@ Coldcrow, Nihlatak.
I like how you two suddenly aim the entire Eyeback case to me to be explained, while you could explain it yourself as well. Obvious results are obvious. First, we didn't knew that day whether EyeBack was scum or not. I am sure pretty much a lot of people were highly suspecting him for possible scum. Not because of his mach 3 lynching, but his overall behaviour. Easy fingerpointing huh?
Unfortunately that day turned into mod kills and now we are in LyLo.
I understand where you're coming from, Fireeye, but Barbarian is not mafia. He's the partner of Sorc.
Early in the game, I claimed Sorc and Barbarian were scum. This is because they were the two player characters in a list of everyone else being monsters. Also, being player characters, they could use Items, and since some SuperUniques drop items when they are killed (Like Countess did), I figured this would be part of a win condition or a reward for getting myslynches. When Sorc claimed her role, I believed it because it fit perfectly into the theory I had. She claimed having a single partner, and that both of them could use items that are dropped during lynch, but only if they were on the wagon. This is reinforced by the fact that Sorc flipped "Player Character" as part of her alignment. I'm not sure why I'm the only one who caught onto this, but I guess I'll just have to blame it on my psychic connection with Pesco.
I had the suspicion that Barbarian and Sorceress
could be partners because of the whole Diablo 2 Lore thing. But this still DOES NOT give us any guarantee that the setup is like that, because it is obvious Trollco setup. You weren't the only one who noticed it. Why else do you think I pointed out all the votings with Sorceress? See my D4 opening where I conclude LyLo. And at the same time Barbarian came into my mind as first.
Come to think of it, since Eyeback is apparently town due to Lylo, That makes all of the people who piled onto him fairly suspicious. I note FireEye had no sympathies for his role, even though I found it was sensible once I had take a look back at his play all game. What about his role made you call him out on bullshit, Fireeye?
Good point indeed. I had no sympathies indeed. So didn't Rakanishu and other players (see D3). He threatens me to claim because he knows "everything" about me, out of nowhere. Happened to be nothing at the end. And you know what was worst? He claimed Rakanishu and I were sharing the same traits, Anti-Town , unable to be tracked or w/e causing more confusion. Now tell me how do you sympathise in such a situation?
Remember Bremm posted his survivor case on Barbarian?
"Barbarian basically lied" is what came to my mind. Either he was scum, or he was survivor, and I needed to know for sure. And guess what, I was right. He immediately hard defends with calling me scum, because I rain down on him hard. Logically I do this. How else am I going to elicit the information? This alone confirms my reads on Barbarian, because look at his claim, survivor and 'carbon-copy' of Sorceress. Comparing this with my own case, I come to the conclusion Barbarian is indeed now telling the truth.
Fire Eye - I've been dismissing you as tunneling town, but there's some weird inconsistency with your cases. Like..What happened to this? I don't think there's a single thing you pursued Eyeback over on Day 3 that happened before Day 3. Why did claiming to be a tracker make Eyeback scum?
Pesco's flip post still doesn't reveal us his role. He still could've been lying about his role of tracker or had been keeping things hidden, but he said Bloodwitch didn't return results on his tracking. Only thing we can confirm is, he was town. And so was Rakanishu. Just because LyLo proven that Raka and Eye were infact town, even startled me. Not just only me, majority was infact suspecting EyeBack that entire day which made him claim in the end.
I can understand Barbarians concerns and paranoia of being careful due to his role. Retracting my pointing on Barbarian, why he knows Bremm is scum must have something to do with his one-shot abilities like Sorceress. If Bremm is indeed scum, then one of his partners are Nihlatak or Corpsefire or Coldcrow. I dropped Summoner previously from my list, Summoner is most town read for me. Worst Bremm, then followed up by possible Corpse and between Nihlatak or Coldcrow I am undecided. One of you is not entirely being honest.
