this is another null post that can ONLY bug me if Alex has missiles. Dammit, I hate posts like this. I can't outright say they are scummy but they feel that way to me since I think Alex is scum
.
This is another 50/50 post. It's not scummy, but it's not really townie. Honestly, I think that's becoming a trend with Alex. He's posting the easy stuff and not analyzing past the current challenge except for that one time on D1.
this post is also lukewarm. The ONLY thing Alex can suggest is that Ciato goes. The part about the challenger not being him wasn't necessary and was worth slight town points, but again, it's easy to say when you expect Ciato's flip to clear you.
I never realized how maddening this was.
Ok, what happened to
this? It was rather unqualified.
this reads as a harder Cid fish while basically just saying more about information rather than analyzing players. I'm REALLY noticing that trend. Rarely is something outside the current challenge mentioned by Alex, and when it is, it's usually the set up.
this is probably the scummiest post to date:
Intelligent vs. townie tell: Check
Easy "pro-town" sentiment: check
Framing a now flipped townie: check
Waffling: Surprisingly, check.
I don't think anyone can really debate those, but I'll entertain arguments.
While
this post is consistent, it's continues the "readable is town yay!" theme.
Another scummy
post by my criteria. Well, also, I'd like to ask. What changed on Cid, Alex? Also, I notice your opinion starts to turn against Kiro though you still don't want him to die. I think others were worrying about Kiro around the same point, but I could be wrong. Finally, there's that "readability=town, craziness = scum" attitude that I don't think holds, and is somewhat scummy to perpetuate. Well, townie to perpetuate in the meta but in this specific game basically hunting easy targets. Finally, a couple obvious theory stances.
this post I cannot make heads or tails of. He's coaching me. I don't like that. But I know my alignment, so he's coaching town. Why is he trying to raise the chance I won't be mislynched? Quite frankly, given the rest of his 50/50 mostly town theory very little town analysis posts, I'm inclined to say it was staged to perpetuate his gracious towniness, but I will admit this post bugs me and my read of Alex.
Ok, I think I get it now.
this and the last post are Alex going for the mislynch. He's been reserved because he had to clean up the messes of prior days to look town, but now that he has enough cred he's using it. Granted, that's a very biased interpretation. It's a matter of "does he believe what he's saying". Given he coached me and seems to be semi non commital on me vs. Chaore...I'm leaning not actually.
this post causes me to ask "Why Serp?" You
never mentioned him before. Further, it is intentionally throwing me to hang myself with two
town options. Granted, I used that option, so I have to accept a hit if I consider this scummy. But I'm not afraid to do that. I am willing to admit that I've been in scummy circumstances as well as Alex. I think that I have less against me if you read my posts. So I'll take the hyporisy hit. Oh, I'll add there's a very nice waffle on Cid that leaves Alex open to sway with the opinion and say he's right either way if Cid flips.
More serp hate.
Where did this
come from. I think I've found the most solid scum tell I'll find on Alex. He's bringing up Serp out of NOWHERE because the town is leaning that way...why?
this post has more wiggle room, plus just an "I agree with Kefit" to explain his newfound obsession with Serp...AFTER the challenge is issued.
this is more UK coaching, also defending stance on Rou. Honestly, nothing to read here except the UK coaching bugs me for the same reason as before.
this is another minor illustration of the "Hey guys, I'm here, I only have opinions on two people, where's the popcorn" attitude. Well, sorta. He does mention K4, but mostly to chastise us for quote stripes
This is the very first time we see all of Alex's opinions, and it's not very impressive. It only explains town reads, it relegates three people to lurker status without a comment on their alignment, and the two scummy he chooses are town. The big problem is that he leaves a lot of waffle room on everyone that's not Kefit. So, yeah.
Well, now that he's in big picture mode, notice that his focus shifts in
this post. Part cid waffle with a lurker hunt. What happened to me and Cha being scum?
this post continues the trend of punishing bad players, not scum players.
this is another "could be pro town speculation, could be scummy framing" post, of which Alex excels at.
I really don't get the somewhat complete change of opinion in
this post. After he's done being irritated that Rou can prove his power (bragging possibly?), he focuses on his lurkers still but doesn't even MENTION me, who was probably a logical death.
this post's main problem is the weird number manipulation. What was the point?
ALL DONE! Let me compress all this. I think I have a better case now.
