Black Stories 3 ~ Case 41: The Spaniards

[Prody]

Was the dog planted there by someone else?

As a prank?

Was the dog Momiji? (which would make sense if Kogasa was indeed the culprit)

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Was the dog planted there by someone else?

YES

As a prank?

NO

Was the dog Momiji? (which would make sense if Kogasa was indeed the culprit)

The dogs name is UNKNOWN. If you want to call it Momiji, go ahead :V

[Thaws]

(which would make sense if Kogasa was indeed the culprit)

I would think if Kogasa was the culprit she'd hide inside the luggage herself. :V

Did the Diva open the luggage?

Was the dog the kind that smell for drugs and illegal stuff?

Did the Diva had anything illegal on her?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Did the Diva open the luggage?

Why do I feel like we had that one before? IRRELEVANT. She noticed the dog, that's all that matters

Was the dog the kind that smell for drugs and illegal stuff?

NO

Did the Diva had anything illegal on her?

NO

[Thaws]

Did the dog reminds the Diva of a past event?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Did the dog reminds the Diva of a past event?

You could say that, YES

[Mushyrulez]

Does ta gender of ta dog's past owner matter?
For that matter, does anything else about him/her, besides that s/he knows the Diva matter?
Does ta Diva have something, be it good or bad, towards canines?
Did ta past owner know about that?
Do ta canine's characteristics matter?

My guess is, some fan of ta Diva decided ta give her a gift, and as all fans do, knew that she was getting off a flight. So, ta fan took her luggage while it was on one of those big spinny-luggage-holding things, put a dog in, put the luggage back on ta spinny-luggage-holding thing, and left. Ta Diva didn't expect anything out of ta norm ta be in her luggage, and either fainted from surprise, or was scared of dogs and fainted because of that.

:V

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Does ta gender of ta dog's past owner matter?

NO, but let's make it a male

For that matter, does anything else about him/her, besides that s/he knows the Diva matter?

YES

Does ta Diva have something, be it good or bad, towards canines?

YES. It can be assumed she likes dogs.

Did ta past owner know about that?

He could at least conclude it, YES

Do ta canine's characteristics matter?

You don't have to find them out in detail, but they do matter, YES

My guess is, some fan of ta Diva decided ta give her a gift, and as all fans do, knew that she was getting off a flight. So, ta fan took her luggage while it was on one of those big spinny-luggage-holding things, put a dog in, put the luggage back on ta spinny-luggage-holding thing, and left. Ta Diva didn't expect anything out of ta norm ta be in her luggage, and either fainted from surprise, or was scared of dogs and fainted because of that.

NO

[Pesco]

Is the dog alive?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Is the dog alive?

Guess I'll have to now: Which dog?  :3

[Pesco]

I don't recall a mention of more than one dog because everyone has been referring to it as "a dog" or "the dog". Both of these are singular.

Is there more than one dog?

Is the dog in the luggage dead?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

I don't recall a mention of more than one dog because everyone has been referring to it as "a dog" or "the dog". Both of these are singular.

Mindhax :3

Is there more than one dog?

YES. There is two dogs in this riddle.

Is the dog in the luggage dead?

The dog that made the diva faint was NOT dead. The other dog, however, was dead, YES

[Pesco]

Is the dead dog in the luggage with the live dog?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Is the dead dog in the luggage with the live dog?

NO

[Thaws]

As a dog lover, the Diva used to own a pet dog that eventually died. A fan of hers decided to buy her a dog that looked like her old dog to make her happy, and sneaked it into her luggage. So when Momiji jumped out as the Diva opened the luggage, the Diva thought her dog came back to life, she then fainted due to shock/happiness.

[Dead Princess Sakana]

As a dog lover, the Diva used to own a pet dog that eventually died. A fan of hers decided to buy her a dog that looked like her old dog to make her happy, and sneaked it into her luggage. So when Momiji jumped out as the Diva opened the luggage, the Diva thought her dog came back to life, she then fainted due to shock/happiness.

Almost, but I'm gonna press for the real answer here. Red parts are correct

[Thaws]

Has the Diva lost her dog before?

If yes, did she try to find it? By advertising it somewhere?

Did the one who put in Momiji thought the dog was the dead one the Diva had?

If yes, did the person put Momiji as an attempt to return the dog to the Diva?

[Pesco]

Did a Korean eat her dog? :V

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Has the Diva lost her dog before?
If yes, did she try to find it? By advertising it somewhere?

None of that. NO

Did the one who put in Momiji thought the dog was the dead one the Diva had?

NO

If yes, did the person put Momiji as an attempt to return the dog to the Diva?

YES, but in a different way than you mean it here.

Did a Korean eat her dog? :V

There is neither Sana nor Acidus involved in this riddle.

[Thaws]

Did the Diva know Momiji was not her pet dog?

Did she know her dog was dead?

Did the one who sneaked in Momiji know the Diva's dog was dead?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Did the Diva know Momiji was not her pet dog?

A bit hard to answer, but I would say NO

Did she know her dog was dead?

YES

Did the one who sneaked in Momiji know the Diva's dog was dead?

YES

[Mushyrulez]

All stupid speculation here that I doubt is correct, but wouldn't hurt ta try 

Ta Diva was a Diva, and, consequently, very busy in life. She loved dogs and owned one. However, due to her responsibilities, she was not able to properly take care of her dog. Her dog then died from this lack of care (maybe abuse?).
Later, someone (maybe an animal rights activist? :V) who knew that the Diva's dog was dead, put it into her luggage after the flight and went away. The Diva, upon arriving after her flight, opened up her luggage and saw her pet dog there, who jumped up at her. With her reputation being threatened due ta her past miscare possibly being revealed, and ta dog itself being alive, caused her ta become overcome with shock and thus fainted.


Because I know that's not right, more questions:

Did ta DIva do something bad like that ta her dead dog?
Are ta profession/role/qualities of ta person relevant? Or could s/he just have been anyone?
Is ta Diva 100% certain that her dead dog was, indeed, dead?
Is ta time of ta dead dog's death relevant?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Ta Diva was a Diva, and, consequently, very busy in life. She loved dogs and owned one. However, due to her responsibilities, she was not able to properly take care of her dog. Her dog then died from this lack of care (maybe abuse?).
Later, someone (maybe an animal rights activist? :V) who knew that the Diva's dog was dead, put it into her luggage after the flight and went away. The Diva, upon arriving after her flight, opened up her luggage and saw her pet dog there, who jumped up at her. With her reputation being threatened due ta her past miscare possibly being revealed, and ta dog itself being alive, caused her ta become overcome with shock and thus fainted.

NO. Correct parts are marked red, blue parts are either irrelevant or incorrect.

Did ta DIva do something bad like that ta her dead dog?

Bad like what? She didn't abuse it, NO

Are ta profession/role/qualities of ta person relevant?

YES

Or could s/he just have been anyone?

NO

Is ta Diva 100% certain that her dead dog was, indeed, dead?

YES. The dog the diva owned is as dead as a dead dog can be.

Is ta time of ta dead dog's death relevant?

YES. Let's say it died before the flight.

[Thaws]

Was the person a psychologist?

Was the person working at the airport?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Was the person a psychologist?

NO

Was the person working at the airport?

YES

[Thaws]

Is the relevance of the person being a Diva explaining how the one working at the airport knew that she love dogs and her dog died?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Is the relevance of the person being a Diva explaining how the one working at the airport knew that she love dogs and her dog died?

I had to read that one three times to get it right (O_O). Anyway, NO. The relevance of the woman being a diva is that the other person knows her for her fame.

[Thaws]

Was it the person's intent to shock the Diva with the dog?

Do we need to know any more about the person's ocupation other than that the person worked at the airport?

[Dead Princess Sakana]

Was it the person's intent to shock the Diva with the dog?

NO

Do we need to know any more about the person's ocupation other than that the person worked at the airport?

NO

[Thaws]

Is the origins of the living dog relevant? Or at least, do we need to know where the airport worker got it?

Was the living dog on the flight? How about the dead one?

Did the airport worker thought the living dog was dead?