Revolutionary Girl Utena Mafia - Night 3 (Student Council Thread)

[ActionDan]

so boring.

Prims: why is serela worthy of being voted over BT?

[GMOFucker: Makin' GMOs To Fuck 'Em]

because I forgot about BT's vote



That said I don't like Serela responding to my post as if my logic is just intuitively scummy. ~ED1 LIGHT FORCE~

[ActionDan]

well is your logic particulary townie?  Is it good logic in your opinion?

[DNAbc]

Dormio is awesome.


Kilga: Requesting Replacement, for serious this time.

[GMOFucker: Makin' GMOs To Fuck 'Em]

I don't think logic can be townie but it's fine for an ED1 vote. If you want TOKEN QUESTIONING then I'll throw this out there: how is that going to help you read me?

[PX]

Vote ActionDan
Vote BT
Vote Huhwhat
Vote Serela
Vote Raikaria

You're all blithering idiots

[BigBangMeteor]

##Vote: PX

why?

[Serela]

Well if I refuse to have ed1 tier reactions to ed1 stuff then how am I going to somewhat help the game advance ;_;

although yeah

##Vote PX

probably the least helpful of the ed1 shenanigans

[WHMZakeri]

Shadoweh and Huhwhat are super town.
Dormio is too awesome for us.

This goes against how I normally play every game I'm in, but uhh ##Vote: Serela.
I'll wait for everyone else to punish PX.

[ActionDan]

I don't think logic can be townie but it's fine for an ED1 vote. If you want TOKEN QUESTIONING then I'll throw this out there: how is that going to help you read me?

By seeing how much of what you say you believe.  As it stands you have a notion that Serela is assigning your logic as scummy (which in turn informs her voting choice).  your logic.  So implicitly you believe logic can be scummy.  So I ask, is it townie, and therefore Serela is in severe error because your logic is townie?  You said no, logic is not townie.   That's why I included the second question:  Bad logic may be called scummy, since it's flawed.  Good logic might be called null.  Since good logic is accessible by both town and scum.  So is your logic good?

[PX]

Well if I refuse to have ed1 tier reactions to ed1 stuff then how am I going to somewhat help the game advance ;_;

although yeah

##Vote PX

probably the least helpful of the ed1 shenanigans

And how exactly as opposed to what?

[ActionDan]

Shadoweh and Huhwhat are super town.
Dormio is too awesome for us.

This goes against how I normally play every game I'm in, but uhh ##Vote: Serela.
I'll wait for everyone else to punish PX.

Actually everyone is scum

but some are more scum than others

[WHMZakeri]

Okay cool then.
Doesn't actually affect my vote, though.

And how exactly as opposed to what?

He probably just decided to jump on your wagon because it looked good.
While you're waiting, you could answer BBM's post.

[CF7]

I slept through awesomeness of Dormio ascending.  :ohdear:
##Vote Zakeri.

[PX]

For blindly accepting somebody's request without even thinking of the fact that there would be any consequences, when Dormio didn't state what activating his power would do when he did it the last time he rolled it. That's why you're all idiots.

[ActionDan]

the consequence was activating a role.  town has more to gain from activating a town role than lose from activating a scum role.  The outcome right now is like a A-.  I'll take that. 

[BT]

^

Though even if PX were right this is just one distracting line. You think people are idiots - what next?

##Vote PX

Zak how can I be as good as you and read Shadowmeh and Birds on RVS posts?

[FinnKaenbyou]

So in the time it took me to wake up we already have a third party victory.

I don't even.

Anyway it's been a while, but:

##Vote: ActionDan

Instantly goes along with Dormio's plan without asking what's going on. Gets extremely reactionary when someone votes for him in the first half hour of gameplay. Dan, why were you so sensitive about an ed1 vote?

the consequence was activating a role.  town has more to gain from activating a town role than lose from activating a scum role.  The outcome right now is like a A-.  I'll take that. 

You're immediately removing the possibility of third party. Which Dormio was. A role with a win request like 'become Captain Planet' is so silly you'd never get it on a proper side.

Darkninja, you're a character;  add some life to this game

Any reason you're calling out Darkninja in particular?

[ActionDan]

So in the time it took me to wake up we already have a third party victory.

I don't even.

Anyway it's been a while, but:

##Vote: ActionDan

Instantly goes along with Dormio's plan without asking what's going on. Gets extremely reactionary when someone votes for him in the first half hour of gameplay. Dan, why were you so sensitive about an ed1 vote?
You're immediately removing the possibility of third party. Which Dormio was. A role with a win request like 'become Captain Planet' is so silly you'd never get it on a proper side.
Any reason you're calling out Darkninja in particular?

I've had the role before, I knew what was going on, see above. 
I asked because if it was serious I was planning on asking a follow up question if it was.  I'm always sensitive to votes on me no matter what stage of the game or for what reasons people give.  That particular vote elicited a reaction because I couldn't immediately tell if it was standard RVS babble or serious.

Are you trying to imply something when you quoted 75?

Darkninja thinks a little differently than the rest of us.  I was curious to see what he was thinking at that time. 

[FinnKaenbyou]

That particular vote elicited a reaction because I couldn't immediately tell if it was standard RVS babble or serious.

The one where his reasoning was 'you voted someone who wasn't playing before day 1 started'? I'd like to know why you thought that might be serious.

Are you trying to imply something when you quoted 75?

No, I was bringing up the quote in question for easy reference. Is this not a thing people do any more?

And I'm going to need some clarification on this 'darkninja thinks differently from the rest of us' thing, because I've never played with him before. Does he have some kind of reputation?

[ActionDan]

The one where his reasoning was 'you voted someone who wasn't playing before day 1 started'? I'd like to know why you thought that might be serious.

No, I was bringing up the quote in question for easy reference. Is this not a thing people do any more?

And I'm going to need some clarification on this 'darkninja thinks differently from the rest of us' thing, because I've never played with him before. Does he have some kind of reputation?

It had 'reasoning' attached (though I missed the ' ') that was both ridiculous and yet did highlight a unique behavior that no one else did during the confirm phase.

yes you referenced 75.  what was the point of commenting on it?

I think DN has a screw loose.  his logic is unique.

[GMOFucker: Makin' GMOs To Fuck 'Em]

I'm always sensitive to votes on me no matter what stage of the game or for what reasons people give.

There were reasonable ways to explain your thought process behind that post and 0 of them started with "I always".

##Unvote
##Vote: ActionDan

self-meta is for SCUM who want to assert how much they're playing like they are when theyre town because theyre trying so hard guys

[ActionDan]

Is the truth unreasonable?

[GMOFucker: Makin' GMOs To Fuck 'Em]

It's not relevant to Rou's question; "I always do this" is just avoiding accountability. I'm also frustrated because most of your questions are chaff and I'd go as far to say you're faking them due to how useless the answers will be.

[ActionDan]

I'm pretty sure I gave as accountable an answer as I could by stating why I reacted to it.  saying I haven't is an untruth.  The statement you take issue with was there to explain why I might be sensitive to a vote placed on me.  in short, I notice it.

Which questions do you think are chaff?

[Raikaria]

For blindly accepting somebody's request without even thinking of the fact that there would be any consequences, when Dormio didn't state what activating his power would do when he did it the last time he rolled it. That's why you're all idiots.

Hey hey I did it my complete accident.

[Raikaria]

*by complete accident. Hell my post as saying Dormio still needed THREE MORE instead of 2; because I thought 'Oh they missed an element'.

Anyway not gonna be able to post too much today; coursework being worked on today. Be back in the evening or tomorrow.

[Kilgamayan]

Sky Paladin replaces Darkninjaabc, effectively immediately. Welcome to the game, Agent Tanya.

[Kilgamayan]

ZETTAI
UNMEI
MOKUSHIROKU

Shadoweh (0): Serela
Serela (2): Shadoweh, Prims, PX, Zakeri
PX (0): Prims
Prims (0): Serela, PX
ActionDan (2): PX, Roukan, Prims
BT (0): PX
Raikaria (1): PX
PX (3): BigBangMeteor, Serela, BT
Zakeri (1): CF7

Not voting (5): ActionDan, Sky Paladin, NekNekoRex, bofh, Raikaria

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch. You have about 36 hours left to vote.

[Sky_Paladin]

I am now C4-Ing the vote tallies so some of them don't add up right.

Shake'em baby~