
I'm suggesting that if town has a way to confirm it's suspicions, it should do so, rather than enter blind. If a third party has to bite the bullet to give town proof of scum, what do I care.
The Huh what/me pairing is the obvious one. I can both prove it wrong and clear at least one of us if I lynch you first. If I'm lying, town still gets to kill both me and huh what with plenty of time since neither or us could attempt a night kill (taking us out of Lylo), and Edible will have either Huh what or me cornered.
Using your lynch we can disprove the existence of a likely scum paring and either prove the innocence or guilt of one or two townies through Edible. Through your help if we are wrong today we lose, but through your lynch if we are wrong today we will know we were wrong and still be able to win.
