Re: So You Want To Be The Townest Mafia (Thread 2)

[ActionDan]

I am vanilla town.

details, why are your scum reads scum?

Who's left anyway?  ActionDan, Rawr, BT, Serela, Chaore, Bob, Dormio, IHNN, Affinity

People who have a non-zero chance of flipping scum: Serela, Chaore, Bob, Dormio, IHNN, Affinity.

Capt.h's town list before scum killed him:

Serela
Rawr
Dan
Bob
BT
LLD
Chaore

Subtracting names:  Dormio, IHNN, Affinity. 

HuhWhat died who wanted IHNN dead first, whereas I was thinking of Dormio for dying.

Info this tells me: not much.  Maybe IHNN should be evicted first.

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

I mean, it's like, hello? Earth to Dan?
Have you noticed that I'm not Serela?
Have you noticed that I'm not saying that Serela's statement that I'm being lazy as adj is inaccurate?
Have you noticed that what I AM saying is that Serela is being hypocritical by applying it only to myself?
Have you noticed that you're a adj yet?
Jesus verb.

[ActionDan]

I gotta say, Dormio, I'm not even angry.
 
I can't be angry that I rolled VT two posts in a row.

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

details, why are your scum reads scum?

I want to ask this question to everyone, because nobody is looking past "herp derp roles OMG".

Anyway, I have assignments due tomorrow that I should work on instead of wasting time on the internet so I think I might go do those instead.
We have two days left anyway, if BT doesn't hammer early so I'll be back with reasons later.

I gotta say, Dormio, I'm not even angry.

This is how much I care.

[ActionDan]

meh, I'll pretend Dormio isn't scum, because if he was I'd think he'd be too ashamed to say what he's saying right now.

doo de da.

Vanilla townie here tttthinks IHNN should die!

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

And also, oh yes, always going to go for textbook theory.
Scum must always kill the people that are right.
It has nothing to do with how active or townie someone seems, the basis for the scum kill is most definitely always "OMG HU IS LOOKIN' AT ME!!1!!1OEN!11"

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

meh, I'll pretend Dormio isn't scum, because if he was I'd think he'd be too ashamed to say what he's saying right now.

And what the CLUCK is that meant to mean?

[ActionDan]

Scum kill people that won't be lynched or that have correct town reads.  just what I've noticed and what I feel most threatened by as scum when I've been scum.

And not when I am a Vanilla townie, like now!

[ActionDan]

If you were scum and knew I was town, you wouldn't be saying what you're saying

to a vanilla townie no less.

[Dr Rawr]

If you were scum and knew I was town, you wouldn't be saying what you're saying

to a vanilla townie no less.

What.....

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

I'm town and I think that you're god-forsaken town. Would I still say whatever it is I'm saying?

And what you're assuming is that scum have been killing this game for correct reads and what I'm saying is that I think that this is a rather presumptuous assumption.

[ActionDan]

Of course if you are scum I will cut open your throat and NUZZLE down your neck post-game

as a vanilla townie.

cut yes.

[Dr Rawr]

 :ohdear:

Well lets do this since affinity is the only common scum read we could evict him today(his logic about huhwhat seems dumb to me still and never liked him since mid day2). If affinity did flip town id pretty much lynch dormio and ihnn in a heart beat. Else would lynch serela also do to his passiveness on lynching affinity and how little sense i can make of his case FROM D1 is

Bobs town because i think his proxy on omba d2 just wouldnt make sense for scum. Though he his full of useless

actiodan is town no matter how dumb some of his posts are(dat theory, dat sarcasm, dat ihnn gambit thing, this thing with dormio and votes)

Bt is town else he would have just ended our suffering

[Dr Rawr]

Oh and chaore is null for some reason. I guess my read on him would be determined by other peoples flips

[Dr Rawr]

Unless BT is one of those people that likes watching people suffer

[Shadoweh]

Forty-Sixth Might As Well Post The Full Votecount

Action Dan (2): Serela, BT,
BT (5): I have no name, Chaore, Affinity, Action Dan, Action Dan
Dr. Rawr (1): Dr. Rawr

Not voting: Mr. Bob, Dormio

Tarred and Feathered: Dr. Rawr, Dormio, Chaore

Tar and Feather Counter: Mr. Bob - Over 24 Hours

Za Leedar: BT!

There are 49 hours remaining.
Day End Counter

[Dr Rawr]

Actually scratch killing affinity today lets just kill ihnn and dormio >.>

[Dr Rawr]

Also dormio yes i would like posts/reasons as to why ihnn is town.

[Mr_Bob]

Bob's (remaining) town reads are Dan, BT, Rawr, Chaore (unfortunately these are mostly from situations revolving around claims).

Affinity is probably scum.  Which is unfortunate because I had been reading him as town up until D3 where his posts deteriorate because he has to defend what is probably a made-up claim.  He did have a solid case on Omba, but I am very aware of how strong Affinity's bussing game is.

That leaves NoName, Serela, and Dormio.
NoName has struck me as inexperienced for most of the game, in the various confrontations he's had. However, something is pinging my gut with his D4.  Re-reading after posting this.
Serela seems like he's probably town with the gambit he made N2 to defend the "cop", he was also the first one to claim an 'enabler' sub-type, rather than a 'seeker' (which scum wouldn't have known, unless there is a rolecop [but then why didn't scum make more appropriate claims?]).
Dormio has been reading as apathetic, even in the face of being lynched.  Gut says it's town surrendering itself to the people, or not giving in to pressure.  Hmm.

Lynching order:
1. Affinity
2. NoName
3. Dormio (presuming there are four scum)

[Affinity]

despite what others think of us still think I am dreaming or Lynch today or nameless. when we are in the role play and other oddballs Lynch is a disgrace.

This foam I suddenly why do you think? judgment is to be ratified, I am pleased that some have said that you?

Serela Bob and the chaos, you better back up and stuff to say unto you, that you. also

At least a few people might be able to deliver much more than four, then the rest of the refuse would be very naive prey.

After this discord? we are dealing with are not, the people of this city why have you brought him?

[Affinity]

words please

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

Why do I have to study statistics again. I thought I was done with maths.

[Affinity]

Despite what you might think of me by others, I think we should either today or anonymous we still dormio Lynch. They are the ones that wasted oddballs to others role and Lynch game.

Bob, I suddenly scrap Why do you think? It is a valid emotion, Do you agree with what other people are saying?

[Affinity]

despite what other people may think of me i still think we should lynch either dormio or nameless today.  they are the ones being the oddballs in the role game and lynching others would be a waste.

bob why do you think i am scum all of a sudden?  it is a valid sentiment but do you agree with what others have been saying?

LOVELY this game

[Affinity]

reason why i am so bloody apathetic about this game now is because day 1 and day 2 are the only useful days and that many people's content such as chaore serela rawr during those days were negligible.  also the post restriction is a REASON TO HATE CONQUEROR FOREVER.  but let me try to make something cool last time.

when i say i want to lynch dormio
my reasons extend beyond role considerations
it is because of the day two things i have raised as well
such as him providing limited reads on others like omba (important due to scumflip)
and that awkward drop of dan (sole scumread of his) which was long overdue

people like serela who accuse me
of going only on roles
without countering the above flaws based on his content
are severely myopic and shortsighted
townreads without reasons (why clear bob and not dormio despite both being useless)
manufactured for posturing
dormio's role should not help allay the doubts of anyone

i think dormio a better lynch than nameless
the day 2 of the latter to my liking
though consider his opinion on omba here when his case on huhwhat had already started
with his subsequent hating of it
and things do seem a bit fishy
the thing about his lack of hierachy to his scumreads throughout days one and two excabarate the above

more words please

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

I hate statistics.

[Affinity]

but in the end if one were to look at content alone in day one and day two
where and whence does the scumminess end?

serela and his five scumreads
his suspicion on dormio vanished in order to kite me(serela counter this if you can)
his bone headed try to misdirect the lynch yesterday
lazily saying do not lynch the cop
when it was clear that he was not a cop in the first place
if dormio is scum i would lynch him the next day and the drop of a hat

chaore and his absurd lack of stances other than bt barring token stuff
rawr his puzzling fascination on nameless and lack of opinions
bob and his lack of anything the entire game past his cuteness (already consumed)
bt and his disappearance for most of day 2

the double town lynch on day 1
the leave allowances on day 2 and bandwagon bumrushes
the taken for granted omba lynch on day 3 which everyone agreed with
where to look and where to pry?
where to give effort when none is due?
in the end i shy from the above in fear
cozying up to the little warmth their roles offer
dormio and nameless (maybe serela now that i think about it) the only lynches i would recommend
in the hope that light may be shed on the earlier's wagon

[Dormio Ergo Sum]

if dormio is scum i would lynch him the next day and the drop of a hat

And if I'm not? Would you still want Serela lynched?

[Affinity]

oh i misread serela's post as clearing dormio on the basis that he is 'just being useless' this game
so replace those bits with 'being generally bone-headed day 1 and 2'
sorry for the misrep but then again its not as if
lumping him along with three other names
makes much difference

a misrep is a misrep though

forgive me

[Serela]

...why did I wake up at 4am?

Anyway.

Dormio's recent spat looks pretty town :/

But... his actual play his been so bleh this game ;_; But -Affinity- is the one pushing this. Blah. I'm going to give up on the WIFOM here for a minute and move on to other topics.

I won't know what to think of Mr.Bob's latest post until we actually get IHNN and/or Affinity flips. Unless they, like, both flipped scum, my bad read on Mr.Bob isn't going anyway. That being said, they're my top two candidates for flipping scum at the moment, sooooooo. (The issue is that everything points towards a fourth scum after that, which=main reason I brought Dormio back into my list of suspects after having cleared him)

Anyway. Affinity's stuff about me.

serela and his five scumreads

There are 4 scum, 0 had been caught. Sure, we didn't really know if there was 4 scum or not at this point, but considering the size of the game and that there ARE... 5 suspects when none have been caught seems pretty entirely normal.

his suspicion on dormio vanished in order to kite me(serela counter this if you can)

Wasn't this because of his claim? (After massclaim happened and claims became AUGH, yeah, Dormio got back in the suspect list, but at the time it seemed good enough for clearing.)

Besides, you're scum ^_^

his bone headed try to misdirect the lynch yesterday
lazily saying do not lynch the cop
when it was clear that he was not a cop in the first place

Okay this is purely a meta argument so feel free to ignore what I say here everyone, but, as HW brought up, this just tends to be something I do :/ I never even thought about that until he mentioned it. I have trouble with not letting claims affect my judgment overly much (Although if the claim seems overly top for the setup or really out of place, well, kill it with fire. I had still thought it'd be entirely reasonable for one of the suggested PRs in the setup to actually be real with the other two faked.)

At this point I'm getting all bleh and waffly over the identity of scum #4, and that's even with assuming Affinity and IHNN both flipped scum. This worries me. Thankfully I'm not the only townie in the game, and we're not even in lylo either!