That's good and all, but don't you think you should also comment on who's scum other than Kenshin?
I'm entirely sold on two people being scum, do I have to catch the entire scumteam d2? ;_;
I actually am pretty confident that Farina will flip scum due to her overall total weirdness today and her opinions towards her scumbuddies Kaori and Uesugi, but seriously trodding down that path and making a case on her before Kaori or Uesugi flips would be ridiculous, so I'm leaving that until we actually get their scum flips out and on the table. I might be able to make a good case on her WITHOUT those twos flips if I reread her d1, but :effort:, I'm fine with where I am now and once one of them flips it should be even easier to make a good case on Farina.
and if one of those three flipped town I'd look at Eclair, but that's getting even farther into future stuff based on flips we don't have, and right now I feel good enough that those three will flip scum that I would actively dislike an Eclair lynch.
Anyway, onto the stuff I'm supposed to be answering.
Can't say much towards what Eclair pointed out to me in her posts to answer, because I really didn't get any chasing done D1 due to not being present until the end. Although,
This isn't a point of 'pot calling the kettle black and since both are black pot's opinion is invalid,' it is 'pot calling the kettle black, why should we lynch kettle over pot?'
I would like to think I've been doing a good job on this part through D2 so far! Eclair, do you think Uesugi's scumhunting effort D2 being practically EXCLUSIVELY LIMITED TO KAORI is okay? Yes, Uesugi is saying more things then just stuff about Kaori. NO, none of it is actually scumhunting or opinions on who she thinks could be scum other then Kaori or anything of the sort.
Now for the one I've sort of been procrastinating on. Comparing my 130 to Uesugi's 144 because a few people have asked for it.
Brief summary of my post: These people are town (including one of the 3 wagon choices), iunno about the lurkers right now but Kaori is pretty bad because ___, I don't want to vote Eclair because ____ and I do not like the others on her wagon. ##Vote Saya-oh wait no, she's town too. (I have now declared a dislike of all three of the wagon choices but a desire to lynch Kaori instead)
Later I collapse mentally and go for the Meiya vote as I manage to convince myself she's somehow less town then the other two wagon choices that I think are town, and because the Kaori lynch is not happening. Claims mess that up because Meiya's looks quite town while Sayaka's is totally weird and freaky.
Brief summary of Uesugi's post:
-I do not currently see a reason why I would want to vote Eclair or Yuno, and I do not believe Meiya is the best choice for D1's lynch.
-Still don't like Sayaka (Not any further advancement of why this is so)
-Cases on three lurkers, two of which practically did not exist and the third barely so
-Okay with lynching any of the lurkers, but going to leave vote on Sayaka
Notice that Uesugi's is polarized towards voting people who almost do not exist (Or practically don't), does not actually comment on anything Sayaka had done in the latter part of D1, and also that she completely dropped Blackrose D2 despite her being the top priority lurker D1, instead focusing on Kaori who had been recieving much more critisism then Blackrose D2 before Uesugi appeared. I personally find her wording in the first - to be weird as well, but whatever, that's not as important I guess.
I'm not sure how I can explicitly point out things in mine that are better, because I didn't logic much in any of them and just barfed reads, and then lots of awkwardness because I thought all three of the wagon choices were town in addition to the issues I was encountering. My end of d1 was pretty bad and there's no avoiding that. However, I -can- explicitly point out things that are bad about Uesugi's post, and I'd like to hope that can count. Honestly, everything Uesugi has done #144 and onward seems pretty scummy looking to me.
Oh, cut. My answer to Eclair's question is that I am a lazy hoe and cannot be arsed to create a case when the day has not actually started yet. If nothing else I like to recieve the NK results first.