Umu...that's a bit tautological. I more mean what evidence there was. The gut doesn't go off for no reason, usually. In my case, my gut goes off on people who feel like they have information they shouldn't have, among other things (which has led me to power role lynches with some regularity).
Actually, thinking on it, if we release the hydra QT, I reveal to Shadoweh a lot of my mafia theory. Not sure if it's right or wrong, but it feels like it makes sense. It might be a good read for you.
@Conq: Psh, cases making you look townie. I use UK MAGIC for that. Anyway, I'll note that while I say ~*~cases are scummy~*~, I'm lying. It's more I'm saying verbosity is anti town, and that it's better to condense your "case" to one or two concise, unarguable points. Basic facts that are scummy. No wiggle room. I'm not sure how to explain it better and I'm not sure I do it well myself, but that's the basic concept, IMO.