PX #188: You said you would make another post. Where was this other post?
Why were you willing to throw IHNN to the side?
You still need to explain your townread of Serela. "I thought Neko was the scum" doesn't cut it since you said you could provide a defense of him. Since we're dealing with a scumflip it's important to know your thought process.
There are blips in his thought process here and there but my main two issues with PX are (a) his refusal to explain his Serela defense and (b) he completely disappeared after promising another post when his vote was on the counterwagon to scum. However, I don't actually think his initial Neko vote looks like an attempt to start a counterwagon, since there was no indication anybody but me would switch.
For now, I will
##Vote: Affinity (L-3). Earlier suspicions on him aren't quelled, interactions with Serela read a lot like weak distancing / prodding of scumbuddy (lots of questioning but Affinity never outright declares Serela scummy until it's clear he can't ignore the wagon) and the recent BT vote looks like an attempt to gain hipster cred by swaying away from the obvious targets. It doesn't make much sense from a town PoV - Affinity had called BT the
"best non-Serela voter D1", and had actual content related to Serela's scumflip in his PX vote, only now he's completely ignoring BT's position on the Serela wagon. Why was the PX vote worth dropping for a case that ignores flips entirely? We're not on D1 anymore, this reads as disconnect to me.
I read Kilga too
Small nitpicks here and there, but
Prefer Affinity
Biggest issue is that
this post let him later hop on any rising wagon, but he then put himself in a position where he couldn't vote Serela over Rex even after claim, so it's hard to hold against him. Nitpick 2:
#182 bugs me because it's a misrep and the Invasion callback is an appeal to... something, when the comparision didn't really apply. I feel like Omba's D1 wasn't actually awful enough to deserve the amount of tunneling Kilga had on him, and that the antagonisms points were exaggerated (see what I said about Invasion reference). Nitpick 3: Excess town reads don't fully make sense, PX's effort is hard to gauge due to his posting style but how are Affinity and I putting in more effort than BT?
