I'm interested in why SB was killed. On the surface, it's strategically a poor scum choice. They should usually go for somebody who either is suspected to have a role, or is generally accepted as town by a majority of players, is perceived as a threat for some reason (usually by being accurate with scum reads), or killing off the player benefits the scum in some way (e.g. by potentially clearing a scum who was voting to kill the victim, shock!). Otherwise, it's just a random killing. I want to believe that SB wasn't randomly picked. That's my assumption before going into this analysis.
So let's have a look at the interactions with SB. First of all, we've got mod confirmation that SB was killed by scum; so we can assume a couple of things from this which I'll get to when they're relevant.
page 2: SB votes Shadoweh.
page 3: SB votes for DNA.
page 3: PX votes for SB.
page 3: SB says:
100% accurate RVS Scumteam: Dark, Serela, Validon
Now watch me die night 1. I'd be in stitches if I did.
page 4: SB votes for Validon.
page 7: PX revotes for SB.
page 8: After a couple of pages back and forth with DNA, SB votes for DNA.
page 8: Sky_Paladin votes for SB.
page 10: SB argues with PX about Dark.
page 16: PX votes for SB (but its after hammer).
page 17: SB goes pop :/
So, why was SB killed?
Option 1 - SB may have had some useful role.
Impossible - it was night 1 and SB had made no claim.
Option 2 - was SB generally accepted as town?
Not really, in fact, there were many who considered him to be potential scum rather than null reads.
Option 3 - Appears to have good reads on who the scum are.
SB implicated - DNA, Validon, Serela. Serela is dead so let's rule him out.
Option 4 - Will implicate another towny in some way
Not really relevant - we know scum killed SB, not vig, so any of the people who wanted him flipped - myself, Kilga, possibly PX - aren't responsible for killing him. In short, if any of us were scum, we would almost certainly have gone for different targets. Personally, I would have killed DNA as he's stated he has a role and is generally accepted to be town. There's also been no interaction between Dark and myself to link back to me.
So far from this read the strongest picks are DNA and Validon. SB was actually voting for Validon when he died. Validon seems like a good case.
I'm going to keep my vote on Shadoweh though while I sleep on it. I'm interested to see what others have to say.