You KNOW, I asked if the subject was up for debate. I didn't mean for you to start debating without me. :V
My argument would be that, even if someone comes here just for the games, it's better than nothing, and all this rule achieves in the activity front is 10 spam-ish posts (I say 'ish' because most people that come here are pretty a-ok).
In other news, the game isn't up yet. What are you slackers doing?