DOTA Kingmaker Mafia (SCUM WIN)

[Shadoweh]

ActionDan, before 48 hours are up you may ##GANK: [name] to kill anyone alive, excluding yourself. Failure to do so within the time limit is grounds for lynch on yourself.

So yes, yes it is.

Amra that is the weirdest post coming from you. When do you feel discussion is productive now?

[Bardiche]

Hammer has fallen, shut up.

I shouldn't need to continuously clarify things because people are all "it's not listed anywhere so :V".

[Bardiche]

What happened? Axe happened!

As Nightstalker, king of the Gank, begins pinging Axe, the group readies themselves to attack... but och! The moment the ranged attacks come rolling in, Axe starts spinning like a fucking top, his Helix Strike scaring everyone the fuck off because shit that thing's gonna kill you if you get close. Clearly the only explanation is that Nightstalker is a fucking feeder, and so everyone murders him instead for trying to send them into a failed gank.

Zakeri is Axe, the Hero, and cannot be lynched!

ActionDan, playing Nightstalker, has been lynched!

It is now Night. You have 24 hours to relax and do nothing.

[ActionDan]

should never have ganked during the day /noob

[Bardiche]

DO NOT:
- Edit posts.
- Spam.
- Be an arsehole.
- Make ad hominem attacks.
- Post at night.

[Bardiche]

IT IS NOW DAY 2 AND YOU MAY POST

Dead people do not count as exempt from the rules, so don't post if you're dead. At all. This includes bah posts. There's also no graveyard. If you want to rage about alive players, do it elsewhere.

IN ANY CASE: Your King for today is Conqueror, and he may ##GANK: someone within 48 hours or face death penalty.

Oh, and Zakeri, playing Axe, Town Hero got killed during the night. Who saw that coming?


Oh, and effective immediately Edible replaces IHNN. That means IHNN can't post here any more.

[Conqueror]

coolbeans
i will resist the urge to immediately gank shadoweh to ask her to respond to my posts from yesterday. she's free to call me scum to try and make me get a town read on her.
today is a contribution day! let's see those posts rolling in, everybody.

[Conqueror]

Is that the best you can do, shadoweh :v

i would also like polaris to explain what he meant by this post and request his opinions on shadoweh!

[Edible]

Ganking Shadoweh because she was one of the only active players D1 is probably not a sound strategy.  Give her a day or two before we decide to stab her in the throat, imo.

Let's kill hero instead.

[PX]

Or Rawr. Or Amra. Because I seriously can't remember who is in this game.

[Shadoweh]

Thanks you Mr. Anonymous King who hates me. -.-
Repeating scumtowntells is scummy silly. And I responded to a bunch of your stuff yesterday. I'm more interested in telling you why you should lynch Polaris today. I can't emphasize how much his iso makes me want to punch him every time I read it with how irrelevantly waffly he is, even more then Serela (holy shit Serela isn't in this game)
His 'switch' from voting PX to Dormio, which I say sarcastically because it's not really a vote switch, it's a 'bad day 1 players that we constantly lynch day 1' list, is as irrelevant as the rest of his posts because there's no fucking reasoning behind it. This is his reasoning.

There isn't even that much to read :V
Dormio scum gut read is better than nothing `_` feel free to place a vote down for the sake of prosperity

GUT! And no reason why he's done torturing PX. I imagine that if one of his 'lynch list' turned up town he would just put PX back on there as Best Easy Justifiable Lynch.

If you'd like second and third choices you'll have to wait for me to get home from work tonight and people actually have a chance to make a second post to judge them by

[BT]

I'm sick but muscling through this anyway.

Dislike PX agreeing with stuff I said in #79 and saying he's weary of Polaris only to settle for the inactivity vote anyway. Might be because Polaris was the one asking for him to vote so... being careful?

Polaris driving discussion but not taking a noticeable solid stance on anything. This isn't scummy, actually, but IHNN handwaving him as town for 'driving discussion' is. He's out so I can't question him about this more but I'm leaning towards a case of That Was Too Easy.

Shadoweh misrepresenting 101 different things is... I want to say it's a scumtell but I'm not sure. To reply to #102, I was questioning labling IHNN as an active lurker so early but agreed with Conq otherwise. (I don't see how you can even mistake this unless you literally haven't read the thread) I'm actually surprised you're going for this shitty Polaris case. Why is his lynch list such a big deal to you?

Edible's suggestion might be a decent choice depending on how stupidly inactive people are. It's meh otherwise. Who do you think is scum? Same question for PX.

Would like to ask glorious king Conqueror what he'd do with two shots. (this is a good question for kings in general imo)

[Edible]

Who do you think is scum?

You, for ignoring who I very blatantly said we should shoot for the sake of unnecessary post analysis. :3c

[BT]

Serious? Either way I don't see why you shouldn't chime in on things. Do you have anything to say on Shadoweh's active D1?

[Edible]

Serious? Either way I don't see why you shouldn't chime in on things. Do you have anything to say on Shadoweh's active D1?

Very serious.  You're sidelining, posting observations instead of scumhunting.

I literally have two posts in the game and you forgot that I said that we shouldn't kill her just for being active on D1?

<_<

[BT]

Yep, you said that but considering there might be more to it than just "being active" I don't see why you won't answer. Do you think she's town as well as active or just active and that's enough? I also don't see how what I'm doing isn't scumhunting when I'm stating what I find off and why.

[Hero999]

I say we kill no one, and everyone shoot else!
...I mean GAME WIPEOUT!!!!
Whos the highlander! YEah!? Un!
Kill Me! Me! Me! Me! So I can DENY MYSELF!!!! Mwuahahahahaa
Kill Dormio do it.

[Polaris]

shadoweh you're being even more dumb, that post you quoted was me responding to IHNN about his scum gut read on dormio

[Shadoweh]

*mumbles something about iso's*
You realize it's worse that you literally have no reason for who you were suspecting right? What would not be 'dumb' is if you could put a why behind any of the people on your lynch list, a why that doesn't include 'gut' or a statement like 'isn't doing anything' without showing in context what that nothing is.

BT what Edible is saying is you've posted four opinions (five if you count Overlord Conqueror) that don't clearly state your opinion on the people you're talking about. See above for why I don't like Polaris's laze list.

Hero what the actual fuck.

[Polaris]

honestly i prioritized px/hero999/rawr (and later, dormio) because lurkers. if i don't immediately see scumminess emanating from people who posted so far then i'm inclined to believe that the scum might have not shown up yet, so if possible i wanted to make them show up (by giving them an excuse to show up by nominating someone for the lynch list, which would by extension allow them to contribute scumreads). if px contributed something and dormio hadn't yet, then what's wrong with pushing at dormio? especially when i was voting hero the whole time `_`

if anyone were to be ganked out of the blue at that point i would have preferred it was one of dormio/hero999/rawr seeing as px contributed and expressed intent to contribute further. i guess zakeri said nothing too so he falls under the general category, but i always feel sorry for zakeri so he was less of a priority.

conq: shadoweh is being dumb but according to the Theory of Shadoweh that i came up with just now, shadoweh is always dumb until d3 or so, and i can't really tell if she's being town or scum

still waiting on dormio/hero999/rawr `_` hero are you expressing that dormio be the one killed today?

[Polaris]

oh right we have that wrath of god thing, i guess we're supposed to handle lurkers with those, maybe `_`

[Shadoweh]

The game had just started, it had been less then 24 hours and just from reading the first page I can see Dormio asking questions that are related to playing the game. As opposed to say, Amra, who said 'plz don't kill me Dan'. You have no standard for your lynches. Saying lurkers is great when you never intend to read back to see if they were lurking and are instead prioritizing on 'easiest to convince people to kill'.

[Shadoweh]

Also I appreciate you refuting me with 'u r dum' I've totally never had that happen before.
The Wrath of God is for lurkers yes. I was thinking we could actually give people time to lurk before shooting them.

[Polaris]

dormio asked questions to dan and zakeri, and both of them are dead now. `_`

[Polaris]

i guess amra should post too but i feel like i can get a read on amra even at his current pace `_`

[Polaris]

wait shadoweh, how many posts per page do you have, since i don't think we have the same settings.

[Bardiche]

Here's a mod with a friendly-- oh, no votes were cast!

But you still spent 12 hours. There's 36 hours left.


Also, please refrain from ad hominem attacks. Mafia is a party game and I will have you play it as such.

[Polaris]

I'm sorry for calling you dumb Shadoweh I hope you will forgive me and also I hope you will tell me how many posts per page you have.

[Shadoweh]

I forgive you but I still want you to die plz.
I use 50 like a sane person. And I don't have a QT with Amra asking what a flip is so I honestly don't know how to get a read this time.

[Conqueror]

##WrathofGod: rawr

Shadoweh your Polaris case sucks and every time I read it I only want to shoot you more.

The game had just started, it had been less then 24 hours and just from reading the first page I can see Dormio asking questions that are related to playing the game. As opposed to say, Amra, who said 'plz don't kill me Dan'. You have no standard for your lynches. Saying lurkers is great when you never intend to read back to see if they were lurking and are instead prioritizing on 'easiest to convince people to kill'.

Stuff like this would be more convincing if I didn't point how you were posting nonsense yesterday re: PX etc and you just ignored it all after my last post. I mean on some level I'm happy to think that people are kowtowing to me and agreeing with my last word, but most of the time I think it's just because they're ignoring me instead.  Also, given that you acknowledge that the game had been going for 24 hours at the point, I don't know what you're trying to push here. As far as I'm concerned Dormio/Amra/Hero/rawr have all provided equal amounts of irrelevant content. Dormio is slightly better but his posts were just minor points that didn't go anywhere. How are you supposed to get a standard for lynching people who all have the same amount of nothing? Your case is "omgggg why no case?" when you're not really a hardcore Making Cases person from your most recent town games and push suspects on gut and feelings etc. So I'm really curious as to why you're pushing this angle.

The Wrath of God is for lurkers yes. I was thinking we could actually give people time to lurk before shooting them.

We should get started, it'll take 48 hours just to nuke one lurker and that's all we have in a day. I get the feeling Hero would be trying harder if he were scum. Yeah yeah, meta, I know. I'm down for wrathing him or rawr either way since it doesn't look like they intend on contributing. Or Amra I guess but I like to be nice to newbies; it helps retention rate. Dormio doesn't go here because Dormio not paying attention is totally a town tell.

People should vote. See like this.
##Vote: Shadoweh

Polaris okay but what do you actually think about people beyond :lurk: You think everyone besides dormio/hero/rawr looks town to you?