Ugh. First off, I am going to be
very annoyed if I lose the game due to other people failing at basic predicate logic, so, therefore, a bit of a lesson in first-order logic and implications. First...
As for other stuff, that's between you two right now, but I will say that Sailor Moon is telling the truth about killing Evangeline. That much is absolutely certain. Also, mindgames aren't better than insta-winning the game. However, given the level of meta I'm seeing here, everything lines up perfectly for ShKanon to have seen that Sailor Moon would be passing the medal to either Evangeline or Stone Mason, and that Evangeline was looking bad. As such, the medal would probably have gone to Evangeline, and she kills Stone Mason to get rid of who she thinks is the towniest player at the time. Then, there's a good chance that Evangeline gets killed right away because of starting at L-1. Then, when they both end up dead, she pulls off a gambit to make Sailor Moon look bad for... agh, brain fart. I lost where I was going. But I'll say that if I had to vote, right here and now, it'd be ShKanon.
First off, no, it's *not* between the two of us, as I caught Sailor Moon in a lie and she has since then managed to not explain it away in a plausible manner. Secondly...
Remember when a player named Alice would rant on about the failings of town here, and one of the points was that Conspiracy Theories Are Bad, Yo; Don't Use Them? Well, yeah, you're using one of them. In fact, you're doing the exact same thing you did at the end of D3 where you seem to have everything figured out but are instead posting what amounts to little more than complete nonsense. First off:
Mason as the towniest player? How in the heck?
Scummiest perhaps, but certainly not the towniest player. Secondly, assuming that Evangeline made it to the beginning of this day alive, and had the Silver Medal placed on
her, she'd start out at L-
2, because we'd be in 4-player LYLO. Assuming that Sailor Moon is town combined with her current logic makes absolutely no sense, because this would necessitate her to kill someone
and fail to realise that placing the Silver Medal on someone else with a scum nightkill going through would cause town to insta-lose upon daybreak (more-or-less) if she had guessed wrong. Now, assuming that she is lying scum it makes perfect sense! She offs Evangeline, and tries to push Mason closer to a lynch the next day. Mason winds up dead, but there's 2 NKs. Claim some harmless role with details that can't really be verified (for instance, it could very well be that Evangeline is Nobu - absolutely nothing in-game confirms this to us at the moment), and if you don't mess it up, you pretty much win, despite the person you placed the Silver Medal on having died.
Secondly, a scum gambit doesn't make any sense if scum could already easily win without the gambit: the point of a gambit is that it is a heavy-risk, heavy-reward action undertaken where the reward outweighs the risk taken, or the reward is needed to save and/or secure your position in the game, which is also currently so precarious that the risk undertaken winds up being next-to-minimal anyway.
If scum can already win, they are not going to attempt to throw the game only to win in a more Rube-Goldbergian fashion. No, just... no. That just doesn't happen, simply because there are too many avenues for a gambit to go wrong in - which is why gambits are only used in specific circumstances, not just "whenever one feels like using a gambit for no good reason"
Thirdly, your scenario requires me to have a fairly good level of ESP so as to predict where the silver medal is going to land. Which makes it even more absurd, really. tl;dr step back, reread the thread, and think about things for a bit before posting something like that again, please.
Then please, tell me how both Evangeline and Stone Mason died. If I'm lying and have no one-shot kill, and Razeluxe is saying his ability did a Cop on her, then it'd have to be either you or Stone Mason who killed one, and implies Stone Mason decided not to use his kill till just now if it's him. If it's you, well, then you can go ahead and explain.
Anyway, onto Sailor Moon. Simple, Evangeline died because you nightkilled her. As the last remaining member of the scumteam.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As for Mason? That was us. We have a one-shot vig, but we lose untargetability and notification of who targeted us the same night that we use it. Overall, there was no reason for us to really use it at all, but when StuffMan was lynched yesterday in pseudo-LYLO, what I had assumed is that we were facing 2 scum, and the reason why it wasn't completely LYLO was due to vig shots. Thus, a shot in the dark, so to speak. Now, why Stone Mason? We had suspected Evangeline all day yesterday, but how LYLO played out strongly suggested her
not being scum. Moreover, a lot of her scumminess rested on her interactions and awkwardness with StuffMan, who flipped town. She still looked awful, but enough of her posts could be explained away as merely
bad play, instead of
scummy play, which made us consider looking elsewhere. Razeluxe to us looked strongly town, and as we were working under the assumption of separate people sending in the NK and the RB (incidentally, this, as well as the 15-player setup, were some of the more major points in favour of there being 2 scum instead of 1), it was a strong point in favour of him being town. That left you and Mr.Mason. You I had cleared up to now mostly on meta (just goes to show you that I should always follow my own advice in that indiscriminate use of meta is
always bad), with a large supplement from what looked like an initially quite good voting record (which instead turned into a 30 Bus Pileup to the point where I'm actually getting flashbacks to WTC LYLO#1, rofl), and Mason had been low-content, low-volume and iffy posting/voting all game, thus us targeting him.
The reason for us not taking the Silver Medal into account was that we assumed that us not doing anything => game over, scum win, combined with the fact that we didn't think that anyone'd be dumb enough to use the Silver Medal in LYLO anyway. Apparently we were wrong in both assumptions, but it caught you nicely in a lie, which ultimately works just as well for town.
In fact, I'm so certain of you being scum right now that I'm going to vote you. Right now. Might as well put my money where my mouth is, after all.
##Vote: Sailor Moon
