Going "I see no reason to think that Affinity/Conq is scum" when you haven't addressed everyone (you haven't addressed Serela all game and you haven't laid down a read on Shadoweh at all, for example) is kind of what. Are they better than the rest? Because you haven't laid a reason for that.
I'd also like to know what your current stance on NNR is. How much from your D1 case have you retracted? Do you agree or disagree with my case?
(Answer whenever you're back?)
And I would like to know the lottery number for the next draw, but I guess you wouldn?t tell me even if you know them.I thought that calling them town reads were already enough to imply that ?I've seen things that make me think they are town? but I was already half asleep at that point. So let me fill in the blanks:
Serela is uninteresting, as in I've only glanced through his post so far.
Shadoweh is a lingering something.
SasAmra-san and Darkoda are both new and have both only rudiments of original content.
Rawr is as easy to read as a brick that fall on the keyboard.
Now back to the topics where I have actually something to say about. My approach on NNR was mostly putting him aside for a while, to get time to ?explore that Terra incognita? that are the above-mentioned player, and then ISO read him again to see if the impression still stands. So I hope you don't mind it when I update my opinion on him as soon as I actually did that.
But about
your case I can say that I have to disagree with the first part, town needs time and reasons to get to solid reads while scum can give solid reads early, when they can't be that strong anyway, and vanish into vagueness later, when it comes to decide on a lynch for an instance.
The rest are valued points and I at last like to think that some goes into the same direction as my case did, particularly the question why he was so focused on Zakeri never looked into other direction.
When I think about it, the wagons today looks like they are set into stone already, so I shift the Terra incognita exploration into the night and ISO-reread NNR now.
PS: And with now I mean after I got myself some cigarettes.