Huh, so Shadoweh
can dayvig.
Alright, I am going to propose that Huh What is the absolute scummiest person alive right now and that lynching him will set us on the way to victory. I will provide a list of six arguments to support that Huh What = Scum, and when I am done I hope you will all agree that
##VOTE: Huh What is the only reasonable course of action, so
I finally get to have my cake and eat itwe need only mash down on the last remaining scum. Also, I'm posting a wall of text here, because being concise has never helped me! Also because I like being a hypocrite and posting walls despite my aversion to them.
The song and dance begins, of course,
with his first case in the game, which boils down to "Bard seriously wants to lynch Serela over RVS shenanigans", which is an absurd point to pursue and strikes me as the "forced case" scum are trying to push
he has been talking of. That he later handwaves this as "I was derp" is honestly the only explanation for the behaviour, but derp comes from scum as equally strong as it comes from town.
He later continues to submit that I must have been entirely serious, which remains a ridiculous point to sit on and, taking a leap into HUH WHAT IS SCUM, would permit a scumWhat to sit back for a while and see if there wasn't anything to jump on.
Secondly, the way he
jumps off the Bard vote is a complete handwave and awkward transition. "Oh, on a re-read". Did you really need a re-read to reveal a major epiphany that my first post in the game was not a full blown "Serela is the scummiest player ever and should lynch immediately"? I find this hard to believe, and from an experienced player as Huh What, the line of inquiry is ridiculous.
When he moves on to the Conqueror case, he makes an interesting line of inquiry, but
backpedals just as quickly on the case. There is an interesting bit of
manipulation here, where he strikes a semblance between Conqueror and PX's inquiries, states that if PX's inquiries are useless, so are Conqueror's. This question is of course silly because no one thinks their case is nonsensical. The irony in that post that most strikes out is
It looks as if you are scum hanging on too hard to the case they believed was the most convenient so that they do not have to backpedal and come up with serious opinions on other players (as that would both draw attention to them and possibly give them extra chances to slip up).
Hi, how's that vote on me going earlyDay1? And at the end of the post, he even declares my vote on Serela wasn't the "primary reason". Uuuh okay, you had other reasons to suspect me at that juncture?
Diving into the next point, argument #4, we submit
this post, and pay specific attention to the line that talks about counterwagons. It's particularly interesting because
just earlier he was decrying Shadoweh as scum. Now she's suddenly the counterwagon to scumConq. That he never lets up on Conq until
after the reveal (and even then still dares suggest scumConq) is also a curious thing and I do not like it.
He declares Shadoweh scummy
here, accusing her of bussing scumbuddyHourai and restating that the rest of D1 stuff also applies. But later everything is forgiven
if Hourai wasn't known to scum. How does it matter? That he drops the case in favour of voting Colt is even more sadfaze, because his Colt case drops to nothing but "Colt is a newbie". That he asserts
Colt is a worse PX is amusing, given he asserts PX is scum but doesn't mention Colt much if at all until he votes Colt. Then suddenly Colt is PX2, except worse.
Finally, he
conveniently knows that scumSchezo was given the radio, and his tracking apparently highlights "oneshot" ability. Erh, really? "You saw Shadoweh use action X on player Z, this action is oneshot"? I'd like to hear the exact details on how you knew it was oneshot!
But Bardiche, I hear you say. Couldn't Huh What really have been derp during D1? No, my dear town. He can't have been derp during D1. Because it's just ridiculous how much his opinion flips and how strongly he latched onto me like a helpless puppy.
But Bardiche, quoth you. What if Huh What's role really tells him if an ability is one-shot or not? :S My dear town. What value is there in revealing he knew who the radio was passed to other than to claim Tracker? ... and why would he claim tracker at this stage in the game when he could still attract the NK? There's just no merit in revealing the radio.
There. Six arguments, as promised. I hope that by now you understand that Huh What is absolutely scum and must die. Kilga is just not that interesting a lynch if you line up the wall here. His only real mark against him is "I'll take the bullet for Bard :C", which honestly can't strike me as particularly scummy... how is suicide scummy? It's not.
There. Can I finally get my cake now? :V
Cut by Caedo, response in a new post.
