Grrr... just as I feared, I accidentally deleted this post when halfway finished. Abridged version.
Key-On's reasons why he voted Comedian come a little late, it looks like a random OMGUS vote.
Mr. Dick lost some town votes for his terrible "Point B", which Mai and Key-on pointed out and made me look at that post again.
And
Sailor Pothead. [ur=http://www.shrinemaiden.org/forum/index.php/topic,9391.msg625202.html#msg625202l]Post 87[/url]. Says those three are bad but no reasons why, and connects them together. Then a pretty much throw away vote on Priney dood, Mai and pro2woman pretty much say everything wrong with your posts.
Mr. Dick then looks mediocre to me, leaning towards townie. His post 99 has some agreeable things.
Abridging ends here.
Cheetohs post is sound. Even if I don't agree with some of it, I can understand how she got to that conclusion. Only thing confusing me is why she still has her vote on CATS.
Monoe's post makes sense to me, not seeing any reason to go after her.
Actually staring at Johnny Cage's post for about 5 minutes, I finally found the part where he labeled Sailor Pothead as "eager town". A townie shouldn't focus on trying to look as town as possible, but should be focusing on trying to find out who the scum are.
Unfunnyman is really just an in between read. Maybe worth picking up later, but not today.
...And then God comes in and votes on the largest wagon. :getdown:
And then
Dick's 114 which goes from down to up and back to down. Pushing scumteams on Day 1 without any flips does not accomplish anything, as it's just baseless speculation and one that could easily be read as scum based.
Hwim isn't really that memorable.
God, please show up.
Key-on is around the same level as unfunnyman. Agreed that his voting position is a little suspicious.
...And the Priney dood shows up with nice throwaway comments, now really showing anything.
Mr Crocker, I like. Post makes all sorts of sense, and shows some nice originality for moving on to Priney dood.
Johnny Cage: We do not forgive. But we will now forget about you, since you seem to have given up on this day. And tunneling down God. Who still hasn't descended yet.
Scummiest in order, from top to bottom:
Sailor Moon, for producing nothing and letting emotion run amuk, especially on an early D1 attack that really had no backbone to it and leaving a vote on an easy target without good reasoning
Johnny Cage, you no longer exist
God, for not existing
Priney dood, for trying a little?
Then Key-on and unfunnyman together.