ok well I don't really have a choice but to wildly speculate if all the information presented is true:
sky paladin might be scum. he could be a godfather, and scum might have chosen to no-kill on night 2. darkninja is the one who brought up the point that scum could have no-killed to prevent useful information for a flip, so it's possible that he chose to no-kill for that very reason to try and implicate kilga if possible. plus, i don't know why sky paladin would be a good kill target in the first place?
like i don't even know anymore