Ah, now I see it. It was at the start. Geez, here I was getting excited for nothing!
In any case, I'm not sure I get the case on Tenshi. The dichotomy doesn't strike me as entirely hard, given everyone had cemented the Town lynch to be on either of BlackRose or Kaori. It would be a right miracle to have moved the lynch onto someone else at the time, so judging by whoever is scummier by the end of it, I don't have problems with Tenshi's conduct much. I, likewise, decided Kaori seemed more scummy to me than BlackRose when moving my vote.
In any case, the above post may indicate where my suspicions lie and they have not moved since Day 1 much. I was willing to let up on Meiya yesterday because multiple people concluded I was tunnelling and I decided to look at others besides Meiya, thinking that if she were the scum I think she is, there would have been pos that provided further evidence; posts which, I believed, would be easier to come by if I did not focus my entire Day on her and turn it into another back-and-forth.
Then Day 2 happened and Meiya provided nearly nothing. I reiterate that Meiya has done nothing but misconstrue others to provide her case. Examples such as:
Firstly, I must ask how miss Martinozzi's thoughts on both miss Gasai and miss Irene have changed. Miss Martinozzi first voted for miss Gasai within this post due to miss Gasai's miller claim. The fact that miss Gasai has claimed to be a miller has not changed. Does this mean that your attitude towards miss Gasai has also failed to change? The same can be said of miss Irene who has, from miss Martinozzi's perspective, claimed to be aligned with anti-town forces in this post. There have been no actions to change this fact so this leaves me to wonder why miss Martinozzi would not be voting for one that she believes to have outright claimed to be aligned with forces that work against the town. Miss Martinozzi claims in this post that she wishes not to leave her vote in a place that will serve no purpose however if miss Martinozzi truly believed miss Irene to be aligned with those that are not working towards town's win condition then would the vote not be serving a purpose simply by being upon miss Gasai? I ask why miss Martinozzi was so quick to give up on her vote on miss Gasai.
To which my response was:
If I didn't mention Gasai during any of my previous posts, it's because I didn't find anything in her posts that really felt scummy enough to talk about. Complaining I do not jump on every little bit and try to spin it into scum is naive and you need to pick up training again. That is not how you catch Galette spies.
And near Day 1 end she claimed:
In this post you state "If I didn't mention Gasai during any of my previous posts, it's because I didn't find anything in her posts that really felt scummy enough to talk about. Complaining I do not jump on every little bit and try to spin it into scum is naive and you need to pick up training again. That is not how you catch Galette spies." May I ask why you said this. I believe that my argument regarding the hypocrisy surrounding accusing miss Gasai of performing untelegraphed actions was directed at miss Miki, not you. Perhaps you, miss Martinozzi, are burdened with a guilty conscience?
I cannot see how she can misconstrue her cases like this continuously and still not get flak from the rest of Town. There is a distinct difference between bad play and
horrible play, and I consider her wordiness and extravagant attitude more of a way to hide the true meaning of her words than anything else. Continuous inattentiveness towards what she claims is Scum is horrible.
That she lurked through the entirety of Day 2 with a few exceptions further raises my heckles, and I just don't like how she picked up her Day 1 Eclair case when most of it honestly was her attempting to discredit my case on her by continuously spinning the truth around like a baby. She voted me for reasons posted at the time of her switch to Sayaka, which is
this post.
She doesn't say why her actions aren't scummy: she returns a question. This is avoiding answering to stuff and it is simply not Townie to avoid answering stuff and justifying yourself. I showed time and again that her vote on Tenshi was, at the time, due to solely one question related to a gross misinterpretation of Tenshi's case on Maka Albarn in the early-game, and it strikes me as a gruesomely inattentive attitude to hold. That she claims Farina was redeemable yet Tenshi was not, despite the entire vote being based on a question oozing with inattentiveness, and then refuses to give further clear answer on it, is the entire crux of why I believe her vote was insincere and Meiya has not been scumhunting. Things like
I also believe that statements such as "You had time to talk about Gasai's blurb on BlackRose, surely you have time to talk about why the person you're voting is a Galette spy." are highly provocative and serve no purpose other than to smear one's name.
are further deflections to answer to stuff. Highly provocative it is, because I want Meiya to finally make clear why I am Scum, and she has yet to provide so.
As we are, once again, pressed for time I shall temporarily cease diverting my energies towards miss Martinozzi
This is of course a riot because Meiya has never diverted any energies to providing a case on why I am Scum.
This post has her voting me, and it contains two arguments:
1) Eclair's case on [Meiya] is contradictory.
2) How have your thoughts on Gasai and Irene changed, Eclair?
That is not a scum case to hold on to to Day 2.
Miss Martinozzi also states that: "This isn't enough reason to vote Tenshi over Farina for me and I want her to make that abundantly clear." I also find the notion that miss Martinozzi feels that she has the authority to determine what appears to be ill-motivated behaviour to others to be laughable. Especially when one considers the fact that miss Martinozzi complains within the very same post about how she cannot do anything if others do not agree with her viewpoints in regards to miss Irene's behaviours.
This is another example of deflection I find when I read back to the early game. If you read her post voting Tenshi over Farina, I believe there is sufficient reason to at the very least ask why Farina is less suspicious than Tenshi, and returning the answer "Haha, you have no authority" to that is at best unhelpful Townie behaviour but likely Scum dancing around the issue.
When I look at her only real post on Day 2
here, the case on BlackRose is needlessly wordy and can be condensed easily:
1) BlackRose provided nothing. This is disadvantageous to Town's win condition.
2) BlackRose continuing to provide nothing shows she intends to continue this tactic that benefits only herself.
3) BlackRose defends lurkers and says Tenshi is suspicious for voting lurkers, while BlackRose herself agrees to Kanzaki's lynch.
4) BlackRose says attacking lurkers is lazy and then says she'd like to see Kanzaki lynched. Question.
5) "I refuse to accept miss Rose's reasons for avoiding placing her vote upon miss Kanzaki."
To be sure, there is no explanation why these actions are scummy: lurking itself is not scummy, and if it is then Meiya is scummy for lurking through Day 2. A tactic that
benefits only oneself isn't so much scummy as third party, and there's the omission of how
continuing that tactic would be hazardous, considering everyone harped on her for not providing. I cannot see how Meiya pressed BlackRose continuing to post in the way everyone criticized as something scummy. It's honestly just dumb.
Number 3) is another inattentive and gross misrepresentation of the truth. I believe BlackRose adequately explained herself there. Number 4) is almost the same, except that Meiya poses a question attached to the observation, rather than a conclusion or opinion. I have never liked people who avoid posting their own opinions.
Number 5 is a blatant admission that the vote is at least partially fuelled by BlackRose not attacking a lurker as her top priority, given BlackRose's reasons were that attacking a lurker would be extremely lazy considering you can put your vote there and call it a day.
Her Day 3 post has no mention of me which is baffling considering I was her sole aim for the better part of Days 1 and 2.
All things considered, I stand by the idea that Meiya is scummy and would like to see her lynched, or else given sufficient reason to believe she isn't Scum enough to want someone else over her.
And now back to rereading Busy.
