And by the way, lynch Bard. He's not a survivor with vig powers; he's a serial killer. And even if he were a survivor, i would have wanted the known survivor lynched today (which is why I was hoping Zak was the survivor).
This, and the declaration that we "have two scum who block Edible" is utterly silly. You throw up a lot of clout to basically say, "Dormio is scum, but lynch Bardiche instead anyway". You still lack any basis on which to claim someone is scum or not other than "role speculation" and "setup mafia", which are interesting games on their own but during LyLo, surely you can come up with something better than that.
This is why I said earlier you do not scumhunt. You only play role speculation games, and off wrong assumptions as well. Declaring that you can down an anti-town player by lynching the survivor
who pretty much agreed to roll with town because he does not want to die and that you should actually do so is flawed on two assumptions.
1) That third-party is directly anti-town. As yet, there is no basis to declare my behaviour as strictly anti-town, or if you have so you must declare it now.
2) That lynching not-scum takes precedence over lynching scum.
I of course disagree with two and find it flawed because the purpose of the game is to eliminate scum, not eliminate independent parties who may or may not work against town, and who more often than not will find themselves forced to pick sides and hey, one side can eliminate you if you're TOO useful, the other will lynch you if you're not useful ENOUGH. And the first side will try to get you lynched harder than the latter side, usually.
Unlike scum, whose win condition is directly opposite town's, lynching a third party is nothing more than being a jerk by denying someone's win condition at the expense of your own lynch. If I die, you gain no valuable interactive information, nor is there the guarantee that a 2 town, 2 scum, 1 third party would result in scum victory.
I would love to continue this, but sleep draws near and so I want to sleep. I am off from school early tomorrow, and so I can provide the analysis no sooner than that.
As far as my kill goes, I can nearly guarantee I will be able to use it tonight, but I can do so under two conditions:
A) That I voted that person at some point during the dayphase
B) That I do not overuse my ability
I have no idea what "overuse" entails nor what the negative effect would be of using it too much.
As far as Edible's list goes, Serp says he cannot answer questions re: role interactions.
