Let's all admit lewd factor are deciding factor to hentai doujins.Judging by base material, i mean original game, Kancolle definitely appealing to more wider audience, mainly designed to appeal with physical attractiveness, from humble to lewd, i won't deny that Kancolle have better base material, for certain "kind of things" among other.
I'm not too knowledgeable about it, but aren't Kancolle in original game are all art by commisioned artist? If so, being a commisioned artist means that they must have very good skill, that would make the
thong & bandage bra base material easy to perceive as pretty & attractive if not sexually, easily desireable.
There's probably more to it than that, but i have like no real experience in Kancolle, probably the ships history if i make a common guess.
From what i read the plot aren't that bad in one of the novel version at least, that one with alternate universe, definitely alluring for male audience i say.
And whats more, Kancolle have friggin girls(& grown up women) voices that comes out when you tap theirrr........wherever you want to "tap" them.
If you are being indecisive i suggest the outer layer of the area where their mammary gland are.There's saying that "after a bad first impression, it can only get better" as a game that hail from por...
pr0n
pr0n site with aim on more wider audience(as wiki states lol) they definitely seems prosper, but the fan service they provide make me wonder what kind of wider audience do they mean, like, apple don't fall far from the tree.
Kancolle indeed deserve their rank up there, normally. And inb4, i apologize if my statement are actually off as i didn't bother look to much into it (lol).
Now let's look at ZUN drawing & laugh merrily together. Actually ZUN drawing style are kind of cute in it's own way when compared to Alphes or Harukawa,
especially the epic smug face on innocent art style.
If Touken Ranbu art are either "male" or "looks like female", Touhou art ambiguous in whether they are "old hag(?)" and "midget looks like little girl or actual(most probably no way) little girl".
Even with the official printworks and spin-off game where they have different artist, drawing still kind of ambiguous. (aside from judging by certain "plot assets", i would be called gross again if i clearly say what they are, the dudes here can be inconsiderate i let you know that)
Then again ZUN has wife & offspring, what liberty does he have if he prefer to keep his dignity
& possibly beers allowance money?
I don't really want to start bragging nonsensically about Phantom Ensemble, Desire Drive, Night Sakura of Dead Spirit, Border of Life & of course the help from fan arrangement.
If what the others said are true about Kancolle can only produce doujin manga/printworks & music, if comparing to touhou which can also produce fangames, i think making fangames need more effort & time than making printworks.
With that, scoring by numbers like that are rather quantity over quality, not saying that its bad or incorrect but it's still just one of another way to decide or judge.
I'm actually not too certain about this one point of mine though, as i never draw manga, but i assume it's rather breeze if you already mastered the skill. seeing those one howr drawing & such.
About "each game having nothing to do with each other" point, it's neither entirely wrong or correct.
I think it's kinda like Gundam franchise, with the amount of the games titles there are it will be inconvenient for newcomer if the latest title require you to know the plot of the previous title, and the previous title require you to know the plot of it's previous title and so on.
Look at that "butterfly Gundam with moustache" and look at how GAR Barbatos Lupus Rex are, you can enjoy Barbatos without you ever need to know about that "butterfly Gundam with moustache" ever, it's not always a bad point.
It's right that most of the Touhou game not really having anything to do with each other, but each of the main game are still about
maniacal cries & frustation the very same flying shrine maiden & the gang in Gensokyou(mostly).
unlike phinal phantasy number number.With all the consideration above, i think that wasn't a fair comparison, both Touhou & Kancolle have their own different handicap. The top can't be necessarily better than the bottom here.
In my opinion Touhou are light and homely while Kancolle looks "exciting", thats fine.
And Touken Ranbu are like k-poop boyband, simply disgusting as fok, but i accept their exsitence as karma for the moronic behaviour of us male. i might have just made enemies.OP don't like Touhou? i mean saying Touhou stale and such, if i talk back i say Kancolle horny.
"yea yea imma shittin at ye moma, come at me bruh"not like i actually dare, OP won't read this anywayActually I see on twitter that someone says Touhou fanbase is actually shifting to young girls instead of grownup male otaku.
That statement might hit a lot of damage to my confidence, if not mentally altering. I demand name, i'll make bussiness.