Seconding Strafe here that the server has begun to grow a bit too large. With chat getting filled with griefer complaints (even in RP world), "where I go" questions from lost RPers, random users popping up for a few minutes, and continuous rebuilding (looks at Night4ce's Church of Mokou, community house, even the now-gone QB), this is getting too far. Building new base further out to reduce the chance of griefers.
Another thing I've noticed is that the server IP seems to be all over - MC Forums, here, YT (this alone scares me)...and now we have 50+ unique players. Brilliant!
I don't think Big Brother is doing much to help.
I highly recommend (1) putting in moderators as soon as possible and (2) taking down instances of the server IP, such as MC Forums (upon the RP registrations ending - tell them to save it somewhere before removing it), your YT channel (just set the teaser vid and others to private, and on future ones don't give away the IP address), the MC server stats banner (which gives the IP away flat-out), and maybe even here (tell users to PM existing players). Maybe we also need spawn jails as well, though we'll first need mods around the clock.
EDIT: I'm personally against reverting and instead encourage more donations to those who have been affected.