OK, so there we go! I
am a bit worried I'm still alive due to how off-track I've been so far but goddamnit, everyone's scum.
Would lynch: Dormio, PX
Would not lynch: Huh What, BT, Pesco
Can be convinced to lynch: Hero, Serela
So yeah, the dread Dormio/PX scumteam. Let's talk about why these two are shit and why they deserve the noose.
Let's start with Dormio and his
very first post in the game, which is cheerleading a wagon on Shadoweh by pointing out WIFOM, but then jumping on BT for utterly camp reasons. One has to wonder about
priorities, as he continues cheerleading the Shadoweh case by accusing her of active lurking while sticking to a BT case, which is reasonably weaker. BT is a new player, I can't imagine Shadoweh active lurking is a weaker charge than BT not making sense yet.
To point out: defending another player is BAD, but it's not a scumtell by itself. Only once the other player flips, and even then it's circumstantial, where active lurking is scummy any way you slice it. His jump off of BT is
sudden and hardly explained, other than that Dan is suddenly worse. He comments that Dan doesn't have cases except PX for ED1 stuff, and that Dan doesn't have comments about the rest of the game.
Up to this point, Dormio has had a case on BT for early day 1 stuff and hasn't commented on anything not Shadoweh or BT. Hypocrisy isn't scummy, but it is when you pretend that the same traits in other people is scummy. I'll note the excusing for activity because this shit was done last game by Dan himself, until we lynched his red-coloured arse.
He explains his case
later, but calls it a reiteration: as if he had to restate a case. Look at the previous post. Is there really a case? His case comes down to "Dan has too many Town reads", and repeats a request for more about the rest of the game. Dormio has still not commented on the rest of the game, focusing solely on Dan without ever going back to how Shadoweh or BT are scum. Or anyone. He's slamming Dan for town reads but doesn't seem to dispute whether the person in question is Town or not, and the add-on from post #150 onwards is just "Dan is defending himself", which again is not a trait that alone defines scumminess.
The case up to this point is Utter Shit. His excuse for not commenting on the rest of the game himself is
anyone not mentioned is town or neutral, and everyone is neutral to him. Way to dodge responsibility. His case on Dan becomes further shit when
he clears Shadoweh without any explanation to it himself, and minor suspicion on BT which doesn't really make a whole lot of sense. Up to here, Dan is scum, Shadoweh is Town, BT is "a thing" and everyone else is neutral.
Don't scumhunt now, you might tire yourself out. His "a thing" of BT is based on Early Day Content, which
he still holds against Dan alongside not commenting on the rest of the game, where his comment was a blanket "everyone's neutral".
He later
contradicts his own case by saying he doesn't care about who Dan thinks are Town. Even though he voted Dan
for clearing people as Town! Dan doing "anything" to save himself isn't really Scum, you know. Town also want to survive, unless you're Pesco and have to suffer Serela clearing JOB as useful content.
NOW THEN,
on to Day2, where Dormio just succesfully lynched Dan based on who Dan cleared as Town and that Dan defended himself too much. This is fucking circumstantial and terrible, in my opinion, but alright. Vote goes to Shadoweh after she was his only Town read the other day! The case isn't that bad, but it's stuff that happened Day 1, and I ill see how that reads as Town one Day and as SUPER SCUM PRIORITY #1 the other Day, and no, he hasn't mentioned anyone outside of Dan/BT/Shadoweh as possible scum yet.
He later finally materialises something and that something is that
there is one scum and three weird, where Huh What is mysteriously mentioned but later not touched on. Pesco also mentioned. These are people others were voicing suspicion of. BT is still there, and he claims that's because BT's list tells us nothing. Whereas Dormio's tells us more amiright. After blanket clearing everyone as "neutral" earlier on, I find this objectionable content from Dormio.
He then moves on to
respond to BT, and we still don't know why Huh What and Pesco are "weird" for him! And then on to D3. Wow, this is going fast. Ninja vote on
Serela out of nowhere based on content from the previous Day, which he made no mention of at all the previous day!
And that's it. No really, that's it. Dormio hasn't done anything else the entire game and has never actively tried to scumhunt besides latching onto the popular Shadoweh case with a good enough case but yeah, that's it. He's mentioned BT, Shadoweh and Dan as scum suspects, one of which went from Scum to Town to Scum, and now suddenly votes Serela out of nowhere, ignoring his suspicions of Pesco and Huh What the previous day. Or his suspicion of BT.
PX case is that he's shit and a lurker but I can write one up by POST ANALYSIS if people really want me to. Do I really need to restate how PX's content doesn't exist?
Want to lynch either of these two, not only for lurking but also because what they HAVE produced is scummy as shit.
