Have been away for most of D4, and I suppose I can only apologize for blanking out on the crucial part of the day.
A quick defense of myself would be that most of Crocker's case on me seems to be 'setting up town fights'; I can't control when I look at Comedian and I can't be blamed for inadvertently encouraging cases on town when I've been doing things like, voting Mai myself and stuff like that. Also; both town and scum can encourage flailing townies, and etc.
Also, CATS has failed to notice that Mai had been pegging Kyon as super townie from D2 backwards, while elevating him to sure-scum right after the D2 flip, which is not just a worse Comedian, but a completely different thing. This rapid shift of opinions doesn't seem to have been adequately explained to this day.
And Cage's idea of scouring Comedian's posts for references to find scum smacks me as lazy and half-hearted, when scum can be silent about whoever they well please, whether thy be scum or not. As Crocker said, it's a two-way thing.
---
Scumpicks:
For Crocker ,what I've found weird is that there's also no mention of the actual cases I made against Mai and to some extent Monoe, which should have been considered, when you have accused Comedian of not having cases himself; I cannot find any good reason as to why you would choose me over Comedian, and your lack of vote at that point is very bad and smacks of wanting to wait and see whether a scum bus would be good or not. I would also like to say that Crocker's opinions pre-D4 have been utterly blank in that he has not only be putting the three easiest targets (Annonymous, CATS, Light) as his top scumpicks all game, he has also not being saying anything about the more interesting cases like those against me or Mai (until D4 where it was needed, while everyone else from Cage to Protoman has put in their fair share of input), which have certainly been around for a good enough time to comment on. This strikes me as scum behavior and lying low, and thus, is worthy of a lynch today. The irrelevant vote on Annonymous two hours before deadline seems like icing on the cake.
Mai is still somewhat lackluster with her shotgun attack on Cage due to a single post, without any reference to what transpired on the past days regarding her, which might point to some roundabout defense of Comedian. Seems like scum desperately trying to search for an alternate target. Also, I feel that my discourse with her is one-sided, which is pretty irritating, and I feel that she has not adequately explained her D2 and D3 thing on Kyon. There's also still very little evidence of opinions carrying over to the next day which I find worrying, what with cases on Crocker evaporating and Kyon turning into scum. I find her D4 significantly better than Crocker's however, but I might switch to Mai if circumstances permit.
Monoe still stands as a question mark for lackluster late D3/D4s.
Protoman is almost the towniest alive now due to the vote on Comedian when it didn't seem as if it was called for.
Cage draws a blank due to using methods of scumhunting we all seem to disagree with, but I can see her thought processes rather clearly, which counts for something. D4 voting patterns were somewhat atrocious, but bandwagon analysis aside, I find her to be the most solid out of other D4 question marks like Mai, Monoe, and Crocker. Will need some rereading.
So yeah,
##Vote: Crocker
