I find homework is best done
by somebody else at 3:00 a.m.~
So, I oversimplified Necro's case, and the part about Ayumu (which I think I clearified already) is a half-decent reason. But, thinking about it, I don't think whether he had a good reason or a bad reason to make the switch has to do with it. No one seems to be able to grasp this, but the quality of reasoning has nothing to do with him being scum or town.
refering back to this post, He makes an entire paragraph devoted to explaining why he doesn't want to vote Ayumu anymore. Then he makes a paragraph twice as long, but filled with fluff like "While the bandwagon hop is neutral..." "...gives me the impression that she's not reading well. " and "since it seems aimed at lying low for awhile". He finishes off by saying that he'd be willing to switch back to Ayumu, which negates any town purpose for explaining why he feels Ayumu is a bad lynch.
If Gardnie was a townie, that post would have been much, much shorter. Something like "I still don't like Ayumu, but Pamela needs to explain exactly what about the Ayumu case it is that she supports." The Gardnie we have, however just feels like he's asking if it's okay if he makes a new case on someone else.
When I said I was willing to vote for you, it was for Day 2.
I was unwilling to immediately lynch you right after you decided to start getting involved.
Were you or were you not aware of how much time there was left in the day?
If you realized the day was getting too short, would you have kept your vote on Remilia, Switched to Ayumu, or Switched to me?
If the bandwagon had time to move onto me fully, and Ayumu was no longer an option, would you still have voted me despite what I quoted above from your post?
Also, what does "You want me to follow suit and vote on the person I believed to be likely town?" mean? Is this in reference to you voting me, or Ayumu, or someone else?
I still take issue with both of you posting before deadline without even considering the way wagons would move (Or in Sid's case, not move at all). But I suppose I should let this go somewhat, since this is a complete mod error (and he's even threatening to shorten the day. Ha.)
I'll have to reread Keikaku Shiba. The only notable thing I remember her doing is telling Remi that she has a day one gut read that she'll tell us "if she doesn't get killed." It sounds like she stalling to me, and it's a day one gut read (i.e. so totally never going to be important) so I don't see a reason to wait for her either.
Also, I checked Bogmire's last post again, and he really does need to put more effort into the game if he doesn't want to be considered scum. If you're voting me and using the reason "
I'm confused!" as half the case, then you should at least ask me a few questions.
Also, since people are interested in my case on Youmu, it was two parts. The Buddying up with Arc part I mentioned, but also when I called her a meanie, I meant it. I didn't like her being overly aggressive, especially on early day one, because that's the time when scum can easily fake aggressiveness and townieness. First Impressions last a while (especially in anonymous games!) so I've learned to become weary of people who try to do that sort of thing. I've dropped the case on Youmu as of the start of day 2.
